Indirect method for nuclear reactions and the role of the self energy

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09140
• Title: Indirect method for nuclear reactions and the role of the self energy
• Author: Gregory Potel (Universidad de Sevilla)
• Classification: nucl-th (Nuclear Theory)
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09140

Abstract

When nucleons (such as nucleons or deuterons) collide with a target nucleus during free propagation, their trajectories are altered by interactions with the nuclear medium, exchanging varying amounts of energy, mass, linear and angular momentum. By studying the perturbations from free-path trajectories, we seek to understand the properties of the propagation medium of the probe particle. This is the essence of utilizing nuclear reactions in experiments to extract nuclear structure information. To address both structural and reaction aspects of specific experiments within a unified framework, it is necessary to identify a theoretical construct that embodies the corrections to particle propagation in the medium relative to the free case, and employ it for determining nuclear spectra (structure) and calculating scattering observables (reactions). The self energy is such a candidate, and this lecture places it at the center of the scattering theory formulation.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

A frequently encountered problem in nuclear reaction experiments is that certain nuclear reactions important for societal applications or fundamental science are difficult to measure directly at existing accelerator beam facilities. Difficulties may arise from:

1. Extremely small cross sections, such as beam energies far below the Coulomb barrier
2. Inability to prepare short-lived target nuclei, such as neutron-induced reactions on unstable isotopes

Significance

Indirect measurement methods provide an effective pathway to address this problem, obtaining the desired reaction cross-section information through alternative reactions (indirect measurements). This requires developing corresponding theory to establish connections between observational data and the studied reaction cross sections.

Limitations of Existing Methods

Traditional distorted-wave Born approximation (DWBA) methods suffer from the following problems:

1. Dependence on phenomenological spectroscopic factors and adjustable optical potentials
2. Lack of consistency between structure and reaction calculations
3. Inadequate description of the continuum spectrum
4. Inability to properly handle coherent contributions from overlapping resonances

Research Motivation

This work aims to establish a unified theoretical framework placing the self energy at the core of scattering theory, achieving consistent descriptions of structure and reactions, and providing a reliable theoretical foundation for indirect nuclear reaction measurements.

Core Contributions

1. Established the Green's function transfer (GFT) formalism: Provides a complete theoretical framework for describing indirect nuclear reactions
2. Unified structure and reaction descriptions: Achieves consistency between structure and reaction calculations through the self energy
3. Developed perturbative derivation methods: Provides new physical insights distinct from earlier formulations
4. Established connections with R-matrix theory: Provides more transparent linkages
5. Provided assessment methods for the validity of the spectator approximation: Analyzes conditions for reducing the three-body problem to a two-body problem

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Study indirect nuclear reactions a(≡x+b) + A → b + (x+A), where only fragment b is detected, obtaining information about the x-A system through this indirect measurement.

Core Theoretical Framework

Self Energy and Optical Potential

The single-particle Schrödinger equation can be written as:

(E - T - Σ(r_xA, r'_xA, E))ψ_0(r_xA) = 0

where Σ is the self energy (optical potential) with the following characteristics:

• Complex: negative imaginary part accounts for absorption processes
• Non-local: reflects many-body correlation effects
• Energy-dependent: arises from coupling to excited states

GFT Formalism

The main result for the indirect reaction cross section is:

dσ^I_R(E,E_b)/dE_b = (2μ/ℏ²k_x)⟨ψ^I_0|ImV(E-E_b)|ψ^I_0⟩ρ(E_b)

where the indirect elastic channel wave function is:

ψ^I_0(r_xA) = ψ^HM + G(E_0-E_b)[V(E-E_b)ψ^HM + ⟨χ_b|U_bA(r_bA)φ_aF⟩]

Spectator Approximation

Under the spectator approximation, the three-body problem (x+b+A) is reduced to two two-body problems:

• Scattering of the x-A system
• b as a spectator carrying x into the reaction region

Technical Innovations

Distinctions from DWBA

1. Normalization handling: GFT automatically handles correct normalization, while DWBA requires introducing spectroscopic factors
2. Continuum description: GFT naturally describes the continuum, DWBA requires artificial discretization
3. Energy dependence: GFT includes complete energy dependence, DWBA typically uses simplified treatment
4. Consistency: GFT ensures consistency between structure and reactions

Nuclear Field Theory (NFT) Implementation

Utilizes Feynman diagram techniques to calculate the self energy, systematically considering coupling between single-particle motion and collective surface vibrations and pairing vibrations.

Experimental Setup

Application Cases

Case 1: ⁹Li(d,p)¹⁰Li Reaction

• Objective: Study the low-excitation spectrum of the unbound nucleus ¹⁰Li
• Method: NFT calculation of self energy, considering strong quadrupole phonon coupling with the ⁹Li core
• Features: Includes relevant two-phonon (anharmonic) contributions

Case 2: ⁴⁰,⁴⁸Ca(d,p) Reactions

• Objective: Embed ab initio structure information into the GFT framework
• Method: Coupled-cluster (CC) method provides ground-state energy and particle-addition amplitudes
• Features: Uses chiral effective field theory interactions, includes two-body and three-body nuclear forces

Evaluation Metrics

• Absolute differential cross sections
• Angular distributions
• Energy spectrum distributions
• Direct comparison with experimental data (no adjustable parameters)

Experimental Results

⁹Li(d,p)¹⁰Li Results

Phase Shifts and Spectral Functions

• Negative parity channel: Forms low-excitation 1̃/2⁻ resonance at approximately 0.45-0.50 MeV with width 0.3-0.35 MeV
• Positive parity channel: s₁/₂ strength pushed into continuum, exhibiting virtual state characteristics with scattering length a≃-8 fm

Angular Distribution Selectivity

• Forward angles (5.5°-16.5°): Dominated primarily by p-wave resonance, s-wave contribution suppressed
• Backward angles (50°-180°): Virtual s-wave contribution emerges, comparable to p-wave component

⁴⁰,⁴⁸Ca(d,p) Results

Convergence Analysis

With increasing model space truncation Nmax, calculations exhibit non-monotonic convergence patterns, with the maximum space (N₂=14, N₃=16) showing good agreement with experimental data.

Absolute Cross-Section Predictions

• ⁴¹Ca: Theoretical low binding approximately 500 keV
• ⁴⁹Ca: Theoretical low binding approximately 600 keV
• After adjustment to experimental binding energies, absolute cross sections show good agreement with experiment

Major Findings

1. Unified description of parity inversion: The same self-energy mechanism uniformly explains parity inversion in ¹¹Be, large s-wave components in ¹¹Li halo nuclei, and normal ordering in ¹²B/¹³C
2. Momentum matching effects: In (d,p) reactions, momentum matching selectivity hides s-wave contributions at forward angles and reveals s-wave contributions at backward angles
3. Parameter-free predictions: The CC+GFT framework achieves absolute cross-section predictions without adjustable parameters

Related Work

Historical Development

The GFT formalism was essentially introduced in the 1980s and has recently been revived in different contexts and variations:

• Udagawa & Tamura (1986)
• Ichimura et al. (1985, 1990)
• Recent: Potel et al. (2015), Lei & Moro (2015)

Comparison with Other Methods

• Faddeev equations: Exact treatment of three-body problems but computationally expensive
• CDCC method: Continuum discretized coupled channels method, computationally complex
• Traditional DWBA: Widely used but lacks microscopic foundation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical unity: The self energy successfully unifies descriptions of nuclear structure and reactions
2. Predictive power: The GFT framework possesses strong predictive capability, particularly for exotic nuclei
3. Experimental guidance: Provides reliable theoretical guidance for future experiments

Limitations

1. Spectator approximation: May fail in low-energy resonance regions
2. Optical potential dependence: Still requires phenomenological optical potential as input
3. Computational complexity: Treatment of non-local potentials increases computational difficulty

Future Directions

1. Beyond the spectator approximation: Develop methods incorporating genuine three-body effects
2. Ab initio optical potentials: Reduce phenomenological input
3. Broader applications: Extend to more types of nuclear reactions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: Placing the self energy at the center of scattering theory provides a new theoretical perspective
2. Methodological completeness: Establishes a complete chain from microscopic Hamiltonian to macroscopic observables
3. Sufficient experimental verification: Validates the method's effectiveness through multiple different types of nuclear reactions
4. Strong predictive capability: Achieves absolute cross-section predictions without adjustable parameters

Weaknesses

1. Mathematical complexity: Non-local, energy-dependent self energies make calculations complex
2. Approximation dependence: The applicable range of the spectator approximation requires more rigorous analysis
3. Phenomenological input: Still requires phenomenological optical potential, not fully ab initio

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides a solid theoretical foundation for indirect nuclear reactions
2. Practical value: Significant importance for rare isotope physics research
3. Method generalization: Extensible to other types of nuclear reaction studies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Rare isotope research: Particularly suitable for studying unstable nuclei difficult to measure directly
2. Astrophysical applications: Provides theoretical support for astrophysically relevant nuclear reactions
3. Nuclear structure research: Probes nuclear structure information through indirect reactions

References

This work cites numerous important references, including:

• Classical many-body theory textbooks: Dickhoff & Van Neck (2005)
• Nuclear reaction theory: Thompson & Nunes (2009), Jackson (1970)
• R-matrix theory: Lane & Thomas (1958), Descouvemont & Baye (2010)
• Nuclear field theory development: Bortignon et al. (1977), Bes (1983)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically develops a theoretical framework for indirect nuclear reactions, successfully applying the self-energy concept to nuclear reaction research. The paper is theoretically rigorous with sufficient experimental verification, making important contributions to the development of nuclear physics theory.