Quantum computing for heavy-ion physics: near-term status and future prospects

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.04207
• Title: Quantum computing for heavy-ion physics: near-term status and future prospects
• Author: João Barata (CERN, Theoretical Physics Department)
• Classification: quant-ph hep-ph nucl-th
• Publication Time/Conference: Quark Matter 2025 conference in Frankfurt, Germany
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.04207

Abstract

This paper discusses recent advances in the application of quantum information science (QIS) to high-energy nuclear physics problems. Following an overview of key developments, open challenges, and emerging connections between these disciplines, the paper highlights recent achievements in studying states of matter, hard probes, and spin correlations using novel quantum technologies. This work summarizes the corresponding presentation at the Quark Matter 2025 conference held in Frankfurt, Germany.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problems to be addressed: Real-time dynamical evolution of QCD matter in heavy-ion collision experiments, the phase diagram structure at finite density, and theoretical description of non-perturbative physical processes.
2. Importance of the problems:
   • Heavy-ion collisions provide a unique experimental platform for exploring QCD at finite temperature and density and out-of-equilibrium properties
   • Successfully produced the quark-gluon plasma (QGP), revealing its nature as "the most perfect fluid in the universe"
   • Significant implications for understanding the matter state of the early universe
3. Limitations of existing methods:
   • Lattice QCD methods suffer from the sign problem in real-time evolution and finite density problems
   • Perturbative methods cannot handle non-perturbative physical processes
   • Different effective descriptions are employed for different evolutionary stages, lacking a unified first-principles approach
4. Research motivation: Developments in quantum information science provide new possibilities for overcoming these obstacles, enabling real-time, finite-density simulations of non-perturbative quantum systems.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic review: First systematic summary of the current status and future prospects of QIS applications in heavy-ion physics
2. Interdisciplinary bridge: Establishes theoretical connections between quantum computing and high-energy nuclear physics
3. Concrete application demonstrations: Provides specific application examples in nuclear structure, hard probes, and spin correlations
4. Technical roadmap: Provides a clear technical roadmap for future development of QIS in heavy-ion physics
5. Feasibility analysis: Objectively assesses the capabilities and limitations of current quantum platforms

Methodology Details

Task Definition

This paper aims to explore how to utilize quantum computing techniques to simulate the QCD matter evolution process in heavy-ion collisions, including:

• Input: Initial state of two counter-moving nuclear wave packets
• Evolution: Unitary evolution through the QCD Hamiltonian
• Output: Quantum state of the final-state hadron ensemble

Theoretical Framework

Four Evolutionary Stages of Heavy-Ion Collisions

1. Initial state (τ < 0): Two incident nuclei, described by the color glass condensate (CGC)
2. Pre-equilibration (τ ≤ 1 fm/c): Formation and expansion of far-from-equilibrium QCD state
3. QGP phase (1 < τ < 5 fm/c): Hydrodynamic evolution of the quark-gluon plasma
4. Hadronization (τ ≥ 5 fm/c): Free-streaming hadron gas

Quantum Computing Implementation Scheme

• State preparation: Preparation of initial counter-moving wave packets on the quantum computer
• Time evolution: Unitary evolution through the QCD Hamiltonian
• Measurement: Sampling measurements of the final-state quantum state

Technical Innovations

1. Real-time evolution capability: Overcomes the sign problem of traditional lattice QCD
2. Non-perturbative treatment: Capable of handling physical processes in the strong coupling regime
3. First-principles methodology: Complete quantum mechanical description based on the QCD Hamiltonian
4. Unified framework: Avoids the use of different effective theories for different stages

Experimental Setup

Quantum Platform Selection

• IBM quantum processors: For small-scale proof-of-concept experiments
• Classical tensor networks: For large-scale exact simulations of two-dimensional theories
• Hybrid approach: Combining advantages of quantum and classical computing

Model Systems

• Two-dimensional QED: As a simplified model of QCD for method verification
• Lattice gauge theories: Discretized quantum field theory models
• Effective models: Simplified descriptions for specific physical processes

Evaluation Metrics

• Spectral functions: Describing the mass and width of bound states
• Correlation functions: Measuring quantum correlations between particles
• Transport coefficients: Characterizing macroscopic properties of the medium
• Bell inequalities: Verifying the existence of quantum entanglement

Experimental Results

Nuclear Structure Studies

1. Parton distribution function (PDF) calculations:
   • Successfully calculated PDFs of the first excited state in two-dimensional QED
   • Observed expected peak structure at energy fraction x = 0.5
   • Verified the quantum computing implementation scheme for light-cone Wilson lines
2. Wilson lines and Wilson loops:
   • Developed ladder discretization methods applicable to quantum devices
   • Implemented gauge-invariant non-local operator calculations

Hard Probes and Energy Loss

1. Meson spectral function evolution:
   • Observed increased bound state width at finite temperature
   • Verified the emergence of imaginary potential between fermions
   • Relationship between thermalization time and drag parameter
2. Jet momentum broadening:
   • Calculated the average transverse momentum squared of jets in QGP medium
   • Investigated the relationship between energy loss and propagation velocity
   • Achieved full dynamical coupling between probe and bulk system

Spin Correlations and Entanglement Tests

1. Quantum correlations in tt̄ production:
   • CMS collaboration experiments verified genuine quantum correlations in tt̄ pairs
   • Provided a paradigm for entanglement tests in high-energy physics
2. Hyperon spin correlations:
   • Calculated spin correlations of ΛΛ̄ in the QCD string model
   • IBM quantum processor results consistent with theoretical expectations
   • Provided theoretical foundation for future EIC experiments

Technical Verification Experiments

Through comparative experiments of meson wave packet evolution in two-dimensional QED, demonstrated:

• Classical exact methods can perfectly simulate wave packet propagation
• Current quantum devices are severely affected by noise, with results degrading rapidly
• Verified the correctness of quantum methods in principle and current technical limitations

Related Work

Quantum Information Science Development

1. Quantum algorithms: Exponential improvements in singular value transformation and quantum matrix operations
2. Tensor network methods: Efficient classical quantum state representation methods
3. Quantum simulators: Rapid development of dedicated quantum devices

Lattice QCD Methods

1. Traditional Euclidean methods: Successful applications in finite-temperature QCD
2. Real-time methods: Sign problem and noise challenges
3. Effective theories: Kinetic theory, relativistic hydrodynamics, etc.

Quantum Technologies in High-Energy Physics

1. Particle physics experiments: Measurement of tt̄ correlations at the LHC
2. Nuclear physics applications: Study of quantum correlations in EIC experiments
3. Theoretical developments: Hamiltonian light-front formalism, open quantum system methods

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Feasibility verification: QIS methods can in principle solve key problems in heavy-ion physics
2. Current limitations: Existing quantum platforms remain constrained by noise and scale limitations
3. Development prospects: As technology advances, quantum methods will play an important role in this field
4. Interdisciplinary value: Promotes deep integration of quantum information science and high-energy nuclear physics

Limitations

1. Technical maturity: Current noise levels in quantum devices limit practical applications
2. Scale limitations: Simulation of large-scale QCD systems remains a long-term goal
3. Theoretical challenges: Bridging from simplified models to actual QCD requires further work
4. Experimental verification: Many theoretical predictions still require experimental verification

Future Directions

1. Hardware improvements: Lower-noise, larger-scale quantum processors
2. Algorithm optimization: More efficient quantum algorithms and error correction schemes
3. Physical applications: Topological structures, equilibration dynamics, hadronization processes
4. Experimental collaboration: Close cooperation with EIC, LHC, and other experiments

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Forward-looking perspective: Accurately grasps the development trends at the intersection of quantum computing and nuclear physics
2. Systematic coverage: Comprehensively covers major research directions in this interdisciplinary field
3. Strong practical value: Provides concrete technical roadmaps and implementation schemes
4. Good balance: Demonstrates potential while objectively analyzing limitations
5. Interdisciplinary value: Provides valuable reference for researchers in both fields

Weaknesses

1. Limited depth: As a review article, discussion of specific technical details is insufficient
2. Experimental verification: Most results remain at proof-of-concept stage, lacking large-scale applications
3. Cost-benefit analysis: Insufficient discussion of cost-benefit of quantum methods relative to classical methods
4. Timeline expectations: Overly optimistic expectations for achieving complete QCD simulations

Impact

1. Academic value: Establishes theoretical foundation for emerging interdisciplinary field
2. Practical prospects: Will generate important application value as quantum technology develops
3. Policy significance: Provides important case study for quantum computing applications in fundamental science
4. Talent cultivation: Promotes training and exchange of interdisciplinary talent

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic research: QCD phase diagram, transport properties, and other fundamental theoretical problems
2. Experimental design: Provides theoretical guidance for heavy-ion collision experiments
3. Technology development: Application of quantum algorithms to physical problems
4. Education and training: Interdisciplinary teaching of quantum information and high-energy physics

References

The paper contains 87 references, covering:

• Fundamental theory of heavy-ion physics 1-6
• Quantum information science methods 7-15
• Specific application research 16-87
• Experimental verification results 59-66

These references provide solid theoretical foundation and technical support for further development of this interdisciplinary field.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality review article that systematically summarizes the current status and future prospects of quantum computing applications in heavy-ion physics. The paper possesses both theoretical depth and practical value, making important contributions to the development of this emerging interdisciplinary field. Although current technology has limitations, with rapid advances in quantum computing technology, this field has broad application prospects.