Dark matter production from evaporation of regular primordial black holes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09395
• Title: Dark matter production from evaporation of regular primordial black holes
• Author: Ngo Phuc Duc Loc (Physics Division, National Center for Theoretical Sciences, National Taiwan University)
• Categories: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09395v1

Abstract

This paper investigates the mechanism of dark matter production from the evaporation of regular primordial black holes (RPBHs). The author focuses on the Hayward metric and Simpson-Visser metric as representative examples of singularity-free RPBHs, with the proposed framework directly applicable to other metrics. RPBHs typically exhibit Hawking temperatures and lifetimes different from standard singular black holes, leading to corresponding corrections in the cosmological constraints of this dark matter production mechanism and a recalculation of the allowed parameter space for obtaining the correct dark matter abundance.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problems to be Addressed

• Singularity Problem: Standard black hole solutions contain unsatisfactory singularities that violate fundamental physical principles
• Dark Matter Origin: Need to identify viable production mechanisms for dark matter
• Early Universe Physics: Understanding the role of primordial black holes in early universe evolution

2. Importance of the Problem

• Observations of unexpectedly early supermassive and intermediate-mass black holes suggest traditional mass growth channels may be insufficient
• The particle nature of dark matter is more amenable to direct detection experiments on Earth compared to compact object forms
• Simultaneously addressing the dark matter problem and black hole singularity problem carries significant theoretical importance

3. Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional singular black holes possess inevitable singularities
• Gravitational collapse of ordinary matter satisfying standard classical energy conditions does not naturally form regular black holes
• Non-self-similar regular black holes violate the standard self-similarity assumption in black hole evaporation

4. Research Motivation

Propose the concept of self-similar regular black holes that maintain standard black hole evaporation behavior while avoiding singularities, providing a new theoretical framework for dark matter production.

Core Contributions

1. Proposes Self-Similar Regular Black Holes: Maintains black hole evaporation self-similarity by fixing the l/M ratio rather than the l value
2. Establishes Universal Theoretical Framework: Develops a method for calculating dark matter production applicable to arbitrary static spherically symmetric regular black holes
3. Corrects Cosmological Constraints: Recalculates BBN constraints, warm dark matter constraints, etc., in the regular black hole case
4. Parameter Space Analysis: Systematically analyzes the allowed parameter regions for obtaining correct dark matter abundance
5. Quantitative Comparison: Provides detailed comparison of differences between Hayward and Simpson-Visser metrics

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate the process of dark matter particle production through Hawking radiation evaporation of regular primordial black holes, calculate dark matter abundance, and determine the parameter space satisfying observational constraints.

Theoretical Framework

1. Regular Black Hole Metrics

Consider the general form of static spherically symmetric metrics:

ds² = -f(r)dt² + dr²/g(r) + h(r)dΩ²

Two specific metrics are studied:

Hayward Metric:

f_Hay(r) = g_Hay(r) = 1 - 2Mr²/(r³ + 2Ml²)
h_Hay(r) = r²

Simpson-Visser Metric:

f_SV(r) = g_SV(r) = 1 - 2M/√(r² + l²)
h_SV(r) = r² + l²

where l is the regularization parameter ensuring singularity removal.

2. Self-Similarity Assumption

Key innovation: Fix the ratio l/M rather than l itself, such that:

• The relationship between Hawking temperature and black hole mass maintains standard form
• Avoids production of stable remnants
• Preserves self-similar behavior of black hole evaporation

3. Hawking Radiation Corrections

Define correction factors:

A(l) ≡ T_H/T_H,Sch    (temperature ratio)
B(l) ≡ r_H/r_H,Sch    (horizon radius ratio)

Mass loss rate:

dM/dt = -B(l)²A(l)⁴ g_*(T_H)/(30720π) × m_pl⁴/M²

4. Dark Matter Production Calculation

Consider two cases:

Initial Hawking Temperature Higher than Dark Matter Mass (T_H,in > m_χ):

N_i = 120g_iζ(3)M_i²/[g_*(T_H)π³m_pl²A(l)]

Initial Hawking Temperature Lower than Dark Matter Mass (T_H,in < m_χ):

N_i = 15g_iζ(3)A(l)m_pl²/[8g_*(T_H)π⁵m_i²]

Cosmological Evolution Analysis

1. Critical Abundance

Critical abundance for regular black holes not dominating the universe:

β_c = 1.78×10⁻⁶ A(l)²B(l) (g_*,eva/106.75)^(1/4) (g_*,in/106.75)^(1/4) (g/M_i)

2. Dark Matter Abundance Formula

Depending on whether a regular black hole-dominated phase exists, four different analytical expressions for dark matter abundance are provided.

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• Hayward Metric: l/M = 0.769 (approaching extremum √(16/27))
• Simpson-Visser Metric: l/M = 1.99 (approaching extremum 2)
• Dark Matter Particle: Scalar particle, g_χ = 1
• Mass Range: 10⁻² - 10² GeV

Constraints

1. Inflation Constraint: M_i > 1.7 g
2. BBN Constraint: M_i < 8.6×10⁸ A(l)^(4/3) B(l)^(2/3) g
3. Warm Dark Matter Constraint: M_i ≤ 2.18×10⁵ A(l)²B(l)² (m_χ/GeV)² g

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Hawking Temperature and Lifetime Corrections

• Hawking temperatures of regular black holes are universally lower than singular black holes
• Lifetime extension can reach 10¹¹ times (near extremum)
• Hayward and Simpson-Visser metrics exhibit similar qualitative behavior

2. Parameter Space Analysis

Analysis of the β-M_i plane reveals:

• Critical Line Shift: β_c line shifts toward smaller abundances
• Inflection Point Displacement: The inflection point at T_H,in = m_χ shifts toward smaller masses
• Strengthened Constraints: BBN and warm dark matter constraints become more stringent

3. Quantitative Comparison

Compared to singular black holes:

• Achieving the same dark matter abundance requires smaller black hole abundance or larger black hole mass
• The allowed parameter space shifts overall toward the lower-left direction
• Simpson-Visser metric shows more pronounced effects than Hayward metric

Physical Picture Interpretation

Small-mass regular black holes are equivalent to large-mass singular black holes, explaining:

• Critical line and constraint shifts toward small masses
• Reduction segment requires smaller abundance compensation
• Increase segment requires larger abundance compensation

Related Work

Regular Black Hole Theory

• Phenomenological Metrics: Bardeen, Hayward, Dymnikova solutions, etc.
• Quantum Gravity Motivation: Simpson-Visser, Peltola-Kunstatter, D'Ambrosio-Rovelli metrics
• Stability Issues: Inner horizon instability remains an active research area

Primordial Black Hole Cosmology

• Formation Mechanisms: Ultra-slow-roll inflation, strong first-order phase transitions
• Constraints: Multiple observational constraints from BBN, CMB, gravitational waves, etc.
• Dark Matter Candidates: Black holes themselves or evaporation products as dark matter

Cosmologically Coupled Black Holes

• Observational Motivation: Discovery of unexpectedly early supermassive black holes
• Theoretical Development: Black hole models with mass growth coupled to cosmic expansion
• Phenomenological Studies: Lack of first-principles derivations to date

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Self-Similar Regular Black Holes: Provide a theoretical framework that avoids singularities while maintaining standard evaporation behavior
2. Dark Matter Production Mechanism: Regular black holes can effectively produce particle dark matter, with systematic shifts in parameter space
3. Constraint Corrections: All cosmological constraints require corresponding corrections, generally becoming more stringent
4. Universality: Framework applies to arbitrary static spherically symmetric regular black hole metrics

Limitations

1. Formation Mechanism: The dynamical formation mechanism of regular black holes remains unclear
2. Stability: Inner horizon instability issues are not fully resolved
3. Approximations: Detailed grey-body factor calculations are neglected
4. Metric Selection: Only two representative metrics are considered

Future Directions

1. Observational Tests: Explore possible observational pathways such as gravitational waves
2. Dynamical Studies: Deeper investigation of regular black hole formation mechanisms
3. Precise Calculations: More accurate calculations including grey-body factors
4. Cosmological Coupling: Combined study of cosmological coupling and evaporation effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: The concept of self-similar regular black holes has significant theoretical value
2. Systematicity: Provides a complete theoretical framework and calculation formulas
3. Generality: Method is generalizable to other regular black hole metrics
4. Physical Intuition: Clearly explains the physical reasons for parameter space shifts
5. Quantitative Analysis: Provides detailed numerical results and constraints

Weaknesses

1. Foundational Assumptions: The existence and formation mechanism of regular black holes lack solid theoretical foundation
2. Approximation Level: Multiple approximations used throughout may affect result accuracy
3. Observational Verification: Lacks direct observational verification pathways
4. Parameter Dependence: Results strongly depend on regularization parameter choice

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new research directions for regular black hole cosmology
2. Methodological Value: Established framework can serve as reference for subsequent research
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects gravitational theory, particle physics, and cosmology
4. Practical Value: Offers new theoretical possibilities for dark matter origin

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Regular black hole physics and early universe cosmology studies
2. Phenomenological Analysis: Theoretical exploration of dark matter production mechanisms
3. Constraint Analysis: Parameter space studies of primordial black hole models
4. Method Development: Reference for calculation frameworks in similar problems

References

The paper cites 76 related references covering important works in regular black hole theory, primordial black hole cosmology, dark matter physics, and other relevant fields, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is an important work in the interdisciplinary field of theoretical physics that innovatively proposes the concept of self-similar regular black holes and systematically investigates dark matter production mechanisms, providing a valuable theoretical framework and computational tools for related research. Despite limitations in foundational assumptions and approximations, its theoretical contributions and methodological value remain noteworthy.