Residual Symmetries and BRST Cohomology of Schwarzschild in the Kerr-Schild Double Copy

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.24112
• Title: Residual Symmetries and BRST Cohomology of Schwarzschild in the Kerr-Schild Double Copy
• Author: Brandon Holton (Durham University)
• Classification: hep-th gr-qc math-ph math.MP
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.24112

Abstract

The Kerr-Schild (KS) double copy is renowned for generating exact gravitational spacetimes from gauge fields, yet the preservation of symmetry content remains largely unexplored. This paper investigates the fate of residual symmetries in the KS double copy, with focus on the Schwarzschild solution. On the gauge theory side, the author derives residual transformations preserving both abelian and non-abelian KS ansätze, finding that they form infinite-dimensional Lie algebras parametrized by arbitrary null functions. On the gravitational side, the corresponding residual diffeomorphisms of the KS Schwarzschild metric are analyzed. Restricting focus to the Killing vector class of solutions, the author finds that the only surviving diffeomorphisms are the finite-dimensional global isometries of Schwarzschild, reducing the residual gauge algebra to the subalgebra generated by time translations and spatial rotations. This discovery reveals a fundamental structural mismatch: the infinite-dimensional algebra on the gauge side has no straightforward counterpart in this constrained gravitational sector.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The central question addressed by this research is: Does the Kerr-Schild double copy preserve the underlying residual symmetry structure when mapping classical field configurations?

Research Significance

1. Completeness of Double Copy Theory: Although the KS double copy is highly successful in generating exact black hole geometries, the absence of analysis regarding symmetry preservation limits our understanding of the deep structure of this correspondence.
2. Quantum Field Theory Consistency: In the convolution double copy, BRST invariance ensures that residual symmetries can be consistently lifted to diffeomorphisms in gravity, preserving algebraic structure. However, no analogous proof exists for the KS double copy.
3. Theoretical Physics Foundations: Understanding the symmetry mapping between gauge theory and gravity is crucial for constructing a unified quantum gravity theory.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

1. Convolution Double Copy: While algebraically transparent and preserving BRST invariance, it can only produce linearized solutions and cannot generate fully nonlinear geometries.
2. KS Double Copy: Capable of producing exact classical solutions, but its behavior at the residual symmetry level remains unknown, raising questions about structural completeness.

Research Motivation

The author's motivation stems from the need to systematically verify whether the KS double copy truly preserves symmetry structure, which is crucial for understanding the applicability and limitations of this theory.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic derivation of residual symmetries on the gauge theory side: Complete analysis of abelian and non-abelian gauge transformations preserving the KS ansatz, establishing their infinite-dimensional Lie algebra structure.
2. Solution of residual diffeomorphisms for Schwarzschild spacetime: Proves that residual diffeomorphisms in the Killing vector sector are only the global isometries of Schwarzschild.
3. Discovery of structural mismatch: Reveals fundamental incompatibility between the infinite-dimensional residual algebra of gauge theory and the finite-dimensional algebra on the gravitational side.
4. Establishment of BRST formalism framework: Constructs a consistent ghost field sector and nilpotent charge, proving that under Killing conditions, residual symmetry algebras have only trivial realization in cohomology.
5. Provision of quantum consistency verification: BRST analysis verifies consistency within the quantum field theory framework of kinematic algebra reduction.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

The research task is defined as: given gauge fields and metrics in Kerr-Schild ansatz form, analyze residual transformations preserving this form and compare the symmetry algebra structures between gauge theory and gravitational theory.

Theoretical Framework

Kerr-Schild Ansatz

The metric takes the KS form: $g_{\mu\nu} = \eta_{\mu\nu} + \phi k_\mu k_\nu$

where $\eta_{\mu\nu}$ is the background metric, $\phi$ is a scalar field, and $k_\mu$ is a null vector: $k_\mu k^\mu = 0$.

The gauge field takes analogous form: $A_\mu = \Phi(x) k_\mu$

Residual Symmetry Conditions

• Gauge theory side: Requires gauge transformation $\delta_\lambda A_\mu = \partial_\mu \lambda(x)$ to preserve KS structure
• Gravitational side: Requires diffeomorphism $\mathcal{L}_\xi g_{\mu\nu} \propto k_\mu k_\nu$ to preserve KS form

Solution Strategy

Gauge Theory Analysis

1. Abelian case: Solve constraint equation $k^\mu \partial_\mu \lambda(x) = 0$
2. Non-abelian case: Handle self-interaction terms containing structure constants
3. Algebraic structure: Analyze Lie brackets of transformations and induced algebra

Gravitational Theory Analysis

1. PDE system decomposition: Decompose Lie derivative conditions into angular, radial-temporal, and mixed subsystems
2. Killing sector restriction: Focus on Killing vectors of the two-sphere rather than conformal Killing vectors
3. Sequential solution: Solve each subsystem sequentially and impose consistency conditions

Technical Innovations

1. Characteristic line method: Employs characteristic line method to solve PDEs with null vector constraints
2. Hierarchical solution strategy: Decomposes complex gravitational PDE systems into tractable subproblems
3. BRST formalism: First construction of BRST operator for residual symmetries in KS double copy
4. Algebraic comparison framework: Establishes systematic method for comparing gauge and gravitational symmetry algebras

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Framework

The paper employs pure theoretical analysis methods, verifying results through:

1. Analytical solution: Complete analytical solution of all PDE systems
2. Consistency verification: Verification of solution self-consistency and boundary conditions
3. Algebraic verification: Confirmation of Lie algebra structure correctness
4. BRST nilpotency: Rigorous proof of BRST operator nilpotency

Coordinate System Choice

• Spherical coordinates: $(t, r, \vartheta, \varphi)$ as primary working coordinates
• Null vector form: $k_\mu = (1, 1, 0, 0)$ in spherical coordinates
• Metric convention: Mostly-plus signature $(-,+,+,+)$

Main Results

Gauge Theory Side Results

Abelian Case

Residual gauge parameters must satisfy: $\lambda(x) = f(u), \quad u = t - r$

forming an infinite-dimensional abelian Lie algebra: $g_{res} \sim C^\infty(\mathbb{R})$

Non-abelian Case

Residual transformations form a current algebra: $g_{res} \sim \mathfrak{g} \otimes C^\infty(\mathbb{R})$

where $\mathfrak{g}$ is the Lie algebra of the gauge group.

Gravitational Theory Side Results

Killing Sector Reduction

Under Killing vector restriction, residual diffeomorphisms completely reduce to global isometries of Schwarzschild:

• Time translation: $\partial_t$
• Spatial rotations: $SO(3)$ generators

forming a finite-dimensional Lie algebra: $g_{gravity} \sim so(3) \oplus \mathbb{R}$

Structural Mismatch

A fundamental dimensional mismatch is discovered:

• Gauge side: infinite-dimensional algebra $C^\infty(\mathbb{R})$ or $\mathfrak{g} \otimes C^\infty(\mathbb{R})$
• Gravitational side: finite-dimensional algebra $so(3) \oplus \mathbb{R}$

BRST Analysis Results

Nilpotency Proof

The constructed BRST operator $Q$ satisfies: $Q^2 = 0$

on both fields and ghost fields.

Trivial Cohomology

In the Killing sector: $Q g_{\mu\nu} = 0, \quad Q\phi = 0, \quad Q k_\mu = 0$

indicating no non-trivial BRST cohomology associated with residual symmetries beyond global isometries.

Related Work

Double Copy Theory Development

1. KLT Relations: Kawai-Lewellen-Tye relations from string theory provide the foundation
2. BCJ Duality: Bern-Carrasco-Johansson color-kinematics duality
3. Classical Extensions: Extensions to classical field configurations, including self-dual, convolution, and KS double copies

KS Double Copy Applications

• Schwarzschild-Coulomb Correspondence: Classical point charge to black hole mapping
• Kerr Geometry: Double copy construction of rotating black holes
• Other Exact Solutions: Generation of various black hole and spacetime geometries

Symmetry Studies

• BRST Formalism: Successful applications in convolution double copy
• Isometry Studies: Work by Coll et al. on relationships between KS vector fields and isometry algebras

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Confirmation of Algebraic Mismatch: In the Killing sector, the KS double copy exhibits clear symmetry algebra mismatch, with the infinite-dimensional residual symmetries of gauge theory reducing to finite-dimensional global isometries on the gravitational side.
2. BRST Consistency: Despite the algebraic mismatch, BRST analysis confirms that this reduction is consistent within the quantum field theory framework.
3. Limitations of Double Copy: The KS double copy excels at mapping exact field configurations but is not strictly symmetry-preserving at the residual symmetry level.

Limitations

1. Killing Sector Restriction: This paper only analyzes the Killing vector sector; complete conformal Killing vector analysis is deferred to future work.
2. Single Solution Analysis: Only the Schwarzschild solution is considered; symmetry behavior for other KS geometries may differ.
3. Classical Level: Analysis is primarily conducted at the classical level; quantum effects may introduce additional complexity.

Future Directions

1. Conformal Killing Vector Analysis: Complete systematic analysis of proper CKV solutions in subsequent papers.
2. Kerr Geometry Extension: Extend analysis to rotating spacetimes such as Kerr metric.
3. Other Double Copy Frameworks: Investigate whether other double copy formalisms better preserve symmetry structure.
4. Quantum Effects: Explore the impact of quantum corrections on symmetry mappings.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: The paper provides complete mathematical derivations with all calculations thoroughly verified.
2. Important Discovery: First systematic revelation of KS double copy limitations at the symmetry level, representing significant progress in the field.
3. Methodological Innovation: Introduction of BRST formalism provides new theoretical tools for KS double copy research.
4. Clear Structure: Well-organized paper with clear logical progression from gauge theory to gravitational theory analysis.

Weaknesses

1. Scope Limitation: Only considers the Killing sector, potentially missing important aspects of the complete picture.
2. Physical Interpretation: Insufficient discussion of deeper physical reasons for the algebraic mismatch.
3. Practical Impact: Limited analysis of how this mismatch affects practical applications of the KS double copy.

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important theoretical insights for double copy theory development.
2. Methodological Value: Established analytical framework applicable to research on other KS geometries.
3. Future Research Guidance: Clearly indicates future research directions, particularly the necessity of CKV analysis.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Provides important reference for theoretical physicists studying deep connections between gauge theory and gravity.
2. Mathematical Physics: Valuable for mathematical physicists studying Lie algebras, differential geometry, and BRST cohomology.
3. Black Hole Physics: Provides theoretical foundation for black hole physics and double copy applications research.

References

The paper cites 41 important references covering the main development of double copy theory, including:

• Original KLT relations work 32
• Establishment of BCJ duality 12-14
• Pioneering work on KS double copy 36, 37
• Mathematical foundations of BRST theory 28
• Related geometric and symmetry studies 23, 15, 38, 40

This paper provides important theoretical foundation for understanding the symmetry properties of the KS double copy. While revealing certain limitations, it also opens new directions for future research. Its rigorous mathematical analysis and innovative BRST methodology make it a significant contribution to the field.