JWST Observations of SN 2024ggi II: NIRSpec Spectroscopy and CO Modeling at 285 and 385 Days Past the Explosion

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09600
• Title: JWST Observations of SN 2024ggi II: NIRSpec Spectroscopy and CO Modeling at 285 and 385 Days Past the Explosion
• Authors: T. Mera, C. Ashall, P. Hoeflich, K. Medler, M. Shahbandeh, C. R. Burns, E. Baron, and 37 co-authors
• Classification: astro-ph.SR (Stellar and Stellar Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (Submitted to ApJL)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09600

Abstract

This paper presents James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) NIRSpec observations of SN 2024ggi in the 1.7–5.5 μm wavelength range at +285.51 and +385.27 days post-explosion. Late-time nebular spectra are dominated by emission lines from various ionization states of H, Ca, Ar, C, Mg, Ni, Co, and Fe. The research team also detected strong CO emission in both the first overtone and fundamental vibrational bands. Most atomic features exhibit asymmetric line profiles, indicating a non-spherical explosion. By combining observed fluxes with non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (non-LTE) radiative transfer simulations, a data-driven methodology was developed to parse the complex molecular emission region, constrain its 3D structure, and reproduce high-fidelity spectral profiles.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Questions

1. Dust Origin in the Early Universe: Supernovae are considered significant contributors to cosmic dust in the early universe, yet major uncertainties remain regarding the dust mass, composition, and grain size distribution produced by different supernova types.
2. Molecular Formation and Dust Precursors: Molecular formation is a precursor process to dust condensation, playing a crucial role in cooling expanding ejecta. These molecules not only provide nucleation sites for dust particles but also regulate the thermal evolution necessary for gas-to-dust conversion.
3. Observational Technical Limitations: Historically, obtaining multi-wavelength spectroscopy of molecular emission regions in hydrogen-rich core-collapse supernovae (SNe II)—particularly near-infrared and mid-infrared coverage from 2.5–25 μm—has been extremely challenging.

Research Significance

• Filling Observational Gaps: JWST provides unprecedented 0.4–25 μm panchromatic observational capability, enabling simultaneous observation of CO and SiO first overtone and fundamental vibrational bands
• Theoretical Validation: Provides critical observational constraints for molecular formation and dust evolution theoretical models
• Methodological Innovation: Develops new data-driven analysis methods to overcome limitations of traditional spherically symmetric models

Core Contributions

1. First Comprehensive Dual-Band CO Observations: Simultaneous JWST observations of complete CO first overtone (2.2–2.4 μm) and fundamental (4.5–5.17 μm) vibrational band spectra
2. Innovative Analysis Method: Development of MOFAT (Molecular Fitting Analysis Tool), employing a data-driven inverse modeling approach
3. 3D Structure Constraints: First observational constraints on the three-dimensional geometry of molecular formation regions in supernova ejecta
4. CO Evolution Tracking: Quantitative tracking of CO mass evolution from 8.7×10⁻³ M☉ to 1.3×10⁻³ M☉
5. Clumpy Structure Discovery: Discovery of density contrast evolution from fc ≈ 1.2 to 2, indicating evolution from approximate uniformity to highly clumped structure

Methodology Details

Observational Setup

JWST NIRSpec Observation Parameters:

• Observation Dates: January 22, 2025 (+285.64 days) and May 2, 2025 (+385.55 days)
• Grating/Filter Combinations: F170LP/G235M (1.66–3.07 μm) and F290LP/G395M (2.87–5.10 μm)
• Spectral Resolution: R ∼ 1000
• Slit: S400A1, employing 3-point nodding pattern

MOFAT Modeling Framework

Core Assumptions:

• Large-scale spherically symmetric geometry
• Uniform expansion envelope
• Radiative transfer including multi-dimensional clumpy structure effects

Seven-Parameter Optimization System:

1. CO Mass (Mass): Total CO mass
2. Inner Boundary Temperature (T₁): Temperature at inner edge of CO shell
3. Minimum Velocity (v₁): Velocity at inner boundary of CO region
4. Velocity Width (Δv): CO shell thickness
5. Density Distribution Index (n): ρ ∼ r⁻ⁿ
6. Relative Clump Size (r/R): Clump size to radius ratio
7. Density Enhancement Factor (fc): Density enhancement within clumps relative to surroundings

Technical Innovations:

• Non-LTE Radiative Transfer: HYDRA code employed for computing molecular opacity and vibrational bands
• Temperature Structure Iteration: Overtone used as inner boundary constraint, fundamental as outer boundary constraint
• Clumpy Geometry Modeling: Support for both oblate and prolate clump morphologies

Experimental Setup

Data Processing

• Standardized reduction using jwst pipeline version 1.18.0
• Outlier detection and scaling factors to reduce bad pixel noise
• Exposure times: 191.695 seconds at +285 days, 472.135 seconds at +385 days

Spectral Analysis

Emission Line Identification:

• Hydrogen Lines: Paα (1.875 μm), Brα (4.051 μm), Brγ (2.166 μm), etc.
• Metal Lines: Fe II, Ni II, Co II, Mg I, O I, etc.
• Molecular Features: CO first overtone and fundamental vibrational bands

Comparison Sample

Spectral comparison with SN 1987A and SN 2023ixf, the only other SNe II with spectral data in this wavelength range.

Experimental Results

Primary Observational Findings

Spectral Evolution Characteristics:

• Hydrogen emission line flux decline with relative enhancement of intermediate-mass and iron-peak element lines
• CO emission feature weakening with relative decay of first overtone high vibrational modes
• All isolated features display pronounced splitting structure, with Ni II 3.119 μm line splitting of 1000±150 km/s

CO Mass Evolution:

• +285 days: MCO ≈ 8.7×10⁻³ M☉
• +385 days: MCO ≈ 1.3×10⁻³ M☉
• Mass reduction factor ∼8, primarily dominated by CO evaporation

Modeling Results

Best-Fit Parameters (Prolate Model P):

Clumpy Structure Evolution:

• Early Phase (+285 days): Approximate uniform distribution (fc ≈ 1.2), both clumpy and non-clumpy models fit adequately
• Late Phase (+385 days): Pronounced clumpiness (fc ≈ 1.8), only clumpy model successfully fits fundamental band

Temperature Structure Constraints

• CO cooling-dominated temperature minimum: ∼2000 K at +285 days, below 2000 K at +385 days
• Temperature profile reveals complex thermal structure in CO region, with outer layers exposed to stronger radiation due to Doppler shift and geometric dilution

Related Work

Historical Observations

• CO First Overtone: Multiple studies detected in ground-based near-infrared observations (Spyromilio & Leibundgut 1996; Davis et al. 2019)
• CO Fundamental: Extremely rare detections outside SN 1987A, primarily limited by spectral coverage
• SiO Detection: Limited to few events observed with Spitzer Space Telescope

Theoretical Model Development

• Forward Modeling: Combining explosion models with molecular formation time evolution (Höflich 1988; Liu et al. 1992)
• Limitations: Spherically symmetric assumptions cannot explain observed complex profiles and flux ratio discrepancies

Innovations in This Work

Compared to traditional methods, the data-driven inverse modeling approach in this paper can:

• Directly constrain 3D structure
• Handle optical depth effects
• Resolve complex temperature distributions

Conclusions and Discussion

Primary Scientific Conclusions

1. CO Formation Timeline: Most CO formed before +285 days, with subsequent evolution dominated by CO dissociation
2. 3D Structure Evolution: Evolution from approximate uniformity to highly clumped structure
3. Non-Spherical Explosion: Spectral line splitting and asymmetric profiles confirm non-spherical explosion
4. Photosphere Location: Photosphere has entered Si-rich layer, but CO inner boundary remains well above photosphere

Predictions for SiO Formation

Based on temperature profiles and equilibrium abundance calculations:

• +285 days: MSiO ≈ 6.3×10⁻⁴ M☉
• +385 days: MSiO ≈ 1.5×10⁻³ M☉

Limitations

1. Insufficient Temporal Coverage: Lack of early observations post-plateau phase prevents study of CO formation process
2. Parameter Degeneracy: Potential degeneracies among certain parameter combinations
3. Model Assumptions: Large-scale spherically symmetric geometry assumption may be oversimplified

Future Directions

1. Early Observations: Observations immediately after SN II exits plateau phase
2. Long-Term Monitoring: Tracking SiO formation and dust formation triggering processes
3. Multi-Target Studies: Extension to larger SNe II samples to establish universal patterns
4. Multi-Dimensional Simulations: Development of forward models incorporating complex 3D structures

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Breakthrough: First utilization of JWST's full wavelength capability for simultaneous dual CO vibrational band observations, achieving unprecedented data quality
2. Methodological Innovation: MOFAT's data-driven inverse modeling approach represents major progress in molecular spectral analysis
3. Physical Insights: First observational constraints on 3D clumpy structure evolution in supernova ejecta
4. Quantitative Analysis: Precise measurements of critical physical parameters including CO mass, temperature, and velocity

Weaknesses

1. Sample Limitations: Based on single supernova with two observation epochs; generalizability requires verification
2. Theory Dependence: Physical interpretation of certain model parameters requires deeper theoretical work
3. Uncertainty Analysis: Insufficient sensitivity analysis regarding external parameter uncertainties such as distance

Impact

Contributions to the Field:

• Provides critical observational constraints for supernova molecular formation theory
• Advances JWST applications in supernova research
• Establishes foundation for future dust formation studies

Practical Value:

• MOFAT tool applicable to molecular emission analysis in other sources
• Provides methodological guidance for JWST supernova observation programs

Reproducibility:

• Detailed description of observational and analytical procedures
• Commitment to release MOFAT code upon dissertation completion

Applicable Scenarios

1. JWST Supernova Observations: Provides standard methodology for similar late-time supernova spectral analysis
2. Molecular Astrophysics: Extensible to other molecular-rich astronomical environments
3. Dust Formation Research: Provides tools for tracking molecular-to-dust evolution processes

References

The paper cites extensive relevant literature, including:

• Classical CO observation work (Wooden et al. 1993; Kotak et al. 2006)
• Theoretical modeling studies (Höflich 1988; Liu et al. 1992)
• Recent JWST observations (Shahbandeh et al. 2024; Medler et al. 2025b)
• Molecular formation theory (Liljegren et al. 2020; Sluder et al. 2018)

This research marks an important milestone in supernova molecular studies entering the JWST era, providing not only unprecedented observational data but, more importantly, developing new analytical methods to parse complex 3D structures, opening new pathways for understanding molecular formation and dust evolution processes in supernovae.