Stability Estimates for Commutativity Properties of the Dirichlet-to-Neumann Operator

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08822
• Title: Stability Estimates for Commutativity Properties of the Dirichlet-to-Neumann Operator
• Author: Romain Speciel
• Classification: math.AP (Analysis of PDEs), math.DG (Differential Geometry), math.SP (Spectral Theory)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08822

Abstract

This paper investigates the relationship between the Laplace-Beltrami operator on the unit sphere $S^{n-1} \subset \mathbb{R}^n$ and the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map $\Lambda$ of the unit ball: $\Delta_{S^{n-1}} = \Lambda^2 + (n-2)\Lambda$. The author aims to characterize manifolds satisfying such exact relationships and measure deviations from this relationship using geometric data. Main contributions include: (1) stability estimates showing that for smooth bounded domains in $\mathbb{R}^3$, if the commutator $[\Lambda, \Delta_{\partial\Omega}]$ is small, then the domain is close to being spherical; (2) investigation of manifolds conformal to the sphere, proving that the above relationship implies a radial metric structure; (3) a modern exposition of Gohberg's lemma.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

The Dirichlet-to-Neumann map is a central object in geometric inverse problems with widespread applications in medical imaging and geophysical exploration. This map sends boundary functions to the normal derivatives of their harmonic extensions into the interior, and is fundamental to the celebrated Calderón problem.

Research Motivation

For the unit ball $B^n$, spherical symmetry allows explicit computation via eigenfunction decomposition, yielding the exact relationship $\Lambda^2 + (n-2)\Lambda = \Delta_{S^{n-1}}$. This surprising relationship between the boundary Laplace-Beltrami operator (a local differential operator) and the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map (a nonlocal pseudodifferential operator) motivates two core questions:

1. Problem I: When is $\Lambda$ exactly a function of $\Delta_{\partial M}$?
2. Problem II: More generally, when does $\Lambda$ commute with $\Delta_{\partial M}$?

Limitations of Known Results

Girouard et al. in references 7,11 proved that for Euclidean domains with $n \geq 3$, $[\Lambda, \Delta_{\partial\Omega}] = 0$ if and only if $\Omega$ is a ball. However, corresponding stability analysis is lacking—that is, the geometric properties of the domain when the commutator is small.

Core Contributions

1. Stability Estimates in the Euclidean Case: Proves Theorem 1.7, establishing that for smooth bounded domains in $\mathbb{R}^3$ diffeomorphic to a ball, if $\|[\Lambda,\Delta_{\partial\Omega}]\|_{H^1(\partial\Omega)\to L^2(\partial\Omega)} < \epsilon$, then there exists a conformal parametrization making the domain close to a ball.
2. Characterization for Conformal Manifolds: For manifolds conformal to the unit sphere, proves that $\Lambda_q$ is a function of the boundary Laplacian if and only if the potential $q$ is radial (Proposition 3.1).
3. Logarithmic Stability Estimates: Establishes Theorem 1.14, providing stability estimates with logarithmic modulus: $\|q - Pq\|_2 \leq C \cdot \omega(\|E\|_*)$, where $\omega(t) = |\log t|^{-\delta}$.
4. Perturbation Theory Results: Proves Theorem 1.17, showing that in the infinitesimal case of conformal perturbations, commutativity is equivalent to the radial nature of the potential.
5. Modern Exposition of Gohberg's Lemma: Provides a detailed modern proof of this fundamental microlocal analysis result in Appendix A.

Detailed Methodology

Problem Setup

Study the commutativity properties of the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map $\Lambda$ with the boundary Laplacian $\Delta_{\partial\Omega}$ and establish corresponding stability theory. Specifically, for a smooth bounded domain $\Omega$, $\Lambda$ is defined as: $\Lambda f = \partial_\nu u$ where $u$ satisfies $\Delta u = 0$ in $\Omega$ and $u|_{\partial\Omega} = f$.

Methodological Framework for the Euclidean Case

Step One: Symbol Analysis (Proposition 2.1)

Apply Gohberg's lemma to convert the analytical hypothesis on commutator norm into geometric conditions on the gradient of the second fundamental form: $\|[\Lambda,\Delta_{\partial\Omega}]\|_{H^1(\partial\Omega)\to L^2(\partial\Omega)} < \epsilon \Rightarrow \|\nabla II\|_\infty < C_n\epsilon$

Key technical points:

• Pseudodifferential operator representation of the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map: $\Lambda = \sqrt{\Delta_{\partial\Omega}} + B$
• Principal symbol computation: $\sigma_0(B)(x,\xi) = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{II(\xi,\xi)}{|\xi|^2} - (n-1)H\right)$
• Application of the Codazzi equation and symbol symmetry

Step Two: Geometric Stability Analysis

Combines two core lemmas:

1. Lemma 2.14 (Diameter Estimate): Uses Topping's inequality and the Bonnet-Myers theorem to establish diameter bounds under the assumption of umbilic points
2. Proposition 2.21: Proves near-umbilic property $\|II - H \cdot \text{Id}\|_\infty < \tilde{C}\epsilon$

Finally applies the De Lellis-Müller theorem 2.17 to complete the proof.

Methodological Framework for the Conformal Case

Metric Reduction

Reduces the conformal metric problem to a Schrödinger equation: for metric $g_\phi = e^{2\phi}g_{\text{std}}$, the corresponding Dirichlet-to-Neumann map is equivalent to the case $(\Delta + q)u = 0$, where $q = \frac{\Delta\sqrt{\gamma}}{\sqrt{\gamma}}$ and $\gamma = e^{(n-2)\phi}$.

Radial Projection Technique

Defines the radial projection operator: $Pf = \int_{SO(n)} f \circ R \, dV$ Uses density of harmonic functions and orthogonality of spherical harmonics to establish characterization results.

Technical Innovations

1. Integration of Microlocal Analysis and Geometry: First systematic application of Gohberg's lemma to geometric analysis of the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map
2. Comprehensive Control of the Second Fundamental Form: Controls not just mean curvature but the gradient of the entire second fundamental form
3. Application of Complex Geometric Optics: Combines CGO techniques with harmonic analysis in the conformal case
4. Precise Characterization of Logarithmic Stability: Provides explicit logarithmic modulus form

Experimental Setup

This is a pure theoretical mathematics paper with no numerical experiments. Results are verified through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Theoretical Verification Methods

1. Constructive Proofs: Explicit construction of function sequences satisfying the conditions
2. Proof by Contradiction: Uses contradiction arguments to eliminate impossible cases
3. Variational Methods: Applies geometric inequalities and variational principles
4. Microlocal Analysis: Uses pseudodifferential operator theory and symbol calculations

Application of Key Inequalities

• Topping's Inequality: Establishes relationships between diameter and mean curvature
• Gauss-Bonnet Theorem: Constrains integral of curvature
• Sobolev Embedding: Controls norm relationships between function spaces

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

Significance of Theorem 1.7

For smooth domains in $\mathbb{R}^3$ with area $4\pi$, establishes quantitative stability: $\|[\Lambda,\Delta_{\partial\Omega}]\|_{H^1(\partial\Omega)\to L^2(\partial\Omega)} < \epsilon \Rightarrow \|\psi - (c_{\partial\Omega} + \iota)\|_{H^2(S^2)} < C\epsilon$

This provides a direct bridge from analytical conditions to geometric conclusions.

Logarithmic Stability of Theorem 1.14

$\|q - Pq\|_2 \leq C \cdot |\log \|E\|_*|^{-\delta}$ Such logarithmic stability is standard in inverse problems, reflecting the inherent difficulty of the problem.

Constructive Examples

Example 2.11 (Delaunay Surfaces)

The author cleverly constructs a counterexample showing that controlling only the mean curvature gradient is insufficient:

• Constructs Delaunay surfaces via elliptic rolling
• Uses smooth truncation techniques to obtain topological spheres
• Proves that $|\nabla H|$ can be arbitrarily small while the surface is far from spherical

This example emphasizes the necessity of controlling the entire second fundamental form.

Perturbation Analysis Results

Theorem 1.17 completely characterizes commutativity at the infinitesimal level: $[\Lambda', \Delta_{S^{n-1}}] = 0 \Leftrightarrow q' = Pq'$

Related Work

Core Literature Context

1. Girouard et al. 7,11: Establish necessary and sufficient conditions for commutativity, but lack stability analysis
2. Sylvester-Uhlmann 12: Application of CGO methods to the Calderón problem
3. De Lellis-Müller 4: Rigidity estimates for near-umbilic surfaces
4. Alessandrini 1: Stability theory for conductivity inverse problems

Novelty of This Work

• First to establish quantitative stability theory for commutativity
• Systematically investigates the conformal case
• Provides a modern complete proof of Gohberg's lemma

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. In the Euclidean case, smallness of the commutator directly implies sphericity of the domain
2. In the conformal case, functional relationships are equivalent to radial structure
3. Stability exhibits logarithmic character, typical in inverse problems

Limitations

1. Dimension Restriction: Main results limited to $\mathbb{R}^3$; higher dimensions require new techniques
2. Topological Assumptions: Requires domains to be diffeomorphic to a ball
3. Smoothness Requirements: Requires sufficiently smooth boundaries
4. Perturbation Theory: Results for the conformal case mainly at the infinitesimal level

Future Directions

The author proposes two important open problems:

• Open Problem 2.26: Extension to higher dimensions and more general topologies
• Open Problem 3.20: Non-perturbative version for the conformal case

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Combines microlocal analysis, differential geometry, and inverse problem theory
2. Methodological Innovation: First systematic application of Gohberg's lemma to geometric analysis
3. Complete Results: Comprehensive theory from necessary and sufficient conditions to quantitative estimates
4. Technical Rigor: Detailed and rigorous proofs, particularly the Gohberg lemma proof in the appendix
5. Important Problem: Resolves an important conjecture in the field

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Strong restrictions on dimension and topology
2. High Technical Threshold: Requires deep background in microlocal analysis
3. Unclear Practical Applications: Practical applicability of theoretical results remains to be explored
4. Computational Complexity: Involved constant estimates may lack precision

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new perspective on Dirichlet-to-Neumann map theory
2. Methodological Value: Exemplifies combination of microlocal analysis and geometry
3. Future Research: Provides research framework for related stability problems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Geometric Inverse Problems: Medical applications such as electrical impedance tomography
2. Spectral Geometry: Geometric applications of eigenvalue problems
3. Conformal Geometry: Stability analysis of metric perturbations

References

The paper cites 15 important references covering multiple domains including microlocal analysis, differential geometry, and inverse problem theory, with high quality and strong relevance.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that resolves important problems in Dirichlet-to-Neumann map theory with novel methods and profound results. While having certain limitations in scope of applicability, it provides important theoretical foundations and methodological guidance for related research.