Localizing the Ising CFT from the ground state of the Ising model on the fuzzy sphere

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09482
• Title: Localizing the Ising CFT from the ground state of the Ising model on the fuzzy sphere
• Author: Kay Jörg Wiese (CNRS-Laboratoire de Physique de l'Ecole Normale Supérieure)
• Classification: hep-th, cond-mat.stat-mech
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09482

Abstract

This paper localizes the phase transition line through finite-size scaling analysis of the ground state energy of the Ising model on the fuzzy sphere. The research strategy involves expressing the ground state energy as $E_{\rm GS}(N)/N_m = E_{0} + E_1 /N_m + E_{3/2}/N_m^{3/2}+ ...$, and seeking the minimum of $E_{3/2}/E_0$ as a function of the coupling parameters. This method successfully reproduces the critical curve and optimal point from PRX 13 (2023) 021009, with similar results obtained when normalizing by the energy gap of the stress tensor $T$ or the first parity-odd operator $σ$.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Core Problem: How to accurately localize the phase transition line and conformal field theory (CFT) critical point of the 3D Ising model within the fuzzy sphere regularization framework
2. Technical Challenge: Existing methods require computing the complete energy spectrum to identify the CFT, which is computationally expensive and complex

Significance

1. Theoretical Importance: Fuzzy sphere regularization is an important new tool for studying 3D CFTs, particularly suitable for non-unitary theories
2. Methodological Value: Provides a simple and efficient method to localize CFTs using only ground state energy information
3. Application Prospects: Can be generalized to other complex systems, such as non-unitary Potts models

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Computational Complexity: Standard methods require finding descendant operator spectra with integer spacing
2. Numerical Cost: Requires computing multiple excited states, resulting in large computational overhead
3. Strong Dependence: Requires prior knowledge of expected CFT properties

Research Motivation

Inspired by the successful application of stationary point conditions for effective central charge in 2D cases, the author aims to generalize similar ideas to 3D, utilizing only ground state energy information to localize CFTs.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a novel CFT localization method: Based on minimizing the coefficient of the $N_m^{-3/2}$ term in the finite-size expansion of ground state energy
2. Verified method effectiveness: Successfully reproduced the known critical curve and optimal conformal point of the Ising model
3. Provided multiple normalization schemes: Beyond ground state energy normalization, verified the equivalence of stress tensor and σ operator energy gap normalizations
4. Established a computationally efficient protocol: Requires only ground state energy calculations, significantly reducing numerical costs

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Objective: Localize the critical line and optimal conformal point corresponding to the CFT in the parameter space $(h,g)$ of the Ising model on the fuzzy sphere

Input: Ground state energy $E_{GS}(N_m)$ for different system sizes $N_m$

Output: Critical coupling parameters $(h^*,g^*)$ and phase transition line

Core Method Architecture

1. Finite-Size Expansion

Expand the ground state energy as a power series in $N_m$: $\frac{E_{GS}(N_m)}{N_m} = E_0 + \frac{E_1}{N_m} + \frac{E_{3/2}}{N_m^{3/2}} + \frac{E_2}{N_m^2} + \frac{E_{5/2}}{N_m^{5/2}} + ...$

With $x = 1/N_m$, the expansion becomes: $\frac{E_{GS}(x|h,g)}{N_m} = E_0(h,g) + E_1(h,g)x + E_{3/2}(h,g)x^{3/2} + E_2(h,g)x^2 + E_{5/2}(h,g)x^{5/2} + ...$

2. CFT Criterion

Define the key quantity: $\chi(h,g) := \frac{E_{3/2}(h,g)}{E_0(h,g)}$

The CFT condition is a stationary point of $\chi$: $\frac{\partial \chi}{\partial h} = \frac{\partial \chi}{\partial g} = 0$

3. Alternative Normalization Schemes

To avoid non-universal ground state energy normalization, two alternative schemes are proposed:

Stress Tensor Normalization: $\chi_T := \frac{E_{3/2}}{\sqrt{N_m}(E_T - E_{GS})}$

σ Operator Normalization: $\chi_σ := \frac{E_{3/2}}{\sqrt{N_m}(E_σ - E_{GS})}$

Technical Innovations

1. Theoretical Inspiration: Inspired by the 3D sphere free energy expansion $F = α_1R^3 + α_2R + \mathcal{F}$, the $N_m^{-3/2}$ term is selected as the key criterion
2. Numerical Stability: Employs weighted polynomial interpolation to handle discrete grid data, with weight function $ρ(h,g) = \exp(-α[(h_i-h)^2/δh^2 + (g_i-g)^2/δg^2])$
3. Systematic Verification: Validates method stability through different truncation orders and system sizes

Experimental Setup

Model Parameters

• System Sizes: $N_m = 8$ to $17$, corresponding to magnetic monopole numbers $s = (N_m-1)/2$
• Coupling Parameter Range: $h \in [0.5, 4.5]$, $g \in [1, 7]$
• Grid Precision: Coarse grid $δh = 0.05, δg = 0.2$; fine grid $δh = 0.01, δg = 0.05$

Numerical Implementation

• Software Tool: FuzzifiED package (Julia implementation)
• Fitting Order: Primarily uses $o = 4$ (including terms up to $x^{5/2}$)
• Computational Resources: 8-core machine, approximately 10 minutes for $N_m = 17$

Reference Benchmarks

• Reference Results: Critical line and optimal point from Zhu et al. PRX 13 (2023) 021009
• Known Critical Parameters: Optimal point approximately at $(h,g) ≈ (3.16, 4.75)$

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Critical Line Reproduction

Successfully reproduces the critical curve from literature, as shown in Figure 4:

• White dashed line represents the reference critical line
• Blue points mark the valley line found by this method
• Cyan diamonds mark the global minimum point

2. Optimal Point Localization

Optimal point locations for different system sizes:

3. Normalization Scheme Comparison

Three normalization schemes ($\chi$, $\chi_T$, $\chi_σ$) yield highly consistent results, validating the robustness of the method.

Ablation Studies

1. Impact of Expansion Order

• $o = 2, 3$: Insufficient precision
• $o = 4$: Optimal choice
• $o = 5, 6$: Increased numerical noise

2. System Size Dependence

Smaller systems ($N_m = 12$) can already localize the phase transition, but precision improves with increasing $N_m$.

3. Importance of Truncation Terms

Must retain $E_2$ and $E_{5/2}$ terms; truncating only to $E_{3/2}$ leads to incorrect results.

Key Findings

1. $\chi$ Value Approaching Zero: Near the optimal point, $\chi$ may approach zero, suggesting that $E_{3/2} = 0$ at the true CFT
2. Stress Tensor Energy Gap Scaling: $\sqrt{N_m}(E_T - E_{GS})$ exhibits the same scaling behavior as $E_{3/2}$
3. Curvature Sign Change: The stress tensor energy gap changes curvature sign at the phase transition point

Related Work

Fuzzy Sphere Regularization Field

1. Pioneering Work: Zhu et al. PRX 13 (2023) 021009 established the fuzzy sphere realization of 3D Ising CFT
2. Extended Applications: Applied to Sp(n) symmetric theories, Chern-Simons matter theories, Potts models, etc.
3. Conformal Generator Construction: Recent work by Fardelli et al. and Fan directly constructs conformal generators

CFT Localization Methods

1. Numerical Conformal Bootstrap: Current gold standard for 3D CFT research, but unsuitable for non-unitary theories
2. 2D Precedent: Jacobsen-Wiese method localizes complex CFTs through effective central charge stationary points
3. Entanglement Entropy Methods: Methods extracting F functions from entanglement spectra

Finite-Size Scaling Theory

1. 2D Theory: Cardy formula and c-theorem
2. 4D Generalization: a-theorem and Weyl anomaly
3. 3D F-theorem: F-function theory developed through holography and supersymmetric models

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method Effectiveness: Minimization of the $N_m^{-3/2}$ term in ground state energy successfully localizes the Ising CFT
2. Computational Advantage: Requires only ground state energy, with computational cost far lower than traditional methods
3. Multiple Verifications: Different normalization schemes yield consistent results, enhancing method credibility

Limitations

1. Theoretical Foundation: The relationship with the 3D sphere F-function remains unclear
2. Universal Applicability Unknown: The method's applicability to other CFTs requires further verification
3. Finite-Size Effects: May require larger system sizes to precisely extract the F-function

Future Directions

1. Theoretical Development: Establish rigorous connections between ground state energy expansion and CFT theory
2. Method Generalization: Application to complex CFTs, such as the 3-state Potts model
3. Precision Enhancement: Explore higher-order corrections and more accurate finite-size formulas

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Method Innovation: First proposal of a method for localizing 3D CFTs based on ground state energy, with novel approach
2. Computational Efficiency: Significantly reduces computational cost compared to traditional methods, with high practical value
3. Result Reliability: Successfully reproduces known results, with multiple verifications enhancing credibility
4. Technical Completeness: Detailed descriptions from theoretical motivation to numerical implementation

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Rigor: Lacks rigorous theoretical derivation, primarily based on analogy and numerical verification
2. Scope of Applicability: Verified only on the Ising model, universal applicability remains to be confirmed
3. F-Function Relationship: Connection with known F-function theory is insufficiently clear
4. System Size Limitations: Limited by ED methods, maximum system size is relatively small

Impact

1. Methodological Contribution: Provides a new numerical tool for CFT research
2. Computational Physics Significance: Demonstrates the rich content of ground state information, inspiring subsequent research
3. Cross-Disciplinary Value: Method may be applicable to phase transition research in other quantum many-body systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. CFT Localization: Suitable for rapid screening of CFT candidate points
2. Parameter Scanning: Initial localization of regions of interest in large parameter spaces
3. Method Verification: Cross-verification tool for other precise methods
4. Educational Demonstration: Simple concepts, suitable for numerical experiments in CFT-related courses

References

This paper cites 32 important references, including:

• 1 W. Zhu et al., PRX 13 (2023) 021009 - Pioneering work on fuzzy sphere Ising model
• 17 J.L. Jacobsen and K.J. Wiese, PRL 133 (2024) 077101 - 2D complex CFT localization method
• 32 Z. Zhou, arXiv:2503.00100 - FuzzifiED software package documentation

Overall Assessment: This is a paper with important innovations in CFT numerical research methods. While its theoretical foundation requires further refinement, its practical value and inspirational significance are substantial, providing valuable new tools for fuzzy sphere regularization and 3D CFT research.