Possible First Detection of Gyroresonance Emission from a Coronal Mass Ejection in the Middle Corona

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.16453
• Title: Possible First Detection of Gyroresonance Emission from a Coronal Mass Ejection in the Middle Corona
• Authors: Surajit Mondal et al. (35 authors from multiple institutions including New Jersey Institute of Technology, California Institute of Technology, Arizona State University, etc.)
• Classification: astro-ph.SR (Solar and Stellar Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (draft version)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.16453

Abstract

Conventional measurements of coronal mass ejection (CME) magnetic fields have remained a key challenge in solar physics. Such measurements are crucial for space weather forecasting and understanding the detailed evolution of CMEs. Despite substantial efforts and multiple proposed methodologies, this objective has not yet been achieved. This paper reports the first possible detection of gyroresonance emission from a CME. Assuming the emission occurs at the third harmonic frequency, the authors estimate magnetic field strengths of 7.9-5.6 G between 4.9-7.5 R⊙. The study further demonstrates that this high magnetic field is not representative of the average field within the CME, but rather is likely associated with small-scale magnetic islands, which are increasingly observed in high-resolution and high-quality white-light imagery.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. CME Magnetic Field Measurement Challenge: CMEs are the most energetic eruptive phenomena in the solar system, and their magnetic field strength is a key parameter determining their geomagnetic effectiveness, yet can currently only be measured routinely through in-situ data.
2. Space Weather Forecasting Requirements: To understand the detailed evolution of CMEs in interplanetary space and provide early warnings for space weather, magnetic field measurements are needed when CMEs are still near the Sun.
3. Remote Sensing Technology Gap: Existing magnetic field measurements rely primarily on fortuitous satellite encounters in interplanetary space, lacking effective remote sensing techniques.

Importance of the Problem

• Space Weather Impact: CMEs are the primary drivers of space weather events in the near-Earth environment.
• Scientific Understanding: Understanding CME magnetic fields is essential for comprehending their propagation and evolution mechanisms.
• Early Warning Requirements: Early magnetic field measurements can provide critical information for space weather forecasting.

Limitations of Existing Methods

Current techniques include:

• Frequency band splitting analysis from Type II bursts
• Circular polarization analysis from moving Type IV bursts
• Standoff distance methods from extreme ultraviolet and optical imagery
• Faraday rotation techniques

These methods can only estimate spatially-averaged magnetic fields, with the averaging scale varying among different methods.

Core Contributions

1. First Detection: Reports the first possible observational detection of thermal gyroresonance emission from a CME.
2. New Measurement Method: Proposes a novel remote sensing method for CME magnetic field measurement based on gyroresonance emission.
3. Magnetic Field Estimation: Estimates magnetic field strengths of 7.9-5.6 G in the altitude range of 4.9-7.5 R⊙.
4. Small-Scale Structure Identification: Confirms the association of high magnetic fields with small-scale magnetic island structures rather than average fields within the CME.
5. Observational Technique Validation: Validates the application potential of OVRO-LWA in CME magnetic field detection.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Analyzing radio spectral characteristics of CMEs to identify gyroresonance emission signals and derive magnetic field strengths based on the relationship between emission frequency and electron cyclotron frequency:

• Input: Multi-frequency radio images and dynamic spectral data
• Output: CME magnetic field strength and its spatiotemporal evolution
• Constraints: Spectral characteristic identification of gyroresonance emission

Observational Architecture

Instrumentation

• OVRO-LWA: Owens Valley Radio Observatory Long Wavelength Array, operating frequency 13.4-86.9 MHz
• Configuration: 352 antennas with multiple solar-dedicated observation modes
• Resolution: Temporal resolution 10 seconds, frequency resolution 24 kHz
• Imaging: 5 MHz bandwidth with optimized dynamic range

Data Processing Pipeline

1. Ionospheric Correction: Manual correction of ionospheric refraction effects using white-light imagery as reference.
2. Image Generation: Multi-frequency image generation at 1-minute cadence.
3. Spectral Extraction: Radio spectral extraction from bright CME feature regions.
4. Signal Identification: Identification of spectra conforming to gyroresonance characteristics.

Technical Innovations

Gyroresonance Emission Identification

Characteristic spectrum of gyroresonance emission:

• Low-Frequency Segment: Optically thick emission with approximately constant brightness temperature
• High-Frequency Segment: Optically thin emission with sharply declining brightness temperature
• Turnover Frequency: Corresponds to harmonics of the electron cyclotron frequency

Magnetic Field Calculation Formula

νg = 2.8sB MHz

Where:

• νg: electron cyclotron frequency
• s: harmonic number (typically 2-4)
• B: magnetic field strength (Gauss)

Assuming s=3, the magnetic field strength can be derived from the observed turnover frequency.

Experimental Setup

Observation Event

• Date: March 9, 2024
• CME Characteristics: White-light CME first detected by LASCO C2 at 22:24 UT
• Source Region: Eruption from the far-side east limb, confirmed from Solar Orbiter perspective
• Observation Window: From CME entry into LASCO C2 field of view until local sunset

Dataset Characteristics

• Frequency Range: 13.4-86.9 MHz
• Temporal Coverage: Approximately 6 hours of continuous observation
• Spatial Range: Heliocentric distances of 4.9-7.5 R⊙
• Data Volume: Approximately 10 TB of raw data per day

Analysis Methods

• Region Selection: Spectral extraction from regions ahead of white-light bright features
• Signal Threshold: Peak intensity >5 times RMS noise level
• Upper Limit Treatment: Upper limits of 5 times RMS provided when below threshold

Experimental Results

Primary Observational Results

Temporal Evolution

CME radio emission was observed beginning at 22:24 UT, consistent with the first detection time of the white-light CME, continuing until near sunset.

Spectral Characteristics

At multiple times between 23:34:07 and 00:16:05 UT, spectra conforming to gyroresonance emission characteristics were observed:

• Constant Segment: Low-frequency brightness temperature approximately 0.1 MK
• Declining Segment: Sharp decrease in high-frequency segment
• Turnover Frequency: Range of 40-70 MHz

Magnetic Field Strength Estimation

Based on the assumption of s=3:

• Time: 23:34 UT - 00:16 UT
• Altitude: 4.9 - 7.5 R⊙
• Magnetic Field: 7.9 - 5.6 G
• Trend: Decreasing with increasing altitude

Model Validation

Gyroresonance Model

Successfully fitted observed spectra using a thermal electron distribution gyroresonance emission model:

• Electron Density: 6×10⁶ cm⁻³
• Magnetic Field Strength: 5.5-7.5 G
• Filling Factor: 13-20%
• Source Region Scale: 0.03-0.25 R⊙

Gyrosynchrotron Radiation Comparison

The gyrosynchrotron radiation model for non-thermal electrons can also fit the observations but requires more complex non-uniform magnetic field distributions and extremely low filling factors (<1%).

Key Findings

1. Small-Scale Magnetic Structures: High magnetic field values correspond to small magnetic islands within the CME rather than the overall average field.
2. Filling Factor: The emission region occupies a small fraction of the observation beam (<20%), indicating that the magnetic field is concentrated in localized regions.
3. Altitude Dependence: The variation of magnetic field strength with altitude does not completely follow adiabatic expansion laws.
4. WISPR Observation Confirmation: Parker Solar Probe's WISPR observations indeed reveal small-scale magnetic structures within the CME.

Related Work

CME Magnetic Field Measurement Techniques

• Frequency Band Splitting Method: Based on frequency band splitting characteristics of Type II radio bursts
• Circular Polarization Method: Utilizing circular polarization degree of moving Type IV bursts
• Standoff Distance Method: Based on shock standoff distance from extreme ultraviolet and optical imagery
• Faraday Rotation Method: Utilizing Faraday rotation effects of linearly polarized sources

Gyroemission Research

• Active Region Applications: Gyroresonance emission primarily used for active region magnetic field measurements
• CME Applications: Gyrosynchrotron radiation has been applied to CME magnetic field and non-thermal electron studies
• Theoretical Foundation: Theoretical framework established by Fleishman & Kuznetsov (2010) and others

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First Detection Confirmed: Successfully detected possible gyroresonance emission from a CME, providing a new method for remote sensing of CME magnetic fields.
2. Magnetic Field Strength Quantification: Measured magnetic field strengths of 7.9-5.6 G in the middle corona region (4.9-7.5 R⊙).
3. Importance of Small-Scale Structures: Confirmed the existence of small magnetic island structures within CMEs and their impact on magnetic field measurements.
4. Observational Technique Feasibility: Validated the application potential of low-frequency radio observations in CME magnetic field research.

Limitations

1. Harmonic Number Uncertainty: The assumption of s=3 requires further verification; different harmonic numbers would affect magnetic field estimates.
2. Emission Mechanism Ambiguity: Both gyroresonance and gyrosynchrotron radiation can explain the observed phenomena.
3. Spatial Resolution Limitations: Cannot precisely determine the spatial scale and location of the emission region.
4. Instrument Commissioning Phase: OVRO-LWA is still under commissioning, with uncertainties in data quality and calibration.
5. Single Event: Based on only one CME event, requiring more observational verification.

Future Directions

1. Imaging Spectropolarimetry: Develop imaging spectropolarimetric observation capabilities to precisely determine harmonic numbers.
2. Multi-Event Statistics: Accumulate more CME observations to establish statistical samples.
3. Theoretical Model Refinement: Develop more accurate theoretical models of small-scale magnetic structures in CMEs.
4. Multi-Wavelength Coordination: Combine observations from other wavelengths to improve magnetic field measurement accuracy.
5. Space Weather Applications: Apply the technique to real-time space weather forecasting.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Scientific Breakthrough: First reported detection of CME gyroresonance emission with significant scientific importance.
2. Methodological Innovation: Proposes a novel remote sensing method for CME magnetic field measurement based on gyroresonance emission.
3. High-Quality Observations: Utilizes advanced OVRO-LWA equipment to obtain high-quality multi-frequency observational data.
4. Rigorous Analysis: Detailed spectral analysis and model comparison with high credibility of conclusions.
5. Theory Integration: Combines observational results with theoretical models and numerical simulations, enhancing reliability of interpretation.

Weaknesses

1. Limited Sample Size: Based on a single CME event with limited statistical significance.
2. Large Uncertainties: Uncertainties exist in harmonic number assumptions and emission mechanism selection.
3. Spatial Localization Precision: Cannot precisely determine the three-dimensional position and structure of the emission source.
4. Instrument Limitations: Observations conducted during instrument commissioning, potentially affecting data quality.
5. Insufficient Theoretical Verification: While the small magnetic island hypothesis is reasonable, it lacks direct verification.

Impact

1. Academic Value: Opens new directions for CME physics and space weather research.
2. Technical Advancement: Promotes the application of radio astronomical techniques in solar physics.
3. Practical Prospects: Provides new technical means for future space weather forecasting.
4. International Collaboration: Demonstrates the importance of multi-institutional cooperation.

Application Scenarios

1. Early CME Warning: Applicable to early magnetic field monitoring after CME departure from the Sun.
2. Space Weather Research: Provides magnetic field input parameters for space weather models.
3. Solar Physics Fundamental Research: Investigates CME internal structure and evolution mechanisms.
4. Radio Astronomy Technique Validation: Validates scientific applications of low-frequency radio observations.

References

The paper cites numerous important references, including:

• Fleishman & Kuznetsov (2010): Theoretical foundation of gyrosynchrotron radiation
• Mondal et al. (2020): Review of CME magnetic field measurements
• Vourlidas et al. (2016): WISPR instrument introduction
• Cappello et al. (2024): Observations of CME small-scale structures

Overall Assessment: This is an observational paper of significant scientific importance, reporting the first possible detection of CME gyroresonance emission and providing a new technical pathway for remote sensing of CME magnetic fields. Despite some uncertainties and limitations, its scientific value and technical innovation merit recognition. Future work requires more observational verification and theoretical refinement to confirm the universality and reliability of this finding.