Carroll Spinors

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.19426
• Title: Carroll Spinors
• Authors: Daniel Grumiller (TU Wien), Lea Mele (Université de Mons), Luciano Montecchio (TU Wien)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.19426

Abstract

This paper presents a concise summary of key aspects of Carroll spinors, dedicated to the late Professor Dharam Ahluwalia—an intrepid advocate of ELKO spinors. The article reviews the fundamental theory of Carroll spinors and constructs Carroll ELKO spinors for the first time.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Rise of Carroll Symmetry: Carroll symmetry, arising as the Poincaré symmetry in the limit where the speed of light approaches zero, has recently received widespread attention in theoretical physics, particularly in flat space holography and BMS symmetry studies.
2. Extension of Spinor Theory: Traditional Dirac spinors are constructed based on Lorentz symmetry, but spinor theory frameworks must be reconstructed in Carroll spacetime.
3. Carroll Generalization of ELKO Spinors: ELKO (Eigenspinors of the charge conjugation operator) spinors, proposed by Dharam Ahluwalia, are fermionic fields with mass dimension 1. This paper attempts to generalize them to the Carroll case.

Research Motivation

• Perfecting fermionic theory under Carroll symmetry
• Exploring the combination of exotic spacetime symmetries with exotic spinors
• Providing fermionic descriptions for flat space holography
• Commemorating Professor Dharam Ahluwalia's scientific contributions

Core Contributions

1. Systematic review of Carroll spinor theory: Including Carroll-Clifford algebra, electromagnetic-type fermionic theory, charge conjugation and parity transformations, etc.
2. Construction of the Carroll-Ising model: As a free field realization of two-dimensional Carroll conformal field theory
3. First proposal of Carroll ELKO spinors: Constructing eigenspinors of the charge conjugation operator in the four-dimensional case
4. Establishment of Carroll ELKO symmetries: Discovering their invariance under subgroups of SIM(2) in the Carroll contraction
5. Summary of Carroll spinor applications: Covering condensed matter physics, gravitational theory, and superstring theory

Detailed Methodology

Carroll Symmetry Foundations

Carroll spacetime is characterized by a degenerate Carroll metric $h$ and the Carroll vector $v$ in its kernel: $h = h_{\mu\nu} dx^\mu dx^\nu, \quad v = v^\mu \partial_\mu, \quad h_{\mu\nu} v^\nu = 0$

The flat Carroll metric is obtained through the limit of the speed of light $c \to 0$: $\lim_{c \to 0}(-c^2 dt^2 + \delta_{ij} dx^i dx^j) = \delta_{ij} dx^i dx^j = h$

Carroll-Clifford Algebra

The Carroll-Clifford algebra contains two sets of anticommutation relations: $\{γ_a, γ_b\} = 2h_{ab} \mathbf{1}, \quad \{γ^a, γ^b\} = 2V^{ab} \mathbf{1}$

where $V^{ab} = -v^a v^b = \text{diag}(-1, 0)$ (in the two-dimensional case).

A representation in the two-dimensional case is: $γ_0 = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 1 \\ 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \quad γ_1 = \begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0 \\ 0 & -1 \end{pmatrix}$$γ^0 = \begin{pmatrix} i & 0 \\ 0 & -i \end{pmatrix}, \quad γ^1 = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 0 \\ i & 0 \end{pmatrix}$

Electromagnetic-Type Fermionic Theory

Magnetic Carroll Fermions

Action constructed using upper-index gamma matrices: $S = \int d^2x \bar{\Ψ}(iγ^a∂_a - m)Ψ$

Upon expansion: $S = i\int d^2x (ψ_0^* \dot{ψ}_1 + ψ_1^* \dot{ψ}_0 - ψ_0^* ψ_0' - mψ_0^* ψ_1 + mψ_1^* ψ_0)$

where $ψ_1$ acts as a Lagrange multiplier, enforcing the constraint $\dot{ψ}_0 = 0$.

Electric Carroll Fermions

Construction using lower-index gamma matrices: $S = \int d^2x \bar{Ψ}γ_0(-∂_0 - im)Ψ$

Upon expansion, yielding a superlocal action: $S = \int d^2x (iψ_1^* \dot{ψ}_1 - mψ_1^* ψ_1)$

Carroll ELKO Construction

In the four-dimensional case, the charge conjugation operator is defined as $\mathcal{C} = CΛ^T K$, where $C$ is the charge conjugation matrix, $Λ$ is the Carroll adjoint matrix, and $K$ is the complex conjugation operator.

For the representation: $γ_0 = \frac{1}{2}\begin{pmatrix} i\mathbf{1} & \mathbf{1} \\ \mathbf{1} & -i\mathbf{1} \end{pmatrix}, \quad γ_i = \begin{pmatrix} \mathbf{0} & iσ_i \\ -iσ_i & \mathbf{0} \end{pmatrix}$

The charge conjugation matrix is: $C = \begin{pmatrix} \mathbf{0} & A \\ -A & \mathbf{0} \end{pmatrix}$

Carroll ELKO eigenstates are: $λ_± = \begin{pmatrix} φ_0 \\ ∓A φ_0^* \end{pmatrix}, \quad ρ_± = \begin{pmatrix} ∓A φ_1^* \\ φ_1 \end{pmatrix}$

satisfying $\mathcal{C}λ_± = ±λ_±$ and $\mathcal{C}ρ_± = ±ρ_±$.

Experimental Setup

Carroll-Ising Model

As a concrete application, the paper studies massless magnetic Carroll fermions: $S = \int d^2x (ψ_0 \dot{ψ}_1 + ψ_1 \dot{ψ}_0 - ψ_0 ψ_0')$

The equations of motion are: $\dot{ψ}_0 = 0, \quad \dot{ψ}_1 = ψ_0'$

Stress Tensor and Ward Identities

The on-shell stress tensor is: $T_0^0 = -T_1^1 = -\frac{1}{2}ψ_0 ψ_0', \quad T_0^1 = -\frac{1}{2}ψ_1 ψ_0' - \frac{1}{2}ψ_0 ψ_1', \quad T_1^0 = 0$

satisfying conformal Carroll Ward identities.

Experimental Results

CCFT₂ Algebra Realization

Upon quantization, mode operators satisfy the BMS₃ algebra (CCFT₂ algebra): $[L_n, L_m] = (n-m)L_{n+m} + \frac{c_L}{12}n(n^2-1)δ_{n+m,0}$$[L_n, M_m] = (n-m)M_{n+m} + \frac{c_M}{12}n(n^2-1)δ_{n+m,0}$$[M_n, M_m] = 0$

For the Carroll-Ising model, the central charges are $c_L = 1$ and $c_M = 0$.

Relationship with Lorentz Ising Model

By "flipping" the vacuum state, the two Virasoro algebras of the Lorentz Ising model can be contracted to the Carroll-Ising model: $L_n := ℓ_n - \bar{ℓ}_{-n}, \quad M_n := ε(ℓ_n + \bar{ℓ}_{-n})$

The CCFT₂ algebra is recovered in the $ε \to 0$ limit.

Symmetries of Carroll ELKO

Carroll ELKO is not invariant under the complete Carroll group, but rather under a subgroup. When choosing $A = σ_1$, only Carroll boosts in the 1 and 2 directions and spatial rotations about the 3-axis preserve the Carroll ELKO structure.

This is analogous to the invariance of Lorentz ELKO under the SIM(2) subgroup, with the Carroll case corresponding to the Carroll contraction of SIM(2).

Related Work

Carroll Symmetry Research

• Duval, Gibbons, and Horvathy proved the isomorphism between D-dimensional conformal Carroll symmetry and D+1-dimensional BMS symmetry
• Recent Carroll-related research has grown exponentially, with primary applications to flat space holography

ELKO Spinor Theory

• Fermionic fields with mass dimension 1 proposed by Dharam Ahluwalia
• Invariant under the SIM(2) subgroup
• Proposed as a dark matter candidate

Carroll Fermions

• First introduced by Banerjee et al. in two dimensions
• Constructed by Bergshoeff et al. through Carroll contraction
• This paper provides the first systematic review and Carroll ELKO construction

Application Prospects

Condensed Matter Physics

• Flat band systems (e.g., magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene)
• Condensed matter systems exhibiting approximate Carroll behavior

Gravitational Theory

• Near-horizon soft hair excitations
• Fermionic descriptions in flat space holography
• Fermionic realization of BMS₃ symmetry

Superstring Theory

• Carroll structure in tensionless superstrings
• Hagedorn scale physics in the early universe

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully constructed a complete framework for Carroll spinor theory
2. First realization of Carroll ELKO spinors
3. Established the Carroll-Ising model as a free field realization of CCFT₂
4. Revealed profound connections between Carroll theory and multiple physical domains

Limitations

1. Carroll ELKO is not invariant under the complete Carroll group, requiring a preferred direction
2. Specific physical applications of Carroll ELKO remain to be found
3. Systematic classification of certain technical details (such as representation choices and electromagnetic-type choices) remains incomplete

Future Directions

1. Explore physical applications of Carroll ELKO
2. Investigate the role of Bunster-Henneaux conditions in Carroll ELKO
3. Deepen understanding of Carroll ELKO symmetry algebras
4. Generalize ELKO-related problems to the Carroll case

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Systematically constructs a comprehensive framework for Carroll spinor theory
2. Technical Innovation: Successfully constructs Carroll ELKO for the first time with considerable technical sophistication
3. Cross-Disciplinary Connections: Reveals profound connections between Carroll theory and condensed matter, gravity, and superstring theory
4. Commemorative Significance: Effectively continues and develops Professor Ahluwalia's ELKO theory

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applications: Specific physical applications of Carroll ELKO remain unclear
2. Technical Choices: Certain technical choices (such as representations and preferred directions) lack deep physical motivation
3. Symmetry Breaking: Carroll ELKO breaks complete Carroll symmetry

Impact

• Supplements Carroll theory with important fermionic components
• May advance further development of flat space holography
• Provides new tools for studying exotic spacetime symmetries

Applicable Scenarios

• Carroll symmetry applications in theoretical physics research
• Fermionic extensions of flat space holography
• Near-horizon physics and soft hair research
• Flat band physics in condensed matter systems

References

The paper includes 96 references, covering important works in Carroll symmetry, ELKO theory, BMS symmetry, flat space holography, and related fields, providing readers with comprehensive literature guidance.