A Further Study on Averaging Commutative and Cocommutative Infinitesimal Bialgebras and Special Apre-Perm Bialgebras

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09208
• Title: A further study on averaging commutative and cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras and special apre-perm bialgebras
• Authors: Quan Zhao, Guilai Liu
• Classification: math.RA (Rings and Algebras)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09208

Abstract

This paper provides an in-depth investigation into the construction theory of averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras and special apre-perm bialgebras. The authors demonstrate that solutions to the averaging associative Yang-Baxter equation (whose symmetric part is invariant) generate quasi-triangular averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras, which can be equivalently characterized as O-operators of weighted admissible averaging commutative algebras. By assuming that the symmetric part of these solutions is either zero or non-degenerate, two important subclasses of quasi-triangular averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras are obtained: the triangular type and the decomposable type, both of which are intimately related to symmetric averaging Rota-Baxter Frobenius commutative algebras.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: This paper aims to generalize the fact that "averaging commutative algebras generate perm algebras" to the bialgebra level and conduct a thorough investigation of the associated construction theory.
2. Significance:
   • Averaging operators were initially studied implicitly by Reynolds in turbulence theory and later found widespread applications in quantum physics and combinatorics
   • Bialgebra structures hold important positions in mathematical physics, such as Lie bialgebras being related to Poisson-Lie groups and playing crucial roles in the infinitesimal deformation of quantum groups
   • Perm algebras play an important role in algebraic operator theory, with their operators being Koszul duals of pre-Lie algebra operators
3. Existing Limitations:
   • Previous work primarily established basic correspondence relationships between averaging commutative algebras and special apre-perm algebras
   • Lacks systematic investigation of the construction theory of these structures, particularly regarding Yang-Baxter equations and O-operators
4. Research Motivation: By introducing concepts such as quasi-triangular, triangular, and decomposable structures, establish a complete construction theory framework to deepen understanding of the relationships between these algebraic structures.

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of Averaging Associative Yang-Baxter Equation (AAYBE): Establishes the foundational construction theory for averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras
2. Establishment of O-Operator Characterization: Proves that solutions to AAYBE can be equivalently characterized using O-operators of admissible averaging commutative algebras
3. Classification of Quasi-Triangular Structures: Systematically investigates two important subclasses of quasi-triangular averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras:
   • Triangular type (symmetric part is zero)
   • Decomposable type (symmetric part is non-degenerate)
4. Establishment of Connection with Rota-Baxter Algebras: Proves the intimate relationship between these structures and symmetric averaging Rota-Baxter Frobenius commutative algebras
5. Parallel Theory Development: Establishes a similar complete theoretical framework for special apre-perm bialgebras
6. Construction of Correspondence Diagrams: Establishes several important commutative diagrams that demonstrate systematic connections between different algebraic structures

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

The core task of this paper is to establish the construction theory for averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras and special apre-perm bialgebras, including:

• Input: Averaging commutative algebra structures and related linear mappings
• Output: Corresponding bialgebra structures and their classifications
• Constraints: Satisfaction of specific Yang-Baxter equations and invariance conditions

Core Theoretical Framework

1. Averaging Associative Yang-Baxter Equation (AAYBE)

For an admissible averaging commutative algebra $(A, ·_A, P, Q)$, if $r = \sum_i u_i \otimes v_i \in A \otimes A$ satisfies the following conditions:

• $A(r) = 0$ (associative Yang-Baxter equation)
• $(P \otimes \text{id} - \text{id} \otimes Q)r = 0$
• $(Q \otimes \text{id} - \text{id} \otimes P)r = 0$

then $r$ is called a solution to AAYBE.

2. O-Operator Characterization

Theorem 2.17: Let $(A, ·_A, P, Q)$ be an admissible averaging commutative algebra, and $r \in A \otimes A$ such that $r + \tau(r)$ is invariant on $(A, ·_A)$. Then the following conditions are equivalent:

• $r$ is a solution to AAYBE such that $(A, ·_A, \Delta_r, P, Q)$ is a quasi-triangular averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebra
• $r^♯$ is an O-operator of weight $-1$

3. Classification Theory

Triangular Case: When $r$ is antisymmetric, a triangular averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebra is obtained.

Decomposable Case: When $(r + \tau(r))^♯$ is bijective, a decomposable averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebra is obtained.

Parallel Theory for Special Apre-Perm Bialgebras

1. Special Apre-Perm Yang-Baxter Equation (SAPP-YBE)

For a special apre-perm algebra $(A, ▷_A, ◁_A)$, define: $SA(r) = \sum_{i,j} u_i ◦_A u_j \otimes v_i \otimes v_j + u_i \otimes v_i ◁_A u_j \otimes v_j + u_i \otimes u_j \otimes v_j ◦_A v_i$

When $SA(r) = 0$, $r$ is called a solution to SAPP-YBE.

2. Construction of Correspondence Relations

Proposition 3.11: Quasi-triangular averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras naturally generate quasi-triangular special apre-perm bialgebras, preserving the fundamental correspondence from averaging algebras to special apre-perm algebras.

Technical Innovations

1. Unified Yang-Baxter Framework: Generalizes the classical Yang-Baxter equation to the settings of averaging algebras and special apre-perm algebras
2. Extension of O-Operator Theory: Systematically develops O-operator theory for these new algebraic structures
3. Classification Method: Achieves natural classification through properties of the symmetric part (zero, non-degenerate)
4. Construction of Commutative Diagrams: Establishes several important commutative diagrams that reveal deep connections between different algebraic structures

Main Theorems and Results

Key Theorems

Theorem 2.6: Let $(A, ·_A, P, Q)$ be an admissible averaging commutative algebra, and $r \in A \otimes A$. If $r + \tau(r)$ is invariant on $(A, ·_A)$ and $r$ is a solution to AAYBE, then $(A, ·_A, \Delta_r, P, Q)$ is an averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebra.

Theorem 3.8: Let $(A, ▷_A, ◁_A)$ be a special apre-perm algebra, and $r \in A \otimes A$. If $r$ is a solution to SAPP-YBE and the symmetric part is invariant, then $(A, ▷_A, ◁_A, \vartheta_r, \theta_r)$ is a special apre-perm bialgebra.

Classification Results

Role of Symmetric Averaging Rota-Baxter Frobenius Commutative Algebras:

• The weight 0 case produces triangular type bialgebras
• The weight -1 case corresponds one-to-one with decomposable type bialgebras

Construction Examples

The paper provides concrete construction examples, such as Examples 2.37 and 3.43, demonstrating the operability of the theory.

Related Work

This paper builds upon the following important works:

1. Averaging Operator Theory: Pioneering work by Reynolds, Kolmogoroff, Kampé de Fériet, and others
2. Bialgebra Theory: Research on infinitesimal bialgebras by Aguiar and colleagues
3. Yang-Baxter Equations: Research on Yang-Baxter equations in associative algebras by Bai and others
4. Perm Algebra Theory: Work on perm algebras and operator theory by Chapoton and others
5. Rota-Baxter Algebras: Related research on operator theory and bialgebra structures

The innovation of this paper lies in unifying theories from these different fields into a single framework and establishing a systematic construction theory.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Establishes a complete construction theory for averaging commutative cocommutative infinitesimal bialgebras and special apre-perm bialgebras
2. Provides a unified theoretical framework through Yang-Baxter equations and O-operators
3. Generalizes the correspondence between averaging algebras and special apre-perm algebras to the bialgebra level
4. Establishes profound connections with symmetric averaging Rota-Baxter Frobenius commutative algebras

Theoretical Significance

1. Unification: Unifies seemingly different algebraic structures under the framework of Yang-Baxter equations
2. Completeness: Provides a complete theoretical system from construction to classification
3. Correspondence: Preserves natural correspondence relationships between different algebraic structures

Future Directions

1. Investigate generalizations of these structures in more general settings
2. Explore further connections with quantum groups and mathematical physics
3. Develop corresponding cohomology theory
4. Study applications in combinatorics and operator theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: The paper establishes a complete theoretical framework with systematic treatment from basic definitions to deep structures
2. Technical Innovation: The extension of O-operator theory and generalization of Yang-Baxter equations possess important technical value
3. Clear Structure: The paper is well-organized, with parallel development from averaging algebras to special apre-perm algebras making the theoretical structure very clear
4. Profound Connections: Reveals deep connections between different algebraic structures, particularly with Rota-Baxter algebras

Technical Contributions

1. Methodology: Provides systematic methods for studying this class of algebraic structures
2. Classification Theory: Achieves natural classification through properties of the symmetric part
3. Construction Methods: Provides concrete construction methods and algorithms

Limitations

1. Application Scope: Primarily focused on theoretical construction; practical applications require further development
2. Computational Complexity: Analysis of computational complexity for concrete calculations is insufficient
3. Generalizability: Generalization to infinite-dimensional cases requires additional technical treatment

Impact

1. Theoretical Impact: Provides new research directions and methods for related fields
2. Technical Impact: The generalization of O-operators and Yang-Baxter equations has broad technical value
3. Interdisciplinary: Promotes cross-disciplinary research between algebra, mathematical physics, and combinatorics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Related research in algebraic geometry and noncommutative geometry
2. Mathematical Physics: Research on quantum groups and integrable systems
3. Combinatorics: Research on operator theory and related combinatorial structures

References

The paper cites 39 important references covering core works in averaging operator theory, bialgebra theory, Yang-Baxter equations, perm algebra theory, and related fields, providing a solid foundation for the theoretical development of this paper.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that makes important contributions to algebraic structure theory. The paper exhibits high technical depth and a complete theoretical framework, laying an important foundation for further research in related fields.