Hausdorff dimension of the singular set for Griffith almost-minimizers in the plane

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08670
• Title: Hausdorff dimension of the singular set for Griffith almost-minimizers in the plane
• Authors: Manuel Friedrich, Camille Labourie, Kerrek Stinson
• Classification: math.AP (Analysis of PDEs)
• Publication Date: October 9, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08670

Abstract

This paper investigates the regularity of crack sets associated with Griffith fracture energy minimizers, which are commonly used in modeling brittle materials. The authors prove that cracks are uniformly rectifiable, and combined with previous ε-regularity results, establish that the Hausdorff dimension of the singular set is strictly less than 1. This dimension estimate applies equally to almost-minimizers. As a byproduct, the authors prove higher-order integrability of the gradient for Griffith energy local minimizers, providing an affirmative answer to an analogue of the De Giorgi conjecture for the Mumford-Shah functional.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Griffith Fracture Theory: Since Griffith's pioneering work in 1921, this theory has been fundamental to understanding the behavior of brittle materials. The core idea is that crack propagation results from competition between stored elastic energy and dissipation associated with infinitesimal crack growth.
2. Variational Framework: Francfort and Marigo reformulated Griffith's ideas in a variational setting, leading to the minimization problem for Griffith energy: $\int_{\Omega\setminus K} Ce(u) : e(u) dx + H^1(K)$ where $\Omega \subset \mathbb{R}^2$ is the reference configuration, $K \subset \Omega$ is the closed crack set, and $u : \Omega \setminus K \to \mathbb{R}^2$ is the displacement field.
3. Regularity Problem: By analogy with the Mumford-Shah conjecture, one expects that within $\Omega$, the cracks of minimizers should consist of smooth curves, intersecting at triple points or terminating at crack tips.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Challenge: Although the complete conjecture is currently unattainable, understanding the structure of singular points is crucial.
2. Technical Difficulties: Unlike the Mumford-Shah functional, Griffith energy involves symmetric gradients and lacks a corresponding coarea formula.
3. Methodological Innovation: New techniques are needed to handle linear elasticity in vector problems with cracks.

Core Contributions

1. Uniform Rectifiability: Proves that cracks of Griffith energy minimizers are locally uniformly rectifiable, meaning cracks are locally contained in curves with controlled geometric properties.
2. Singular Set Dimension Estimate: By combining ε-regularity results with uniform rectifiability, establishes the existence of a singular set $K^* \subset K$ such that $\dim(K^*) < 1-\delta$, and $K \setminus K^*$ is a $C^{1,1/2}$ manifold.
3. Higher-Order Integrability: Proves that the gradient of local minimizers has higher-order integrability, namely $e(u) \in L^p_{loc}$ for some $p > 2$.
4. Extension to Almost-Minimizers: All results apply to almost-minimizers, extending the applicability of the results.

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Study minimizers and almost-minimizers of Griffith energy $(u,K)$ in the plane, where:

• $u$ is the displacement field
• $K$ is the crack set
• The goal is to understand the geometric structure and singularities of cracks

Core Technical Methods

1. Uniform Rectifiability Proof

Key Idea: Prove that in most balls, cracks are "almost connected," meaning gaps have uniformly small size.

Main Steps:

1. Initialization of p-elastic energy: Using Ahlfors regularity and abstract results, find balls where $\omega_p(y,r) \leq \varepsilon$
2. Construction of separated rigid regions: Using piecewise Korn inequality, find rigid pieces in low elastic energy regions that are almost separated by cracks
3. Jump lower bounds: Prove that jumps between different rigid regions have lower bounds: $\frac{|b_i - b_j| + r|A_i - A_j|}{\sqrt{r}} \geq c_{jump}$
4. Connectivity argument: Through contradiction construction of competitors, prove that cracks must almost separate these regions

2. Singular Set Dimension Estimate

Porosity Method:

1. ε-regularity initialization: Use uniform rectifiability to initialize flatness $\beta$
2. Jump initialization: Initialize normalized jump $J$ through auxiliary lemmas
3. Porosity proof: Find large regions in each ball where $K$ is smooth
4. Dimension estimate: Exploit porosity to derive $\dim(K^*) < 1-\delta$

Technical Innovations

1. Piecewise Korn Inequality Application: Innovatively applies piecewise Korn inequality to handle rigidity control on domains with cracks.
2. Jump Initialization: Develops new techniques to initialize normalized jump $J$, overcoming control loss due to frame invariance.
3. Uniform Geometric Control: Establishes uniform control of crack geometric structure at all scales and locations.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Analysis Framework

This is a pure theoretical mathematics paper without numerical experiments, establishing results through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Key Parameters and Constants

• Ahlfors regularity constants: $C_{Ahlf} \geq 1$ and $\varepsilon_{Ahlf} \in (0,1)$
• Uniform rectifiability constants: $C_{ur} \geq 1$ and $\varepsilon_{ur} > 0$
• ε-regularity parameters: $\varepsilon_0 > 0$ and $\gamma \in (0,1)$

Proof Strategy

1. Normalization techniques: Use scale-invariant quantities such as $\omega_p$, $\beta_K$, $J_u$
2. Abstract lemma applications: Systematically apply Lemmas 4.2 and 4.3 for energy initialization
3. Geometric measure theory tools: Employ finite perimeter sets, Caccioppoli partitions, and other tools

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

Theorem 2.1 (Regularity of Almost-Minimizers)

For exponent $\alpha \in (0,1)$, there exist constants $\delta > 0$ such that for any almost-minimizer $(u,K)$ with gauge $h(t) = h(1)t^\alpha$, there exists a closed set $K^* \subset K$ satisfying:

• $\dim(K^*) < 1-\delta$
• $K \setminus K^*$ is a $C^{1,\alpha/2}$ manifold
• For local minimizers: $e(u) \in L^p_{loc}$, for some $p > 2$

Theorem 2.2 (Uniform Rectifiability)

The crack set $K$ of almost-minimizers of Griffith energy $(u,K)$ is locally uniformly rectifiable in $\Omega$.

Key Technical Estimates

1. Elastic Energy Control: $\int_{B(x,r)\setminus K} |e(u)|^2 dx \leq \bar{C}_{Ahlf}r$
2. Flatness Estimate: Obtained through uniform rectifiability $\int_{K\cap B(x,r/2)} \left(\int_0^{r/2} \beta^2_K(y,t)\frac{dt}{t}\right) dH^1(y) \leq C_0 r$
3. Jump Lower Bound: Under appropriate conditions $J(y,\gamma r_0) \geq C_0$

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Mumford-Shah Functional: Classical results by Ambrosio, De Giorgi, and others provide important inspiration for this work
2. Existence Theory: Dal Maso introduced the GSBD space; Friedrich et al. developed new compactness strategies
3. Regularity Theory:
   • Conti et al. proved local closedness and Ahlfors regularity of cracks
   • Babadjian et al. and Labourie-Lemenant obtained the first $C^{1,\alpha}$ regularity results
   • Earlier work by Friedrich-Labourie-Stinson 31 removed topological assumptions

Relationship to Mumford-Shah

The methodology is inspired by David-Semmes' analysis of the Mumford-Shah functional, but key differences include:

• Mumford-Shah penalizes the full gradient, allowing use of the coarea formula
• Griffith energy involves only symmetric gradients, requiring new technical tools

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Understanding Geometric Structure: First proof of uniform rectifiability of cracks in Griffith minimizers
2. Quantifying Singularities: Establishes strict upper bound on singular set dimension $\dim(K^*) < 1-\delta$
3. Regularity Enhancement: Proves higher-order integrability of the gradient, answering a De Giorgi-type conjecture

Limitations

1. Dimensional Restriction: Results are established only in the two-dimensional plane
2. Specific Structure: Although dimension less than 1 is proven, the precise characterization of the singular set (e.g., whether it consists of isolated points) remains open
3. Optimality: Whether the expected optimal integrability $e(u) \in L^{4,\infty}_{loc}$ can be achieved remains unresolved

Future Directions

1. Higher-Dimensional Extension: Extend results to three and higher dimensions
2. Precise Structure: Characterize the exact geometric structure of the singular set
3. Optimal Integrability: Achieve $L^{4,\infty}$ integrability and complete Mumford-Shah-type conjecture

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Innovation: Cleverly combines piecewise Korn inequality and uniform rectifiability theory, solving long-standing technical challenges
2. Theoretical Depth: Establishes milestone results in Griffith energy theory, filling important theoretical gaps
3. Systematic Methodology: The developed technical framework has broad applicability to related problems
4. Clear Exposition: Well-structured paper with careful treatment of technical details

Weaknesses

1. Dimensional Restriction: Methods strongly depend on piecewise Korn inequality in two dimensions, making higher-dimensional extension difficult
2. Constant Dependence: Specific values and optimality of several key constants remain unclear
3. Application Scope: Results are primarily theoretical; connections to practical fracture mechanics require further development

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important progress in the mathematical theory of fracture mechanics
2. Methodological Value: Developed technical tools have broad application prospects for free discontinuity problems
3. Interdisciplinary Connection: Bridges geometric measure theory, calculus of variations, and materials science

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Provides methodological guidance for studying other free discontinuity problems
2. Numerical Analysis: Provides theoretical foundation for numerical methods for Griffith energy
3. Materials Science: Supports mathematical modeling for understanding brittle material fracture

References

The paper cites 41 important references, including:

• 1 L. Ambrosio's classical work on existence for variational problems
• 5 L. Ambrosio, N. Fusco, D. Pallara's monograph on BV functions
• 18 G. David's monograph on the Mumford-Shah functional
• 31 Authors' previous work on ε-regularity
• 32 Authors' related work on strong existence

Summary: This is a paper with important breakthroughs in the mathematical theory of fracture mechanics. Through innovative technical methods, it resolves long-standing theoretical problems and provides a solid foundation for further development in this field.