Hyperbolic Continuous Topological Transition in Real Space

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.02032
• Title: Hyperbolic Continuous Topological Transition in Real Space
• Authors: Junke Liao¹, Tao Hou¹, Huanyang Chen¹,*
• Affiliations: ¹Department of Physics, Xiamen University
• Classification: physics.optics
• Corresponding Author: Huanyang Chen (kenyon@xmu.edu.cn)

Abstract

Hyperbolic topological transition refers to the phenomenon wherein isofrequency contours in hyperbolic materials transform from one topological structure (such as hyperbolic) to another (such as elliptical or different hyperbolic topologies). However, current research has been limited to topological transitions in momentum space, which impedes real-space observation of different hyperbolic states and their associated topological transitions within a single system. This work investigates real-space hyperbolic continuous topological transitions using gradient-index (GRIN) lenses, exemplified by the hyperbolic Luneburg lens. By introducing Wick rotation, we demonstrate how spatially modulated refractive index mediated by out-of-plane permittivity variation drives continuous transitions between hyperbolic type I and type II topologies. Furthermore, using a harmonic oscillator model, we reveal the intrinsic relationship between the parameter E of the hyperbolic Luneburg lens and its dominant topological behavior, extending this concept to the broader Morse lens framework.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Issue: Traditional hyperbolic topological transition research is confined to momentum space, preventing simultaneous observation of different hyperbolic states and their topological transitions in real space within a single system
2. Significance: The topological properties of hyperbolic materials determine unique edge states and quantum phenomena, which are crucial for quantum imaging, optical computing, and on-chip integrated technologies
3. Existing Limitations:
   • Experiments can only observe hyperbolic state transitions by varying frequency or material structure parameters
   • Lack of research on coexistence of multiple hyperbolic states in real space and their transitions
   • Inability to simultaneously observe different hyperbolic states within the same system

Research Motivation

The authors aim to achieve real-space coexistence and continuous transition of hyperbolic type I and type II states through gradient-index lens design, providing theoretical foundations for tunable topological material design.

Core Contributions

1. First Realization of Real-Space Hyperbolic Continuous Topological Transition: Through hyperbolic Luneburg lens design, simultaneous observation of coexistence and continuous transition between hyperbolic type I and type II states within a single system
2. Establishment of Wick Rotation Theoretical Framework: Demonstration of how spatially modulated refractive index drives topological transitions through sign changes in out-of-plane permittivity
3. Revelation of Intrinsic Relationship Between Parameter E and Topological Behavior: Analysis using harmonic oscillator model of parameter E's decisive role in the system's dominant topological behavior
4. Extension to Morse Lens Framework: Establishment of unified expressions for gradient-index lenses supporting hyperbolic continuous topological transitions
5. Experimental Feasibility Verification: Validation of theoretical predictions based on α-MoO₃ material platform

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Foundation

Wick Rotation Transformation

For two-dimensional transverse electric (TE) or transverse magnetic (TM) waves, the material permittivity tensor is:

ε = μ = [1, 0; 0, 1; 0, 0, n²(x,y)]

Through Wick rotation transformation x' = ix, y' = y, converting Euclidean space to Minkowski space:

• Line element: ds'² = -dx'² + dy'²
• Radial distance: r' = √(y'² - x'²)

Hyperbolic Luneburg Lens Design

The traditional Luneburg lens refractive index distribution n²(r) = 2E - r² becomes, after Wick rotation:

n'²(r') = 2E + x'² - y²

The corresponding permittivity tensor is:

ε' = μ' = [1, 0; 0, -1; 0, 0, n²(r')]

Topological Transition Mechanism

Dispersion Relation Analysis

• Region where n'² > 0: Dispersion relation k_y² - k_x² = n'²(r') corresponds to type I hyperbolic material
• Region where n'² < 0: Dispersion relation k_x² - k_y² = |n'²(r')| corresponds to type II hyperbolic material
• Boundary where n'² = 0: Realizes continuous topological transition between type I and type II

Harmonic Oscillator Model Analogy

The Wick-rotated system is analogous to the Schrödinger equation:

-ℏ²/2m (∂²/∂y² - ∂²/∂x²)φ(x,y) + mω²/2(y² - x²)φ(x,y) = Eφ(x,y)

Through separation of variables:

{ℏ²/2m ∂²φ(x)/∂x² - mω²x²/2 φ(x) = -A φ(x)
{-ℏ²/2m ∂²φ(y)/∂y² + mω²y²/2 φ(y) = (A + E)φ(y)

The sign of parameter E determines the formation location of focal or defocusing lines.

Morse Lens Extension

Generalized Morse Lens

The concept is extended to the broader Morse lens framework:

n²(r') = 2r'²⁽ᵐ⁻¹⁾ - r'²⁽²ᵐ⁻¹⁾

where m = 1, 2, 3, ...

Symmetry Analysis

• m is odd: Breaks positive-negative symmetry of n'², producing single focal and defocusing lines
• m is even: Preserves positive-negative symmetry of n'², producing multiple foci and eliminating defocusing lines

Experimental Setup

Numerical Simulation Parameters

• Wavelength: λ = 1 (theoretical analysis), λ = 1.063 cm (actual material simulation)
• Frequency: ω = 937 cm⁻¹ (α-MoO₃ material)
• Material Parameters: α-MoO₃ in-plane permittivity εₓ = 1.377 + 0.025i, εᵧ = -1.374 + 0.098i

Experimental Design

1. Ray Tracing Analysis: Hamiltonian optics method for analyzing light trajectories
2. Electromagnetic Field Distribution Simulation: Finite element method for computing TE wave field distributions
3. Parameter Scanning: Analysis of system behavior under different E values (-4, 0, +4)

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Topological Transition Characteristics

1. Case E = 0: System exhibits C₄ symmetry, producing four focal points with simultaneous presence of type I and type II hyperbolic regions
2. Case E ≠ 0: Focal points degenerate into defocusing lines while maintaining hyperbolic topological transition characteristics
3. Continuous Transition: Type I and type II hyperbolic states achieve continuous transition at the n'² = 0 boundary

Field Distribution Analysis

• Type I Region (n'² > 0): Wave propagation primarily along y-direction, forming vertical hourglass shape
• Type II Region (n'² < 0): Wave propagation primarily along x-direction, forming horizontal hourglass shape
• Forbidden Region: Square-shaped forbidden propagation region forms at the center

Morse Lens Verification

Morse lenses of different orders m all achieve hyperbolic continuous topological transitions:

• m = 1: Corresponds to hyperbolic Luneburg lens
• m is odd: Produces single focal point and defocusing line
• m is even: Produces multiple focal points without defocusing lines

Experimental Feasibility

Simulations based on α-MoO₃ platform demonstrate:

• High-quality imaging achievable at short distances (d = λ)
• Material loss limits source-image distance, but performance is good in near-field range

Related Work

Hyperbolic Material Research

1. Artificial Hyperbolic Metamaterials: Metal-dielectric composite structures applied to negative refraction and subwavelength imaging
2. Natural Hyperbolic Materials: α-MoO₃, h-BN and other 2D materials with low-loss characteristics
3. Topological Transitions: Momentum-space topological transitions achieved by varying frequency or structure parameters

Gradient-Index Lenses

1. Transformation Optics: Optical device design through coordinate transformations
2. Luneburg Lens: Classical gradient-index lens with perfect focusing properties
3. Maxwell Fish-Eye Lens: Counterexample not supporting hyperbolic continuous topological transitions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First theoretical design and numerical verification of real-space hyperbolic continuous topological transition
2. Establishment of hyperbolic GRIN lens theory under Wick rotation framework
3. Revelation of intrinsic relationship between parameter E and topological behavior
4. Extension to unified Morse lens framework

Limitations

1. Material Loss: In-plane loss of α-MoO₃ limits practical application distance
2. Experimental Challenges: Requires precise control of gradient air gaps and substrate modification
3. Theoretical Constraints: Currently applicable only to specific GRIN lens types

Future Directions

1. Search for low-loss hyperbolic material platforms
2. Development of experimental fabrication techniques
3. Extension to three-dimensional systems
4. Exploration of connections with discrete lattices

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First extension of topological transitions from momentum space to real space, with significant theoretical importance
2. Novel Methodology: Application of Wick rotation provides new insights for designing novel optical devices
3. In-Depth Analysis: Harmonic oscillator model analogy provides profound physical insights
4. Complete Framework: Extension from single Luneburg lens to unified Morse lens framework

Weaknesses

1. Limited Experimental Verification: Primarily based on numerical simulations, lacking comprehensive experimental validation
2. Material Limitations: Loss issues of existing material platforms remain unresolved
3. Application Scenarios: Practical feasibility and advantages require further demonstration

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new research directions for hyperbolic materials and topological photonics
2. Technical Potential: May generate applications in subwavelength imaging and optical computing
3. Theoretical Significance: Enriches theoretical framework of transformation optics and gradient-index materials

Applicable Scenarios

1. Hyperbolic metamaterial design
2. Topological photonic devices
3. Phonon polariton manipulation
4. Quantum optical applications

References

The paper cites 45 important references covering key works in hyperbolic materials, topological photonics, transformation optics and related fields, providing solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Summary: This paper makes important theoretical contributions at the intersection of hyperbolic materials and topological photonics. Through ingenious Wick rotation design, it achieves real-space hyperbolic continuous topological transition, providing theoretical foundations for novel optical device design. Although experimental verification requires further strengthening, its theoretical innovation and potential application value make it an important work in this field.