A microscopic approach to nonlinear theory of spin-charge separation

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09515
• Title: A microscopic approach to nonlinear theory of spin-charge separation
• Authors: Oleksandr Tsyplyatyev, Yiqing Jin, María Moreno, Wooi Kiat Tan, Christopher J.B. Ford
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el cond-mat.mes-hall quant-ph
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09515

Abstract

The behavior of spin-charge separation phenomena beyond the low-energy regime has remained an unresolved mystery. This study develops a microscopic theory of correlation functions through strong-coupling expansion of the Hubbard model, demonstrating its validity in the experimentally relevant regime of $r_s > 1$. By calculating spectral functions, the authors demonstrate the stability of nonlinear spin-charge modes across the entire band and systematically investigate all nonlinear features. The research validates theoretical predictions through experiments in semiconductor quantum wires, observing signals consistent with nonlinear excitation continua and finite spectral density near the $3k_F$ point, indicating the robustness of Hubbard model predictions for finite-range interactions.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

Interactions in one-dimensional electron systems induce a transition from Fermi liquid to Luttinger liquid, producing pseudogaps and spin-charge separation phenomena. While these effects have been experimentally verified in the low-energy linear regime, the nonlinear behavior beyond this region remains unknown.

Problem Significance

1. Theoretical Completeness: Understanding the complete energy spectrum of spin-charge separation is crucial for the theory of one-dimensional strongly correlated electron systems
2. Experimental Relevance: Practical experimental conditions typically involve finite interaction strengths ($r_s > 1$), requiring theoretical guidance
3. Technical Applications: Interaction-based band engineering offers possibilities for novel quantum devices

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Field Theory Approaches: Encounter divergence problems or uncertain results in the nonlinear regime
2. Algebraic Methods: Although the Lieb-Wu exact solution provides the complete spectrum, direct application of algebraic methods to correlation function calculations in the Hubbard model remains unsuccessful
3. Lack of Experimental Verification: Absence of systematic experimental verification of theoretical predictions in the nonlinear regime

Core Contributions

1. Development of New Microscopic Theory: Constructed a $t/U$ expansion method starting from $U=\infty$ for calculating correlation functions of the Hubbard model
2. Validation of Theory: Verified the validity of the expansion method in the $r_s > 1$ regime through occupation number calculations
3. Revelation of Nonlinear Features: Systematically investigated the stability and nonlinear characteristics of spin-charge separation modes across the entire band
4. Experimental Verification: Confirmed theoretical predictions in semiconductor quantum wires, observing experimental signals of nonlinear excitations
5. Theory-Experiment Connection: Demonstrated the applicability of the Hubbard model to finite-range interactions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study spin-charge separation phenomena in one-dimensional Hubbard models, particularly behavior in the nonlinear regime. Input consists of system parameters (hopping integral $t$, interaction strength $U$, particle number $N$); output includes spectral function $A(k,E)$ and other observables.

Theoretical Framework

Hubbard Model

The core model under investigation is: $H = -t\sum_{j\alpha}(c^\dagger_{j\alpha}c_{j+1,\alpha} + c^\dagger_{j\alpha}c_{j-1,\alpha}) + U\sum_j n_{j\uparrow}n_{j\downarrow}$

$t/U$ Expansion Method

1. $U=\infty$ Limit: Lieb-Wu wave function factorizes into spin and charge components $|\Psi^0\rangle = |\Psi^0_c\rangle \otimes |\Psi^0_s\rangle$
2. Quasi-momentum Expansion: $k_j = k^0_j + \frac{t}{U}k^1_j, \quad q_m = q^0_m + \frac{t}{U}q^1_m$
3. Key Parameter: Dimensionless parameter $\gamma = 0.09\lambda_F U/t$, where $\lambda_F = 4L/N$ is the Fermi wavelength

Matrix Element Calculation

Matrix elements $\langle f|c_{\pm k\alpha}|0\rangle$ are calculated using the algebraic Bethe ansatz method:

$\langle f|c_{1\uparrow}|0\rangle = \langle f|c_{1\uparrow}|0\rangle^0 + \frac{t}{U}\langle f|c_{1\uparrow}|0\rangle^1$

where the linear term decomposes as: $\langle f|c_{1\uparrow}|0\rangle^1 = \langle f|c_{1\uparrow}|0\rangle^0(T_c + T_s + T_{cs})$

Technical Innovations

1. Factorization Exploitation: Clever utilization of wave function factorization properties in the $U=\infty$ limit
2. Algebraic Method Adaptation: Successful adaptation of algebraic methods from spin chains to the Hubbard model
3. Systematic Expansion: Establishment of a complete $t/U$ expansion framework including eigenvalues and wave functions
4. Experimental Interface: Development of corresponding transport theory connecting theoretical predictions to experimental measurements

Experimental Setup

Experimental System

GaAs/Al₀.₃₃Ga₀.₆₇As double quantum well heterostructure:

• Upper Well: Array of 300 highly uniform quantum wires, length $L = 18\mu m$
• Lower Well: Two-dimensional electron gas serving as detection layer
• Well Separation: $d = 32nm$

Measurement Technique

Magnetic transport spectroscopy:

• Energy Resolution: Fermi level relative position between wells tuned via bias voltage $V_{dc}$
• Momentum Resolution: Momentum transfer $\Delta k = eBd/\hbar$ achieved via in-plane magnetic field $B$ producing Lorentz force
• Signal Extraction: Measurement of inter-well current $I$, calculation of conductance $G = dI/dV_{dc}$

Experimental Parameters

• Gate Voltage Range: $V_{FG} = -664mV$ to $-693mV$
• Density Range: $n_{1D} \approx 42-45\mu m^{-1}$
• Interaction Strength: Fitted value $\gamma = 1.25-1.30$

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

Occupation Number Analysis

• At $\gamma = 10$, spectral weight partially flows back from the $3k_F$ point at $U=\infty$ to below $k_F$
• The $3k_F$ Fermi point remains stable, manifesting as divergence in $\partial_k n_k$
• Integral $I = 2\int_{k_F}^{\infty} dk n_k/N = 0.25 + 0.05/\gamma$ validates expansion validity

Spectral Function Characteristics

1. Mode Separation: Single-particle band splits into spin and charge modes across the entire band
2. Asymmetry: Nonlinear components exhibit asymmetry relative to electron chemical potential $\mu$
3. Stability Differences:
   • Hole sector ($E < \mu$): Spin mode stable, charge mode unstable at bottom
   • Particle sector ($E > \mu$): Charge mode stable, spin mode becomes weaker singularity

Experimental Verification Results

Mode Identification

• Successfully observed spin and charge mode dispersion relations consistent with theoretical predictions
• Fitting with complete Lieb-Wu equations yields $\gamma = 1.25$

Nonlinear Continuum

• Large asymmetry observed around charge mode in particle sector
• Asymmetry scale approximately $k_F$, consistent with theoretical prediction of nonlinear excitation continua
• Observed amplitude significantly reduced, consistent with Hubbard model prediction

$3k_F$ Signal

• Finite signal obtained through integration of $G$ over $V_{dc}$
• Similar patterns reproduced at different gate voltages
• Although shape does not perfectly match theoretical $n_k$, confirms finite spectral density near $3k_F$ point

Quantitative Comparison

• Theoretical Prediction: Amplitude of $A(k,E)$ near $3k_F$ point approximately 100 times smaller than at $k_F$
• Experimental Observation: Expected amplitude of $G$ near $3k_F$ just below noise level ($|G| \sim 0.05\mu S$)
• Consistency: Theoretical weak signal successfully detected through integrated measurement

Related Work

Theoretical Development

1. Tomonaga-Luttinger Theory: Established foundational theoretical framework for one-dimensional electron systems
2. Lieb-Wu Exact Solution: Provided complete spectrum of Hubbard model, though correlation function calculations remain difficult
3. Algebraic Bethe Ansatz: Successfully applied in spin chains, but extension to Hubbard model encountered difficulties
4. Field Theory Methods: Encounter divergence or uncertain results in nonlinear regime

Experimental Progress

1. ARPES Experiments: Observed spin-charge separation in quasi-one-dimensional materials
2. Quantum Wire Experiments: Confirmed theoretical predictions in linear regime through transport measurements
3. Cold Atom Experiments: Provided controllable platform for strongly correlated one-dimensional systems

Positioning of This Work

This paper provides the first complete microscopic theory of spin-charge separation in the nonlinear regime and validates theoretical predictions through experiments, filling an important gap in the field.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Completeness: Established systematic $t/U$ expansion theory for Hubbard model correlation functions
2. Nonlinear Stability: Demonstrated stability of spin-charge separation modes across entire band
3. Experimental Verification: First experimental observation of theoretical predictions in nonlinear regime
4. Universality: Demonstrated applicability of Hubbard model to finite-range interactions

Limitations

1. Expansion Validity: $t/U$ expansion requires $\gamma > 1$, limiting applicable range
2. Transport Theory: Transport theory for nonlinear Luttinger liquid remains incomplete, affecting quantitative comparison
3. Hierarchy Truncation: Currently considers only first two levels ($l \leq 1$) of hierarchy; higher-order contributions may affect $3k_F$ signal
4. Experimental Constraints: $3k_F$ signal near noise level, requiring more precise experimental techniques

Future Directions

1. Theory Extension: Develop higher-order $t/U$ expansion and complete nonlinear transport theory
2. Experimental Improvement: Enhance measurement precision for better detection of weak nonlinear signals
3. Material Extension: Verify theoretical predictions in other one-dimensional strongly correlated systems
4. Application Exploration: Interaction-based band engineering applications in quantum devices

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First successful application of algebraic methods to Hubbard model correlation function calculations
2. Systematic Completeness: Provides complete theoretical framework from microscopic model to experimental observation
3. Experimental Verification: Theoretical predictions confirmed by convincing experimental evidence
4. Technical Breakthrough: Resolves long-standing theoretical problems in the nonlinear regime

Weaknesses

1. Mathematical Complexity: Extremely complex theoretical derivations may limit broader applicability
2. Approximation Limitations: Convergence and precision of $t/U$ expansion require further verification
3. Experimental Challenges: Some experimental signals are weak, requiring more precise measurement techniques
4. Quantitative Matching: Discrepancies between theory and experiment remain in certain details

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important breakthrough for one-dimensional strongly correlated electron system theory
2. Practical Significance: Provides theoretical foundation for interaction-based quantum device design
3. Methodological Contribution: Demonstrates successful example of combining exactly solvable models with experiments
4. Field Advancement: May inspire theoretical research on other strongly correlated systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. One-Dimensional Quantum Wires: Study of strongly correlated electron behavior in semiconductor quantum wires
2. Quasi-One-Dimensional Materials: Organic conductors, carbon nanotubes, and other quasi-one-dimensional systems
3. Cold Atom Systems: One-dimensional Fermi gases in optical lattices
4. Theoretical Research: Correlation function calculations in other integrable models

References

The paper cites important literature in the field, including:

• Pioneering work by Tomonaga and Luttinger
• Lieb-Wu exact solution
• Development of algebraic Bethe ansatz
• Important experimental work verifying spin-charge separation
• Related research on quantum wire transport spectroscopy

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality paper with significant breakthrough implications for strongly correlated electron system theory. The authors successfully resolve long-standing theoretical problems in the nonlinear regime and validate theoretical predictions through precise experiments. Although there remains room for improvement in technical details and quantitative matching, the combination of theoretical innovation and experimental verification makes this an important contribution to the field.