Slow dynamics from a nested hierarchy of frozen states

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.03159
• Title: Slow dynamics from a nested hierarchy of frozen states
• Authors: Vanja Marić, Luka Paljk, Lenart Zadnik (University of Ljubljana)
• Classification: cond-mat.stat-mech, quant-ph
• Publication Date: October 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.03159

Abstract

This paper identifies the mechanism of slow heterogeneous relaxation in quantum kinetically constrained models (KCMs), where potential strength is controlled by a coupling parameter. Through an expansion around the large coupling limit, a nested hierarchy of frozen states is revealed, where states remain frozen on timescales determined by powers of the coupling strength. Classification of these states and their Krylov complexity evolution indicate that timescales correlate with spatial separations between sites that the kinetic constraints allow to promote dynamics. Correlations within frozen states relax slowly and exhibit metastable plateaus with durations set by powers of the coupling parameter, while correlations in other states decay rapidly.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Problem: Understanding the microscopic mechanisms of slow relaxation and dynamical heterogeneity in quantum kinetically constrained models
2. Significance:
   • Rapid development of quantum technologies provides strong motivation for theoretical investigation of slow relaxation mechanisms in quantum many-body systems
   • KCMs are experimentally realizable in Rydberg atom platforms with important applications
   • These systems exhibit not only slow relaxation but also support rich non-equilibrium phenomena

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Previous research primarily explained dynamical slowness through quantum many-body scars and enhanced kinetic constraints in the strong coupling limit
• Lack of complete microscopic understanding of the entire hierarchy of relaxation timescales
• Absence of a unified framework determining timescales and heights of all plateaus

Research Motivation

This work aims to go beyond the strong coupling limit and establish a complete framework capable of determining plateau timescales and heights, explaining the entire hierarchy of relaxation times.

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete large coupling expansion framework: Based on full large coupling expansion of the Hamiltonian, defining a nested hierarchy of computational basis ground states
2. Revealed classification rules for frozen states: Proved that Ck contains spin configurations where any two ↓ spins are separated by at least k ↑ spins
3. Determined the timescale hierarchy: Through Krylov complexity analysis, proved that level-k states remain frozen on timescales t∼Δᵏ
4. Calculated plateau heights in correlations: Provided analytical expressions for plateau heights in correlation functions of frozen states, accurate to O(Δ⁻²) corrections
5. Established spatial-temporal correlations: Linked relaxation times to spatial separations between sites promoting dynamics

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the dynamics of the one-dimensional XPX model: $H_{XPX} = \sum_{j=1}^L \sigma^x_{j-1}(1-\sigma^z_j)\sigma^x_{j+1} + \Delta\sigma^z_j$

where Δ is the coupling parameter controlling potential strength, and the system exhibits slow dynamics for |Δ|>1.

Model Architecture

1. Large Coupling Expansion

Employ a recursive scheme to compute the large coupling expansion, obtaining anti-Hermitian operator S and Hermitian operator H_F: $H_{XPX} = e^{-S}He^S, \quad H = H_F + \Delta V, \quad [H_F,V] = 0$

where:

• $S = \sum_{n≥1} \Delta^{-n}S_n$
• $H_F = \sum_{n≥0} \Delta^{-n}H_{F,n}$
• Truncation: $H^{(k)} := \Delta V + \sum_{n=0}^{k-1} \Delta^{-n}H_{F,n}$

2. Frozen State Hierarchy

Define the set of frozen states: $C_k := \{|s⟩ ≡ |s_1...s_L⟩ | H^{(k)}|s⟩ = ε(s)|s⟩\}$

forming a nested hierarchy: $C_1 ⊇ C_2 ⊇ ... ⊇ C_k ⊇ ...$

3. Key Findings

• Frozen state characteristics: Except for the vacuum state, Ck contains configurations where any two ↓ spins are separated by at least k ↑ spins
• State counting formula: $|C_k| = 1 + \sum_{N=⌈kL/(k+1)⌉}^L \frac{L}{kN-(k-1)L}\binom{kN-(k-1)L}{L-N}$
• Asymptotic behavior: $|C_k| \sim χ_k^L$, where χk satisfies χk(χ-1) = 1

Technical Innovations

1. Complete large coupling expansion: First provision of arbitrary-order large coupling expansion for the XPX model
2. Nested hierarchy structure: Innovative identification of nested structure of frozen states and its relationship to timescales
3. Krylov complexity analysis: Utilization of Krylov complexity to quantify state evolution, verifying frozen timescales
4. Spatial-temporal correlations: Establishment of exponential relationship between promoting site separation and relaxation time

Experimental Setup

Numerical Methods

• Exact diagonalization calculations using QuSpin package
• System sizes: Main results based on L=14 systems
• Coupling strengths: Δ = 4, 8, 16, 32 and other values

Evaluation Metrics

1. Time-averaged correlation function: $c_t(s) = t^{-1}\int_0^t dτ c_τ(s), \quad c_t(s) := \frac{1}{L}\sum_{j=1}^L ⟨s|n_j(t)n_j(0)|s⟩$
2. Krylov complexity: $K_t(ψ) = \sum_{n=0,1,2,...} n|⟨ψ(t)|B_n⟩|^2$
3. Plateau height estimation: $c_{pl}(s) = \frac{N_↑(s)}{L} + O(Δ^{-2})$

Comparative Analysis

• Comparison of dynamical behavior across different level-k states
• Verification of consistency between theoretical predictions and numerical results
• Analysis of scaling behavior at different Δ values

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Timescale Hierarchy:
   • Level-k states remain frozen on timescales t∼Δᵏ
   • Krylov complexity exhibits scaling collapse under rescaled time t/Δᵏ
   • Verification of theoretically predicted exponential timescale separation
2. Correlation Function Plateaus:
   • Correlation functions in frozen states exhibit persistent plateaus
   • Plateau height determined by initial ↑ spin density: $c_{pl}(s) ≈ N_↑(s)/L$
   • Correlations in non-frozen states decay rapidly
3. State Counting Scaling:
   • Numerical verification of analytical formula |Ck| accuracy
   • Confirmation of asymptotic scaling $|C_k| \sim χ_k^L$
   • Observation of correlation between Krylov sector count and frozen state count

Ablation Studies

1. Different truncation orders: Verification of predictions for k=1,2,3,4 and other truncations
2. System size effects: Confirmation of scaling behavior in range L=4 to 16
3. Coupling strength dependence: Demonstration of scaling collapse from Δ=4 to 32

Case Studies

The paper also validates similar phenomena in the quantum Fredrickson-Andersen model, demonstrating method universality. In this model, similar observations include:

• Krylov complexity of level-k states collapses under rescaled time t/Δᵏ
• Similar timescale hierarchy structure

Experimental Findings

1. Spatial heterogeneity: Relaxation time exhibits exponential relationship with spatial separation between promoting spins
2. Plateau evolution: Two-stage plateaus at large Δ become single-stage, consistent with O(Δ⁻²) correction predictions
3. Universality: Mechanism applies to other quantum KCMs, such as quantum FA model

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Classical KCMs: Historically played important role in understanding dynamical slowness and heterogeneity in structural glasses
2. Quantum KCMs: Experimental implementation in Rydberg atom platforms has driven theoretical research
3. Hilbert space fragmentation: Related to exotic non-equilibrium phenomena such as quantum many-body scars

Advantages of This Work

• Provides complete microscopic mechanism explanation, transcending previous phenomenological descriptions
• Establishes quantitative relationships between spatial structure and timescales
• Provides analytical expressions for plateau heights

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Mechanism identification: Successfully identified microscopic mechanisms of slow relaxation in quantum KCMs
2. Hierarchy structure: Established nested frozen state hierarchy based on spatial separation
3. Timescales: Determined exponential timescales related to spatial separation between promoting sites
4. Quantitative predictions: Provided precise calculation methods for correlation plateau heights

Limitations

1. System sizes: Numerical results primarily based on relatively small systems (L≤16)
2. Model specificity: Focuses mainly on XPX model, though applicability to FA model is verified
3. Large coupling assumption: Theoretical framework based on large coupling expansion; intermediate coupling regime may require higher-order corrections

Future Directions

1. Extension to other models: Investigation of broader categories of quantum KCMs
2. Hilbert space cages: Exploration of relationships with recently discovered Hilbert space cages
3. Conserved quantities: Study of connections with emergent (quasi-)conserved quantities
4. Experimental verification: Verification of theoretical predictions in Rydberg atom platforms

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical depth: Provides complete large coupling expansion framework with strong theoretical foundation
2. Methodological innovation: Nested hierarchy concept offers new perspective for understanding complex dynamics
3. Quantitative precision: Provides verifiable analytical predictions, including state counting formulas and plateau heights
4. Universality: Method applicable to multiple quantum KCMs, demonstrating broad applicability
5. Experimental relevance: Results closely related to Rydberg atom experiments with practical significance

Weaknesses

1. Computational complexity: High-order terms in large coupling expansion are computationally complex, limiting practical application range
2. Finite-size effects: Numerical verification primarily conducted on small systems; thermodynamic limit behavior requires further confirmation
3. Intermediate coupling regime: Theoretical prediction accuracy may decrease for experimentally relevant intermediate coupling strengths

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides important theoretical tools for studying slow dynamics in quantum many-body systems
2. Practical value: Offers guidance for designing and controlling dynamical behavior in quantum simulators
3. Reproducibility: Provides detailed computational methods and numerical results, facilitating reproduction and verification

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum simulation: Implementation and control of KCMs in Rydberg atom arrays
2. Theoretical research: Analysis of other quantum systems with kinetic constraints
3. Materials science: Understanding quantum glassy states and slow relaxation phenomena
4. Quantum computing: Design of quantum algorithms with specific dynamical properties

References

The paper cites 61 important references, covering:

• Foundational work on classical KCMs (Fredrickson & Andersen, 1984)
• Rydberg atom experiments (Bernien et al., Nature 2017)
• Hilbert space fragmentation theory (Yang et al., PRL 2020)
• Quantum many-body scars (Turner et al., Nature Physics 2018)

This paper holds significant importance in quantum many-body system dynamics research, providing not only profound theoretical insights but also concrete predictions and guidance for experimental investigation. The nested hierarchy framework established may become a standard tool for understanding slow dynamics in complex quantum systems.