Observation of a pseudoscalar excess at the $t\bar{t}$ threshold

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09070
• Title: Observation of a pseudoscalar excess at the $t\bar{t}$ threshold
• Author: A. Grohsjean (on behalf of the CMS Collaboration)
• Classification: hep-ex (High Energy Physics - Experiment), hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Time/Conference: October 2025, first presented at the 59th Moriond Conference
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09070

Abstract

The CMS Collaboration has recently observed an excess of pseudoscalar particles near the top quark-antitop quark ($t\bar{t}$) production threshold. One possible explanation involves the formation of short-lived $t\bar{t}$ quasi-bound states. This paper summarizes results first presented at the 59th Moriond Conference and outlines their potential implications.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

This study aims to detect and analyze whether signals exist near the $t\bar{t}$ production threshold that exceed Standard Model expectations, particularly seeking evidence for possible quasi-bound state formation.

Significance

1. Unique properties of the top quark: As the heaviest known elementary particle, the top quark decays before hadronization, allowing its spin information to be transferred to decay products
2. Theoretical predictions: Non-relativistic quantum chromodynamics (NRQCD) predicts bound state enhancement effects near the production threshold
3. New physics exploration: $t\bar{t}$ spin correlations serve as sensitive probes for new physics

Existing Limitations

Although $t\bar{t}$ pairs cannot form stable bound states due to the extremely short lifetime of the top quark, theoretical predictions suggest quasi-bound state effects should exist near the threshold, which previously lacked clear experimental observation.

Research Motivation

Based on the NRQCD theoretical framework, in proton-proton collisions, gluon-gluon fusion processes dominate the production of $^1S_0[1]$ states (referred to as $\eta_t$). This study aims to provide the first clear experimental observation of this phenomenon.

Core Contributions

1. First observation: First observation of pseudoscalar particle excess near the $t\bar{t}$ threshold
2. Signal confirmation: Established pseudoscalar nature through statistical significance exceeding 5σ
3. Precise measurement: Measured $\eta_t$ production cross section as $\sigma(\eta_t) = 8.8 \pm 0.5 \text{(stat)} ^{+1.1}_{-1.3} \text{(syst)}$ pb
4. Theoretical verification: Experimental results agree with theoretical prediction of 6.4 pb
5. Methodological innovation: Developed analysis method combining mass distributions and angular observables

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Input: 13 TeV proton-proton collision data from the LHC (138 fb$^{-1}$) Output: Determination of $\eta_t$ particle production cross section and properties Constraints: Dilepton final state selection, $t\bar{t}$ mass reconstruction precision approximately 15-25%

Model Architecture

Theoretical Framework

A simplified model describing CP-odd, spin-0 color-singlet particles with direct couplings to gluons and top quarks:

• Mass: $m_{\eta_t} = 343$ GeV
• Width: $\Gamma_{\eta_t} = 2.8$ GeV

Event Selection Strategy

1. Lepton selection: Two opposite-charge leptons (electrons and/or muons), $p_T > 20$ GeV
2. Kinematic cuts:
   • At least one lepton satisfying $p_T > 25$ GeV
   • Dilepton invariant mass > 20 GeV
   • Additional requirement of missing transverse momentum > 40 GeV in ee and μμ channels
3. Jet requirements: At least two jets with $p_T > 30$ GeV, at least one b-tagged jet

Reconstruction Algorithm

Employs kinematic reconstruction algorithm utilizing W boson and top quark mass constraints along with missing transverse momentum information to reconstruct $t\bar{t}$ invariant mass $m_{t\bar{t}}$.

Technical Innovations

Angular Observables

Introduction of two key spin correlation observables:

1. $c_{hel}$: Scalar product of unit momentum vectors of two leptons in their respective mother top quark rest frames
2. $c_{han}$: Similar to $c_{hel}$ but with sign flip in the component parallel to the top quark direction

These observables effectively distinguish between scalar and pseudoscalar $t\bar{t}$ events.

Joint Fitting Strategy

Uses joint distribution of $m_{t\bar{t}}$, $c_{hel}$, and $c_{han}$ for binned profile likelihood fitting (20×3×3 bins), maximizing statistical power.

Experimental Setup

Dataset

• Data source: 13 TeV pp collision data collected by the CMS detector
• Integrated luminosity: 138 fb$^{-1}$
• Period: LHC Run 2 data
• Preprocessing: Kinematic reconstruction, mass resolution approximately 15% near threshold, approximately 25% in high mass region

Evaluation Metrics

1. Statistical significance: Signal strength measured using standard deviations (σ)
2. Production cross section: Cross section measurement in picobarns (pb)
3. Fit quality: Model goodness-of-fit assessed through $\chi^2$/ndf

Comparison Methods

1. Fixed-order perturbative QCD (FO pQCD): Primary background expectation
2. Different generator comparisons:
   • POWHEG v2 hvq + PYTHIA 8.240 (standard)
   • POWHEG + HERWIG 7.2.2
   • MG5_aMC@NLO
   • bb4l POWHEG vRES

Implementation Details

• Normalization: Using inclusive cross section 833.9$^{+20.5}_{-30.0}$ pb
• Corrections: Applied NNLO QCD and NLO electroweak corrections
• Systematic uncertainties: Considered generator modeling, parton shower, top quark mass uncertainties

Experimental Results

Main Results

Cross Section Measurement

Measured $\eta_t$ production cross section: $\sigma(\eta_t) = 8.8 \pm 0.5 \text{(stat)} ^{+1.1}_{-1.3} \text{(syst)} \text{ pb}$

This result agrees with theoretical prediction of 6.4 pb, consistent within error margins.

Statistical Significance

Through scalar-pseudoscalar joint fitting, the statistical significance of the $\eta_t$ component exceeds 5σ, while the scalar $\chi_t$ component shows no significant contribution, establishing the pseudoscalar nature of the observed signal.

Distribution Analysis

Figure 1 shows $m_{t\bar{t}}$ distributions in three representative angular observable bins:

• Clear deviation between data and FO pQCD+background expectation
• Most significant $\eta_t$ signal contribution in the rightmost panel ($-\frac{1}{3} < c_{hel} < \frac{1}{3}$, $-\frac{1}{3} < c_{han} < \frac{1}{3}$)

Systematic Uncertainty Analysis

Primary systematic uncertainty sources:

1. $t\bar{t}$ production modeling (dominant): bb4l prediction comparison produces largest uncertainty
2. Parton shower modeling: Particularly strong coupling constant variations in final-state radiation
3. Top quark mass and Yukawa coupling variations
4. HERWIG alternative parton shower model

Related Work

Theoretical Foundation

1. NRQCD predictions: Pioneering work by Fadin, Khoze, Sjöstrand and others predicting threshold behavior
2. Bound state effects: Studies by Sumino, Yokoya and others on bound state effects at hadron colliders
3. Modern calculations: Latest theoretical predictions for LHC Run 2 data by Fuks and colleagues

Experimental Evidence

1. Previous ATLAS and CMS measurements: Enhancement observed in differential cross section measurements in the $t\bar{t}$ threshold region
2. Spin correlation studies: ATLAS and CMS reported minor theory-experiment discrepancies in quantum entanglement studies

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First clear observation: Observation of pseudoscalar particle excess near $t\bar{t}$ production threshold
2. Theoretical verification: Results support NRQCD theoretical predictions regarding $\eta_t$ quasi-bound states
3. Property determination: Established pseudoscalar nature of signal through 5σ significance

Limitations

1. Theoretical modeling: NNLO modeling of $t\bar{t}$ off-shell production requires improvement
2. Systematic uncertainties: Generator modeling remains primary error source
3. Signal model: Simplified model may not fully describe complex threshold physics

Future Directions

1. Semi-leptonic channel analysis: Extension to semi-leptonic decay channels with larger statistical samples
2. ATLAS confirmation: Awaiting independent verification by ATLAS experiment
3. Theoretical improvements: Require more precise $\eta_t$ signal modeling and NNLO off-shell calculations
4. HL-LHC prospects: High-luminosity LHC will provide higher precision measurements

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Advanced experimental techniques: Clever combination of mass and angular observables in multidimensional analysis
2. High statistical significance: Observation exceeding 5σ establishes credibility of discovery
3. Comprehensive systematic study: Detailed systematic uncertainty analysis and comparison across different generators
4. Close theoretical connection: Good agreement with NRQCD theoretical predictions

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical uncertainties: Limitations of simplified model and theoretical prediction uncertainties
2. Generator dependence: Results sensitive to different event generator settings
3. Single experiment: Requires independent confirmation from other experimental collaborations

Impact

1. Field breakthrough: Potentially opens new chapter in top quark physics
2. Theoretical verification: Provides important validation for NRQCD application in heavy quark systems
3. New physics exploration: Opens new avenue for searching new physics phenomena at $t\bar{t}$ threshold

Applicable Scenarios

This method applies to:

1. Study of heavy flavor quark quasi-bound states at high-energy colliders
2. Precision QCD tests near threshold
3. Search for new resonances and bound states

References

This paper cites extensive literature ranging from theoretical predictions (Fadin et al., 1990) to latest experimental results (ATLAS and CMS quantum entanglement observations, 2024), reflecting the deep theoretical foundation and experimental heritage of this research.

Summary: This is an experimentally significant discovery, providing the first observation of pseudoscalar excess near the $t\bar{t}$ threshold, offering important clues for understanding the quantum chromodynamic properties of the top quark and searching for new physics. Despite challenges in theoretical modeling, its 5σ statistical significance and agreement with theoretical expectations make it an important advance in particle physics.