Strong-coupling superconductivity near Gross-Neveu quantum criticality in Dirac systems

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.25318
• Title: Strong-coupling superconductivity near Gross-Neveu quantum criticality in Dirac systems
• Authors: Veronika C. Stangier (Karlsruhe Institute of Technology), Daniel E. Sheehy (Louisiana State University), Jörg Schmalian (Karlsruhe Institute of Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Strongly Correlated Electron Systems), cond-mat.supr-con (Superconductivity), hep-th (High Energy Physics Theory)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.25318

Abstract

This paper investigates the coupling of two-dimensional massless Dirac fermions near the charge neutrality point to bosonic modes via Yukawa interactions. The authors explore a striking possibility: whether a system with no charge carriers at zero temperature can still exhibit superconductivity. The study reveals that superconductivity emerges near Gross-Neveu quantum criticality, provided that fermions no longer behave as well-defined quasiparticles—that is, when their anomalous dimension in the normal state becomes sufficiently large. In other words, well-defined fermions do not superconduct, while ill-defined fermions do. The authors analyze four bosonic modes with different symmetries, each capable of driving normal-state criticality, with three cases producing distinct superconducting phases.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of Dirac Materials: Two-dimensional gapless Dirac materials occupy a central position in condensed matter physics, including monolayer graphene, twisted bilayer graphene, twisted bilayer WSe₂, and other systems.
2. Gross-Neveu Criticality: Under strong coupling conditions, Gross-Neveu (GN) quantum criticality has attracted widespread attention. At the GN critical point, fermions spontaneously acquire mass due to spontaneous symmetry breaking.
3. Superconducting Mechanisms: Traditional superconductivity theory primarily focuses on quasiparticle pairing near the Fermi surface, with limited understanding of superconducting mechanisms in carrier-free systems.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Challenge: To explore whether Dirac systems near the charge neutrality point without charge carriers can exhibit superconductivity.
2. Strong-Coupling Physics: To investigate strong-coupling Dirac fluid physics using an SYK-inspired framework.
3. Material Relevance: To provide theoretical guidance for experimental systems such as twisted materials.

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of Superconducting Critical Conditions: Determines that superconductivity requires the fermion anomalous dimension η_ψ to exceed a critical value η_ψ^c ≈ 0.14628.
2. Establishment of "Ill-defined Quasiparticle Superconductivity" Concept: Demonstrates that well-defined fermions do not superconduct, while ill-defined fermions do.
3. Systematic Analysis of Four Pairing Mechanisms: Provides complete analysis of four distinct Yukawa coupling matrices, finding that three can produce superconductivity.
4. Provision of Algebraic Criteria: Offers concise algebraic conditions for determining pairing possibilities in arbitrary Dirac theories.
5. Phase Fluctuation Analysis: Demonstrates that although phase fluctuations are strong, they do not destroy the superconducting state.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

To investigate superconducting instabilities in two-dimensional massless Dirac fermion systems near the Gross-Neveu critical point, with inputs being the system's Yukawa coupling parameters and fermion-boson interactions, and outputs being the superconducting transition temperature and pairing state symmetry.

Model Architecture

Fundamental Hamiltonian

The system's Hamiltonian is:

H = v_F ∑_l ∫ d²x ψ†_l(x)(-i∇)·α ψ_l(x) 
    + (1/2) ∑_s ∫ d²x [π²_s(x) + ω²_0 φ²_s(x) + v²_B (∇φ_s(x))²]
    + (1/N) ∑_lms ∫ d²x [g_lm,s ψ†_l(x)Υψ_m(x)φ_s(x) + h.c.]

Where:

• ψ_l(x) is a four-component Dirac spinor
• φ_s(x) is a scalar bosonic field
• Υ is the coupling matrix with four possible choices

Large N,M Saddle-Point Method

1. Bilocal Field Introduction: Define normal and pairing correlation functions

   G(x,x') = (1/N) ∑_l ψ_l(x) ⊙ ψ†_l(x')
   F(x,x') = (1/N) ∑_l ψ_l(x) ⊙ (ψ_l(x')u_T)
   D(x,x') = (1/M) ∑_s φ_s(x)φ_s(x')
   

2. Saddle-Point Equations: Self-consistent equations in the large N,M limit

   Σ(x) = g² (M/N) Υ_i G(x)Υ_i D(x)
   Φ(x) = -τ_i g² (M/N) Υ_i F(x)Υ_i D(x)
   

Technical Innovations

1. SYK-Inspired Framework: Employs the random coupling large-N method proposed by Kim et al., enabling controlled investigation of the strong-coupling regime.
2. Anomalous Dimension Control: Controls the fermion anomalous dimension through the M/N ratio, achieving the range 0 < η_ψ < 1/2.
3. Spherical Harmonic Expansion: Expands the pairing wave function in spherical harmonics, converting integral equations into solvable form.
4. Algebraic Criteria: Proposes three algebraic conditions to determine pairing possibilities:
   • Γ^r_J, α_i = 0 (i=1,2)
   • Γ^r_J Υ_i = τ Υ_i Γ^r_J
   • (Γ_J u_T)^T = -Γ_J u_T

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Calculation Framework

1. Parameter Range: Anomalous dimension η_ψ ∈ (0, 0.5), corresponding to M/N from 0 to ∞
2. Critical Coupling: Determines critical pairing strength λ^c_p through integral equations
3. Angular Momentum Analysis: Systematically analyzes pairing states with different angular momenta l=0,1,2, etc.

Evaluation Metrics

1. Superconducting Transition Temperature: T_c/Λ as the primary metric
2. Critical Anomalous Dimension: η^c_ψ ≈ 0.14628
3. Pairing Strength: Ratio of λ_p to λ^c_p

Comparative Analysis

1. Four Coupling Matrices: Υ₁ = γ⁰, Υ₂ = iγ⁰γ³, Υ₃ = iγ¹γ², Υ₄ = iγ⁰γ⁵
2. Different Pairing Channels: Scalar (S), Vector (V), Tensor (T), Axial-Vector (A), Pseudoscalar (P)

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Superconducting Emergence Conditions:
   • Superconductivity appears only when η_ψ > η^c_ψ ≈ 0.14628
   • Corresponds to a critical ratio M/N ≈ 0.85
2. Pairing State Analysis:
   • Υ₁ (γ⁰): Produces scalar pairing, Φ(P) ∼ P^(-1/2-η_ψ±iδ) × 1
   • Υ₂ (iγ⁰γ³): Produces vector pairing, Φ(P) ∼ P^(-1/2-η_ψ±iδ) × γ³
   • Υ₄ (iγ⁰γ⁵): Produces pseudoscalar pairing, Φ(P) ∼ P^(-1/2-η_ψ±iδ) × γ⁵
   • Υ₃ (iγ¹γ²): Does not produce superconductivity; pairing strength consistently below critical value
3. Transition Temperature Behavior:

   T_c = Λ exp(-D/√(λ_p - λ^c_p))
   

   
   where D = π√(1+2η_ψ)

Ablation Studies

1. Angular Momentum Dependence: Only l=0 states can pair; higher angular momentum states require stronger coupling
2. Dimensional Effects: Demonstrates that two-component Dirac spinors cannot produce superconductivity
3. Approximation Method Verification: Differential equation approximations show high consistency with complete integral equation results

Case Studies

For a specific orbital-spin coupling model (Equation 96):

• Υ₁ coupling produces spin singlet/orbital triplet states
• Υ₂ coupling produces circulation-correlated pairing states
• Υ₄ coupling produces orbital singlet/spin triplet states

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Gross-Neveu Criticality: Large-N expansion, ε-expansion, Monte Carlo simulations
2. Dirac Material Superconductivity: Graphene, topological insulator surface states
3. SYK Model: Quantum chaos, strong-coupling physics

Advantages of This Work

1. Controlled Method: Provides controlled analysis in the strong-coupling regime compared to traditional small-parameter expansions
2. Universality: Provides algebraic criteria applicable to arbitrary Dirac theories
3. Experimental Relevance: Highly relevant to twisted material experiments

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Anomalous Quasiparticle Superconductivity: First demonstration that ill-defined quasiparticles are more prone to superconductivity than well-defined quasiparticles
2. Critical Dimension: Determines the universal critical value η^c_ψ ≈ 0.14628
3. Pairing Mechanisms: Three Yukawa couplings can produce superconducting states with different symmetries
4. Phase Fluctuation Stability: BKT transition temperature is of the same order as mean-field T_c

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: Employs random coupling assumption; actual materials have specific coupling structures
2. Large-N Approximation: Finite-N systems may exhibit different behavior
3. Critical Value Precision: The specific value of η^c_ψ may deviate due to approximations

Future Directions

1. Specific Material Applications: Extension to 16×16 and 8×8 Dirac matrices in twisted bilayer graphene and WSe₂
2. Topological Properties: Investigation of connections with charged skyrmions
3. Disorder Effects: Analysis of pairing state stability against disorder and magnetic fields

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Introduces the novel concept of "ill-defined quasiparticle superconductivity," challenging traditional quasiparticle pictures
2. Advanced Methods: Successfully extends SYK methods to superconducting problems in Dirac systems
3. Systematic Results: Provides complete analysis of all possible pairing channels and symmetries
4. Strong Practicality: Algebraic criteria can be directly applied to other Dirac systems

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Verification: Lacks direct experimental evidence supporting theoretical predictions
2. Parameter Estimation: Correspondence between M/N ratio and actual materials remains unclear
3. Dynamical Properties: Primarily focuses on thermodynamic properties; dynamical response analysis is limited

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new analytical framework for strongly correlated Dirac systems
2. Experimental Guidance: Offers theoretical guidance for twisted material experiments in searching for superconductivity
3. Method Generalization: Successful application case of SYK methods in condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Twisted Materials: Twisted bilayer graphene, twisted WSe₂, and similar systems
2. Strongly Correlated Dirac Systems: Two-dimensional materials with strong Yukawa coupling
3. Quantum Critical Systems: Electronic systems near Gross-Neveu critical points

References

This paper cites 100 related references, primarily including:

• Kim et al. (2021): Original work on SYK-inspired framework
• Gross & Neveu (1974): Pioneering work on Gross-Neveu model
• Extensive experimental and theoretical research on graphene, twisted materials, and strongly correlated systems

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that achieves important breakthroughs in superconductivity theory of Dirac systems. By introducing the concept of "ill-defined quasiparticle superconductivity" and conducting systematic pairing analysis, it provides new perspectives for understanding superconducting mechanisms in strongly correlated Dirac materials. Despite certain theoretical assumptions and approximations, its results have significant guiding value for current twisted material experiments.