Improved bounds for the minimum degree of minimal multicolor Ramsey graphs

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09068
• Title: Improved bounds for the minimum degree of minimal multicolor Ramsey graphs
• Authors: Yamaan Attwa, Sam Mattheus, Tibor Szabó, Jacques Verstraete
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09068

Abstract

This paper provides two novel construction methods for constructing $r$ edge-disjoint $K_{k+1}$-free graphs on the same vertex set, each possessing the property that every small induced subgraph contains a complete graph on $k$ vertices. The main innovation of the paper lies in combining algebraic and probabilistic coloring schemes, leveraging the beneficial algebraic and combinatorial properties of Hermitian unitals. When $r \geq c\frac{k}{\log^2 k}$ and $k$ is sufficiently large, these constructions improve several upper bounds on the minimum possible minimum degree of minimal $r$-color Ramsey graphs for the clique $K_{k+1}$.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem studied in this paper is determining the minimum degree of minimal Ramsey graphs. For a graph $H$ and number of colors $r$, define $s_r(H) := \min\{\delta(G) | G \in M_r(H)\}$ as the minimum possible minimum degree that can occur among all minimal $r$-Ramsey graphs of $H$.

Problem Significance

1. Theoretical Importance: Ramsey theory is a core branch of combinatorics, and the minimum degree problem reveals the fine structure of Ramsey graphs
2. Comparison with Classical Results: For the two-color case, Burr et al. proved that $s_2(K_k) = (k-1)^2$, a surprising exact result since Ramsey graphs typically have exponential vertex counts, yet the minimum degree is only a quadratic function of $k$
3. Multicolor Generalization: Understanding behavior in the multicolor case is crucial for perfecting Ramsey theory

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Parameter Range Restrictions: Existing bounds perform unevenly across different parameter ranges, lacking unified optimal bounds
2. Technical Bottlenecks: Fox et al.'s construction yields $s_r(K_k) = O(r^3k^3\log^3 k)$ when $r \geq k^2$; Bamberg et al. improved this to $O(r^{5/2}k^5)$, but still falls short of the conjectured $r^2k^2$ bound
3. Method Singularity: Existing constructions rely primarily on purely algebraic or purely probabilistic methods, lacking effective combination

Core Contributions

1. Improved Upper Bounds: For sufficiently large $k$ and $r \geq c\frac{k}{\log^2 k}$, proved that $s_r(K_k) \leq 2400k^2r^{2+\frac{30}{k}}\log^{20} r \log^{20} k$
2. Constant $k$ Case: Reduced the logarithmic factors in the upper bound from $8k^2$ to $2$, i.e., $s_r(K_k) \leq C_k(r\log r)^2$
3. Novel Construction Method: First effective combination of algebraic and probabilistic coloring schemes, utilizing properties of Hermitian unitals
4. Semi-saturation Number Bounds: Proved $\text{ssat}_r(K_k) \leq 4(k-2)^2r^2$, answering an open question of Tran
5. Lower Bound Improvement: Provided new lower bound $s_r(K_k) = \Omega(kr^2)$

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Construct $K_{k+1}$-free $r$-color patterns $G_1,\ldots,G_r$ on vertex set $[n]$ such that every $r$-coloring contains a strongly monochromatic $K_k$, where strongly monochromatic means both vertices and edges have the same color.

Model Architecture

Step One: Finite Geometry Construction (Algebraic Component)

1. Projective Plane Setup: Use projective plane $PG(2,q^2)$ of order $q^2$
2. Hermitian Unital Bundle: Construct a bundle consisting of $q$ Hermitian unitals with common tangent line $\ell_\infty$ at point $p_\infty$$U_\lambda: X^{q+1} + YZ^q + Y^qZ + \lambda Z^{q+1} = 0, \quad \lambda \in \mathbb{F}_q$
3. Partition Property: Every line not passing through $p_\infty$ is tangent to exactly one unital and intersects the remaining $q-1$ unitals

Step Two: Probabilistic Refinement (Probabilistic Component)

1. Color Assignment: Within each $U_\lambda$, uniformly randomly color points with $c$ colors
2. Parameter Selection: $c = \lceil\frac{8r}{q}\rceil \leq \frac{q}{48\log q}$
3. Graph Construction: For each color $i$, define graph $\tilde{G}_i$ with vertex set being the line set $L$, and edge set being pairs of lines intersecting at points of color $i$

Technical Innovation Points

1. Algebraic-Probabilistic Hybrid Method

• Algebraic Guarantees Structure: Hermitian unitals ensure rigid structure of $K_{k+1}$
• Probabilistic Controls Density: Random coloring controls the size and distribution of each color class

2. Point-Clique Decomposition

Each graph $\tilde{G}_i$ decomposes into edge-disjoint maximal cliques (point-cliques), a structured decomposition that simplifies analysis of $K_{k+1}$-freeness.

3. Fan Analysis

For any $K_{k+1}$ in $\tilde{G}_i$, there exists a point-clique containing exactly $k$ or $k+1$ points of this clique, termed $(k+1)$-fans and degenerate cases respectively.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Construction Verification

This paper primarily conducts theoretical analysis, verifying construction validity through the following steps:

1. Parameter Selection: Use Chebyshev's theorem to select appropriate primes $q$
2. Probabilistic Analysis: Apply Chernoff bounds to prove concentration of random coloring
3. Combinatorial Arguments: Control probability of bad events via union bound

Key Lemma Verification

• Lemma 4: Proves existence of coloring such that each color class size lies in $[q^3/2c, 2q^3/c]$
• Lemma 5: Establishes properties of point-clique structure
• Lemma 6: Proves existence of large $K_k$-free subset in $K_{k+1}$-free graphs

Experimental Results

Main Theorem Results

Theorem 1 (General Case)

For sufficiently large $k$ and $r$ satisfying $k \leq r\log^2 r$, $s_r(K_k) \leq 2400k^2r^{2+\frac{30}{k}}\log^{20} r \log^{20} k$

Theorem 2 (Constant $k$)

For all $k \geq 3$, there exists constant $C_k$ such that for all $r \geq 2$, $s_r(K_k) \leq C_k(r\log r)^2$

Theorem 3 (Semi-saturation Number)

For all $k,r \geq 2$, $\text{ssat}_r(K_k) \leq 4(k-2)^2r^2$

Theorem 4 (Lower Bound)

For all $k,r \geq 3$, $s_r(K_k) = \Omega(kr^2)$

Parameter Range Analysis

1. Range $r \geq c\frac{k}{\log^2 k}$: Theorem 1 provides upper bound approaching $(rk)^{2+o(1)}$
2. Constant $k$ Case: Theorem 2 improves logarithmic factors from $8k^2$ to $2$
3. Constant $r$ Case: Existing bounds give $s_r(K_k) \leq Cr^3k^2\log^3 r \log^2 k$

Related Work

Classical Results

1. Burr-Erdős-Lovász (1976): Established exact value $s_2(K_k) = (k-1)^2$
2. Fox et al. (2016): Proved general bounds $(2)$ and $(5)$ for multicolor case
3. Hàn-Rödl-Szabó (2018): Provided bounds for constant color case $(4)$

Technical Development

1. Erdős-Rogers Function: Improvements in $f_{k,k+1}(n)$ directly impact Ramsey graph constructions
2. Finite Geometry Methods: Constructions using projective planes and pseudo-lines in higher dimensions
3. Algebraic Constructions: Leveraging algebraic properties of finite fields to ensure triangle-free properties

Innovation in This Paper

1. First Combination: Effective combination of algebraic and probabilistic methods
2. Hermitian Unital Application: Thorough exploitation of its algebraic and combinatorial properties
3. Parameter Optimization: Provides improvements across multiple parameter ranges

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Upper Bound Improvements: Significant improvements over existing bounds in important parameter range $r \geq c\frac{k}{\log^2 k}$
2. Method Innovation: Algebraic-probabilistic hybrid method provides new perspective for the field
3. Problem Resolution: Partially answers Bamberg et al.'s conjecture regarding $r^2k^2$ bounds

Limitations

1. Parameter Restrictions: Construction is only effective when $r \geq c\frac{k}{\log^2 k}$
2. Constant Factors: While asymptotic behavior is improved, constant factors remain large
3. Lower-Upper Gap: Significant gap remains between upper and lower bounds

Future Directions

1. Complete Range Coverage: Seek constructions optimal across all parameter ranges
2. Exact Constants: Determine exact constant factors in $s_r(K_k)$
3. Monotonicity Conjecture: Prove $s_r(K_{k+1}) \geq s_r(K_k)$

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Innovation: Clever combination of algebraic and probabilistic methods represents genuine innovation
2. Significant Results: Provides substantial improvements across multiple important parameter ranges
3. Deep Analysis: Thorough exploitation of Hermitian unital properties demonstrates author expertise
4. Clear Presentation: Well-structured paper with accurate technical detail descriptions

Weaknesses

1. Applicable Range: Parameter restrictions of construction prevent complete problem resolution
2. Computational Complexity: Actual computational complexity of construction is relatively high
3. Constant Optimization: Some constant factors may have further optimization potential

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new perspective on core problems in Ramsey theory
2. Methodological Value: Hybrid method may inspire research on other combinatorial problems
3. Subsequent Research: Provides foundation for further improvements

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Foundational research in combinatorics and Ramsey theory
2. Algorithm Design: Algorithm construction for graph coloring and extremal graph theory problems
3. Related Fields: Interdisciplinary applications in coding theory, computational complexity, etc.

References

The paper cites 30 important references covering classical results and recent advances in Ramsey theory, particularly:

• Pioneering work by Burr, Erdős, and Lovász
• Research on multicolor Ramsey graphs by Fox et al.
• Recent results on Erdős-Rogers functions by Mubayi and Verstraete
• Related theory of Hermitian unitals in finite geometry

This paper makes important contributions to extremal combinatorics. Its innovative hybrid method and significant result improvements represent important progress in the field. While room for improvement remains, it establishes a solid foundation for subsequent research.