Broadband interferometry-based searches for photon-axion conversion in vacuum

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.16725
• Title: Broadband interferometry-based searches for photon-axion conversion in vacuum
• Authors: Josep Maria Batllori, Dieter Horns, Marios Maroudas (Institut für Experimentalphysik, Universität Hamburg)
• Classification: hep-ex (High Energy Physics - Experiment)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.16725

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel experimental apparatus called the WISP Interferometer (WINTER) for detecting photon-axion conversion over a broad mass range, independent of dark matter assumptions. The apparatus employs a free-space Mach-Zehnder interferometer with an external magnetic field and vacuum environment integrated into one arm, achieving photon-axion mixing through the Primakoff effect and detection via amplitude modulation. The expected axion-induced signal is modulated through polarization changes. The experimental design incorporates a Fabry-Pérot cavity with finesse 10⁵ operating in vacuum, significantly enhancing sensitivity. The apparatus is sensitive to photon-axion coupling strengths of $g_{aγγ} \gtrsim 5.5 \times 10^{-15} \text{GeV}^{-1}$, applicable to axions with masses up to 84.8 μeV.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Axion Theory: Axions are hypothetical particles in Standard Model extensions, originally proposed to solve the strong CP problem in quantum chromodynamics (QCD), and have become important dark matter candidates.
2. Limitations of Existing Detection Methods:
   • Haloscope Experiments: While highly sensitive, they are model-dependent and rely on unverified assumptions about local dark matter density and distribution
   • Light-Shining-through-Wall (LSW) Technique: Model-independent and inherently broadband, but requires double photon-to-axion conversion, limiting sensitivity
3. Scientific Significance: The coupling between axions and photons in external magnetic fields provides a key mechanism for detection. Lattice QCD predictions suggest axion mass ranges of 50-1500 μeV for axions constituting partial dark matter in post-inflationary scenarios.

Research Motivation

• Develop model-independent, broadband, high-sensitivity axion detection methods
• Explore theoretically predicted but experimentally unexplored parameter spaces
• Provide axion detection pathways independent of dark matter assumptions

Core Contributions

1. Proposes WINTER Experimental Scheme: First combination of free-space Mach-Zehnder interferometer with high-finesse Fabry-Pérot cavity for axion detection
2. Achieves Broadband Model-Independent Detection: Avoids the double conversion limitation of LSW experiments through single-stage photon-axion conversion
3. Attains High Sensitivity: Expected sensitivity of $g_{aγγ} \gtrsim 5.5 \times 10^{-15} \text{GeV}^{-1}$, covering axions with masses up to 84.8 μeV
4. Develops Desktop Prototype: A prototype system under construction validates the feasibility of the scheme
5. Provides Complete Theoretical Framework: Detailed derivation of the physical mechanisms and detection principles of photon-axion mixing

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: 1064 nm laser beam, external magnetic field (9T, 10m long) Output: Measurement of photon-axion conversion probability Objective: Detect minute amplitude changes caused by the Primakoff effect

Experimental Architecture

1. Mach-Zehnder Interferometer (MZI)

• Sensitive Arm: Placed in strong magnetic field within vacuum chamber, integrated with Fabry-Pérot cavity
• Reference Arm: Serves as control, unaffected by magnetic field
• Operating Principle: Detects light intensity differences between the two arms

2. Fabry-Pérot Cavity (FPC)

• Length: LFPC = 10 m
• Finesse: F ≈ 10⁵
• Reflectivity: R = 1 - 20 ppm
• Free Spectral Range: FSR = 15 MHz
• Linewidth: Δf = 150 Hz

3. Modulation System

• Amplitude Modulation (EOM-AM): Frequency ωm ≈ 1 kHz
• Polarization Modulation (EOM-PC): Frequency ωsig ≈ 20 Hz
• Phase Modulation (EOM-PM): For PDH locking, frequency 7.5 MHz

Physical Mechanisms

Photon-Axion Mixing Theory

In an external magnetic field, the wave equation for the photon-axion system is: $\left[\partial_z^2 + M^2\right]\psi(z) = 0$

where the mixing matrix is: $M^2 = \frac{1}{2ω}\begin{pmatrix} k_γ^2 & -G \\ -G & k_a^2 \end{pmatrix}$

Mixing energy: $G = g_{aγγ}B_{ext}/2$

Conversion Probability

The photon-to-axion conversion probability is: $P_{γ→a} = \frac{G^2}{G^2 + \frac{m_a^4}{16ω_γ^2}} \sin^2\left(\sqrt{G^2 + \frac{m_a^4}{16ω_γ^2}} z\right)$

Under the approximation $k_{osc}z \ll 1$: $P_{γ→a} ≃ (Gz)^2 = \frac{g_{aγγ}^2 B_{ext}^2}{4} z^2$

Technical Innovations

1. Interferometric Measurement: Leverages the high-precision amplitude measurement capability of interferometers
2. Cavity Enhancement Effect: FPC amplifies effective optical path length and circulating power by a factor of finesse squared
3. Dark Fringe Operation: Operating near dark fringe significantly reduces shot noise
4. Multi-Modulation Scheme: Searches for signals at selected frequencies through polarization modulation

Experimental Setup

Main Parameters

• Laser: 130W, 1064 nm continuous-wave laser
• Magnetic Field: 9T superconducting dipole magnet, 10 m length (similar to LHC test magnet)
• Vacuum Level: High vacuum environment to minimize scattering
• Beam Diameter: 5 cm mirrors, optimized for diffraction loss

Control Systems

A. Polarization Power Matching

• Linear polarizer (LP1) set to 45°
• Pockels cell (EOM-PC) for polarization modulation
• PID control loop maintains power balance between polarization states

B. Cavity Locking

• PDH locking scheme, modulation frequency 7.5 MHz
• Piezoelectric mirror (M3) adjusts cavity length to match resonance condition
• Faraday isolator prevents backscatter

C. Interferometer Stabilization

• Operates at dark fringe at 0.01% power point
• Piezoelectric mirror (M4) compensates phase variations
• Amplitude modulation frequency 1 kHz for locking

Noise Analysis

Primary noise sources:

1. Detector Dark Current: NEP_PD2 ≈ 0.5 fW/√Hz
2. Shot Noise: NEP_SN ≈ 0.05 fW/√Hz
3. Total Noise Power: 3.95 fW (bandwidth 10 Hz, measurement time 365 days)

Experimental Results

Sensitivity Predictions

Based on signal-to-noise ratio analysis, WINTER's expected sensitivity is:

$g_{aγγ} ≈ 5.5 × 10^{-15} \text{GeV}^{-1} \left(\frac{\text{SNR}}{3}\right)^{1/2} \left(\frac{B}{9\text{T}}\right)^{-1} \left(\frac{L_{\text{FPC}}}{10\text{m}}\right)^{-1}$

Mass Coverage Range

• Coherence Length: $L_{\text{coh}} = \frac{π}{k_{\text{osc}}} ≃ 10\text{m} \left(\frac{m_a}{0.54\text{meV}}\right)^{-2}$
• Maximum Detectable Mass: 84.8 μeV (corresponding to 10 m cavity length)

Prototype System

Desktop prototype under construction:

• 2W, 1550 nm laser
• 1.2T permanent magnet, 1 m long
• 1 m long FPC, finesse 3×10⁴
• Expected sensitivity: $g_{aγγ} \gtrsim 1 × 10^{-11} \text{GeV}^{-1}$ (mass up to 222 μeV)

Related Work

Existing Axion Search Experiments

1. CAST: Solar axion search, dependent on astrophysical sources
2. ALPS II: LSW technique, requires double conversion
3. PVLAS: Birefringence measurement, does not use interferometric techniques
4. WISPFI: Fiber interferometer, requires tuning to specific resonance

Technical Advantages Comparison

• Model Independence: Does not depend on dark matter assumptions
• Broadband Characteristics: Covers large range of axion masses
• Single-Stage Conversion: Avoids conversion efficiency loss of LSW
• High Sensitivity: Approaches theoretical QCD axion band

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. WINTER provides a novel broadband, model-independent axion search method
2. Expected sensitivity reaches $g_{aγγ} \gtrsim 5.5 × 10^{-15} \text{GeV}^{-1}$, covering important theoretical parameter space
3. Technical scheme is feasible, prototype system is under construction

Limitations

1. Coherence Length Constraint: For a given cavity length, there exists a maximum detectable axion mass
2. Magnetic Field Requirements: Requires strong magnetic field and long magnet, high technical demands
3. Vacuum Requirements: Requires high-quality vacuum environment
4. Thermal Effects: High-power laser may cause thermal distortion

Future Directions

1. Prototype Validation: Complete desktop prototype and validate key technologies
2. Sensitivity Optimization: Further improve cavity finesse and laser power
3. Mass Range Extension: Develop tunable cavity length systems
4. System Integration: Integrate with existing large-scale facilities (e.g., LHC magnets)

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Innovation: First combination of high-finesse FPC with MZI for axion search
2. Theoretical Completeness: Provides complete physical theory and mathematical derivations
3. Strong Practicality: Technical scheme is realistic and feasible, prototype construction has begun
4. Parameter Optimization: Detailed analysis of optical losses, thermal effects, and other engineering issues
5. Broadband Coverage: Capable of exploring large ranges of unexplored parameter space

Weaknesses

1. Technical Challenges: Requires extremely high-precision optical systems and stable environmental control
2. Cost Considerations: Requires expensive superconducting magnets and high-power lasers
3. Competitive Analysis: Detailed comparison with other axion search experiments could be more thorough
4. System Noise: Analysis of certain noise sources may require more experimental verification

Impact

1. Scientific Value: Provides new experimental pathways for axion physics
2. Technology Advancement: Promotes development of precision optical measurement techniques
3. International Collaboration: Based on COST action, promotes international scientific cooperation
4. Industrial Applications: Related technologies may have applications in gravitational wave detection and other fields

Applicable Scenarios

• Fundamental physics research laboratories
• Large-scale scientific facilities (e.g., particle accelerator facilities)
• Precision measurement and metrology science
• Dark matter and dark energy research

References

The paper cites 33 important references, covering:

• Axion theory foundations (Peccei-Quinn, Kim, et al.)
• Experimental techniques (Sikivie, CAST collaboration, et al.)
• Optical interferometry techniques (Pound-Drever-Hall, et al.)
• Numerical computation methods (Fox-Li method, et al.)

Technical Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper proposing an innovative axion search scheme with in-depth theoretical analysis and feasible technical approach, likely to have significant impact in the field of axion physics.