Towards Quantum Simulations of Sphaleron Dynamics at Colliders

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08910
• Title: Towards Quantum Simulations of Sphaleron Dynamics at Colliders
• Authors: Min Huang, Ying-Ying Li, Yandong Liu, Hao Zhang
• Classification: hep-ph hep-ex hep-lat hep-th
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08910

Abstract

Sphaleron dynamics in the Standard Model remain experimentally unobserved in high-energy particle collisions, with theoretical predictions hindered by their non-perturbative real-time nature. This work investigates quantum simulation approaches to address this challenge. Using a 1+1 dimensional O(3) model as a protocol for studying sphaleron dynamics in electroweak theory, the authors identify sphaleron configurations and establish lattice parameters capable of reproducing continuum sphaleron energy with controllable precision. Subsequently, quantum algorithms are developed to simulate sphaleron evolution incorporating quantum effects. This work establishes the foundation for quantum simulations to study interactions between classical topological objects and particles in quantum field theory, which are typically inaccessible through classical methods and computations.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Missing Experimental Observation of Sphaleron Processes: In the Standard Model, sphalerons are finite-energy saddle-point solutions in field space that lead to baryon and lepton number violation, crucial for explaining observed baryon asymmetry, yet remain unobserved in high-energy collisions.
2. Enormous Discrepancies in Theoretical Predictions: Various computational methods yield sphaleron production rate predictions differing by several orders of magnitude, potentially due to the real-time nature of multi-sphaleron processes invalidating Euclidean spacetime calculations.
3. Computational Challenges in Non-perturbative Quantum Processes: Sphaleron processes are inherently non-perturbative real-time quantum field theory processes requiring real-time simulations with Hamiltonian descriptions, exceeding the capabilities of traditional computational methods.

Research Motivation

1. New Opportunities from Quantum Computing: With quantum technology development, the number of quantum computing storage units (qubits) is expected to grow polynomially, creating new opportunities for non-perturbative calculations.
2. Similarities of the 1+1 Dimensional O(3) Model: This model exhibits remarkable similarities to non-Abelian gauge theories and, when augmented with explicit symmetry-breaking terms, serves as a toy model for studying sphaleron production in electroweak theory.

Core Contributions

1. Established Sphaleron Configurations on the Lattice: Identified and constructed discrete lattice sphaleron solutions in the 1+1 dimensional O(3) nonlinear sigma model, resolving the mapping problem from continuous to discrete theory.
2. Determined Lattice Parameters with Controllable Precision: Systematically established parameter choices for lattice volume L and lattice spacing a such that lattice sphaleron energy reproduces continuum results with controllable accuracy.
3. Developed Quantum Algorithms for Sphaleron Evolution: Designed quantum circuits based on Trotterization schemes capable of simulating sphaleron time evolution incorporating quantum effects.
4. Proposed Two Strategies for Quantum State Construction: To address the quantum state corresponding to classical configurations, proposed coherent state methods and background field methods as possible research directions.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

The research objective is to simulate sphaleron processes on quantum computers, including:

• Input: Initial classical sphaleron configuration
• Output: Quantum evolution dynamics of sphalerons, including decay products and decay rates
• Constraints: Qubit number limitations in the NISQ era (~100 qubits)

Theoretical Framework

O(3) Nonlinear Sigma Model

The classical action is:

S = (1/g²)∫dt dx [1/2 ∂μn·∂μn - ω²(1 + n·ez)]

where n(x)·n(x) ≡ 1 is a normalized classical field from R² to S².

Parametrization

Using spherical coordinate parametrization:

n(ξ,η) = (sin η sin ξ, sin η cos η(cos ξ - 1), -sin²η cos ξ - cos²η)

Sphaleron Solution in Continuum

Under the condition η = π/2, the sphaleron configuration is:

ξsph(x) = {
  2 arcsin(sech(ωx)), x < 0
  2π - 2 arcsin(sech(ωx)), x ≥ 0
}

with corresponding sphaleron energy: Esph = 8ω/g²

Lattice Discretization

Lattice Hamiltonian

For a system with 2N+1 lattice sites and lattice spacing a = L/2N:

H^latt = (1/ag²)∑[k=-N to N-1](1 - nk·nk+1) + (aω²/g²)∑[k=-N to N](1 + nk·ez)

Boundary Conditions and Constraints

To avoid trivial solutions, constraint conditions are adopted:

ξ-N = 0, ξ0 = π, ξN = 2π
For all k ∈ [-N,N): ξk < ξk+1

Quantum Algorithm Design

Quantized Hamiltonian

Ĥtot = (g²/2a)∑L̂²k + (1/ag²)∑(1 - n̂k·n̂k+1) + (aω²/g²)∑(1 + n̂k·ez)

Trotterization Decomposition

The Hamiltonian is decomposed into three non-commuting terms:

• Ĥ₁ = (g²/2a)∑L̂²k (momentum term)
• Ĥ₂ = (1/ag²)∑(1 - n̂k·n̂k+1) (interaction term)
• Ĥ₃ = (aω²/g²)∑(1 + n̂k·ez) (potential term)

Second-order Trotterization: U(Δt) = ∏l=1 to 3Ul(Δt)∏l=0 to 3Ul(Δt)

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• Number of lattice sites: 2N+1 = 5 to 241 sites
• Lattice volume: L = 12
• Symmetry-breaking parameter: ω = 1/2
• Coupling constant: g = 1
• Quantum number truncation: lmax = 1 (corresponding to nq = 2 qubits per site)

Evaluation Metrics

1. Relative Energy Error: δE ≡ Esph(L,a) - Esph
2. Configuration Convergence: Comparison of 1 + nk·ez distribution with continuum solution
3. Energy Density Distribution: Comparison of dE/dx with continuum theory

Quantum Circuit Complexity Analysis

• For 5-site system (2N+1=5), lmax=1:
  • n̂k·ez decomposed into K₁=4 independent Pauli strings
  • n̂k·n̂k+1 decomposed into K₂=34 independent Pauli strings
  • Single Pauli string evolution requires O(50) CNOT gate depth
  • Total circuit depth: O(5×10³) to O(3×10⁴)

Experimental Results

Lattice Parameter Optimization Results

1. Energy Convergence: As the number of lattice sites increases to 2N+1≥15, lattice sphaleron energy rapidly converges to the continuum value with well-controlled relative error.
2. Configuration Precision: Figure 4 shows that as lattice spacing a decreases, the lattice sphaleron configuration gradually approaches the continuum solution, achieving near-perfect coincidence at 2N+1=241.
3. Energy Density Distribution: Figure 5 demonstrates the convergence behavior of energy density dE/dx at different lattice site numbers, validating the effectiveness of discretization.

Quantum Algorithm Feasibility

• For NISQ devices (~100 qubits), the current approach requires specialized quantum error mitigation/correction to obtain reliable results
• Trotterization error estimate: For ε_ps ~ 1%, Δt/a ~ 0.1, approximately r ~ 100 Trotter steps are needed

Related Work

Sphaleron Theory Research

1. Classical Sphaleron Solutions: Manton (1983), Klinkhamer-Manton (1984) established saddle-point solutions in Weinberg-Salam theory
2. Finite Temperature Calculations: Large-scale lattice simulations computing sphaleron rates at finite temperature
3. Collider Phenomenology: Predictions of baryon number violation processes at LHC and ultra-high-energy neutrino collisions

Quantum Simulations of Quantum Field Theory

1. Sigma Model Quantum Simulations: Alexandru et al. (2019) first simulated sigma models on quantum computers
2. Nonlinear Sigma Models: Bruckmann et al. (2019) studied O(3) models using matrix product states
3. Topological Term Simulations: Araz et al. (2023) investigated quantum simulations of nonlinear sigma models with topological terms

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established lattice representations of sphalerons in the 1+1 dimensional O(3) model and verified convergence to the continuum limit
2. Developed a complete quantum algorithm framework capable of simulating real-time evolution dynamics of sphalerons
3. Established theoretical and technical foundations for quantum simulations of sphaleron processes in the Standard Model

Limitations

1. Qubit Requirements: Current NISQ device qubit counts and coherence times limit system scale
2. Truncation Effects: Finite lmax truncation violates commutation relations, affecting quantization accuracy
3. Initial State Construction: The definition of quantum states corresponding to classical sphaleron configurations requires further investigation

Future Directions

The paper proposes three main development directions:

1. Sphaleron Production Rate Calculation: Develop quantum algorithms to extract sphaleron production rates and branching ratios in high-energy collisions
2. Chern-Simons Number Evolution: Measure topological charge changes during sphaleron dynamics
3. Fermionic Degrees of Freedom: Incorporate fermionic fields into the framework to study complete baryon number violation processes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High Innovation: First application of quantum computing to sphaleron dynamics research, opening new research directions
2. Theoretical Rigor: Systematically addresses the mapping from continuous to discrete theory, proving saddle-point properties of sphaleron solutions
3. Complete Methodology: Forms a comprehensive research framework from classical configuration identification to quantum algorithm design
4. Practical Value: Provides new approaches to solving the long-standing sphaleron observation problem in the Standard Model

Limitations

1. High Quantum Resource Requirements: Required quantum circuit depth poses challenges for NISQ devices, making practical implementation difficult
2. Model Simplification: The 1+1 dimensional O(3) model remains significantly simplified compared to 4-dimensional electroweak theory
3. Unresolved Initial State Problem: The quantum state construction method corresponding to classical sphaleron configurations remains unclear

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides new research paradigms for quantum simulations in quantum field theory
2. Practical Prospects: With quantum technology development, may solve important outstanding problems in high-energy physics
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects quantum computing, high-energy physics, and condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Suitable for studying quantum dynamics of topological solitons
2. Method Development: Provides reference for quantum simulations of other non-perturbative quantum field theory problems
3. Educational Use: Serves as a typical case study for quantum simulations in quantum field theory

References

The paper cites 42 important references covering classical and cutting-edge work in sphaleron theory, quantum simulations of quantum field theory, and lattice field theory, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.