Microscopic theory of strain-controlled split superconducting and time-reversal symmetry-breaking transitions in $s+id$ superconductor

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.19137
• Title: Microscopic theory of strain-controlled split superconducting and time-reversal symmetry-breaking transitions in $s+id$ superconductor
• Authors: Anton Talkachov, Egor Babaev (KTH Royal Institute of Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con (Condensed Matter Physics - Superconductivity)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.19137

Abstract

This paper investigates the emergence conditions of $U(1)\times \mathbb{Z}_2$ superconducting states with spontaneously broken time-reversal symmetry (BTRS) under applied stress on a square lattice. Calculations demonstrate that when critical temperatures coincide at zero strain, linear kinks appear under uniaxial and isotropic strain; otherwise, no kinks occur. Linear kinks are absent under shear strain. Microscopic calculations reveal a complex phase diagram, including non-monotonic behavior of BTRS transitions. Beyond Ginzburg-Landau theory, another result is that for materials with small Poisson's ratio, the $U(1)$ critical temperature may decrease under 100 uniaxial compressive strain. The second part of the paper considers the effects of boundaries and sample finiteness on the strain-induced separation of $T_c^{U(1)}$ and T_c^{\mathbb{Z}_2 transitions. Finite samples exhibit BTRS boundary states with persistent superconducting currents over a wide band-filling range. Compared to infinite systems, mesoscopic samples with 110 surfaces have BTRS domes occupying larger regions of the band-filling-temperature phase space, suggesting that boundary presence facilitates stabilization of the BTRS phase.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

The core problem addressed in this paper is understanding how external stress controls spontaneous breaking of time-reversal symmetry in superconductors, particularly the separation mechanism of $U(1)$ and $\mathbb{Z}_2$ critical temperatures in the $s+id$ superconducting state.

Importance of the Problem

1. Fundamental Physics: Superconducting states with broken time-reversal symmetry ($U(1)\times\mathbb{Z}_2$) exhibit rich physical phenomena, distinct from conventional superconductors with only broken $U(1)$ gauge symmetry
2. Experimental Relevance: Directly related to experimental observations in materials such as Sr₂RuO₄ and iron-based superconductors
3. Application Prospects: Potential novel applications including sensitive strain sensors and detection schemes based on multicritical points

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Ginzburg-Landau Theory: Standard GL methods predict that $U(1)$ superconducting critical temperature always increases under 100 uniaxial stress, contradicting certain experimental observations
2. Neglect of Poisson Effect: Most theoretical work ignores the response of transverse strain to longitudinal external strain
3. Infinite System Assumption: Lack of systematic study of finite-size effects and boundary states

Research Motivation

Through microscopic theoretical calculations including Poisson effects, systematically study the effects of strain on BTRS superconducting states and explore the role of boundary effects in stabilizing the BTRS phase.

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of Complex Strain-Temperature Phase Diagram: Microscopic calculations reveal complex behavior beyond GL theory, including non-monotonic dependence of BTRS transitions
2. Importance of Poisson Ratio Effects: Demonstrates that the Poisson ratio parameter significantly affects critical temperature response to strain, potentially leading to reduced $U(1)$ critical temperature under compressive strain
3. Boundary Stabilization Mechanism: Discovers that boundaries provide additional stabilization for BTRS states, with finite samples exhibiting larger BTRS phase regions than infinite systems
4. Systematic Analysis of Strain Types: Comprehensive analysis of different effects of uniaxial, shear, and isotropic strain on critical temperature separation
5. Persistent Current in Boundary States: Predicts detectable persistent superconducting currents in BTRS boundary states of finite samples

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the critical temperature separation behavior of $U(1)$ superconducting transitions and $\mathbb{Z}_2$ time-reversal symmetry-breaking transitions in $s+id$ superconductors on a square lattice under different types of external stress.

Model Architecture

Basic Hamiltonian

The superconducting gap is expressed as a linear combination of different irreducible representations: $\Delta(k) = \sum_\alpha \Delta_\alpha \gamma_\alpha(k)$

where $\gamma_\alpha(k)$ are basis functions for symmetry $\alpha$.

Self-Consistent Equations

The self-consistent gap equation is: $\Delta_\alpha = \sum_\beta S_{\alpha\beta} \Delta_\beta$

where matrix elements are: $S_{\alpha\beta} = V_\alpha \int_{BZ} \frac{dk'}{S_{BZ}} \gamma_\alpha(k') \gamma_\beta(k') \frac{\tanh(E_{k'}/2T)}{2E_{k'}}$

Strain Effect Modeling

For 100 uniaxial stress, the dispersion relation is: $\xi(k) = -2(1+\delta t)\cos k_x - 2(1-\nu\delta t)\cos k_y - \mu$

where $\delta t$ is the strain-induced change in hopping integral and $\nu$ is Poisson's ratio.

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic Incorporation of Poisson Effects: First systematic study of Poisson ratio effects on BTRS phase diagrams
2. Finite-Size Effects: Development of numerical methods for treating boundary states in finite samples
3. Unified Treatment of Multiple Strain Types: Establishment of unified framework for handling uniaxial, shear, and isotropic strain

Experimental Setup

Model Parameters

• Nearest-neighbor interaction: $V_1 = 2$
• On-site interaction: $V_0 \in [-0.5, 0.5]$
• Poisson ratio range: $\nu \in [0, 1]$
• Strain range: $\delta t \in [-0.2, 0.2]$

Numerical Methods

1. Infinite Systems: Self-consistent iteration for solving coupled integral equations
2. Finite Systems: Fourier transform method for Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations
3. Convergence Criterion: $\max_{\langle r,r' \rangle}|1 - \Delta_{r,r'}(m+1)/\Delta_{r,r'}(m)| < 10^{-7}$

Phase Diagram Criteria

• $U(1)$ Transition: Maximum eigenvalue of matrix $S$ equals 1
• BTRS Transition: Two largest eigenvalues of matrix $S$ both equal 1
• Boundary State Criterion: $\max_r |j(r)| > 0.001 \frac{2e}{\hbar}$

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Strain Dependence of Critical Temperatures

1. Linear Kink Behavior: Linear kinks appear under uniaxial and isotropic strain when $T_c^{U(1)} = T_c^{\mathbb{Z}_2}$ at zero strain; absent under shear strain
2. Poisson Ratio Effects:
   • $\nu \in [0, 0.1]$: $T_c^{U(1)}$ monotonically decreases under compressive strain
   • $\nu \in [0.35, 1]$: $T_c^{U(1)}$ monotonically increases under compressive strain
   • $\nu \in (0.1, 0.35)$: Non-monotonic behavior with initial decrease followed by increase

Complex Behavior of BTRS Phase Diagram

1. Phase Dome Movement:
   • Small Poisson ratio ($\nu = 0$): BTRS dome shifts toward small band filling
   • Large Poisson ratio ($\nu = 1$): BTRS dome shifts toward large band filling
   • Intermediate Poisson ratio ($\nu = 0.3$): Non-monotonic movement first toward small then toward large band filling
2. Non-Monotonic Behavior of $T_c^{\mathbb{Z}_2}$: For $\nu \in (0.25, 0.45)$, $T_c^{\mathbb{Z}_2}$ exhibits non-monotonic dependence, potentially dropping to zero and reappearing

Boundary Effects

Boundary State Stabilization

1. Enlarged BTRS Region: BTRS dome in finite samples is larger than in infinite systems
2. Persistent Current: BTRS boundary states generate detectable persistent superconducting currents
3. Surface Orientation Dependence: 110 surfaces more favorable for BTRS boundary states than 100 surfaces

Finite-Size Phase Diagram

• Boundary BTRS States: Localized boundary BTRS states exist over wide band-filling ranges
• Enhanced Critical Temperature: Boundary critical temperatures exceed bulk values in certain band-filling regions

Case Study

For the specific case $V_1 = 2$, $\nu = 0.3$, $\delta t = 0.1$:

• BTRS phase difference changes from $\pi/2$ (tetragonal system) to $(0, \pi/2)$ (orthorhombic system)
• All gap components are non-zero, indicating mixed-state formation
• Boundary current density reaches $10^{-4} \times 2e/\hbar$ order of magnitude

Related Work

Theoretical Research

1. Ginzburg-Landau Theory: Li et al. (1993) established GL theory framework for mixed-symmetry superconductors
2. Microscopic Theory: O'Donovan and Carbotte (1995) and others developed mixed order parameter theory in BCS models
3. Strain Effects: Fischer and Berg (2016) studied fluctuations and strain effects in chiral p-wave superconductors

Experimental Research

1. Sr₂RuO₄: Grinenko et al. (2021) observed separation of superconducting and time-reversal symmetry-breaking transitions under stress
2. Iron-Based Superconductors: Grinenko et al. (2017, 2020) observed BTRS in ion-irradiated Ba₀.₂₇K₀.₇₃Fe₂As₂
3. This Work's Innovation: First systematic study of Poisson effects on BTRS phase diagrams and discovery of boundary stabilization mechanism

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Beyond GL Theory: Microscopic calculations reveal complex phase diagram behavior unpredictable by GL theory
2. Critical Role of Poisson Ratio: Poisson ratio significantly affects critical temperature response to strain, potentially causing behavior opposite to GL theory predictions
3. Boundary Stabilization: Boundaries provide important stabilization for BTRS phases, expanding their existence regions
4. Distinction of Strain Types: Different strain types (uniaxial, shear, isotropic) have different effects on critical temperature separation

Limitations

1. Single-Band Approximation: Considers only single electron band, potentially overlooking multiband effects
2. Mean-Field Approximation: Neglects quantum fluctuation effects, which may be important near critical points
3. Linear Strain Approximation: Only considers linear strain dependence of hopping integrals
4. Specific Lattice: Studies only square lattice; other lattice structures may exhibit different behavior

Future Directions

1. Fluctuation Effects: Study electronic quadrupole effects in strongly fluctuating systems
2. Multiband Systems: Extension to multiband superconductors
3. Experimental Verification: Design experiments to verify predicted boundary states and persistent currents
4. Device Applications: Explore novel detection schemes based on bicritical points

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Provides microscopic theoretical framework beyond GL theory, revealing rich physical phenomena
2. Systematicity: Comprehensively considers different strain types, Poisson ratio effects, and boundary effects
3. Experimental Relevance: Closely related to experimental observations in Sr₂RuO₄ and similar materials
4. Numerical Rigor: Employs rigorous numerical methods and convergence criteria
5. Novel Discoveries: Reveals non-monotonic behavior of BTRS phase diagrams and boundary stabilization mechanism

Shortcomings

1. Model Simplification: Single-band model may be oversimplified; real materials typically are multiband systems
2. Parameter Dependence: Results strongly depend on material parameters like Poisson ratio, which may have significant uncertainties in real materials
3. Temperature Range: Primarily focuses on behavior near critical temperature; low-temperature phase diagram may be more complex
4. Disorder Effects: Does not consider disorder effects on BTRS phase, which may be important in real materials

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important theoretical foundation for understanding strain-controlled BTRS superconducting states
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers clear theoretical predictions for designing relevant experiments
3. Application Potential: Predicted sensitive strain response applicable to novel sensor design
4. Method Innovation: Developed theoretical methods applicable to other unconventional superconductors

Applicable Scenarios

1. Materials Design: Guide design of new materials with tunable BTRS phases
2. Strain Engineering: Optimize experimental schemes for strain-controlled superconductivity
3. Mesoscopic Devices: Design quantum devices based on BTRS boundary states
4. Basic Research: Deepen understanding of microscopic mechanisms of time-reversal symmetry breaking

References

This paper cites 63 relevant references, covering:

• Theoretical and experimental studies of BTRS superconducting states
• Ginzburg-Landau theory of strain effects
• Experimental observations in Sr₂RuO₄ and iron-based superconductors
• Boundary state theory in finite-size superconductors
• Numerical computation methods and techniques

Key references include experimental work by Grinenko et al. on Sr₂RuO₄, GL theory by Li et al., and various developments in microscopic theoretical methods.

Summary: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that reveals the complex physical picture of strain-controlled BTRS superconducting states through rigorous microscopic theoretical calculations, providing an important theoretical foundation for understanding and controlling unconventional superconductors. The paper's main contributions lie in discovering new physical phenomena beyond existing theoretical frameworks, particularly the important roles of Poisson effects and boundary effects.