Revealing the temperature effect on the nucleon-nucleon inelastic cross section in isospin-asymmetric nuclear medium

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09337
• Title: Revealing the temperature effect on the nucleon-nucleon inelastic cross section in isospin-asymmetric nuclear medium
• Authors: Manzi Nan, Pengcheng Li, Guojun Wei, Xilong Xiang, Wei Zuo, Qingfeng Li
• Classification: nucl-th (Nuclear Theory)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09337

Abstract

The nucleon-nucleon (NN) inelastic scattering cross section plays a crucial role in constraining the nuclear equation of state at high baryon density and in describing the formation and evolution of compact astrophysical objects. This study investigates the temperature T dependence of Δ^{++} and Δ^{-} production cross sections in isospin-symmetric and asymmetric nuclear media within a self-consistent relativistic Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck (RBUU) framework. Two relativistic mean-field parameterizations are employed: density-dependent parameterization (DD-MEδ) and nonlinear parameterization (OMEG). Both parameterizations yield similar T-dependent baryon effective masses and mass splittings, although OMEG exhibits stronger density dependence at higher densities (> 1.5ρ₀).

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

1. Astrophysical Applications: The Δ(1232) resonance plays a special role in intermediate-energy heavy-ion collisions (HICs) and various astrophysical phenomena, serving as a key to understanding neutron stars, supernova explosions, and binary neutron star merger dynamics
2. Nuclear Equation of State Constraints: NN inelastic scattering cross sections are crucial for constraining the nuclear equation of state at high density, directly affecting the extraction of high-density symmetry energy information from pion-related observables
3. Long-standing Theory-Experiment Discrepancy: Transport models systematically overpredict pion multiplicity, a discrepancy that has persisted for over two decades

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Phenomenological Treatment: Existing methods predominantly employ phenomenological density-dependent reduction factors, lacking a self-consistent theoretical framework
2. Neglect of Temperature Effects: Although particle spectra are typically used to extract effective temperatures in HICs, the temperature dependence of scattering cross sections is frequently overlooked
3. Inconsistent Theoretical Framework: Mean-field potentials and collision terms often originate from different interactions, lacking self-consistency

Research Motivation

This work aims to establish a fully self-consistent framework in which mean-field potentials and collision terms derive from the same underlying interaction, appropriately accounting for energy, density, isospin, and temperature dependence, with particular focus on temperature effects on NN → NΔ scattering cross sections.

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Study of Temperature Effects: The first systematic investigation of temperature dependence of NN inelastic scattering cross sections within a self-consistent RBUU framework
2. Dual Parameterization Comparison: Employs DD-MEδ and OMEG parameterizations to reveal model dependence
3. Isospin Asymmetry Effects: Deeply investigates suppression mechanisms of temperature effects in isospin-asymmetric nuclear matter
4. Quantitative Temperature-Density Relationship: Establishes quantitative relationships between temperature dependence and density, revealing more pronounced temperature effects at high density
5. Astrophysical Application Guidance: Provides valuable input for improving thermal treatment of Δ-related dynamics in transport models

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

This study is based on quantum hadrodynamics (QHD)-type Lagrangian containing free and interaction parts:

$L = L_F + L_I$

where the free Lagrangian density is: $L_F = \bar{\Psi}[i\gamma^\mu\partial_\mu - m_N]\Psi + \bar{\Psi}_{\Delta\nu}[i\gamma^\mu\partial_\mu - m_\Delta]\Psi^\nu_\Delta + \text{meson terms}$

Effective Lagrangian

The interaction part includes couplings of nucleons and Δ particles with σ, ω, δ, and ρ mesons: $L_I = g^{\sigma}_{NN}\bar{\Psi}\Psi\sigma + g^{\delta}_{NN}\bar{\Psi}\vec{\tau}\cdot\Psi\vec{\delta} - g^{\omega}_{NN}\bar{\Psi}\gamma_\mu\Psi\omega^\mu - g^{\rho}_{NN}\bar{\Psi}\gamma_\mu\vec{\tau}\cdot\Psi\vec{\rho}^\mu + \text{Δ coupling terms}$

Parameterization Schemes

1. DD-MEδ Parameter Set: Density-dependent coupling constants, applicable to ground-state nuclear experiments
2. OMEG Parameter Set: Nonlinearly dependent coupling constants, applicable to astrophysical observations

Effective Mass Calculation

In the Hartree approximation, the effective masses of protons and neutrons are determined by σ and δ exchange: $m^*_{p/n} = m_N - g^{\sigma}_{NN}\sigma \mp g^{\delta}_{NN}\delta$

The effective masses of Δ isospin states are related through Clebsch-Gordan coefficients: $m^*_{\Delta^{++}/\Delta^{-}} = m_\Delta - g^{\sigma}_{\Delta\Delta}\sigma \mp g^{\delta}_{\Delta\Delta}\delta$

Temperature Dependence Treatment

Fermion and antifermion distribution functions: $f_i(p) = \frac{1}{1 + e^{[E^*_i(p)-\mu^*_i]/T}}$$\bar{f}_i(p) = \frac{1}{1 + e^{[E^*_i(p)+\mu^*_i]/T}}$

Experimental Setup

Computational Parameters

• Density Range: ρ₀ to 3ρ₀ (ρ₀ = 0.16 fm⁻³ is nuclear saturation density)
• Temperature Range: 0-150 MeV
• Isospin Asymmetry: α = (ρₙ - ρₚ)/(ρₙ + ρₚ) = 0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3
• Center-of-Mass Energy: √s = 2.0-3.2 GeV, with emphasis on √s = 2.326 GeV (corresponding to kinetic energy EK = 1 GeV)

Reaction Channels

Two primary Δ production channels are investigated:

1. pp → nΔ⁺⁺: Proton-proton collision producing Δ⁺⁺
2. nn → pΔ⁻: Neutron-neutron collision producing Δ⁻

Evaluation Metrics

Temperature-dependent ratio quantifying temperature effects: $R(\alpha, T) = \frac{\sigma^*(\alpha, T)}{\sigma^*(\alpha, T=0)}$

Experimental Results

Temperature and Density Dependence of Effective Masses

1. Density Effects: At low density (ρ ≤ 1.5ρ₀), DD-MEδ and OMEG results are similar; at high density, OMEG shows stronger density dependence
2. Temperature Effects: In the 0-150 MeV range, effective masses increase slowly with temperature
3. Isospin Splitting: Proton effective mass consistently exceeds neutron effective mass, with splitting strengthening as density increases

Temperature Effects in Isospin-Symmetric Nuclear Matter

1. Cross Section Enhancement: Elevated temperature leads to significant enhancement of scattering cross sections, primarily due to increased baryon effective masses with temperature
2. Density Suppression: Cross sections monotonically decrease with increasing density, with OMEG parameterization showing faster decrease
3. Model Dependence: Results from both parameterizations are similar at low density; at high density, OMEG shows stronger temperature sensitivity

Special Behavior in Isospin-Asymmetric Nuclear Matter

1. Channel Differences: σ_{pp→nΔ⁺⁺}(α≠0) > σ{NN→NΔ}(α=0), while σ*{nn→pΔ⁻}(α≠0) < σ*_{NN→NΔ}(α=0)
2. Temperature Effect Suppression: Temperature dependence in isospin-asymmetric nuclear matter is somewhat suppressed compared to symmetric matter
3. Density Sensitivity: R(α=0,T) > R(α=0.3,T) is more pronounced at high density

Temperature Effects of Isospin Dependence

1. Low Asymmetry: At α = 0.1 and 0.2, the ratio is nearly independent of temperature
2. High Asymmetry: At α = 0.3, isospin dependence becomes complex, exhibiting model dependence
3. Channel Specificity: pp → nΔ⁺⁺ and nn → pΔ⁻ channels exhibit different temperature-isospin coupling behavior

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Early Research: Studies of Δ resonance roles in HICs began in the 1990s
2. Pion Observables: Over the past three decades, π⁻/π⁺ ratios have been widely used to constrain density dependence of symmetry energy
3. Model Improvements: Recent findings emphasize the importance of in-medium corrections to NN → NΔ cross sections

Position of This Work

1. Enhanced Self-Consistency: Compared to phenomenological approaches, this work provides a more self-consistent theoretical framework
2. Temperature Effect Supplement: Fills the gap in temperature effect research
3. Multi-Parameterization Verification: Two different parameterizations enhance result reliability

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Temperature Enhancement Effect: In the 0-150 MeV range, Δ production cross sections show significant enhancement with increasing temperature
2. Density-Temperature Coupling: Temperature dependence strengthens with increasing density, exhibiting model dependence above 1.5ρ₀
3. Isospin Suppression: Temperature effects in isospin-asymmetric nuclear matter are somewhat suppressed compared to symmetric matter
4. Complex Isospin-Temperature Coupling: Isospin dependence in highly asymmetric systems depends on both the parameter set and temperature

Physical Mechanisms

1. σ-Meson Dominance: Temperature effects are primarily contributed by σ-meson exchange
2. δ-Meson Contribution: Isospin effects are mainly determined by δ-meson exchange
3. Phase Space Factors: Near-threshold enhancement originates from rapid growth of phase space factor |p⃗f|/|p⃗i|

Astrophysical Significance

1. Neutron Star Physics: Provides important input for understanding Δ particle behavior in neutron star interiors
2. Supernova Dynamics: Helps improve simulations of supernova explosions and binary neutron star mergers
3. Equation of State Constraints: Provides new constraints on high-density nuclear equation of state

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Self-Consistency: Establishes a self-consistent framework where mean-field potentials and collision terms derive from the same interaction
2. Systematic Investigation: First systematic study of temperature effects on NN inelastic scattering cross sections
3. Multi-Dimensional Analysis: Simultaneously considers energy, density, temperature, and isospin dependence
4. Model Verification: Enhanced result reliability through two different parameterizations
5. Quantitative Results: Provides precise numerical results and ratio relationships

Technical Innovations

1. RBUU Framework Extension: Successfully extends RBUU theory to finite temperature regime
2. Effective Lagrangian Construction: Complete effective Lagrangian including δ-meson coupling
3. Self-Consistent Iterative Solution: Solves meson field equations through self-consistent iteration

Limitations

1. Temperature Range Restriction: Behavior at extremely high temperatures exceeding 150 MeV requires further investigation
2. Parameterization Dependence: Results exhibit strong model dependence at high density
3. Lack of Experimental Verification: Absence of direct experimental data to verify theoretical predictions
4. Approximation Treatment: Hartree approximation may be insufficient in certain cases

Impact Assessment

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important temperature effect research for nuclear physics theory
2. Practical Value: Furnishes important input parameters for transport model improvements
3. Interdisciplinary Impact: Significant implications for both nuclear physics and astrophysics
4. Foundation for Future Research: Establishes important foundation for subsequent related studies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Heavy-Ion Collision Experiments: Provides theoretical support for experimental analysis at HIAF, FAIR, and similar facilities
2. Astrophysical Simulations: Applicable to theoretical modeling of extreme environments such as neutron stars and supernovae
3. Transport Model Improvements: Provides reference for Δ-related process treatment in various transport models
4. Nuclear Equation of State Research: Offers new pathways for constraining high-density nuclear equation of state

Future Perspectives

Theoretical Development Directions

1. Higher Temperature Research: Extension to chiral symmetry restoration temperature regime
2. Quantum Fluctuation Effects: Consideration of quantum corrections beyond Hartree approximation
3. Dynamical Evolution: Investigation of temperature time evolution effects on scattering cross sections

Experimental Verification Needs

1. HICs Experiments: Require more precise measurements of pion production and Δ resonance
2. Temperature Extraction: Improvement of effective temperature extraction methods in HICs
3. Multi-Messenger Observations: Combination of gravitational wave and electromagnetic signal astrophysical observations

Application Extensions

1. Other Resonance States: Extension to research on other baryon resonance states
2. Quark Matter: Extension toward quark matter phase transition regions
3. Magnetic Field Effects: Consideration of correction effects in strong magnetic field environments

This research provides important theoretical contributions to understanding nuclear matter properties under extreme conditions and holds significant implications for interdisciplinary research between nuclear physics and astrophysics.