Hänsch-Couillaud locking of a large Sagnac interferometer: advancing below the flicker floor

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08183
• Title: Hänsch-Couillaud locking of a large Sagnac interferometer: advancing below the flicker floor
• Authors: Jannik Zenner (Universität Bonn), Karl Ulrich Schreiber (TUM & University of Canterbury), Simon Stellmer (Universität Bonn)
• Classification: physics.optics
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08183

Abstract

Large Sagnac interferometers appear in Earth sciences as unique rotation sensors in the form of active ring lasers, with sensitivity allowing detection of geodetic and seismic signals. However, passive laser gyroscope variants remain under development, exploring appropriate laser frequency stabilization techniques to achieve required sensitivity and stability levels. This paper presents for the first time a passive laser gyroscope with Hänsch-Couillaud locking, employing a phase-locking scheme to overcome the flicker noise floor, achieving a sensitivity of 3.1 nrad/s, corresponding to 7.7×10⁻⁵ times Earth's rotation rate.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed by this research concerns the improvement of laser frequency stabilization techniques in passive laser gyroscopes. Specifically:

1. Technical Challenges: Passive laser gyroscopes require external lasers simultaneously stabilized to both clockwise and counterclockwise cavity resonance modes, imposing extremely high demands on laser frequency stability
2. Limitations of Existing Methods: All current passive laser gyroscopes employ Pound-Drever-Hall (PDH) locking schemes, which suffer from residual amplitude modulation (RAM) problems
3. RAM Problem: Asymmetry in the phase of frequency modulation sidebands caused by optical elements leads to non-zero error signal baseline and fluctuations

Significance

• Earth Science Applications: High-precision rotation measurement is crucial in geodesy, seismology, and fundamental physics research
• Technical Advantages: Passive laser gyroscopes avoid gain media and laser plasma in active ring lasers, eliminating lock-in effects, backscattering, and plasma dynamics issues
• Precision Requirements: Measurement precision at the 10⁻⁴-10⁻⁵ level of Earth's rotation rate is needed

Research Motivation

To find alternative approaches to PDH locking schemes that fundamentally avoid the root causes of RAM problems, improving measurement precision and long-term stability of passive laser gyroscopes.

Core Contributions

1. First Implementation: First demonstration of a passive laser gyroscope based on Hänsch-Couillaud (HC) locking scheme
2. Technical Innovation: Development of phase-locking enhanced HC locking method, successfully overcoming the flicker noise floor
3. Performance Improvement: Achievement of 3.1 nrad/s rotation measurement sensitivity, comparable to PDH-locked systems of equivalent size
4. Method Validation: Demonstration of HC locking as a viable alternative to PDH schemes, completely avoiding RAM problems

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: External laser frequency signal Output: Laser beams stably locked to both clockwise and counterclockwise modes of the ring cavity Objective: Minimize noise in Sagnac frequency measurement, achieving high-precision rotation rate detection

Experimental Setup Architecture

1. Ring Cavity System

• Geometric Structure: Square ring laser cavity with 3.5 m side length
• Optical Parameters:
  • Four mirrors with 4 m radius of curvature
  • Finesse approximately 36,000
  • Free spectral range: f_FSR = 21.4232 MHz
  • Cavity linewidth: f_FWHM ≈ 600 Hz

2. Laser System

• Laser: TOPTICA DL PRO diode laser, frequency f_L = 473.614 THz
• Beam Distribution: Laser divided into four branches of different intensities
  • 100 μW for PDH pre-stabilization
  • One branch for wavelength meter monitoring
  • Two branches for HC locking

Hänsch-Couillaud Locking Method

Standard HC Locking Principle

1. Birefringence Utilization: HC method exploits the inherent birefringence of high-finesse ring cavities
2. Polarization Detection: Uses 45° linearly polarized light to interrogate s-polarized cavity modes
3. Frequency Shifting: Frequency shift of 9·f_FSR = 192.8088 MHz via acousto-optic modulator (AOM)
4. Differential Detection: Separation of p and s polarization components through quarter-wave plate, half-wave plate, and Wollaston prism

Phase-Locking Enhancement Scheme

Key Innovation: Amplitude modulation of AOM drive signal to overcome flicker noise

Modulation signal expression:

s_AOM(t) = (1/2)[1 + m·cos(2πf_m t)] · s_AOM

Where:

• Modulation frequency: f_m = 10 kHz
• Modulation depth: m ≈ 1
• Intracavity power modulation only 5.9% (due to cavity low-pass filtering effect)

Demodulation Process:

1. Mix photodiode signal with phase-corrected modulation frequency
2. Suppress residual modulation through 2.2 kHz cutoff Butterworth low-pass filter

Technical Innovations

1. Avoiding RAM Problems: HC method requires no frequency modulation, fundamentally eliminating RAM generation
2. Phase-Locked Detection: Through amplitude modulation and synchronous demodulation, signal is shifted from flicker noise to higher frequencies
3. Bidirectional Independent Locking: Independent HC locking of clockwise and counterclockwise directions at different corners of the ring cavity
4. Polarization Optimization: 45° polarization angle selection to maximize HC error signal signal-to-noise ratio

Experimental Setup

System Configuration

• Environmental Control: Vacuum cavity with stabilized temperature and pressure
• Geometric Stability: Ring circumference controlled via stacked piezoelectric actuators with nanometer-level precision
• Frequency Monitoring: Real-time monitoring via wavelength meter at 200 Hz sampling rate

Evaluation Metrics

1. Power Spectral Density (PSD): Analysis of noise characteristics in rotation rate measurement
2. Allan Deviation: Assessment of measurement stability at different integration times
3. Sagnac Frequency Accuracy: Direct measurement of rotation detection sensitivity

Comparison Methods

• Standard HC Locking: Baseline HC method without phase-locking enhancement
• Phase-Locked Enhanced HC Locking: Improved method proposed in this paper
• Literature Comparison: Performance comparison with similar-sized PDH-locked passive gyroscopes

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Noise Characteristic Analysis

Power Spectral Density Comparison:

• Standard HC Method: 1/f flicker noise dominance below 2 Hz
• Phase-Locked Enhanced Method: Achievement of pure shot noise limit, PSD level approximately 1.2×10⁻⁸ rad/s/√Hz

2. Allan Deviation Performance

Phase-Locked Enhanced HC Locking:

• Best Sensitivity: 7.7×10⁻⁵ Ω_E (3.1 nrad/s) at 6-second integration time
• Sagnac Frequency Deviation: 24 mHz
• Single-Direction Locking Accuracy: 17 mHz, corresponding to 2.8×10⁻⁵ times cavity linewidth

Standard HC Locking:

• Flicker Floor: 5.5×10⁻⁴ Ω_E, corresponding to 170 mHz Sagnac frequency deviation
• Limitation Range: Cannot overcome flicker floor within 0.2-200 second integration time

Noise Source Identification

1. Acoustic Interference: 23 Hz and 34 Hz peaks from laboratory cooling fans
2. Electronic Noise: 50 Hz peak from electronic equipment
3. Long-Term Drift: Random walk beyond 200 seconds attributed to thermomechanical deformation of wave plates

Experimental Findings

Key Insights

1. Flicker Noise Mechanism: Inherent flicker noise limitation of standard HC method restricts low-frequency performance
2. Phase-Locking Effectiveness: 10 kHz modulation frequency successfully shifts signal out of flicker noise band
3. Environmental Sensitivity: Long-term stability primarily limited by optical elements affected by temperature fluctuations

Performance Comparison

Performance comparable to similar-sized PDH-locked passive laser gyroscopes reported in literature, validating HC method as a viable alternative.

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Active Ring Lasers: Exemplified by the G-ring at Wettzell, Germany, leading in sensitivity and stability
2. Passive Laser Gyroscopes: Exploration of externally-driven ring resonators, avoiding negative effects of intracavity gain media
3. Frequency Stabilization Techniques: Research on PDH locking and RAM suppression methods

Positioning of This Work's Contribution

• Method Innovation: First application of HC locking to large passive laser gyroscopes
• Technical Breakthrough: Resolution of inherent flicker noise problem of HC method through phase-locking scheme
• Performance Validation: Achievement of measurement precision comparable to existing PDH methods

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Technical Feasibility: HC locking serves as an effective alternative to PDH schemes in passive laser gyroscopes
2. Performance Improvement: Phase-locking enhancement successfully overcomes flicker noise floor
3. Precision Achievement: Measurement precision of 7.7×10⁻⁵ Earth's rotation rate achieved

Limitations

1. Long-Term Stability: Drift beyond 10 seconds primarily caused by environmental factors
2. Temperature Sensitivity: Thermomechanical deformation of wave plates affects long-term performance
3. Increased Complexity: Phase-locking scheme adds system complexity

Future Directions

1. Environmental Control: Improved temperature and pressure control for enhanced long-term stability
2. Optical Optimization: Use of more stable polarization optical elements
3. Application Extension: Phase-locking enhancement technique potentially useful in other HC application domains

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Innovation: First successful application of HC locking to large passive laser gyroscopes
2. Problem Resolution: Targeted solution to RAM problems of PDH methods
3. Comprehensive Experiments: Detailed noise analysis and performance comparison
4. Practical Technology: Simple and cost-effective phase-locking scheme

Weaknesses

1. Long-Term Performance: Incomplete resolution of long-term drift issues
2. Environmental Dependence: High requirements for temperature control
3. Limited Scope: Superior to standard method only within specific integration time ranges

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new pathways for passive laser gyroscope technology development
2. Practical Potential: Application prospects in Earth science measurements
3. Technology Promotion: Phase-locking enhancement technique potentially applicable in other precision measurement domains

Applicable Scenarios

• Earth science research requiring high-precision rotation measurement
• Precision laser frequency stabilization applications requiring RAM avoidance
• Rotation sensing applications with medium integration times (0.3-200 seconds)

References

This paper cites 31 important references covering fundamental theory of the Sagnac effect, ring laser technology, frequency stabilization methods, and related experimental techniques, providing solid theoretical and technical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a technically innovative and rigorously designed optical precision measurement paper that successfully demonstrates the application potential of HC locking in passive laser gyroscopes, providing valuable new insights for technological development in this field.