Information Loss and Cost in Symmetry Breaking

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.24625
• Title: Information Loss and Cost in Symmetry Breaking
• Authors: J. Molina-Vilaplana (Universidad Politécnica de Cartagena), G. Sierra, H.C.-Zhang (Instituto de Física Teórica, UAM-CSIC)
• Classification: quant-ph hep-th math-ph math.MP
• Publication Date: October 9, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.24625

Abstract

This paper establishes an algebraic and information-theoretic framework to characterize symmetry breaking of generalized non-invertible symmetries in two-dimensional space. Symmetry reduction is modeled within subfactor theory, where condensable Frobenius algebras play the role of subgroups in the categorical setting. This perspective naturally connects to the description of anyon condensation in topological matter phases. The core of the approach involves coarse-graining maps or conditional expectations, which act as quantum channels to project observables from phases with higher symmetry to phases where condensation partially or completely breaks the symmetry. By employing relative entropy as an entropy order parameter, the information loss induced by condensation is quantified, and universal bounds controlled by the Jones index—equal to the quantum dimension of the condensate—are established.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Rise of Generalized Symmetries: Recent studies of generalized global symmetries (including non-invertible symmetries) in quantum field theory have emphasized the importance of extended topological operators that realize these symmetries. These symmetries are controlled by fusion categories, transcending traditional group actions.
2. Complexity of Symmetry Breaking: In theories with topological order and non-abelian anyon excitations, the traditional concept of subgroups no longer applies, making the characterization of symmetry-broken phases complex. New mathematical tools are needed to describe the breaking patterns of these generalized symmetries.
3. Importance of Anyon Condensation: In topologically ordered systems, anyon condensation is a fundamental process through which certain anyons condense to form a new vacuum, leading to changes in topological order.

Research Motivation

The core motivation of this paper is to establish a unified framework to:

• Describe the breaking patterns of generalized symmetries
• Quantify information loss in the symmetry breaking process
• Connect operator algebras, tensor category theory, and quantum information theory

Core Contributions

1. Established an Algebraic-Information-Theoretic Unified Framework: Combined subfactor theory with quantum information theory to study generalized symmetry breaking.
2. Introduced Entropy Order Parameter: Defined an entropy order parameter based on quantum relative entropy to quantify information loss in symmetry breaking.
3. Established Universal Bounds: Proved that the universal upper bound on information loss is controlled by the Jones index: $S_A(\rho|\tilde{\rho}) \leq \log \lambda$.
4. Provided Explicit Implementations: Gave explicit constructions of conditional expectations and lifting maps via Kraus operators.
5. Validated the Theoretical Framework: Verified the validity of the theory through concrete examples including $\mathbb{Z}_N$ groups, toric code, and Rep($S_3$).

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the transition from high-symmetry phase $\mathcal{A}$ to symmetry-broken phase $\mathcal{T}$ in the anyon condensation process, quantifying the information loss in this process.

Theoretical Framework

1. Subfactor Theory Foundations

• Subfactor Inclusion: $\mathcal{T} \subset \mathcal{A}$, where $\mathcal{A}$ describes the uncondensed phase and $\mathcal{T}$ describes the condensed phase
• Jones Index: $\lambda = [\mathcal{A} : \mathcal{T}] = q$ (quantum dimension of the condensate)
• Conditional Expectation: $\varepsilon_A: \mathcal{A} \to \mathcal{T}$ implements the restriction map

2. Mathematical Description of Anyon Condensation

Restriction Map (condensation process): $a \to \sum_{t \in \mathcal{T}} n_a^t t, \quad \forall a \in \mathcal{A}$

Lifting Map (inverse process): $t \to \sum_{a \in \mathcal{A}} n_a^t a, \quad \forall t \in \mathcal{T}$

where $n_a^t$ are branching coefficients satisfying quantum dimension consistency conditions: $d_a = \sum_{t \in \mathcal{T}} n_a^t d_t$$d_t = \frac{1}{q} \sum_{a \in \mathcal{A}} n_a^t d_a$

3. Quantum Channel Implementation

Kraus Representation of Conditional Expectation: $\varepsilon_A(\rho) = \sum_{a \in \mathcal{A}} K_a \rho K_a^\dagger$

where Kraus operators are defined as: $K_a = \sum_{t \in \mathcal{T}} \sqrt{n_a^t} \sqrt{\frac{d_t}{d_a}} \Lambda_{t,a}$

Lifting Map: $\tilde{\rho} = \alpha(\rho_A) = \sum_{a \in \mathcal{A}} L_a \varepsilon_A(\rho) L_a^\dagger$

where: $L_a = \sum_{t \in \mathcal{T}} \sqrt{\frac{n_a^t}{\lambda}} \sqrt{\frac{d_a}{d_t}} \Lambda_{a,t}$

Technical Innovations

1. Unified Perspective: First unifies gauging and anyon condensation under the same algebraic structure.
2. Explicit Construction: Provides explicit Kraus representations of conditional expectations and lifting maps.
3. Information-Theoretic Quantification: Introduces relative entropy as an order parameter to quantify the degree of symmetry breaking.
4. Universal Bounds: Establishes information loss upper bounds related to the Jones index.

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

The paper validates the theoretical framework through three concrete examples:

1. Abelian Group $\mathbb{Z}_N$: Validates basic concepts as the simplest example
2. Toric Code: Demonstrates application in concrete topological models
3. Rep($S_3$): Shows complex behavior in the non-abelian case

Evaluation Metrics

Relative Entropy Order Parameter: $S_A(\rho|\tilde{\rho}) = \sum_{a \in \mathcal{A}} p_a \log \frac{p_a}{\tilde{p}_a}$

where $p_a = \text{tr}(\rho \Pi_a)$ and $\tilde{p}_a = \text{tr}(\tilde{\rho} \Pi_a)$.

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Results for $\mathbb{Z}_N$ Group

For Lagrangian algebra $A = \sum_r r$:

• Jones index: $\lambda = |G| = N$
• Relative entropy: $S_A(\rho|\tilde{\rho}) = \log N - H(p)$
• Order parameter vanishes in the symmetric phase $p_r = 1/N$

2. Results for Toric Code

For condensation algebra $A = 1 + Y$:

• Jones index: $\lambda = 2$
• Relative entropy: $S_A(\rho|\tilde{\rho}) = \log 2 - H(p) - (p_1 + p_Y)\log(p_1 + p_Y) - (p_X + p_Z)\log(p_X + p_Z)$

Specific examples:

• $\{p\} = \{1/2, 1/2, 0, 0\} \Rightarrow S_A = 0$
• $\{p\} = \{1/2, 0, 0, 1/2\} \Rightarrow S_A = \log 2$

3. Results for Rep($S_3$)

Demonstrates three distinct condensation patterns:

• $A = 1 + X$: $\lambda = 2$, $\mathcal{T} \sim \text{Vec}(\mathbb{Z}_3)$
• $A = 1 + Y$: $\lambda = 3$, $\mathcal{T} \sim \text{Vec}(\mathbb{Z}_2)$
• $A = 1 + X + 2Y$: $\lambda = 6$, $\mathcal{T} \sim \text{Vec}(\mathbb{C})$ (Lagrangian algebra)

Key Findings

1. Verification of Universal Bounds: All examples satisfy $S_A(\rho|\tilde{\rho}) \leq \log \lambda$
2. Characterization of Symmetric Phases: The order parameter vanishes when the initial state has a "symmetric" distribution
3. Perturbative Behavior: For small perturbations $\delta p_r \ll 1$, the order parameter behaves as $S_A \sim \sum_r (\delta p_r)^2$

Related Work

Main Research Areas

1. Generalized Symmetry Theory: Foundational work by Gaiotto et al. establishing the basis of generalized global symmetries
2. SymTFT Framework: Characterizing symmetries through higher-dimensional topological field theory
3. Anyon Condensation Theory: Mathematical foundations established by Bais-Slingerland et al.
4. Operator Algebra Methods: Applications of von Neumann algebra theory in quantum field theory

Innovations of This Paper

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to:

• Combine subfactor theory with quantum information theory
• Provide quantitative descriptions of information loss
• Establish universal entropy bounds

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Unified Framework: Successfully established a unified algebraic-information-theoretic framework for describing generalized symmetry breaking
2. Quantitative Description: Relative entropy provides a quantitative measure of the degree of symmetry breaking
3. Universal Bounds: The Jones index provides a universal upper bound on information loss
4. Practical Application: The framework is validated in multiple concrete examples

Limitations

1. Dimensional Constraints: Current framework primarily applies to finite-dimensional cases
2. Abelian Assumptions: Some constructions assume abelian algebra structures
3. Complete Phase Transitions: Does not fully describe complete topological phase transitions from $\mathcal{A}$ to deconfined phases $\mathcal{U}$

Future Directions

1. Higher-Dimensional Extensions: Extend to type II/III von Neumann algebras
2. Experimental Verification: Test the relative entropy order parameter in lattice realizations of topological phases
3. SymTFT Connection: Establish connections with symmetric topological field theory invariants
4. Anomaly Studies: Explore interactions between condensation, anomalies, and entropy

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First to establish deep connections between subfactor theory and quantum information theory
2. Mathematical Rigor: Provides a complete mathematical framework with rigorous proofs
3. Practical Value: Provides computable entropy order parameters and universal bounds
4. Rich Examples: Validates the theory through multiple concrete examples
5. Interdisciplinary: Successfully connects operator algebras, tensor categories, and quantum information

Weaknesses

1. Complexity: The mathematical framework is relatively complex, potentially limiting broader applications
2. Experimental Verification: Lacks experimental verification in real physical systems
3. Computational Complexity: Relevant computations may become difficult for large systems

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for generalized symmetry research
2. Methodological Value: Demonstrates how to apply abstract mathematical theory to concrete physical problems
3. Future Development: Lays the foundation for further research in related fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Topological Quantum Computing: Understanding the impact of anyon condensation on quantum information processing
2. Condensed Matter Theory: Studying topological phase transitions and symmetry breaking
3. Quantum Field Theory: Analyzing breaking patterns of non-invertible symmetries
4. Mathematical Physics: Exploring connections between operator algebras and physics

References

The paper includes 61 references spanning from foundational von Neumann algebra theory to cutting-edge generalized symmetry research, reflecting the interdisciplinary nature and theoretical depth of this work. Key references include Jones's original work on subfactor theory, Gaiotto et al.'s generalized symmetry theory, and Araki's relative entropy theory.