Emergent continuous symmetry and ground-state factorization induced by long-range interactions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08391
• Title: Emergent continuous symmetry and ground-state factorization induced by long-range interactions
• Authors: Yue Yu (Yale University), Myung-Joong Hwang (Duke Kunshan University)
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08391

Abstract

In conventional theory, spontaneous breaking of $Z_2$ symmetry typically produces emergent excitations with the same symmetry and renormalized mass. Contrary to this conventional view, this paper proposes a theory in which low-energy excitations in the symmetry-broken phase acquire continuous symmetry, despite the fundamental symmetry of the system being discrete. In the presence of anisotropic long-range interactions, the order parameter renormalizes the relative strength of particle-number-conserving and non-conserving interactions. When one of the two renormalized interactions vanishes, a conservation law absent in the original Hamiltonian emerges, producing continuous symmetry. A remarkable consequence of the emergent continuous symmetry and conservation law is that it constrains quantum correlations in the ground state to zero, leading to ground-state factorization in the presence of strong interactions.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Limitations of conventional theory: In systems with $Z_2$ symmetry breaking, excitations typically preserve the same discrete symmetry. This paper questions whether this conventional view always holds.
2. Physical mechanism of ground-state factorization: Although ground-state factorization has been observed in various spin models, its physical origin remains unclear, and research has been primarily limited to spin systems.
3. Exploration of continuous variable systems: It remains unclear whether generic quantum many-body systems involving continuous variables (such as harmonic oscillators) admit ground-state factorization.

Research Significance

• Provides a new theoretical framework for understanding emergent phenomena in quantum phase transitions
• First discovery of ground-state factorization in continuous variable systems
• Provides universal tools for diagnosing ground-state factorization points

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical breakthrough: Proposes a universal theoretical framework for emergent continuous symmetry in discrete symmetry systems
2. Physical mechanism revelation: Identifies emergent continuous symmetry as the physical origin of ground-state factorization
3. Model extension: First discovery of ground-state factorization in the Dicke model, extending to continuous variable systems
4. Diagnostic tool: Proposes a method to diagnose ground-state factorization points by identifying emergent continuous symmetry
5. Universality verification: Verifies the universality of the theory in the Dicke lattice model and LMG model

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework: Landau Theory

Mean-field energy functional

The authors construct a generic asymmetric Landau potential:

$\bar{E}_{MF}(\bar{X}, \bar{P}) = \bar{X}^2 + \bar{P}^2 - \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{1 + (2g_+\bar{X})^2 + (2g_-\bar{P})^2}$

where $\bar{\alpha} = \bar{X} + i\bar{P}$ is the dimensionless order parameter, and $g_\pm$ denote the anisotropic interaction strengths.

Symmetry analysis

• When $g_+ = g_-$: The system possesses continuous $U(1)$ symmetry
• When $g_+ \neq g_-$: The system has only $Z_2$ symmetry ($\bar{X}(\bar{P}) \rightarrow -\bar{X}(\bar{P})$ invariance)

Emergent continuous symmetry condition

In the symmetry-broken phase, the fluctuation energy around the mean-field solution is:

$\bar{E}_{fluc}(\bar{x}, \bar{p}) = (1-\frac{1}{g_+^4})\bar{x}^2 + (1-\frac{g_-^2}{g_+^2})\bar{p}^2$

When $|g_+g_-| = 1$, the curvatures in both directions become equal, and the fluctuation potential acquires continuous symmetry.

Anisotropic Dicke Model

Hamiltonian

$H_{Dicke} = \omega_0 a^\dagger a + \Omega J_z + \frac{2\lambda_+}{\sqrt{N_a}}(a^\dagger + a)J_x - i\frac{2\lambda_-}{\sqrt{N_a}}(a^\dagger - a)J_y$

Effective Hamiltonian in the superradiant phase

Through unitary transformation and Holstein-Primakoff transformation:

$H_{Dicke}^{sp} = \omega_0 a^\dagger a + \tilde{\Omega}b^\dagger b + (\tilde{\lambda}_+ + \lambda_-)(ab^\dagger + a^\dagger b) + (\tilde{\lambda}_+ - \lambda_-)(ab + a^\dagger b^\dagger)$

Emergent conservation laws

• When $g_+g_- = 1$ (i.e., $\tilde{\lambda}_+ = \lambda_-$): The counter-rotating term vanishes, and $N_{sum} = a^\dagger a + b^\dagger b$ is conserved
• When $g_+g_- = -1$ (i.e., $\tilde{\lambda}_+ = -\lambda_-$): The co-rotating term vanishes, and $N_{diff} = a^\dagger a - b^\dagger b$ is conserved

Technical Innovations

1. Unified theoretical framework: Uses Landau theory to uniformly describe emergent continuous symmetry in different physical systems
2. Conservation law identification: Clarifies the correspondence between emergent continuous symmetry and specific conservation laws
3. Factorization mechanism: Reveals the physical mechanism by which particle-number conservation leads to ground-state factorization

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

1. Anisotropic Dicke model: Harmonic oscillator coupled to $N$ spin-1/2 particles
2. Dicke lattice model: Generalization to arbitrary dimensions and lattice geometries
3. Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick (LMG) model: Fully connected quantum spin system

Analysis Methods

1. Mean-field theory: Exact in the thermodynamic limit
2. Holstein-Primakoff transformation: Maps collective spins to bosons
3. Unitary transformation: Eliminates mean-field contributions to obtain the fluctuation Hamiltonian

Evaluation Metrics

• von Neumann entropy: $S_v(\rho_g) = -\text{Tr}[\rho_g \log_2 \rho_g]$ measures ground-state entanglement
• Order parameter: Characterizes phase transitions and symmetry breaking
• Energy gap: Characterizes the nature of the excitation spectrum

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Ground-state factorization in the Dicke model

• On the $g_+g_- = 1$ line (emergent Tavis-Cummings line), the ground state completely factorizes
• On the $g_+g_- = -1$ line (emergent anti-Tavis-Cummings line), continuous symmetry emerges but the ground state does not factorize
• This is the first discovery of ground-state factorization in continuous variable systems

Universality of the Dicke lattice model

• Emergent continuous symmetry condition: $|g_+g_-| = g_c^2 = 1 + \frac{Jz}{\omega_0}$
• Ground-state factorization is independent of lattice geometry and dimension
• Ground-state form: $|\Psi_g\rangle = \bigotimes_j (|0\rangle_j \otimes |N_a/2, -N_a/2\rangle_j)$

Reinterpretation of the LMG model

• Ground-state factorization condition $\gamma_x\gamma_y = h^2$ corresponds to emergent continuous symmetry
• The conserved quantity is $N_{sum} = b_1^\dagger b_1 + b_2^\dagger b_2$
• Provides a unified physical explanation for previously known ground-state factorization phenomena

Numerical Verification

• von Neumann entropy plots clearly display ground-state factorization lines
• Phase diagram analysis confirms theoretically predicted phase boundaries
• System behavior in different parameter regions is entirely consistent with theory

Related Work

Ground-state factorization research

• Historical development: Beginning with Vidal et al. (2004) discovery in the LMG model
• Diagnostic tools: Quantum information theory methods for detecting factorization points
• Limitations: Previous research primarily limited to spin systems

Dicke model research

• Classical results: Superradiant phase transition and Goldstone modes in the isotropic case
• Experimental implementations: Realization in cavity QED systems and ion traps
• Contribution of this work: Discovery of new physics in the anisotropic case

Quantum phase transition theory

• Symmetry breaking: Traditional Goldstone theorem and excitation spectrum
• Long-range interactions: Exactness of mean-field theory
• Emergent phenomena: Renormalization effects induced by order parameters

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical breakthrough: Demonstrates that discrete symmetry systems can produce emergent continuous symmetry
2. Physical mechanism: Order parameter renormalization of interaction strength is the key mechanism
3. Universal phenomenon: This is a universal feature of quantum phase transitions in fully connected systems
4. Practical value: Provides new tools for diagnosing ground-state factorization

Limitations

1. Scope of applicability: Primarily applicable to fully connected systems with long-range interactions
2. Theoretical framework: Based on mean-field theory; further research needed for short-range interaction systems
3. Experimental verification: Requires verification of theoretical predictions in actual physical systems

Future Directions

1. Short-range interactions: Explore applicability of the framework to short-range interaction systems
2. Experimental implementation: Realization and observation in cavity QED systems and ion traps
3. Application extension: Explore applications in quantum information and quantum computing

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: Proposes a novel theoretical framework that challenges conventional views
2. Mathematical rigor: Rigorous mathematical derivations based on Landau theory
3. Universality: Theory verified in multiple important physical models
4. Practical value: Provides clear guidance for experimental and numerical research
5. Clear presentation: Logical structure and clear physical picture

Weaknesses

1. Lack of experimental verification: Primarily theoretical work lacking direct experimental evidence
2. Limited scope of applicability: Mainly applicable to long-range interaction systems
3. Numerical validation: Some results require more detailed numerical verification

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides new perspectives for quantum phase transition theory
2. Practical significance: Broad application prospects in quantum optics and condensed matter physics
3. Methodological contribution: Provides new tools for studying emergent phenomena

Applicable Scenarios

• Superradiant phase transitions in cavity QED systems
• Collective spin dynamics in ion traps
• Phase transition phenomena in cold atomic gases
• Design and optimization of quantum simulators

References

The paper cites 37 important references covering classical and recent research in related fields including Goldstone theorem, quantum phase transitions, ground-state factorization, and Dicke model, providing a solid foundation for theoretical development.

Overall Assessment: This is a paper of significant theoretical value that introduces the concept of emergent continuous symmetry and provides a unified theoretical framework for understanding ground-state factorization phenomena in quantum many-body systems. The theory is rigorous, widely applicable, and has important implications for the development of quantum physics.