Trends and Performance Visualization of Clutch Time in Japan's Professional B.League

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08597
• Title: Trends and Performance Visualization of Clutch Time in Japan's Professional B.League
• Authors: Shota Shiiku, Jun Ichikawa (Shizuoka University)
• Classification: physics.soc-ph (Sociophysics)
• Publication Date: 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08597

Abstract

With Japan's increasing competitiveness in basketball and critical performances in international competitions, clutch time performance has become increasingly important. This study analyzes clutch time performance in Japan's B.League using play-by-play and technical statistics data from the 2023-24 season. Clutch time is defined as the final 5 minutes of a game with a point differential of 5 or fewer. The study compares efficiency and shooting selection between clutch and non-clutch periods. The research focuses on effective field goal percentage (eFG%) across different spatial regions, including the paint, mid-range, and three-point areas, and investigates trends at both league and team levels. Through K-means clustering analysis of selected technical statistics features, the study further characterizes player types during clutch time. Results show that paint shots and clean three-point attempts maintain relatively high efficiency under pressure, while mid-range shooting effectiveness is more context-dependent. The championship finals exhibited tighter defense and targeted schemes, reducing three-point shooting percentages for many teams.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

This research addresses gaps in clutch time performance analysis for Japanese basketball, specifically including:

1. Clutch Time Shooting Efficiency Analysis: Quantifying performance differences across shooting zones under high-pressure conditions
2. Tactical Adaptability Assessment: Evaluating teams' ability to adjust tactics during clutch moments
3. Player Role Identification: Identifying player types that fulfill different functions during clutch time

Research Significance

1. Practical Relevance: Japan's basketball performance in international competitions such as the 2024 Paris Olympics highlights the importance of clutch time execution
2. Theoretical Value: Existing research primarily focuses on NBA data, lacking in-depth analysis of developing basketball markets
3. Tactical Guidance: Providing data-driven support for coaches' clutch time tactical planning

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Data Scope Limitations: Prior research primarily based on NBA data, lacking analysis of other leagues
2. Single Metrics: Most studies employ only simple indicators such as raw field goal percentage
3. Lack of Spatial Analysis: Insufficient consideration of value differences across shooting zones

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Analysis of Clutch Time in B.League: Filling a gap in Japanese professional basketball data analysis
2. Multi-Dimensional Efficiency Assessment Framework: Spatial region analysis methodology based on eFG%
3. Player Type Clustering Model: Identifying four player archetypes during clutch time through K-means
4. Tactical Adaptability Insights: Revealing how defensive intensity in championship finals influences shooting selection
5. Practical Tactical Recommendations: Providing guidance for lineup configuration and tactical choices during clutch moments

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Input: Play-by-play data and technical statistics from 739 games in the B.League 2023-24 season Output: Clutch vs. non-clutch efficiency comparison, team trend analysis, player type classification Constraints: Clutch time defined as final 5 minutes with point differential ≤ 5

Data Processing Architecture

1. Clutch Time Definition

• Time Window: Final 5 minutes of game
• Point Differential Threshold: ≤ 5 points
• Data Source: B1 League regular season + B.LEAGUE CHAMPIONSHIP 2023-24

2. Shooting Zone Classification

3. Core Metric Calculation

Effective Field Goal Percentage (eFG%):

eFG% = (FGM + 0.5 × 3PM) / FGA

Where:

• FGM: Total field goals made
• 3PM: Three-pointers made
• FGA: Total field goal attempts

Technical Innovations

1. Spatial Efficiency Analysis: Decomposing traditional overall shooting percentage into three value intervals, more accurately reflecting modern basketball shooting value
2. Pressure Context Comparison: Quantifying pressure impact through direct comparison of clutch vs. non-clutch moments
3. Multi-Level Analysis Framework: Combining league-wide, team-level, and individual player analysis
4. Clustering Feature Engineering: Player classification based on clutch time performance, identifying different tactical roles

Experimental Setup

Dataset

• Scale: 739 games (B1 League regular season + championship finals)
• Time Span: 2023-24 season
• Data Type: Play-by-play data + technical statistics
• Filtering Criteria: Player analysis requires ≥10 shot attempts and ≥10 three-point attempts

Evaluation Metrics

1. eFG%: Effective field goal percentage (primary metric)
2. Win Rate Correlation: Pearson correlation coefficient
3. Statistical Significance: t-test (p < 0.05)
4. Clustering Quality: K-means internal validation

Analysis Methods

1. Descriptive Statistics: Distribution characteristics of eFG% across zones
2. Hypothesis Testing: Paired t-tests for clutch vs. non-clutch periods
3. Correlation Analysis: Relationship between shooting efficiency and win rate
4. Cluster Analysis: K-means identification of player types

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Overall Efficiency Comparison

• Paint Shots: No significant difference between clutch and non-clutch times
• Three-Point Shots: Significant decline during clutch time t(46) = -3.004, p = 0.004
• Mid-Range Shots: Generally lower efficiency, pressure impact not significant

2. Win Rate Correlation Analysis

Key Finding: Non-clutch three-point efficiency shows significant positive correlation with win rate, while clutch time correlation is weaker.

3. Championship Finals vs. Regular Season Comparison

• Most Teams: Three-point shooting percentage declined during championship finals clutch time
• Ryukyu Golden Kings: Maintained stable three-point attempt rate and shooting percentage
• Chiba Jets, Nagoya Diamond Dolphins: Both attempt rate and shooting percentage declined

Player Type Clustering Results

Four player archetypes identified through K-means clustering:

Key Insight: Star scorer type contributes most to win rate, but balanced contributors also perform well.

Case Studies

Success Case: Ryukyu Golden Kings

• Stable three-point performance during clutch time in both regular season and finals
• Strong tactical execution consistency, unaffected by pressure

Challenge Case: Chiba Jets

• Both three-point attempt rate and shooting percentage declined during championship finals
• Likely affected by targeted defensive schemes

Related Work

Major Research Directions

1. NBA Clutch Time Analysis: Sarlis et al. proposed the EoCC metric to quantify player clutch impact
2. Shooting Selection Theory: Skinner et al. studied optimal shooting strategies in end-game situations
3. Pressure Performance Research: Schweickle et al. systematically reviewed critical performance in sports

Advantages of This Study

1. Geographic Extension: First systematic analysis of Asian professional basketball league
2. Methodological Innovation: Comprehensive framework combining spatial analysis and player clustering
3. Strong Practicality: Directly serving tactical needs of developing basketball markets

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Shooting Zone Efficiency Ranking: Paint ≈ Three-Point > Mid-Range, consistent with modern basketball value philosophy
2. Pressure Impact Pattern: Three-point shooting most susceptible to clutch time pressure
3. Tactical Adaptability: Championship finals require greater tactical flexibility to counter targeted defense
4. Player Configuration Strategy: Optimal combination of star scorers and balanced contributors

Limitations

1. Time Definition Constraints: The 5-minute, 5-point differential definition may miss other critical moments
2. Sample Size Limitations: Relatively scarce clutch time data, affecting statistical power
3. Missing Contextual Factors: Failure to account for foul situations, timeout usage, and other tactical factors
4. Causality: Correlation analysis cannot establish causal relationships

Future Directions

1. Extended Time Windows: Analyzing clutch time across different point differentials and time periods
2. Contextual Refinement: Incorporating richer contextual variables such as point differential and foul situations
3. Predictive Models: Developing predictive models for clutch time performance
4. Cross-League Comparison: Comparing with other Asian or developing basketball leagues

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Research Value: Filling an important gap in Asian basketball data analysis
2. Scientifically Rigorous Methodology: Using modern basketball analysis indicators such as eFG%
3. Strong Practicality: Directly serving decision-making needs of coaches and team management
4. Comprehensive Analysis: Multi-level analysis framework from league, team, to individual player levels
5. Clear Visualization: Chart design facilitates understanding of complex data relationships

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Statistical Power: Some correlation analyses fail to reach significance levels
2. Sample Representativeness: Based on single-season data, potential for random variation
3. Missing Mechanistic Explanations: Lacks in-depth exploration of psychological and physiological mechanisms underlying phenomena
4. Limited Comparative Baselines: Lacks cross-comparison with mature leagues such as the NBA

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new research perspectives for sports data science
2. Practical Value: Directly applicable to B.League team tactical planning
3. Methodological Value: Analysis framework generalizable to other sports
4. Policy Reference: Provides data support for Japanese basketball development policies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Professional Basketball Teams: Clutch time tactical planning and player rotation
2. Youth Development Systems: Targeted cultivation of clutch time execution ability
3. Sports Data Analysis: Providing analysis templates for other leagues
4. Sports Research: Athletic performance under pressure situations

References

The paper cites 16 important references, covering:

• Classic NBA clutch time analysis research (Oliver, Sarlis, et al.)
• Basketball analysis methodology (Skinner, Sandholtz, et al.)
• Pressure performance psychology research (Schweickle, et al.)
• Latest data-driven basketball strategy research (Eppel, Foteinakis, et al.)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality sports data science research paper with important contributions in both methodology and practicality. While it has certain limitations in statistical testing and sample size, its pioneering research value and clear analytical framework make it an important reference in the field.