Experimental observation of energy-band Riemann surface

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08819
• Title: Experimental observation of energy-band Riemann surface
• Authors: Dali Cheng, Heming Wang, Janet Zhong, Eran Lustig, Charles Roques-Carmes, Shanhui Fan
• Classification: physics.optics, cond-mat.other
• Institutions: Stanford University (Ginzton Laboratory, Department of Electrical Engineering, Department of Applied Physics)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08819

Abstract

Non-Hermiticity naturally arises in many physical systems that exchange energy with their environment. The presence of non-Hermiticity leads to many novel topological physics phenomena and device applications. In non-Hermitian energy band theory, the foundation of these physics and applications, both energies and wavevectors can take complex values. The energy bands thus become a Riemann surface, and such an energy-band Riemann surface underlies all the important signatures of non-Hermitian topological physics phenomena. Despite a long history and recent theoretical interests, the energy-band Riemann surface has not been experimentally studied. Here we provide a photonic observation of the energy-band Riemann surface of a non-Hermitian system. This is achieved by applying a tunable imaginary gauge transformation on the platform of the photonic synthetic frequency dimension. From the measured topology of the Riemann surface, we reveal the complex-energy winding, the open-boundary-condition spectrum, the generalized Brillouin zone, and the branch points. Our findings demonstrate a unified framework in the studies of diverse effects in non-Hermitian topological physics through an experimental observation of energy-band Riemann surfaces.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Universality of non-Hermitian systems: Non-Hermiticity naturally appears in many physical systems exchanging energy with their environment, particularly in photonics due to gain and loss in media
2. Theory development versus experimental gap: Although the concept of energy-band Riemann surfaces traces back to Kohn's pioneering work in 1959, experimental studies have been lacking
3. Importance of non-Hermitian topological physics: Non-Hermiticity leads to many novel topological phenomena, including non-Hermitian skin effects, exceptional points, and exceptional rings

Research Motivation

1. Need for unified theoretical framework: All important experimental signatures of non-Hermitian band theory relate to specific topological features on the energy-band Riemann surface
2. Urgency of experimental verification: Theoretical predictions require experimental verification to establish a complete physical picture
3. Technological applications: Applications in lasers, sensing, and communications require deeper understanding of non-Hermitian systems

Core Contributions

1. First experimental observation: Provides the first experimental observation of the energy-band Riemann surface of a non-Hermitian system
2. Innovative experimental method: Develops tunable imaginary gauge transformation technique based on the photonic synthetic frequency dimension platform
3. Unified measurement framework: Reveals complex-energy winding, open-boundary-condition spectrum, generalized Brillouin zone, and branch points from experimentally measured Riemann surface topology
4. Bridge between theory and experiment: Establishes a unified framework for studying diverse effects in non-Hermitian topological physics

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Foundation

Hamiltonian Model

Consider a one-dimensional tight-binding lattice model with translational invariance: $H_0 = \sum_{x\in\mathbb{Z}} \sum_{n\in\mathbb{Z},-r\leq n\leq r} g_n a_{x+n}^\dagger a_x$

where $g_n$ is the coupling strength, satisfying $g_n^* = g_{-n}$ for Hermitian systems, while for non-Hermitian systems $g_n$ can be arbitrary complex numbers.

Band Structure

The band structure connects the energy E of a state to its wavevector k: $E(k) = \sum_{-r\leq n\leq r} g_n e^{-ink}$

For non-Hermitian systems, both E and k can be complex, forming an energy-band Riemann surface.

Imaginary Gauge Transformation Method

Core Concept

Probe system behavior at arbitrary complex wavevectors through imaginary gauge transformation $k \to k + i\sigma$: $E(k + i\sigma) = \sum_{-r\leq n\leq r} g_n e^{n\sigma} e^{-ink}$

This corresponds to the modified lattice model: $H(\sigma) = \sum_{x\in\mathbb{Z}} \sum_{n\in\mathbb{Z},-r\leq n\leq r} (g_n e^{n\sigma}) a_{x+n}^\dagger a_x$

Experimental Implementation

In the photonic synthetic frequency dimension, implemented through periodic phase and amplitude modulation:

• Phase modulation: $\tau_{PM}(t) = e^{-2ig T_R \cos \Omega_R t}$
• Amplitude modulation: $\tau_{AM}(t) = e^{-2\kappa T_R \sin 2\Omega_R t}$

The imaginary gauge transformation is realized by substituting $\Omega_R t \to \Omega_R t + i\sigma$.

Experimental Platform Design

Ring Resonator System

• Ring resonator supporting equally-spaced frequency modes
• Periodic phase and amplitude modulation coupling adjacent frequency modes
• Each frequency mode treated as a lattice site

Measurement Scheme

• Excite the resonator with continuous-wave laser and measure transmission intensity signal $\mathcal{T}(\delta, t)$
• Interpret time t as wavevector k
• Resonance center position corresponds to $\text{Re}(E(k))$
• Linewidth corresponds to $\text{Im}(E(k))$

Experimental Setup

Specific Model

Study a lattice model H₁ with non-Hermitian next-nearest-neighbor coupling: $H_1 = \sum_x [g(a_{x+1}^\dagger a_x + a_{x-1}^\dagger a_x) + \kappa(a_{x+2}^\dagger a_x - a_{x-2}^\dagger a_x)]$

where $g = 2\kappa = 0.2$, and the band is $E(k) = 2g\cos k - 2i\kappa \sin 2k$.

Experimental Parameters

• Free spectral range: $\Omega_R$
• Round-trip time: $T_R = 2\pi/\Omega_R$
• Imaginary gauge parameter: $\sigma$ ranging from -0.5 to 0.5

Data Processing

• Extract complex energy using Lorentzian lineshape fitting
• Extend data through symmetry relation $E(\pi - k) = -E(k)$

Experimental Results

Energy-band Riemann Surface Reconstruction

1. Basic measurement: Measure conventional periodic boundary condition spectrum at $\sigma = 0$
2. Imaginary gauge scanning: Measure cross-sections at different $\text{Im}(k)$ planes by varying $\sigma$
3. Three-dimensional reconstruction: Stack complex energies from different $\sigma$ values on corresponding constant-$\text{Im}(k)$ planes

Topological Feature Identification

Complex-Energy Winding

• Observe winding patterns of complex-energy trajectories in different $\text{Im}(k) = \sigma$ planes
• Winding number characterizes point-gap topological properties
• Self-intersection points correspond to branch cuts

Open-Boundary-Condition Spectrum and Generalized Brillouin Zone

Identified by analyzing self-intersections of complex-energy winding:

• Self-intersection points satisfying winding number conditions (0, +1, 0, -1) constitute the OBC spectrum
• Corresponding wavevectors form the generalized Brillouin zone
• Experimental results show excellent agreement with theoretical predictions

Branch Point Observation

1. Branch point location: Model H₁ has four branch points located at $E = \pm 0.298 \pm 0.155i$
2. Cusp structure: Observe cusp features in complex-energy winding near branch points
3. Topological properties: Verify topological characteristics through closed trajectories around branch points

Physical Significance and Applications

Unified Theoretical Framework

Experiments confirm the energy-band Riemann surface as a unified framework for understanding non-Hermitian topological physics:

• Branch cuts correspond to OBC spectrum and GBZ
• Branch points correspond to Van Hove singularities
• Riemann surface topology determines system physical properties

Comparison with Traditional Methods

1. Measurement approach: Traditional methods require constructing open-chain systems; this method measures within the bulk
2. Information completeness: Provides complete complex-energy information rather than only real energy
3. Universality: Generalizable to multidimensional and multi-band systems

Related Work

Theoretical Development

• Kohn (1959): Introduction of energy-band Riemann surface concept
• Recent theoretical work: Non-Hermitian skin effects, generalized Brillouin zone theory
• Topological classification: Symmetry classification of non-Hermitian systems

Experimental Progress

• Photonic platforms: PT-symmetric microring lasers, exceptional point sensors
• Circuit systems: Non-Hermitian effects in topological circuits
• Ultracold atoms: Non-Hermitian quantum simulation

Uniqueness of This Work

Provides the first direct experimental observation of energy-band Riemann surfaces, filling an important gap between theory and experiment.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully achieved the first experimental observation of energy-band Riemann surfaces in non-Hermitian systems
2. Verified theoretical connections between Riemann surface topology and physical observables
3. Established a unified experimental framework for non-Hermitian topological physics research

Technical Significance

• Provides experimental tools for non-Hermitian topological device design
• Advances non-Hermitian physics from theory toward applications
• Opens new directions for quantum simulation

Future Directions

1. Multidimensional extension: Extend to two-dimensional and three-dimensional non-Hermitian systems
2. Multi-band systems: Study complex topological structures of multi-band models
3. Continuous systems: Apply to photonic crystals and metasurfaces
4. Nonlinear effects: Combine with nonlinear dynamics research

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Pioneering nature: First experimental observation of a long-standing theoretical concept with milestone significance
2. Methodological innovation: Imaginary gauge transformation technique is clever and practical
3. Experimental rigor: Systematic measurements and detailed data analysis
4. Theoretical depth: Deep understanding of connections between topological physics and experimental phenomena
5. Technical completeness: Complete chain from theoretical derivation to experimental implementation

Technical Highlights

1. Synthetic dimension platform: Full utilization of programmability of photonic synthetic frequency dimension
2. Complex parameter control: Precise control of complex wavevectors
3. Topological measurement: Direct measurement of topological invariants and topological phase transitions

Limitations

1. Model constraints: Currently limited to one-dimensional tight-binding models
2. Parameter range: Limited range for adjusting imaginary gauge parameters
3. Signal-to-noise ratio: Measurement precision of imaginary part of complex energy limited by system loss

Impact Assessment

1. Academic value: Provides important experimental foundation for non-Hermitian topological physics
2. Technological advancement: Promotes development of non-Hermitian photonic devices
3. Interdisciplinary impact: May influence condensed matter physics, quantum optics, and other fields
4. Educational significance: Provides intuitive physical realization of complex analysis theory

Reproducibility

The experimental design is clear, theoretical derivation complete, and shows good reproducibility. The maturity of the synthetic frequency dimension platform also facilitates verification by other research groups.

References

The paper cites 78 relevant references, covering a complete literature landscape from fundamental theory to latest experimental progress, particularly:

• Foundational works in non-Hermitian topological theory
• Experimental studies of non-Hermitian systems in photonics
• Development of synthetic dimension techniques
• Measurement methods in topological physics

Overall Assessment: This is an excellent paper of significant academic value and technical innovation, providing the first experimental observation of the important theoretical concept of energy-band Riemann surfaces and making important contributions to the development of non-Hermitian topological physics. The experimental design is ingenious, results are convincing, theoretical analysis is in-depth, and the work possesses strong influence and inspirational value.