Semihard interactions at TeV energies

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.08963
• Title: Semihard interactions at TeV energies
• Authors: T. V. Iser, E. G. S. Luna (Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil)
• Categories: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), hep-ex (High Energy Physics - Experiment), nucl-th (Nuclear Theory)
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.08963

Abstract

This paper investigates the high-energy behavior of the total cross section σ_tot and the ratio of real to imaginary parts of the scattering amplitude ρ in proton-proton (pp) and antiproton-proton (p̄p) scattering. The study is based on a QCD-inspired model in which the growth of the cross section is primarily driven by semihard processes involving gluons. The paper addresses the tension between measurements from the ATLAS/ALFA and TOTEM collaborations, demonstrating that independent analyses of their datasets can provide statistically consistent overall descriptions of the data, although the model predictions cannot fully reproduce the central value of the ρ parameter at √s = 13 TeV. The slight discrepancy between model predictions obtained using asymptotically leading cross-symmetric elastic scattering amplitudes and experimental central values points to the possible existence of an odd component in the semihard amplitude at high energies.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Theoretical description of high-energy hadron scattering: How to accurately describe the total cross section and ρ parameter in proton-proton and antiproton-proton scattering in the TeV energy region
2. Experimental data tension: Resolving systematic differences between measurements from ATLAS/ALFA and TOTEM collaborations in the LHC energy region
3. QCD theory validation: Verifying the validity of QCD-based minijet models at high energies
4. Odderon existence: Investigating whether cross-symmetric antisymmetric components need to be included in high-energy scattering amplitudes

Significance

• Fundamental physics understanding: The behavior of strong interactions at extremely high energies is a core issue in particle physics
• Cosmic ray physics applications: High-energy hadron scattering cross sections are crucial for cosmic ray cascade simulations
• LHC experiment guidance: Providing theoretical expectations for LHC and future collider experiments

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Pure soft process models cannot explain the rapid growth of cross sections at high energies
• The applicability of traditional Regge theory at extremely high energies remains controversial
• Systematic differences in data from different experimental groups lack unified explanation

Core Contributions

1. Unified theoretical framework: Establishing a QCD-based eikonal minijet model capable of simultaneously describing contributions from soft and semihard processes
2. Solution to experimental tension: Achieving consistent descriptions of ATLAS/ALFA and TOTEM data by introducing normalization factors to handle luminosity uncertainties
3. Odderon effect prediction: Based on model deviations from 13 TeV data, predicting that high-energy scattering may require inclusion of asymptotically surviving odd components
4. Systematic PDF study: Assessing the impact of different parton distribution functions (NNPDF4.0, CT18) on high-energy predictions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Studying two key observables in hadron-hadron scattering in the forward direction (t=0):

• Input: Collision energy √s, hadron type (pp or p̄p)
• Output: Total cross section σ_tot(s) and ρ parameter ρ(s) = Re A(s,0)/Im A(s,0)
• Constraints: Satisfying unitarity, analyticity, and crossing symmetry

Model Architecture

1. Eikonal Representation

The scattering amplitude adopts the eikonal form:

A^AB(s,t) = i ∫₀^∞ b db J₀(b√(-t))[1 - e^(-χ^AB(s,b))]

where χ(s,b) is the complex eikonal function, decomposed into even and odd components:

χ^pp,p̄p(s,b) = χ₊(s,b) ± χ₋(s,b)

2. Soft-Hard Decomposition

The eikonal function is decomposed into soft and semihard process contributions:

χ±(s,b) = χ±_soft(s,b) + χ±_SH(s,b)

3. Semihard Eikonal

The semihard contribution based on QCD parton model:

χ₊_SH(s,b) = (1/2)N σ_QCD(s)W_SH(b;ν_SH)

where:

• σ_QCD(s): QCD jet production cross section
• W_SH(b;ν_SH): Parton overlap density function
• N, ν_SH: Adjustable parameters

4. QCD Cross Section Calculation

Including dominant gluon-initiated processes: gg→gg, qg→qg, q̄g→q̄g, gg→qq̄

Using NLO parton distribution functions and K-factor corrections:

dσ̂^NLO_ij→kl/dp²_T = K dσ̂^LO_ij→kl/dp²_T

Technical Innovations

1. Crossing symmetry handling: Automatically satisfying analyticity constraints through dispersion relations
2. NLO correction strategy: Using K-factors and NLO PDFs to partially include higher-order corrections
3. Soft-hard unification: Handling different energy scale physics processes within a single framework
4. Experimental tension treatment: Addressing systematic uncertainties through normalization parameters

Experimental Setup

Datasets

Two data ensembles:

• Ensemble A: PDG data + ATLAS/ALFA measurements (√s = 7, 8, 13 TeV)
• Ensemble T: PDG data + TOTEM measurements (√s = 2.76, 7, 8, 13 TeV)

Energy range: √s = 10 GeV to 13 TeV

PDF Selection

• NNPDF4.0: Machine learning approach based on neural networks
• CT18: CTEQ-TEA collaboration global analysis
• MSHT20: Test case (results too steep, poor fit quality)

Evaluation Metrics

• χ²/ν: Reduced chi-square test for fit quality
• Parameter uncertainties: 90% confidence intervals
• Prediction accuracy: Deviations from experimental central values

Implementation Details

• Free parameters: 7 (2 semihard + 5 soft process parameters)
• p_T^min selection: 1.1 GeV (CT18), 1.3 GeV (NNPDF4.0)
• Fitting method: χ² minimization, requiring positive-definite covariance matrix

Experimental Results

Main Results

Fit Quality

13 TeV Prediction Comparison

Ensemble A Results:

• CT18: σ_tot = 103.2 mb, ρ = 0.113
• NNPDF4.0: σ_tot = 102.7 mb, ρ = 0.105
• ATLAS/ALFA experiment: σ_tot = 104.68±1.08 mb, ρ = 0.098±0.011

Ensemble T Results:

• CT18: σ_tot = 107.8 mb, ρ = 0.120
• NNPDF4.0: σ_tot = 107.1 mb, ρ = 0.111
• TOTEM experiment: σ_tot = 110.1±2.0 mb, ρ = 0.09-0.10±0.01

Key Findings

1. Statistical consistency: Both datasets achieve statistically satisfactory fits (χ²/ν ≈ 1.1)
2. ρ parameter deviation: Model predictions for ρ are systematically higher than experimental central values
3. PDF sensitivity: NNPDF4.0 is closer to experimental data than CT18
4. Energy extrapolation: The model exhibits reasonable asymptotic behavior at high energies

Systematic Analysis

• Parameter correlations: Soft process parameters are statistically independent of semihard parameters
• Scale dependence: NLO treatment significantly reduces scale sensitivity
• Uncertainty propagation: Theoretical uncertainties are absorbed through K-factors and normalization parameter N

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Regge theory: Pomeron and Odderon exchange models
2. Minijet models: QCD-based semihard scattering theory
3. Eikonal methods: Scattering amplitude parameterization satisfying unitarity
4. Experimental measurements: Precision measurements from LHC forward detectors

Advantages of This Work

1. Theoretical rigor: Strictly satisfying analyticity and unitarity constraints
2. Experimental coverage: Unified treatment of data from ISR to LHC across all energy ranges
3. Systematic study: First systematic analysis of ATLAS/ALFA and TOTEM data tension
4. Predictive power: Predicting odderon effects based on theoretical deviations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Model validity: QCD-inspired eikonal model can statistically describe high-energy hadron scattering data
2. Experimental consistency: ATLAS/ALFA and TOTEM data can achieve consistent descriptions under their respective normalizations
3. Odderon indication: Systematic deviation of ρ parameter suggests possible need for including odd component contributions
4. Gluon dominance: High-energy scattering is indeed driven by gluon-dominated semihard processes

Limitations

1. LO approximation: Although using NLO PDFs, the basic framework remains leading order
2. K-factor simplification: Constant K-factor cannot fully replace complete NLO calculations
3. Soft process model: Soft eikonal parameterization remains phenomenological
4. Missing odd component: Current model does not include semihard odd components

Future Directions

1. Odd component study: Developing models incorporating asymptotically surviving odd components
2. Unitarization improvement: Systematically studying effects of different unitarization schemes
3. NLO refinement: More rigorous NLO treatment and resummation techniques
4. New experimental data: Incorporating future measurements at higher energies and precision

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Rigorous theoretical framework satisfying fundamental physical constraints
2. Experimental relevance: Directly addressing important current LHC experimental controversies
3. Predictive value: Predicting possible odderon existence based on theoretical analysis
4. Methodological innovation: Clever handling of experimental systematic errors through normalization methods
5. Computational rigor: Detailed numerical implementation and error analysis

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical level: Still remains at semi-phenomenological level, lacking pure theoretical derivation
2. Parameter count: 7 free parameters are relatively numerous, with potential overfitting risk
3. Energy extrapolation: Reliability of predictions at extremely high energies requires further verification
4. Odd component treatment: Discussion of odd components mainly based on fitting deviations, lacking independent evidence

Impact

1. Experimental guidance: Providing theoretical framework for resolving LHC experimental controversies
2. Theory development: Promoting combination of high-energy QCD and Regge theory
3. Cosmic ray applications: Providing important input for ultra-high-energy cosmic ray research
4. Future experiments: Providing theoretical expectations for next-generation collider experiments

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-energy colliders: Theoretical predictions for LHC and future higher-energy colliders
2. Cosmic ray physics: Simulation of ultra-high-energy cosmic ray interactions with atmosphere
3. Theoretical research: Phenomenological study of QCD in non-perturbative regions
4. Experimental analysis: Theoretical interpretation framework for forward scattering experiments

References

The paper cites 64 important references, covering the complete development from early minijet model proposals to latest LHC experimental results, with particular attention to:

• QCD theoretical foundations 1-9
• Eikonal method development 10-18
• Minijet model evolution 25-35
• LHC experimental measurements 37-47
• Related theoretical work 48-64

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that successfully combines rigorous QCD theory with precision experimental data, not only resolving current experimental controversies but also pointing the way for future theoretical and experimental research. The paper demonstrates high technical level, comprehensive analysis, and trustworthy conclusions, possessing significant academic value and practical significance for the high-energy physics field.