Spin-Locking Spectroscopy of Harmonic Motion

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08732
• Title: Spin-Locking Spectroscopy of Harmonic Motion
• Authors: Florian Kranzl, Adria Rospars, Johannes Franke, Manoj K. Joshi, Rainer Blatt, Christian F. Roos
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08732v1

Abstract

Noise characterization of quantum harmonic oscillators is crucial for many experimental platforms. This paper experimentally demonstrates the motion spin-locking spectroscopy method, which allows direct measurement of the motion noise spectrum of quantum harmonic oscillators. The researchers measured the motion noise of a single trapped ion in the frequency range of 200 Hz to 5 kHz, with power spectral density resolution spanning two orders of magnitude in noise. Coherent modulation in the oscillator frequency can be detected at the $10^{-6}$ level.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: In quantum computing and quantum simulation platforms, control of the motion state of trapped particles is critical. Whether charged ions in radiofrequency traps or neutral atoms in optical tweezer arrays, particles must be cooled near the motion ground state and maintain stable motion to achieve high-fidelity quantum operations.
2. Problem Significance:
   • Two-qubit entangling operations (such as Mølmer-Sørensen gates) use common motion modes to mediate entanglement between qubits
   • Fluctuations in the trapping potential perturb the motion state, leading to quantum gate operation errors
   • Therefore, characterization of noise acting on trapped particles is necessary
3. Limitations of Existing Methods:
   • Ramsey experiments with Fock state superpositions
   • Motion spin-echo experiments with displaced coherent states
   • CPMG-type experiments with displaced cat states
   • Response measurements with modulated periodic driving
   • These methods either only indirectly obtain the noise spectrum or require experimental determination of response functions to reconstruct the spectrum
4. Research Motivation: Develop a method capable of directly measuring the noise spectrum of quantum harmonic oscillators, particularly for (harmonic) trapped ion systems.

Core Contributions

1. Experimentally demonstrated the motion spin-locking spectroscopy method, capable of directly measuring the noise spectrum of quantum harmonic oscillators
2. Measured motion noise of a single trapped ion in the frequency range of 200 Hz to 5 kHz, with power spectral density resolution spanning two orders of magnitude
3. Achieved relative frequency sensitivity at the $10^{-6}$ level, capable of detecting coherent modulation in the oscillator frequency
4. Provided a tool for improving charged particle trap stability, applicable to other systems with external degrees of freedom

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The task studied in this paper is to develop and validate a method for directly measuring the motion noise spectrum of quantum harmonic oscillators. The input is the motion state of a trapped ion system, and the output is the noise power spectral density in a specific frequency range.

Theoretical Foundation

Spin-Locking Spectroscopy Principle

In spin-locking spectroscopy, a two-level system (qubit) is resonantly driven by an oscillator with Rabi frequency Ω:

$H_{int}(t) = \frac{\hbar\Omega}{2}\left(e^{-i\phi(t)}\sigma_+ + e^{i\phi(t)}\sigma_-\right)$

where the phase $\phi(t) = \int_0^t \Delta(t')dt' + \phi(0)$ accounts for the time-dependent phase variation between the oscillator and the qubit.

Under the small phase change approximation $|\phi| \ll 1$ and applying the rotating wave approximation:

$H(t) = \frac{\hbar\Omega}{2}\phi(t)[\cos(\Omega t)\sigma_y - \sin(\Omega t)\sigma_z]$

Noise Response

For zero-mean Gaussian noise, the magnetization decays exponentially:

$\langle\sigma_x(t)\rangle = e^{-\frac{1}{2}\Omega^2 S_\phi(\Omega)t}\langle\sigma_x(0)\rangle$

where $S_\phi(\Omega)$ is the phase noise power spectral density at the Rabi frequency.

For coherent modulation $\phi(t) = \beta\cos(\omega t + \delta)$, when $\omega = \Omega$:

$\langle\sigma_x(t)\rangle = \cos\left(\frac{1}{2}\beta\Omega t\right)$

Motion Spin-Locking Spectroscopy

Experimental System

• Ion System: $^{40}Ca^+$ ions in a linear radiofrequency trap with transverse confinement frequency ~3 MHz
• Qubit Encoding: Ground state $|↓⟩ = |^4S_{1/2}, m=1/2⟩$ and metastable state $|↑⟩ = |^3D_{5/2}, m=5/2⟩$
• Laser System: 729 nm Ti:Sa laser, stabilized to high-finesse cavity with linewidth <10 Hz

Key Technical Innovations

1. Coherent Motion State Preparation: Using electric fields resonant with the ion oscillation frequency to prepare coherent motion states, rather than attempting to prepare high Fock states
2. Optimal Displacement Selection: Selecting average phonon number $\bar{n} = 610$ to maximize sideband coupling strength
3. Dual Transition Contrast: Simultaneously measuring carrier and motion sideband transitions to distinguish different noise sources

Experimental Protocol

1. Prepare coherent motion state $|\alpha⟩ = \sum_0^\infty c_n |↓,n⟩$
2. Blue sideband π/2 pulse creates superposition state $|+⟩_x = \sum_0^\infty c_n(|↓,n⟩ + |↑,n+1⟩)/\sqrt{2}$
3. Continuous rotation $R_x$ with duration t and Rabi frequency Ω
4. π/2 analysis pulse measures remaining magnetization $\langle\sigma_x(t)\rangle$

Experimental Setup

Experimental Parameters

• Confinement Frequencies: $\nu_x = 2\pi \times 3.167$ MHz, $\nu_y = 2\pi \times 2.909$ MHz
• Lamb-Dicke Parameter: $\eta = 0.038(3)$
• Excited State Lifetime: Decay rate $\Gamma = 0.9$ s$^{-1}$
• Frequency Range: 200 Hz - 5 kHz

Evaluation Metrics

• Noise Power Spectral Density: $S_\nu(\omega)$ (Hz²/Hz)
• Relative Frequency Sensitivity: $\Delta\nu/\nu_x$ level
• Modulation Index: $\beta$ and phase offset $\delta$

Comparison Methods

Contrast the noise spectrum of motion sideband transitions with that of carrier transitions to distinguish motion noise from laser/magnetic field noise.

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Noise Spectrum Measurement:
   • Motion noise spectrum in the 200 Hz to 5 kHz range shows a series of distinct peaks
   • Noise background decays according to $\omega^{-1.5}$ law
   • Carrier transition shows major noise peak at 60 kHz produced by laser lock feedback loop
2. Coherent Modulation Detection:
   • In the 400-1400 Hz range, confinement frequency is modulated up to $\Delta\nu = 56(2)$ Hz
   • Corresponding relative change $\Delta\nu/\nu_x = 2 \times 10^{-5}$
   • Uncertainty at approximately $10^{-6}$ level
3. Coupling Strength Verification:
   • Relative coupling strength of blue sideband reaches maximum at $\bar{n} = 610$ phonons
   • Relative standard deviation of Rabi frequency distribution $\sigma_\Omega = 3 \times 10^{-4}$

Case Analysis

Figure 3(b) shows the time evolution of several noise peaks, where magnetization exhibits damped oscillations rather than simple exponential decay, indicating these peaks have considerable coherence. By fitting the damped oscillation form of equation (5), both the modulation index and noise spectral density can be extracted simultaneously.

Experimental Findings

1. Noise Source Identification: Motion noise peaks appear only in sideband transitions, confirming their origin from confinement frequency fluctuations
2. Coherent Characteristics: Some noise peaks display coherent modulation characteristics, possibly originating from electronic stabilization circuits of the trap driving signal
3. Frequency Limitations:
   • Low frequency end: Strong noise exceeds weak noise approximation range
   • High frequency end: Laser noise dominates

Related Work

Comparison with Traditional Methods

1. Fock State Superposition Ramsey Experiments: Only indirectly obtain noise spectrum
2. Displaced Coherent State Motion Spin-Echo: Requires complex state preparation
3. CPMG-Type Experiments: Requires determining response function to reconstruct spectrum
4. Periodic Driving Response Measurement: High experimental complexity

Spin-Locking Spectroscopy Applications

• Superconducting qubit noise research
• Weak radiofrequency magnetic field detection
• Laser frequency noise measurement
• Single trapped ion electric field noise measurement

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully demonstrated the motion spin-locking spectroscopy method, capable of directly measuring the motion noise spectrum of quantum harmonic oscillators
2. Achieved high-precision noise measurement in the 200 Hz-5 kHz range, with power spectral density resolution spanning two orders of magnitude
3. Achieved relative frequency sensitivity at the $10^{-6}$ level, capable of detecting coherent frequency modulation

Limitations

1. Laser Noise Limitation: Probe laser noise limits high-frequency measurement capability
2. Finite Lifetime Limitation: Finite excited state lifetime sets the lower limit of detectable noise spectral density $S_{\nu,lim} = \Gamma$
3. Frequency Range Limitation: Current method is limited by strong noise below 200 Hz and laser noise above 5 kHz

Future Directions

1. Raman Transitions: Using Raman transitions connecting two ground states can eliminate laser noise and finite lifetime limitations
2. Multi-Ion Systems: Using N-ion crystals can reduce Lamb-Dicke parameter $\eta \propto 1/\sqrt{N}$
3. Application to Other Platforms: Extensible to other systems with external degrees of freedom such as optical traps

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Method Innovation: First extension of spin-locking spectroscopy to motion noise measurement, providing direct measurement capability
2. Clever Experimental Design: Coherent motion state preparation avoids the complexity of high Fock state preparation
3. High Measurement Precision: Achieves frequency sensitivity at the $10^{-6}$ level with noise resolution spanning two orders of magnitude
4. Reliable Results: Effective distinction of different noise sources through comparison of carrier and sideband transitions

Weaknesses

1. Limited Frequency Range: Measurable frequency range is relatively narrow due to multiple limiting factors
2. System Specificity: Current experiments validated only in $^{40}Ca^+$ system; applicability to other systems requires further verification
3. Theoretical Analysis Depth: Physical mechanism analysis of noise sources could be more thorough

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new experimental tools and theoretical framework for quantum noise spectroscopy
2. Practical Value: Directly applicable to improving stability of quantum computing and simulation platforms
3. Reproducibility: Clear experimental protocol and complete theoretical derivation ensure good reproducibility

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Computing Platforms: Noise diagnostics for trapped ion, neutral atom, and other qubit systems
2. Precision Measurement: Quantum sensing applications requiring high frequency stability
3. Fundamental Research: Basic physics research on quantum system-environment interactions

References

The paper cites 16 important references covering key areas including Mølmer-Sørensen gates, various noise measurement techniques, spin-locking spectroscopy theory and applications, providing a solid theoretical foundation and experimental comparison for this research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper making important contributions to the field of quantum noise spectroscopy. The method is novel, the experimental design is ingenious, the results are reliable, and it has significant practical value for quantum information processing and precision measurement fields.