Fabrication, Characterization and Modeling of a High-Temperature Superconducting Double Racetrack Coil

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09640
• Title: Fabrication, Characterization and Modeling of a High-Temperature Superconducting Double Racetrack Coil
• Authors: Lauro Ferreira, Yasmine Baazizi, Simon Meunier, Tanguy Phulpin, Tian-Yong Gong, Loïc Quéval
• Classification: physics.acc-ph
• Conference: Symposium de Génie Électrique (SGE 2025), Toulouse, France, 1-3 July 2025
• Affiliated Institutions: Paris-Saclay University, Sorbonne University, CNRS, GeePs Laboratory
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09640

Abstract

This paper presents a comprehensive review of the fabrication, characterization, and modeling of high-temperature superconducting double racetrack coil (DRC). A DRC coil was fabricated using ReBCO superconducting tape with an internally developed winding system. The coil was first characterized under direct current conditions to obtain its IV characteristics and critical current, followed by measurements of AC losses under alternating current conditions (60 Hz and 120 Hz). These experimental measurements were compared with a 3D finite element model, demonstrating reasonable agreement within the scope of modeling assumptions. The coil exhibited excellent performance with no degradation during the winding process, making it suitable for further investigation. This validates the effectiveness of the manufacturing process and superconducting coil characterization methodology.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. High-temperature superconducting coil geometry optimization: Superconducting materials are supplied in tape form, requiring the design of appropriate coil geometries to fully utilize their performance
2. Manufacturing process reliability: Superconducting tapes are susceptible to mechanical stress damage during winding, necessitating the development of precise manufacturing processes
3. Performance prediction and modeling: Accurate numerical models are needed to predict the electromagnetic performance of coils and guide design optimization

Significance

High-temperature superconducting (HTS) coils have important applications in several critical fields:

• Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage (SMES): Providing efficient energy storage
• Motor Systems: Achieving high power density and efficiency
• Power Transformers: Reducing volume and losses

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Geometric constraints: Traditional single pancake and single racetrack structures require resistive connections, limiting conductor length
2. Connection complexity: Internal connections make series-parallel configurations of coils difficult
3. Modeling accuracy: Existing analytical models (such as Norris formula) cannot accurately predict the actual performance of complex geometries

Research Motivation

Development of double racetrack coil (DRC) to overcome the above limitations: no resistive connections required, external connections facilitate integration, and can accommodate longer conductor lengths.

Core Contributions

1. Developed a dedicated winding system: Designed and manufactured a winding machine capable of precise control over the winding process and minimizing mechanical stress
2. Fabricated high-performance DRC coil: Successfully wound a double racetrack coil with 20 turns (10 turns per layer), 12 meters of ReBCO tape, with no performance degradation
3. Established comprehensive characterization methodology: Including an integrated characterization platform with DC IV characteristic measurements and AC loss measurements
4. Constructed 3D finite element model: Implemented a numerical model using COMSOL that accurately predicts critical current
5. Validated manufacturing process: Through comparison of experimental and simulation results, demonstrated the reliability of the manufacturing process

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Design, fabricate, and characterize a double racetrack high-temperature superconducting coil, including:

• Inputs: ReBCO superconducting tape, G-10 support structure, design parameters
• Outputs: Functional superconducting coil with known electromagnetic performance
• Constraints: Maintain superconducting performance, avoid mechanical damage, satisfy geometric requirements

Manufacturing Process

Winding System Design

• Precise Control: Manual precise control over the winding process
• Stress Minimization: Special design to reduce mechanical stress on superconducting tape
• Multi-geometry Compatibility: Support for multiple geometric structures including single/double pancake/racetrack

Coil Specification Parameters

Characterization Methods

Direct Current Characteristic Measurement

• Equipment: Gargantua high-current platform (maximum 4800 A, 10 V DC)
• Cooling: 77 K liquid nitrogen bath cooling
• Measurement: Step current excitation, nanovoltmeter voltage measurement
• Standard: 1 μV/cm critical current criterion

AC Loss Measurement

• Equipment: PAChinko platform, including function generator, power amplifier, step-down transformer, and lock-in detection
• Frequency: 60 Hz and 120 Hz (avoiding 50 Hz power line interference)
• Method: Electrical measurement technique

Numerical Modeling

Model Architecture

• Software: COMSOL Multiphysics PDE module
• Method: 3D finite element method
• Formulation: H-formulation homogenization method
• Symmetry: Utilizes quarter-symmetry to reduce computational load

Key Parameters

• Critical Current Density: Considering local magnetic field dependence
• Material Properties: Corrected based on literature database 14
• Boundary Conditions: Symmetric boundaries and insulating boundaries

Experimental Setup

Test Samples

1. Reference Sample: 10 cm short tape sample for baseline measurement
2. DRC Coil: Complete double racetrack coil with voltage leads located 1 cm from the connector

Measurement Conditions

• Temperature: 77 K liquid nitrogen temperature
• Environment: Self-field conditions (no external magnetic field)
• Current Range: DC 0-200 A, AC peak 0-100 A

Evaluation Metrics

• Critical Current: Based on 1 μV/cm criterion
• n-value: Power law exponent characterizing the sharpness of superconducting transition
• AC Loss: Power loss per unit length (W/m)

Experimental Results

Main Results

Direct Current Characteristic Comparison

AC Loss Measurement

• Frequency Dependence: Loss increases linearly with frequency, consistent with theoretical expectations
• Current Dependence: Linear relationship in logarithmic coordinates
• Numerical Range: Approximately 10^-4 to 10^-2 W/m at 60 Hz

Simulation Verification

IV Characteristic Prediction

• Consistency: Simulated and experimental IV curves show excellent agreement
• Critical Current: Simulation accurately predicts approximately 30% critical current reduction
• Physical Mechanism: Confirms that the reduction is primarily caused by the coil's own magnetic field rather than mechanical damage

AC Loss Prediction

• Qualitative Consistency: Simulation captures the frequency and current dependence of losses
• Quantitative Differences: Some numerical discrepancies exist, primarily due to:
  • Simplified material properties (not accounting for critical current non-uniformity)
  • Neglected thermal effects (local temperature rise)
  • Mesh density and solver parameter effects

Theoretical Comparison Analysis

• Norris Formula: Analytical formula shows significant discrepancy with experimental results
• Reason for Discrepancy: Norris model assumes isolated infinite-length conductors, neglecting:
  • Coil bending effects
  • Inter-turn magnetic field coupling
  • Geometric boundary effects

Related Work

Superconducting Coil Geometric Structures

The field primarily focuses on four basic geometries:

1. Single Pancake: Simple but requires connections
2. Double Pancake: No connections but limited applications
3. Single Racetrack: Suitable for long straight segment applications
4. Double Racetrack: Focus of this paper, combining multiple advantages

Manufacturing Technology Development

• Stress Control: Mechanical stress is the primary factor causing superconducting performance degradation
• Winding Precision: High-precision winding is critical for maintaining performance
• Quality Control: Real-time monitoring and control systems are necessary

Numerical Modeling Methods

• H-formulation: Suitable for large-scale superconductor modeling
• T-A formulation: Another commonly used method
• Homogenization Technique: Effective method for handling multi-turn coils

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Fabrication: Successfully fabricated a high-performance DRC coil, validating the manufacturing process
2. Performance Retention: The coil's critical current is 166 A, retaining 72.8% compared to the tape, primarily due to magnetic field effects
3. Effective Modeling: The 3D finite element model accurately predicts critical current and reasonably predicts AC loss trends
4. Process Validation: The winding process caused no superconducting performance degradation, demonstrating process reliability

Limitations

1. Voltage Measurement Location: Voltage leads near the connector may affect critical current measurement accuracy
2. Modeling Simplifications: Material non-uniformity and thermal effects not considered
3. Frequency Limitation: Only two frequency points (60 Hz and 120 Hz) tested
4. Single Temperature: Testing only conducted at 77 K

Future Directions

1. Optimize Measurement Methods: Improve voltage lead placement to enhance measurement accuracy
2. Extend Modeling: Include thermal effects and material non-uniformity
3. Application Integration: Integrate DRC coil into practical superconducting transformers
4. Performance Optimization: Further reduce AC losses and improve efficiency

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Systematic Approach: Forms a complete system from fabrication to characterization to modeling
2. Engineering Practicality: Developed winding system and characterization methods have practical application value
3. Sufficient Verification: Manufacturing process reliability verified through multiple methods
4. Advanced Modeling: 3D finite element modeling considers complex electromagnetic coupling effects
5. Detailed Data: Provides detailed material parameters and measurement data

Weaknesses

1. Limited Theoretical Depth: Lacks in-depth theoretical analysis of physical mechanisms
2. Limited Parameter Study: Lacks systematic investigation of geometric parameter effects on performance
3. Limited Temperature Range: Restricted to 77 K, unexplored wider temperature range
4. Long-term Stability: No evaluation of coil long-term operational stability
5. Cost Analysis: Lacks manufacturing cost and economic feasibility analysis

Impact

1. Technical Contribution: Provides reliable manufacturing process methods for superconducting coils
2. Engineering Value: Developed equipment and methods can be promoted to other research institutions
3. Application Prospects: Lays foundation for industrialization of superconducting power equipment
4. Academic Significance: Provides experimental and theoretical basis for superconducting coil design optimization

Applicable Scenarios

1. Power Equipment: Superconducting transformers, motors, fault current limiters, etc.
2. Energy Storage Systems: Superconducting magnetic energy storage (SMES) systems
3. Research Equipment: High-field magnets, particle accelerator magnets
4. Transportation: Maglev train traction transformers

References

The paper cites 15 important references covering:

• Superconducting coil applications (SMES, motors, transformers)
• Manufacturing techniques and testing methods
• Numerical modeling and simulation techniques
• Material databases and theoretical models

These references provide solid theoretical foundation and technical support for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality engineering and technical paper that systematically addresses the fabrication, characterization, and modeling of high-temperature superconducting double racetrack coils. The research is rigorous, the methodology is scientific, the results are reliable, and it has significant value in promoting the engineering applications of superconducting technology.