Study of Several Families of λ-Quiddities and Lower Bounds for the Maximum Size of Irreducible λ-Quiddities over Finite Fields

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09219
• Title: Study of Several Families of λ-Quiddities and Lower Bounds for the Maximum Size of Irreducible λ-Quiddities over Finite Fields
• Author: Flavien Mabilat
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics)
• Publication Date: October 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09219

Abstract

This paper investigates several families of λ-quiddities over finite fields and their irreducibility properties. λ-Quiddities are solutions of n-tuples in a fixed set satisfying a matrix equation fundamental to modular group combinatorics and Coxeter frieze research. By introducing the concept of irreducibility, the author restricts the study to a finite number of elements that must be determined. The main objectives are to define several families of λ-quiddities over finite fields, investigate their irreducibility properties, and particularly establish lower bounds for the maximum size of irreducible elements over finite fields 𝔽_q.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: Investigate irreducibility properties of λ-quiddities over finite fields and establish lower bound estimates for their maximum size
2. Significance: λ-Quiddities are closely related to modular group combinatorics and Coxeter frieze theory, which is crucial for understanding the structure of these mathematical objects
3. Existing Limitations:
   • Complete classification results are difficult to obtain for general rings
   • Existing general lower bound estimates (Theorem 2.5) are relatively crude and far from actual values
   • Lack of refined analysis for specific families
4. Research Motivation: Obtain more precise lower bound estimates by defining special families and investigating their irreducibility, particularly for finite fields

Core Contributions

1. Generalization of Monomial Minimal Solutions: Extends monomial minimal solutions from ℤ/pℤ to all finite fields, proving irreducibility of all nonzero solutions
2. Generalization of Binomial Minimal Solutions: Extends the concept of binomial minimal solutions to general rings, providing sufficient conditions for irreducibility
3. Introduction of Trinomial Minimal Solutions: Defines new families of trinomial minimal solutions and establishes complete characterization theorems for irreducibility
4. Establishment of Precise Lower Bounds:
   • For finite fields of characteristic 2: ℓ_𝔽_q ≥ q + 1
   • For finite fields of characteristic ≠ 2: ℓ_𝔽_q ≥ (q+1)/2
   • Provides stronger lower bounds for specific types of finite fields
5. Proposes Two Important Conjectures: Concerning the relationship between generators and quadratic residues over finite fields

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

For a commutative unital ring A, a λ-quiddity is an n-tuple (a₁,...,aₙ) satisfying the matrix equation: $M_n(a_1,...,a_n) := \begin{pmatrix} a_n & -1_A \\ 1_A & 0_A \end{pmatrix} \cdots \begin{pmatrix} a_1 & -1_A \\ 1_A & 0_A \end{pmatrix} = \pm\text{Id}$

Core Concepts

1. Irreducibility: A λ-quiddity is irreducible if it cannot be expressed as the sum (⊕ operation) of two smaller λ-quiddities
2. Continued Fractions: Utilizes continued fractions K_n(a₁,...,aₙ) to represent matrix elements and investigate irreducibility
3. Three Main Families:
   • Monomial minimal solutions: minimal size solutions with all components equal
   • Binomial minimal solutions: minimal size solutions of the form (a,b,...,a,b)
   • Trinomial minimal solutions: minimal size solutions of the form (u,u⁻¹,u⁻¹,...,u,u⁻¹,u⁻¹)

Technical Innovations

1. Matrix Computation Techniques: Simplifies complex matrix calculations using continued fraction properties in Proposition 3.3
2. Quadratic Residue Theory: Cleverly applies quadratic reciprocity law and related theory to determine irreducibility conditions
3. Combinatorial Counting Methods: Establishes lower bounds by comparing the number of generators with elements satisfying specific conditions
4. Recursive Construction: For trinomial solutions, establishes recursive formulas to compute all possible sub-continued fractions

Experimental Setup

Data Verification

• Numerical verification using Maxima software
• Verification range: primes p < 2,000,000 (verification of Conjecture 1)
• Specific calculations of exact values for several small finite fields

Computational Tools

• Continued fraction calculation algorithms
• Quadratic residue determination programs
• Irreducibility verification programs

Experimental Results

Main Results

Theorem 4.4 (Monomial Solution Lower Bounds):

• Characteristic 2: ℓ_𝔽_q ≥ q + 1
• Characteristic ≠ 2: ℓ_𝔽_q ≥ (q+1)/2

Theorem 6.2 (Complete Characterization of Trinomial Solutions): Let u ∈ 𝔽_q*, m be the size of u-trinomial minimal solution, and o(u) be the order of u in 𝔽_q*. Then:

• Characteristic 2: m = 3o(u)
• Characteristic ≠ 2 and o(u) even: m = 3o(u)/2
• Characteristic ≠ 2 and o(u) odd: m = 3o(u)

Irreducibility is equivalent to u not being a root of the polynomial X^(2l) ± X^(l+1) - 1 (1 ≤ l ≤ ⌊m/6⌋)

Theorem 6.12 (Strong Lower Bound for Characteristic 2): If n ≠ 1 is odd and 2ⁿ-1 is squarefree, then ℓ_𝔽_(2ⁿ) ≥ 3(2ⁿ-1)

Specific Numerical Results

• ℓ_𝔽_(512) ≥ 1533 (n=9)
• ℓ_𝔽_(2048) ≥ 6141 (n=11)
• ℓ_𝔽_(65537) ≥ 98,304 (Fermat prime)

Computational Verification

Computer verification confirms Conjecture 1 holds for all p < 2,000,000, supporting the correctness of the theoretical analysis.

Related Work

1. Coxeter Frieze Theory: Originates from Coxeter's 1973 research on Pentagramma mirificum
2. Modular Group Combinatorics: Related to subgroups of SL₂(ℤ) and generator representations
3. Previous Results:
   • Ovsienko's theorem: Provides recursive construction of ±Id
   • Conley-Ovsienko theorem: Provides exact counting
   • Author's prior work: Classification results on ℤ/Nℤ

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully generalizes monomial and binomial solution theory from ℤ/pℤ to all finite fields
2. Trinomial solutions provide the strongest lower bound estimation tools
3. For many special types of finite fields, near-optimal lower bounds are obtained

Limitations

1. Exact values in general cases remain difficult to determine
2. Some lower bounds only hold for specific types of finite fields
3. Binomial solutions, while providing irreducibility conditions, fail to improve lower bounds

Future Directions

1. Verify and prove the two proposed conjectures
2. Investigate λ-quiddities over more general rings
3. Explore other types of special families
4. Establish upper bound estimation theory

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Cleverly combines algebraic number theory, combinatorics, and matrix theory
2. Technical Innovation: The introduction and complete characterization of trinomial solutions represents important innovation
3. Computational Verification: Extensive numerical verification supports theoretical results
4. Systematicity: Systematically investigates λ-quiddities families from three different perspectives

Weaknesses

1. Scope of Application: Some strong results only apply to specific types of finite fields
2. Conjecture Dependence: Some strongest results depend on unproven conjectures
3. Computational Complexity: Irreducibility determination for trinomial solutions may be complex in practice

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new research tools and methods for λ-quiddities theory
2. Practical Value: Lower bound estimates provide guidance for related computational problems
3. Reproducibility: Provides detailed algorithms and computational programs

Applicable Scenarios

1. Research on combinatorial problems over finite fields
2. Modular group representation theory
3. Related computational problems in algebraic geometry
4. Applications in cryptography involving finite fields

References

The paper cites 31 related references, primarily including:

• Coxeter's original work 4
• Foundational theory by Ovsienko and Conley 3, 25
• Author's series of prior works 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22
• Classical textbooks on finite field theory 11, 27

This paper makes significant contributions to λ-quiddities theory research, particularly in establishing precise lower bound estimates for the finite field case, providing important theoretical tools and computational methods for this emerging research field.