Scrambling-Enhanced Quantum Battery Charging in Black Hole Analogues

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.23598
• Title: Scrambling-Enhanced Quantum Battery Charging in Black Hole Analogues
• Authors: Zhilong Liu¹, Ying Li¹, Zehua Tian²*, Jieci Wang¹†
• Classification: quant-ph gr-qc
• Publication Date: arXiv:2509.23598v2 quant-ph 10 Oct 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.23598

Abstract

This paper investigates the effects of quantum information scrambling in black hole analogue systems on quantum battery charging processes. The research employs position-dependent XY spin chains as analogues of curved spacetime, exploring how black hole scrambling affects quantum battery charging efficiency through controlled quenches of the scrambling parameter. The study demonstrates that carefully designed differences in scrambling parameters before and after the quench can significantly enhance both the maximum stored energy $E_{\max}$ and peak charging power $P_{\max}$. The optimal charging time $\tau_*$ exhibits minimal dependence on the initial horizon parameter $x_{h0}$ but decreases monotonically with increasing quenched horizon parameter $x_{ht}$, demonstrating an accelerated charging mechanism mediated by spacetime-analogue scrambling dynamics.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Core Problem: How can quantum information scrambling characteristics in black hole systems be exploited to optimize quantum battery charging performance?
2. Technical Challenge: Understanding the relationship between chaotic scrambling dynamics and quantum battery charging efficiency
3. Application Need: Developing more efficient quantum energy storage devices

Significance Analysis

1. Theoretical Importance: Black holes represent the fastest quantum information scramblers in nature; understanding their scrambling mechanisms is crucial for quantum information theory
2. Technical Value: As a key component of quantum technology, quantum battery performance optimization has significant implications for quantum computing, quantum communication, and related fields
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects gravitational physics, quantum information theory, and quantum thermodynamics

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. SYK Model Constraints: In the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, scrambling behavior depends on system size, making independent investigation of chaotic effects difficult
2. Bandwidth Regularization Issues: Traditional methods require complex bandwidth regularization procedures
3. Parameter Control Difficulties: Lack of effective methods for independently controlling scrambling strength

Research Motivation

The unique properties of gravitational analogue systems—where scrambling strength is independent of system size—provide an ideal platform for investigating the effects of chaotic scrambling on quantum battery charging processes.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a quantum battery model based on black hole analogue systems: Utilizing position-dependent XY spin chains to simulate curved spacetime effects
2. Established a scrambling parameter quench protocol: Controlling scrambling strength through horizon parameter adjustment
3. Revealed the scrambling-enhanced charging mechanism: Demonstrating that strong post-quench scrambling ($x_{ht} > x_{h0}$) significantly improves charging performance
4. Provided systematic performance analysis: Quantifying the dependencies of maximum stored energy, peak power, and optimal charging time
5. Validated theoretical predictions: Confirming through numerical calculations the linear relationship between Lyapunov exponent and horizon parameter

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Initial scrambling parameter $x_{h0}$ and quenched scrambling parameter $x_{ht}$Output: Quantum battery charging performance metrics ($E_{\max}$, $P_{\max}$, $\tau_*$) Constraints: Non-commutativity of system Hamiltonian $[H_0, H_t] \neq 0$

Model Architecture

1. Gravitational Analogue System

Based on the line element of 1+1 dimensional black hole spacetime: $ds^2 = -f(x)dt^2 + \frac{1}{f(x)}dx^2$

where the metric function is: $f(x) = x^2(1 - x_h/x)$

2. XY Spin Chain Hamiltonian

$H_{XY} = \sum_{n=1}^L \left[-\kappa_n(\sigma_n^x\sigma_{n-1}^x + \sigma_n^y\sigma_{n-1}^y) - \mu\sigma_n^z\right]$

where the hopping interaction strength is: $\kappa_n = \frac{f[(n-\frac{1}{2})d]}{4d}$

3. Quench Protocol

The system Hamiltonian evolves in time as: $H_{sys}(t) = H_0 + \lambda(t)(H_1 - H_0)$

The time-dependent hopping parameter: $\kappa_n(t) = \kappa_n^{(0)} + \lambda(t)(\kappa_n^{(1)} - \kappa_n^{(0)})$

where $\lambda(t) = \Theta(\tau - t)\Theta(t)$ is the Heaviside step function.

4. Performance Metrics

• Stored Energy: $\Delta E = \langle H_0 \rangle_t - \langle H_0 \rangle_0$
• Maximum Stored Energy: $E_{\max} \equiv \max_t \Delta E(t)$
• Maximum Charging Power: $P_{\max} \equiv \max_\tau P(\tau)$, where $P(\tau) \equiv \Delta E(\tau)/\tau$
• Optimal Charging Time: $\tau_* = \arg\max_\tau P(\tau)$

Technical Innovations

1. Independent Scrambling Control

Unlike the SYK model, scrambling behavior in this system is entirely determined by the hopping interaction distribution, independent of system size, enabling precise control of chaotic effects.

2. Parameterized Scrambling Strength

Direct control of the Lyapunov exponent through the horizon parameter $x_h$: $\lambda_L = \frac{x_h}{2}$

3. Dual-Parameter Optimization Strategy

Fine-tuning charging performance through selection of the $(x_{h0}, x_{ht})$ parameter pair.

Experimental Setup

Numerical Computation Parameters

• System Size: L = 250 (primary calculations)
• Parameter Range: $x_{h0}, x_{ht} \in [0, 5]$
• Metric Function: $f(x) = x^2(1 - x_h/x)$
• Initial State: System ground state $|\psi(0)\rangle = |0\rangle$

Evaluation Metrics

1. Maximum Stored Energy ($E_{\max}$): Maximum energy the system can store
2. Maximum Charging Power ($P_{\max}$): Peak power during the charging process
3. Optimal Charging Time ($\tau_*$): Time required to achieve maximum power

Verification Methods

1. OTOC Calculation: Verifying chaotic behavior through out-of-time-order correlators
2. Linear Fitting: Confirming the linear relationship between Lyapunov exponent and horizon parameter
3. Nested Commutator Analysis: Investigating the effects of higher-order terms on scrambling propagation

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Lyapunov Exponent Verification

Numerically computed Lyapunov exponents show excellent agreement with theoretical predictions:

• Fitting Slope: 0.992 ± 0.032
• Coefficient of Determination: R² = 0.9957
• Theoretical Value: $\lambda_{fit} = x_h$

2. Maximum Stored Energy Analysis

• Near the diagonal ($x_{h0} = x_{ht}$), stored energy approaches zero, consistent with expectations from $[H_0, H_t] = 0$
• $E_{\max}$ increases monotonically with parameter difference $|\Delta x_h| = |x_{ht} - x_{h0}|$
• Superior energy storage performance observed in the $x_{ht} > x_{h0}$ region

3. Charging Power Optimization

• Maximum charging power is significantly enhanced in the $x_{ht} > x_{h0}$ region
• Peak charging power is achieved when $x_{h0}$ is small and $x_{ht}$ is large
• Power enhancement effects are more pronounced than energy storage enhancement

4. Charging Time Compression

• Optimal charging time $\tau_*$ is nearly insensitive to initial parameter $x_{h0}$
• $\tau_*$ decreases monotonically with increasing $x_{ht}$
• Strong post-quench scrambling achieves charging acceleration

System Size Effects

• With increasing system size, both maximum charging power and optimal charging time decrease
• Larger systems possess broader energy bandwidth and larger Hilbert space
• Boundary effects become more pronounced in larger systems

Nested Commutator Analysis

Higher-order nested commutators $\|[H,W]_k\|$ (k = 3,4,5,6) exhibit exponential growth with scrambling strength, confirming the enhanced complexity of scrambling propagation mechanisms.

Related Work

Quantum Battery Research

1. Dicke Model: Superextensive power scaling proposed by Ferraro et al.
2. SYK Model: Chaotic scrambling effects studied by Rossini et al.
3. Spin Chain Models: Many-body quantum batteries by Le et al.
4. Cavity QED Architecture: Various hybrid quantum systems

Gravitational Analogue Systems

1. AdS/CFT Correspondence: Curved spacetime simulations by Yang et al.
2. Superconducting Experiments: On-chip black hole simulations by Shi et al.
3. Ion Trap Platforms: MSS bound verification by Tian et al.

Quantum Chaos Theory

1. MSS Bound: Maldacena-Shenker-Stanford chaos bound
2. OTOC Diagnostics: Chaos criterion using out-of-time-order correlators
3. Butterfly Effect: Global propagation of local perturbations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Scrambling Enhancement Mechanism: Quantum scrambling in black hole analogue systems significantly improves quantum battery charging performance
2. Parameter Optimization Strategy: Strong post-quench scrambling ($x_{ht} > x_{h0}$) is key to achieving efficient charging
3. Time Compression Effect: Increased scrambling strength leads to compression of optimal charging time
4. Size Independence: Scrambling behavior is independent of system size, facilitating parameter control

Limitations

1. Finite-Size Effects: Boundary effects may influence scrambling propagation in large systems
2. Bandwidth Regularization: Enforced bandwidth regularization reduces effective scrambling parameters
3. Experimental Implementation: Requires precise control of position-dependent hopping interactions
4. Long-Time Behavior: Long-term stability of scrambling dynamics requires further investigation

Future Directions

1. Experimental Verification: Implementation of this charging protocol on superconducting quantum processors
2. Higher-Dimensional Extensions: Investigating charging performance in higher-dimensional black hole analogues
3. Open Systems: Considering environmental dissipation effects on scrambling-enhanced charging
4. Machine Learning Optimization: Utilizing reinforcement learning for further charging strategy optimization

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First combination of black hole scrambling theory with quantum batteries, opening new research directions
2. Method Uniqueness: Exploiting the size-independent scrambling characteristics of gravitational analogues enables precise parameter control
3. Result Convincingness: Excellent agreement between numerical results and theoretical predictions validates model effectiveness
4. Interdisciplinary Value: Connects gravitational physics, quantum information, and quantum thermodynamics

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Feasibility: Precise implementation of position-dependent hopping interactions presents experimental challenges
2. Limited Finite-Size Discussion: Relatively limited discussion of boundary effects
3. Energy Retention Analysis: Lacks analysis of energy retention capability after charging
4. Insufficient Comparative Analysis: Systematic comparison with other quantum battery charging protocols is incomplete

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new physical mechanisms and optimization strategies for quantum battery theory
2. Practical Value: Offers guidance for future quantum energy storage device design
3. Methodological Significance: Demonstrates the application potential of gravitational analogues in quantum technology
4. Inspirational Effect: May stimulate further research on applications of chaotic dynamics in quantum technology

Application Scenarios

1. Quantum Computing: Efficient energy management solutions for quantum processors
2. Quantum Communication: Rapid energy transfer and storage in quantum networks
3. Quantum Sensing: Stable energy supply for quantum sensors
4. Fundamental Research: Ideal platform for studying quantum chaos and quantum thermodynamics

References

Key References

1. Maldacena, J., Shenker, S. H., & Stanford, D. (2016). A bound on chaos. JHEP, 08, 106.
2. Yang, R.-Q., et al. (2020). Simulating quantum field theory in curved spacetime with quantum many-body systems. Phys. Rev. Res., 2, 023107.
3. Rossini, D., et al. (2020). Quantum advantage in the charging process of Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev batteries. Phys. Rev. Lett., 125, 236402.
4. Shi, Y.-H., et al. (2023). Quantum simulation of Hawking radiation and curved spacetime with a superconducting on-chip black hole. Nature Commun., 14, 3263.

Summary: By ingeniously combining black hole physics and quantum battery theory, this paper proposes a novel quantum battery charging mechanism enhanced by scrambling. The research is theoretically significant and provides new perspectives and methods for the future development of quantum energy storage technology.