Non-closed scalar charge in 4-dimensional Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet black hole thermodynamics

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08686
• Title: Non-closed scalar charge in 4-dimensional Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet black hole thermodynamics
• Authors: Romina Ballesteros, Marcela Cárdenas, Eric Lescano
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 9, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08686v1

Abstract

This paper develops a covariant differential forms framework for defining scalar charge in static, asymptotically flat black holes within four-dimensional Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet (EsGB) gravity theory. By contracting the scalar field equations of motion with the horizon generator k, a non-closed form of scalar charge is obtained, revealing volume contributions encoded in a 3-form that measures the obstruction to closure. When shift symmetry is present, this obstruction vanishes, and the 2-form scalar charge satisfies Gauss's law, depending only on boundary data. The framework allows analysis of the role of non-closed scalar charge in black hole thermodynamics and provides a covariant, charge-based explanation for the spontaneous scalarization mechanism.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is how to define a covariant scalar charge for general scalar coupling functions f(φ) in Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity theory, and to understand the role of these charges in black hole thermodynamics and spontaneous scalarization mechanisms.

Problem Significance

1. Theoretical Significance: EsGB theory naturally emerges in the low-energy effective action of string theory, where scalar couplings typically correspond to dilaton fields, and the Gauss-Bonnet term captures leading α' corrections to the classical Einstein-Hilbert action.
2. Physical Significance: In four dimensions, the GB term is a topological invariant and does not affect dynamics unless coupled to a dynamical scalar. Once such coupling is introduced, it modifies the dynamics and may induce scalar hair in black hole solutions.
3. Application Value: Paves the way for thermodynamic studies of more complex gravitational solutions, including derivation of the Smarr formula.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Shift Symmetry Restriction: Existing covariant scalar charge definitions primarily apply to theories with shift symmetry, lacking systematic treatment for general coupling functions f(φ).
2. Closure Problem: For general couplings, scalar charge is no longer a closed 2-form, preventing direct application of Gauss's law.
3. Thermodynamic Incompleteness: Lack of systematic methods to incorporate non-closed scalar charges into a complete thermodynamic framework.

Research Motivation

By developing a covariant differential forms framework to systematically handle scalar charge definitions under general coupling functions and connecting them to black hole thermodynamics and spontaneous scalarization mechanisms, providing a unified geometric understanding.

Core Contributions

1. Constructed a covariant framework for non-closed scalar charge: Defined non-closed form scalar charge for general scalar coupling functions f(φ) in EsGB theory, revealing the 3-form volume contribution Wk.
2. Established geometric meaning of obstruction terms: Proved that the 3-form Wk measures the obstruction to scalar charge closure, which vanishes in the shift-symmetric case.
3. Derived generalized Komar charge and Smarr formula: Complete thermodynamic relations including volume integral contributions; for the special dilaton coupling f(φ) = e^(-φ), volume contributions vanish.
4. Provided charge-based explanation for spontaneous scalarization: Connected the scalarization mechanism to scalar charge behavior and volume terms, offering geometric and covariant understanding.
5. Proved integral convergence: For a broad class of coupling functions, established convergence of relevant surface integrals and volume integrals.

Detailed Methods

Task Definition

Define covariant scalar charge for static, spherically symmetric, asymptotically flat black holes in EsGB gravity theory and analyze its role in thermodynamics. Input: general scalar coupling function f(φ); Output: complete scalar charge expression including boundary and volume terms.

Theoretical Framework

EsGB Action

The 4-form Lagrangian density of the theory is:

S = (1/16πG_N) ∫ [-⋆(e^a ∧ e^b) ∧ R_ab + (1/2)dφ ∧ ⋆dφ + α'f(φ)G]

where G is the 4-form Gauss-Bonnet density:

G = (1/2)ε_abcd R^ab ∧ R^cd

Scalar Charge Construction

By contracting the scalar field equations of motion with the Killing vector k:

ı_k E_φ = -ı_k d⋆dφ + α'∂_φf(φ)ı_k G

Using Cartan's formula and field invariance conditions:

ı_k E_φ = dı_k ⋆dφ + α'd(∂_φf(φ)X_k) - α'd(∂_φf(φ)) ∧ X_k

where X_k = -2P^ab_k R̃_ab is a Lorentz scalar and P^ab_k is the momentum map.

Obstruction Term Definition

Define the 3-form obstruction term:

W_k = d(∂_φf(φ)) ∧ X_k

This leads to non-closed scalar charge:

Q = -(1/4π)[ı_k ⋆dφ - 2α'∂_φf(φ)P^ab_k R̃_ab]

satisfying dQ = W_k.

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic treatment of general couplings: Without assuming shift symmetry, directly handles arbitrary f(φ).
2. Geometric obstruction terms: Encodes non-closure in a 3-form with clear geometric meaning.
3. Covariant construction: Entire framework maintains general covariance using differential forms language.
4. Unified thermodynamic description: Unifies scalar charge, Wald entropy, and Smarr formula in one framework.

Experimental Setup

Metric Configuration

Consider static spherically symmetric metric:

ds² = e^A(r)dt² - e^B(r)dr² - r²dΩ²_(2)

Asymptotic Behavior Analysis

At spatial infinity, metric components and scalar field asymptotic expansion:

φ = φ_∞ + Σ/r - MΣ/r² + O(r^(-3))

where Σ is the scalar charge parameter.

Convergence Analysis

For smooth coupling functions f(φ), proved:

1. Surface integrals converge at spatial infinity
2. Volume integral W_k decays as O(r^(-5)), ensuring absolute convergence
3. For broad classes of coupling functions (linear, polynomial, exponential forms), integrals are finite

Experimental Results

Main Results

Scalar Charge Expressions for Different Couplings

1. Linear coupling f(φ) = φ:

   Σ = 2α'κ
   

   
   Volume contribution W_k = 0 (shift-symmetric case)
2. Dilaton coupling f(φ) = e^(-φ):

   Σ = -2α'κe^(-φ_h) - (α'/4π)∫W_k
   

   
   Generalized Komar charge is closed (Z_k = 0)
3. Polynomial coupling f(φ) = φ^(2n):

   Σ = 2α'κ(2nφ_h^(2n-1)) - (α'/4π)∫W_k
   

Wald Entropy and Smarr Formula

General expression for Wald entropy:

S = (1/4G_N)(A + 2α'f(φ_h))

Smarr formula including volume contributions:

M = 2TS - Σ/4 + 2α'Φ_α'

where Φ_α' is the conjugate thermodynamic potential.

Spontaneous Scalarization Analysis

Conditions for spontaneous scalarization:

1. Scalar-free background must satisfy field equations: ∂φf(φ∞) = 0
2. Trivial configuration must be unstable under scalar perturbations: ∂²_φf(φ_∞) > 0

The obstruction term W_k becomes a linear function of ∂²_φf(φ_∞) and scalar perturbations under perturbation, providing a covariant geometric measure of instability.

Convergence Verification

For all considered coupling functions, verified:

1. Scalar charge integrals at spatial infinity converge to Σ
2. Volume integrals decay as O(r^(-5)), ensuring finiteness
3. Consistency of thermodynamic relations

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. No-hair theorems in scalar-tensor theories: Work by Bekenstein, Sotiriou, and others
2. Scalarization in Gauss-Bonnet gravity: Research by Silva, Doneva, and others on spontaneous scalarization
3. Covariant charge definitions: Applications of Wald formalism and Komar integrals
4. Black hole thermodynamics: Extended thermodynamics and generalizations of Smarr formula

Advantages of This Work

1. Generality: Handles arbitrary coupling functions, not limited to special cases
2. Covariance: Completely covariant differential forms framework
3. Completeness: Complete treatment from charge definition to thermodynamic relations
4. Geometric Insight: Provides geometric understanding of spontaneous scalarization

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. In EsGB theory, general coupling functions lead to non-closed scalar charge, whose non-closure is measured by the 3-form W_k
2. Shift symmetry is necessary and sufficient for scalar charge closure
3. For dilaton coupling f(φ) = e^(-φ), the generalized Komar charge becomes closed
4. The obstruction term W_k provides geometric origin of the spontaneous scalarization mechanism

Limitations

1. Static Restriction: Current analysis limited to static, spherically symmetric black holes
2. Asymptotic Flatness: Does not consider AdS or other asymptotic structures
3. Numerical Solution Dependence: Some integrals require specific numerical solutions

Future Directions

1. Rotating Black Holes: Extension to Kerr-like black holes including angular momentum contributions
2. AdS Case: Study holographic interpretations in asymptotically AdS spacetimes
3. Near-Horizon Geometry: Study universal relations of near-horizon geometry when W_k ≠ 0
4. Higher Dimensions: Extension to higher-dimensional EsGB theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Completely covariant differential forms treatment, mathematically strict
2. Deep Physical Insight: Connects non-closure of scalar charge to spontaneous scalarization
3. Result Completeness: Complete derivation from fundamental definitions to thermodynamic relations
4. Method Innovation: New framework systematically handling non-shift-symmetric cases
5. Convergence Proof: Rigorous proof of convergence for relevant integrals

Weaknesses

1. Limited Application Scope: Primarily applicable to static spherically symmetric cases
2. Numerical Computation Dependence: Some results require numerical solution of field equations
3. Lack of Experimental Verification: Theoretical results lack discussion of observational verification
4. Complexity: For general couplings, expressions become quite complicated

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new tools for thermodynamic research in EsGB theory
2. Methodological Value: Differential forms method generalizable to other modified gravity theories
3. String Theory Application: Direct application value for string theory black hole research
4. Reproducibility: Clear methods and verifiable results

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Black Hole Physics: Study black hole properties in modified gravity theories
2. String Theory Applications: Analyze black hole solutions in string theory effective actions
3. Gravitational Wave Physics: Understand gravitational deviations in strong-field regions
4. Cosmological Applications: Study scalar field roles in cosmic evolution

References

The paper cites extensive relevant literature, including:

• Classical work by Wald on black hole entropy and Noether charges
• Important research by Silva, Doneva, and others on spontaneous scalarization
• Recent advances by Ortín and others on covariant charge definitions
• Related literature on string theory and modified gravity

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions to black hole thermodynamics research in Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity theory. The paper employs rigorous methods, presents complete results, and provides new geometric insights for understanding scalar charge and spontaneous scalarization in modified gravity theories. While application scope has certain limitations, its theoretical framework possesses strong generalizability and application value.