On the stability of the Bishop's property(β) under compact perturbations

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09289
• Title: On the stability of the Bishop's property(β) under compact perturbations
• Author: Salah Mecheri
• Classification: math.FA (Functional Analysis)
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09289

Abstract

Let $B(X)$ denote the Banach algebra of all bounded linear operators acting on a Banach space $X$. Whether the sum and product of commuting decomposable operators remain decomposable is one of the most important open problems in local spectral theory of operators on Banach spaces. Similarly, it is unknown whether local spectral properties such as the single-valued extension property, Dunford property (C), Bishop property (β), or decomposability property (δ) are preserved under sums and products of commuting operators. Bourhim and Muller proved that the single-valued extension property is not preserved under sums and products of commuting operators. On the positive side, Sun showed that the sum and product of two commuting operators with Dunford property (C) possess the single-valued extension property. Recently, Aiena and Muller proved that the (localized) single-valued extension property is stable under commuting Riesz perturbations. This paper proves that Bishop property (β), decomposability property (δ), or decomposable operators are stable under quasinilpotent, compact, and algebraic commuting perturbations.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problems to be addressed: This paper primarily investigates the stability of local spectral properties of operators (particularly Bishop property (β)) under various perturbations, including:
   • Stability of Bishop property (β) under Helton class operator perturbations
   • Stability of decomposability property (δ) and decomposable operators under algebraic perturbations
   • Preservation of these properties under compact and quasinilpotent perturbations
2. Significance of the problem:
   • The decomposability of sums and products of commuting decomposable operators is a central open problem in local spectral theory of operators on Banach spaces
   • The study of stability of local spectral properties is crucial for understanding the spectral structure of operators
   • These results have important applications in invariant subspace theory, harmonic analysis, and automatic continuity theory
3. Limitations of existing approaches:
   • Bourhim and Muller have proven that the single-valued extension property is not preserved under sums and products of commuting operators
   • Systematic research on the stability of Bishop property (β) and decomposability property (δ) is lacking
4. Research motivation: Direct verification of Bishop property (β) for concrete operators is typically difficult; therefore, finding more tractable sufficient conditions is necessary.

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of the Helton class concept: Defined that operator S belongs to the Helton class of R, meaning there exists an integer k≥1 such that $C_{(R,S)}^k(I) = 0$
2. Proved stability of Bishop property (β) under Helton class perturbations: If R possesses Bishop property (β) and S belongs to the Helton class of R, then S also possesses Bishop property (β)
3. Established equivalence of Bishop property (β) between nilpotent equivalent operators: Proved that nilpotent equivalent operators possess the same Bishop property (β)
4. Proved stability of decomposability property and decomposability under algebraic perturbations: Provided preservation theorems for these properties under algebraic, compact, and quasinilpotent perturbations
5. Provided sufficient conditions for Bishop property (β) of 2×2 operator matrices

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigation of the stability of local spectral properties of operators under perturbations, specifically including:

• Input: Bounded linear operators T with certain local spectral properties
• Perturbations: Special types of operators commuting with T (Helton class, algebraic, compact, quasinilpotent, etc.)
• Output: Proof that perturbed operators retain the corresponding local spectral properties

Core Concepts and Definitions

1. Helton class definition: For $R \in B(X)$, if there exists an integer $k \geq 1$ such that operator S satisfies $C_{(R,S)}^k(I) = 0$, then S is said to belong to the Helton class of R, denoted $S \in \text{Helton}_k(R)$, where: $C_{(R,S)}^k(I) = \sum_{j=0}^k (-1)^{k-j}\binom{k}{j}R^jS^{k-j}$
2. Bishop property (β): An operator $T \in B(X)$ possesses Bishop property (β) at $\lambda_0$ if there exists $v > 0$ such that for each open subset $U \subset D(\lambda_0; v)$ and any sequence $\{f_n\}_{n=1}^{\infty} \subset O(U;X)$, $\lim_{n\to\infty}(T-\lambda I)f_n(\lambda) = 0 \text{ in } O(U;X) \Rightarrow \lim_{n\to\infty}f_n(\lambda) = 0 \text{ in } O(U;X)$

Main Theorems and Proof Strategies

Theorem 2.1 (Transitivity of Bishop property in Helton class): Let $R \in B(X)$ possess Bishop property (β) at $\lambda_0$. If $S \in \text{Helton}_k(R)$, then S possesses Bishop property (β) at $\lambda_0$.

Proof strategy:

• Utilize the definition of Helton class: $\sum_{j=0}^k (-1)^{k-j}\binom{k}{j}R^jS^{k-j} = 0$
• Through induction, progressively derive $f_n(\lambda) \to 0$ from $(R-\lambda)^k f_n(\lambda) \to 0$

Theorem 2.3 (Equivalence for nilpotent equivalent operators): If $S, T \in B(X)$ are nilpotent equivalent, then T possesses Bishop property (β) at $\lambda_0$ if and only if S possesses Bishop property (β) at $\lambda_0$.

Theorem 2.5 (Stability under algebraic perturbations): Let $T \in B(X)$ and $K \in B(X)$ be an algebraic operator with $TK = KT$. If T possesses Bishop property (β) at each zero of the polynomial $p$ (where $p(K) = 0$), then $T+K$ possesses Bishop property (β) at 0.

Technical Innovations

1. Introduction of Helton class: A new operator class that generalizes the concept of nilpotent operators, providing a new framework for studying operator perturbations
2. Inductive proof technique: Skillfully exploits the definition of Bishop property (β) through induction to progressively reduce operator powers
3. Spectral decomposition method: Utilizes classical spectral decomposition for algebraic operators, reducing the problem to finite-dimensional cases

Experimental Setup

This is a pure theoretical mathematics paper with no numerical experiments or datasets. All results are obtained through rigorous mathematical proofs.

Main Results

Core Theorems

1. Stability of Bishop property (β):
   • Stable under Helton class perturbations (Theorem 2.1)
   • Stable under nilpotent perturbations (Corollary 2.1)
   • Stable under algebraic perturbations (Theorem 2.5)
2. Stability of decomposability property (δ):
   • Stable under algebraic perturbations (Corollary 2.2)
3. Stability of decomposable operators:
   • Stable under algebraic perturbations (Corollary 2.3)
   • Stable under nilpotent perturbations (Corollary 2.4)

Application Results

Corollary 2.7 provides stability of decomposable operators under the following perturbations:

1. Quasinilpotent operator perturbations
2. Compact operator perturbations
3. Operator perturbations with discrete spectrum

Concrete Examples

The paper provides examples using left shift and right shift operators, demonstrating that decomposability property (δ) is not preserved under conjugation operations and is not preserved under restriction operations.

Related Work

1. Historical development:
   • N. Dunford introduced the single-valued extension property in studying spectral operators
   • Bishop, Foias and others developed the foundations of local spectral theory
   • Eschmeier and Putinar established connections with sheaf theory
2. Recent progress:
   • Negative results by Bourhim and Muller: single-valued extension property is not preserved
   • Positive results by Sun: sums and products of operators with Dunford property (C) preserve the single-valued extension property
   • Results by Aiena and Muller on Riesz perturbations
3. Positioning of this paper: This paper fills the gap in research on the stability of Bishop property (β) and decomposability property (δ) under perturbations.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Bishop property (β) is stable under multiple types of perturbations (Helton class, algebraic, nilpotent)
2. Decomposability property (δ) and decomposability are stable under algebraic perturbations
3. These results provide new tools and insights for local spectral theory

Limitations

1. Restrictions on perturbations: Requires that perturbation operators commute with the original operator, which may be restrictive in practical applications
2. Difficulty in concrete verification: Although stability results are provided, verification of these properties for concrete operators remains difficult
3. Open problems: The problem of sums and products of commuting operators remains incompletely resolved

Future Directions

1. Investigation of stability under non-commuting perturbations
2. Search for more general perturbation classes
3. Development of more effective verification methods

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: Introduction of the Helton class concept provides a new framework for operator perturbation theory
2. Strong systematicity: Establishes a complete theoretical system from special to general cases
3. Rigorous proofs: All theorems have complete mathematical proofs
4. Broad applicability: Results can be applied to invariant subspace theory, harmonic analysis, and multiple other fields

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient examples: Lacks more concrete application examples
2. Computational complexity: Does not discuss the computational complexity of verifying these properties
3. Numerical methods: Lacks methods for numerical verification

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides important tools for the development of local spectral theory
2. Practical value: Provides theoretical foundation for applied research in operator theory
3. Reproducibility: As pure mathematical theory, all results are verifiable

Applicable Scenarios

1. Research in spectral theory of operators in functional analysis
2. Investigation of invariant subspace problems
3. Applications of operator algebras and local spectral theory
4. Theoretical analysis of perturbation theory

References

The paper cites 24 related references, covering classical literature and recent advances in local spectral theory, including:

• Foundational work by Dunford on spectral operator theory
• Pioneering research by Bishop on local spectral properties
• Monographs by Eschmeier and Putinar
• Recent work by Aiena, Muller, and others

This paper makes important contributions to the field of local spectral theory of operators. Through the introduction of new concepts and establishment of a systematic theoretical framework, it advances understanding of the stability of operator spectral properties. Although it is purely theoretical research, it provides a solid theoretical foundation for related applied fields.