Taming forward scattering singularities in partial waves

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08784
• Title: Taming forward scattering singularities in partial waves
• Authors: Marta Fuentes Zamoro (UAM/CSIC), Benjamín Grinstein (UCSD), Pablo Quílez (UCSD)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Submission Date: October 9, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08784v1

Abstract

Perturbative partial wave amplitudes diverge when the t-channel exchanged particle is massless. This paper argues that such divergences are artifacts of perturbation theory and provides a prescription for all-order correction factors that render partial waves finite. As an example, this method is applied to longitudinal $W^+W^-$ elastic scattering (where photon t-channel exchange contributions exist), deriving improved semi-perturbative unitarity bounds on the Higgs mass. The method is also useful for t-channel exchange of extremely light particles.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

Partial wave decomposition plays a crucial role in many important developments in particle physics:

1. Experimental data analysis: Used to reveal quantum numbers of resonant states observed in scattering
2. Theoretical analysis: Widely employed to exploit unitarity consequences of scattering amplitudes
3. Bound setting: Partial wave unitarity conditions are essential for establishing upper bounds on scattering amplitudes at asymptotically large center-of-mass energies

Core Problem

When massless particles are exchanged in the t-channel, the resulting scattering amplitude exhibits singularities in the forward direction—a non-integrable divergence that renders partial wave amplitudes ill-defined. This is precisely the same divergence displayed by the Rutherford scattering amplitude.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

Traditional methods regulate this divergence by introducing a small mass m in the propagator of the t-channel exchanged particle. However, the resulting unitarity bounds are sensitive to the value of mass m and become meaningless in the m→0 limit.

Research Motivation

This paper proposes a prescription that renders partial waves finite by incorporating non-perturbative effects, thereby resolving this long-standing technical difficulty.

Core Contributions

1. Proposes a new correction prescription: Provides a systematic method for handling partial wave divergences arising from massless particle exchange in the t-channel
2. Establishes theoretical foundation: Connects the correction factor to the exact solution of Coulomb scattering, providing physical intuition
3. Improves Higgs mass bounds: Applied to $W^+_LW^-_L$ scattering, yields improved semi-perturbative unitarity bounds
4. Extends application scope: The method applies to t-channel exchange of extremely light particles, with important implications for dark matter physics

Methodology Details

Core Prescription

For photon exchange between particles with charges $z_1$ and $z_2$, the tree-level amplitude is corrected as:

$T^{(0)} \rightarrow T^{(0)}e^{iW}$

where the phase factor is: $iW = \left(\epsilon - i\frac{z_1z_2\alpha_{em}}{\beta}\right)\ln\left[\frac{(1-\cos\theta)}{2}\right]$

Here $\beta = \sqrt{(p_1 \cdot p_2)^2 - m_1^2m_2^2}/(p_1 \cdot p_2)$ is the relative velocity, and $\epsilon \to 0^+$.

Physical Principles

The correction factor can be understood as:

1. Soft photon resummation: Resummation of long-range (soft) photon exchange contributions, corresponding to ladder diagram contributions
2. Non-relativistic limit: In the non-relativistic case, this exactly corresponds to the exact solution of Coulomb scattering
3. Relativistic generalization: Work by Dalitz and Weinberg provides supporting evidence for the relativistic case

Technical Implementation

The corrected partial wave amplitude integral: $a_\ell = \frac{1}{32\pi}\int_{-1}^{1} d\cos\theta \, P_\ell(\cos\theta) \, T^{(0)}(\sqrt{s}, \cos\theta) \, e^{iW}$

The oscillating phase factor $e^{iW}$ renders the originally divergent integral integrable.

Experimental Setup

Application Case: $W^+_LW^-_L$ Scattering

Studies elastic scattering of longitudinally polarized W bosons, which includes:

1. t-channel photon exchange: Causes forward divergence
2. Z boson exchange: Also yields divergent contributions in the large momentum expansion
3. Higgs exchange: Provides mass-dependent contributions

Scattering Amplitude

In the $p \to \infty$, fixed $\theta \neq 0$ limit: $T^0 = -\sqrt{2}G_F\left(2m_H^2 - \frac{(3+\cos^2\theta)(1-\cos\theta)m_Z^2}{1}\right)$

Calculation Details

Uses the complete scattering amplitude expression, including all t-channel contributions, with phase corrections applied to handle singularities.

Experimental Results

Higgs Mass Bounds

1. Classical LQT bound: $m_H \leq 1234$ GeV (considering only Higgs contribution)
2. Improved bound in this work: $m_H \lesssim 1420$ GeV (including all tree-level contributions)

Although numerically slightly weaker, the new bound:

• Includes all tree-level contributions (including photon exchange)
• Does not depend on the problematic large momentum expansion
• Provides more complete and consistent treatment

Key Findings

The corrected partial wave amplitude contains terms of the form $m_Z^2/\alpha_2$, demonstrating the non-perturbative nature of the result, where $\alpha_2 = g_2^2/4\pi$.

Light Particle Applications

For particles with mass $m \ll p$, the method eliminates unphysical sensitivity to mass, allowing calculations in the zero-mass limit.

Related Work

Historical Background

1. Classical results: Exact solution of Coulomb scattering (Messiah, Gottfried, et al.)
2. Relativistic generalization: Dalitz's quantum field theory calculations
3. Infrared divergences: Weinberg's work on infrared divergences from massless mediators
4. Unitarity bounds: Pioneering work by Lee, Quigg, and Thacker

Uniqueness of This Work's Contribution

• Provides a systematic prescription for handling partial wave divergences
• Establishes connections with known exact results
• Extends to relativistic cases and arbitrary spin

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method validity: The oscillating phase factor successfully tames forward scattering singularities
2. Physical reasonableness: The correction factor has clear physical interpretation (soft photon resummation)
3. Practical applications: Important applications in Higgs physics and light particle research

Limitations

1. Theoretical proof: Lacks rigorous first-principles derivation
2. Gluon exchange: Strong interaction case is more complex, requiring further study
3. Higher-order corrections: Systematic extension of the method requires more work

Future Directions

1. Rigorous proof: Establish first-principles foundation for the method
2. Strong interactions: Extend to gluon exchange cases
3. Phenomenological applications: Applications in effective field theory and new physics searches

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Innovation: Provides a new approach to a long-standing technical problem
2. Physical intuition: Connection with known exact results enhances credibility
3. Practical value: Broad application prospects in particle physics phenomenology
4. Mathematical rigor: Prescription is explicit and calculations are reproducible

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical foundation: Lacks complete theoretical proof
2. Scope of applicability: Treatment of strong interaction cases is insufficient
3. Numerical verification: Requires more independent numerical checks

Impact

This work is expected to have significant impact in:

1. Standard Model studies: Improved theoretical calculations in electroweak physics
2. New physics searches: Provides tools for beyond Standard Model research
3. Effective field theory: Applications in SMEFT and HEFT studies

Applicable Scenarios

• Scattering processes involving massless or extremely light particle t-channel exchange
• Theoretical analyses requiring precise unitarity bounds
• Dark matter and axion physics research
• Unitarity constraints in effective field theory

References

The paper cites important literature in the field, including:

• Lee, Quigg, and Thacker's classical unitarity bound work
• Pioneering research by Dalitz and Weinberg on infrared divergences
• Exact solutions of Coulomb scattering in quantum mechanics textbooks
• Recent advances in effective field theory unitarity constraints