On The Roots of Independence Polynomial: Quantifying The Gap

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09197
• Title: On The Roots of Independence Polynomial: Quantifying The Gap
• Authors: Om Prakash (The Institute of Mathematical Sciences, HBNI, Chennai, India), Vikram Sharma (The Institute of Mathematical Sciences, HBNI, Chennai, India)
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics), cs.DM (Discrete Mathematics)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09197

Abstract

This paper investigates the distribution of roots of the independence polynomial of graphs. The independence polynomial $I(G,z) := \sum_k (-1)^k a_k(G) z^k$ is the generating polynomial corresponding to independent sets of different sizes in graph G, where $a_k(G)$ denotes the number of independent sets of size k in G. This polynomial has important applications in combinatorics, complexity theory, and statistical physics. It is known that when G is connected, $\beta(G)$ (the minimum real root) is a simple real root less than 1, and all other roots have absolute values strictly greater than $\beta(G)$. This paper provides the first quantification of the gap between $\beta(G)$ and other roots.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem Background: The study of independence polynomials is significant in multiple fields:
   • Counting problems in combinatorics
   • Approximation algorithm design in complexity theory
   • Hard-core models in statistical physics
2. Limitations of Existing Research:
   • Goldwurm and Santini proved that $\beta(G)$ is the unique minimum real root
   • Csikvári provided an alternative proof
   • However, these proofs are existential in nature and cannot quantify the specific gap between $\beta(G)$ and other roots
3. Research Motivation:
   • Quantifying the gap between roots is significant for algorithm design
   • May provide theoretical foundations for designing efficient algorithms for certain graph classes
   • Fills theoretical gaps in the field

Core Contributions

1. Main Theoretical Result: Proves that for a connected graph G with n vertices, the disk centered at the origin with radius $\beta(G) + (\beta(G)/n)^{O(n)}$ contains only the minimum root $\beta(G)$
2. Technical Innovations:
   • Application of Smale's γ-function to study local function behavior
   • Construction of majorant functions to upper bound the absolute values of complex functions
   • Integration of univalence radius theory from complex analysis
3. Explicit Lower Bounds for Specific Graph Classes: Provides precise root gap calculations for path graphs, cycle graphs, and complete bipartite graphs
4. Methodological Contribution: Provides a systematic approach to quantify the separation between polynomial roots

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Given a connected graph G, quantify the minimum gap between the minimum root $\beta(G)$ of the independence polynomial $I(G,z)$ and other roots.

Core Technical Framework

1. Key Function Definition

For any vertex $u \in V$, define: $f_u(z) := \frac{zI(G \setminus N[u], z)}{I(G \setminus u, z)}$

where $N[u]$ is the closed neighborhood of vertex u.

2. Two-Step Proof Strategy

Step One: Local Univalence

• Define $r_G := \frac{\beta(G) \cdot \text{dia}(G)}{2n}$
• Prove that $I(G,z)$ is injective on $D(\beta(G), r_G/2)$

Step Two: Global Root Separation

• For each point on the circle $\beta(G)e^{i\theta}$, construct a disk containing no roots
• Use majorant function techniques to handle absolute values of functions

3. Majorant Function Construction

For the base case $\frac{z}{(1-z)^{\ell}}$, its majorant function on $re^{i\theta}$ is: $g_r(\theta) := \frac{r}{(1-r\cos\theta)^{\ell}}$

Recursively, for more complex functions: $F_{u,r}(\theta) := \frac{r}{(1-r\cos\theta)^{\ell} \prod_j(1-G_{j,r}(\theta))}$

Technical Innovations

1. Application of γ-function: First application of Smale's γ-function to root analysis of independence polynomials
2. Majorant Function Technique: Innovative use of monotonically decreasing majorant functions to control the behavior of complex functions
3. Integration of Geometry and Algebra: Skillful combination of geometric intuition from complex analysis with algebraic structures from graph theory

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

This paper is primarily theoretical work, with results verified through:

1. Specific Graph Class Calculations:
   • Path graphs $P_n$
   • Cycle graphs $C_n$
   • Complete bipartite graphs $K_{n \times n}$
2. Numerical Verification:
   • Functional behavior analysis of star graph $S_3$
   • Plotting absolute value functions to verify theoretical predictions

Evaluation Criteria

• Tightness of theoretical bounds
• Consistency with known results
• Computational feasibility

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

Theorem 1.1: Let G be a connected graph with n vertices. Then the disk centered at the origin $D\left(0, \beta(G) + \left(\frac{\beta(G)}{n}\right)^{O(n)}\right)$ contains only the minimum root $\beta(G)$ of the independence polynomial.

Precise Results for Specific Graph Classes

1. Path Graphs $P_n$: $\frac{\alpha}{\beta} = 1 + \Omega\left(\frac{1}{n^2}\right)$
2. Cycle Graphs $C_n$: $\frac{\alpha}{\beta} = 1 + \frac{2\pi^2}{n^2} + O(n^{-4})$
3. Complete Bipartite Graphs $K_{n \times n}$: $\frac{|\alpha|}{\beta} \approx 9.119 - O\left(\frac{1}{n^2}\right)$

Technical Verification

Numerical analysis of star graph $S_3$ verifies:

• Majorant functions indeed upper bound the original functions
• Monotonicity properties of functions
• Consistency between theoretical predictions and numerical computations

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Early Work:
   • Existential studies of independence polynomial roots
   • Characterization of root-free regions
2. Key Breakthroughs:
   • Goldwurm-Santini: Proved uniqueness and simplicity of $\beta(G)$
   • Csikvári: Provided alternative proof methods
3. Position of This Work:
   • First quantification of root gaps
   • Important progress from existence to quantitative analysis

Technical Connections

• Connections with Trace Monoid theory
• Applications of Pringsheim's theorem
• Use of maximum modulus principle from complex analysis

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Contribution: First provision of quantitative bounds on independence polynomial root gaps
2. Methodological Value: Establishes a systematic framework for analyzing such problems
3. Computational Significance: Provides precise calculation formulas for specific graph classes

Limitations

1. Tightness of Bounds: Current bounds may not be optimal
2. Computational Complexity: Computation remains difficult for general graphs
3. Scope of Applicability: Primarily limited to connected graphs

Future Directions

1. Algorithm Applications: Study efficient algorithms for graph classes with large root gaps
2. Bound Improvements: Seek tighter upper and lower bounds
3. Generalization: Extend to other graph polynomials

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Breakthrough: Resolves a long-standing quantitative problem
2. Methodological Innovation: Skillfully combines complex analysis, graph theory, and combinatorics
3. Technical Depth: Employs advanced mathematical tools (γ-functions, majorant functions)
4. Completeness: Provides detailed analysis from theory to concrete examples

Weaknesses

1. Practical Utility of Bounds: The $O(n)$ exponent may make bounds too loose for large graphs
2. Computational Complexity: Actual computation of root gaps remains difficult
3. Generalizability: Unclear whether methods apply to other polynomials

Impact

1. Theoretical Value: Fills an important theoretical gap
2. Methodological Significance: Provides new analytical frameworks
3. Application Potential: May inspire new algorithm design approaches

Applicable Scenarios

• Theoretical research in graph theory and combinatorial optimization
• Applications requiring precise root analysis
• Algorithm design for specific graph classes

References

The paper cites 21 important references, including:

• Goldwurm & Santini (2000): Foundational theory of independence polynomial roots
• Csikvári (2012): Alternative proof methods
• Flajolet & Sedgewick (2009): Analytic combinatorics methods
• Blum et al. (1998): Complexity theory of real computation

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical paper that resolves an important problem in independence polynomial root analysis. While its practical applicability is limited, its theoretical value is significant and provides a foundation for further development in the field.