Continuous Inverse Ambiguous Functions on Lie Groups

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.09958
• Title: Continuous Inverse Ambiguous Functions on Lie Groups
• Authors: David Schmitz, Sadman Rahman, Anthony Kindness
• Classification: math.GR (Group Theory), math.GT (Geometric Topology)
• Publication Date: October 11, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.09958

Abstract

This paper investigates the existence of continuous inverse ambiguous functions on Lie groups. An inverse ambiguous function is defined as a bijection f : G → G on a group G satisfying the functional equation f^(-1)(x) = f(x^(-1)) for all x ∈ G. The authors systematically study the existence of such functions on various classical Lie groups, including tori, elliptic curves over various fields, vector spaces, additive matrix groups, and multiplicative matrix groups.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Inverse ambiguous functions represent a relatively recent concept in group theory that connects the inverse of a function with the inverse of group elements. For a bijection f on a group G, it is called an inverse ambiguous function if it satisfies f^(-1)(x) = f(x^(-1)). This is equivalent to the condition f(f(x)) = x^(-1).

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Value: Inverse ambiguous functions generate 4-order cyclic subgroups in the homeomorphism group of topological groups, and can be viewed as "square roots of the inverse map"
2. Geometric Significance: For topological groups, continuous inverse ambiguous functions must be homeomorphisms, connecting group structure with topological structure
3. Classification Problem: Determining which Lie groups admit continuous inverse ambiguous functions is a natural classification problem

Existing Research Foundation

• Schmitz's 2017 work studied inverse ambiguous functions on additive and multiplicative groups of fields
• For finite groups, complete existence characterization exists: inverse ambiguous functions exist if and only if the number of non-self-inverse elements is divisible by 4
• This paper extends the research to the continuous case and Lie groups

Core Contributions

1. Complete Classification of Tori: Proves that continuous inverse ambiguous functions exist on the n-dimensional torus T^n if and only if n is even
2. Systematic Study of Elliptic Curves:
   • Elliptic curves over the complex numbers always admit inverse ambiguous functions
   • Over the real numbers, existence is determined by the sign of the discriminant
   • Over finite fields, specific existence criteria are provided
3. Dimension Characterization of Vector Spaces: An n-dimensional real vector space admits continuous inverse ambiguous functions if and only if n is even
4. Partial Results on Matrix Groups: Provides existence or non-existence proofs for several important matrix Lie groups

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Given a Lie group G, determine whether there exists a continuous bijection f : G → G such that f(f(x)) = x^(-1) for all x ∈ G.

Main Technical Methods

1. Fundamental Group Method

For path-connected spaces, utilizing the functorial properties of the fundamental group:

• A continuous inverse ambiguous function f induces an automorphism f_* on the fundamental group
• Must satisfy f_* ∘ f_* = ι_, where ι_ is the automorphism induced by the inverse map
• Determine existence by analyzing the automorphism group of the fundamental group

Key Lemma: No continuous inverse ambiguous function exists on the circle group S^1, because the automorphism group of Z contains no element whose square equals -id.

2. Orientation Analysis Method

Utilizing the concept of orientation from differential topology:

• Orientation properties of the inverse map ι: det(dι|_) = (-1)^{n^2}
• The composition f∘f of a continuous inverse ambiguous function f must preserve orientation
• Contradiction arises when ι reverses orientation while f∘f preserves it

3. Direct Product Construction Method

Constructive Proof: For even-dimensional cases, explicit construction is provided:

f: (z₁,w₁; z₂,w₂; ...; zₙ,wₙ) ↦ (w₁,z₁⁻¹; w₂,z₂⁻¹; ...; wₙ,zₙ⁻¹)

4. Connected Component Exchange Method

For groups with two connected components, functions can be defined that exchange between different components.

Technical Innovations

1. Unified Theoretical Framework: Combines algebraic methods (fundamental groups) with geometric methods (orientation)
2. Deep Connection of Dimension Parity: Reveals the essential relationship between the existence of inverse ambiguous functions and the parity of space dimension
3. Concrete Construction Methods: For cases where existence holds, explicit function constructions are provided

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

This is pure theoretical mathematics research, with main objects of study including:

1. Tori: T^n = (S^1)^n
2. Elliptic Curves: Elliptic curves over the complex numbers C, real numbers R, and finite fields F_q
3. Vector Spaces: R^n, C^n, F_q^n
4. Matrix Groups: GL_n(R), SL_n(R), O(n), SO(n)
5. Spheres: S^n (as topological spaces)

Analysis Methods

• Fundamental group computation and homotopy theory
• Orientation theory in differential topology
• Lie group theory
• Algebraic geometry (elliptic curve theory)

Experimental Results

Main Results

Complete Classification of Tori

Theorem 2.2: When n is odd, no continuous inverse ambiguous function exists on T^n Theorem 2.4: When n is even, continuous inverse ambiguous functions exist on T^n

Proof Strategy:

• Odd case: π₁(T^n) ≅ Z^n, requiring the existence of a matrix A ∈ GL_n(Z) such that A² = -I_n, but det(A)² = (-1)^n = -1 has no solution
• Even case: Explicit construction f(z,w) = (w, z^(-1))

Systematic Results on Elliptic Curves

1. Complex Elliptic Curves (Theorem 3.1): All complex elliptic curves admit continuous inverse ambiguous functions
2. Real Elliptic Curves (Theorem 3.2):
   • Exist when Δ_E > 0 (E(R) ≅ S^1 × Z₂)
   • Do not exist when Δ_E < 0 (E(R) ≅ S^1)
3. Finite Field Elliptic Curves: Inverse ambiguous functions exist when the Weierstrass equation y² = x³ + ax + b has 3 distinct roots in F_q

Dimension Characterization of Vector Spaces

Theorem 4.3: An n-dimensional real vector space admits continuous inverse ambiguous functions if and only if n is even

Corollaries:

• M_n(R) admits continuous inverse ambiguous functions if and only if n is even
• The space of n×n real matrices with trace zero admits continuous inverse ambiguous functions if and only if n is odd

Partial Results on Matrix Groups

1. Orthogonal Groups: O(2) and SO(2) do not admit continuous inverse ambiguous functions
2. Special Linear Groups: SL_n(R) does not admit continuous inverse ambiguous functions when n is even
3. Special Orthogonal Groups: SO(n) does not admit continuous inverse ambiguous functions when n ≡ 2,3 (mod 4)

Counterexample Construction for Spheres

Theorem 4.8: There exists a homeomorphism f : S^n → S^n satisfying f(f(z)) = -z if and only if n is odd

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Schmitz (2017): First defined inverse ambiguous functions, studied the case over fields
2. Schmitz & Gallagher (2018): Extended to finite non-abelian groups
3. This Paper: First systematic study of the continuous case on Lie groups

Related Concepts

• Involutions: The study of f² = id has a rich history
• Anti-involutions: f² = -id is systematically studied for the first time in this paper
• Group Automorphisms: Related to properties of elements in Homeo(G)

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Dimension Parity Regularity: For many classical Lie groups, the existence of inverse ambiguous functions is closely related to the parity of some characteristic dimension of the group
2. Topological Obstructions: Fundamental group and orientation theory provide effective tools for proving non-existence
3. Construction Methods: For cases where existence holds, explicit constructions can usually be provided

Limitations

1. Unresolved Cases:
   • GL_n⁺(R) (n even)
   • SL_n(R) (n odd)
   • SO(n) (n ≡ 0,1 mod 4)
   • GL_n(C) (n > 1)
2. Method Limitations: Current orientation methods fail in certain cases
3. Disconnected Groups: Analysis becomes more complex for groups with multiple connected components

Future Directions

1. Algebraic K-theory Methods: May require deeper algebraic topology tools
2. Lie Algebra Methods: Analyze the problem from an infinitesimal perspective
3. Computational Verification: Perform concrete calculations for low-dimensional cases
4. Generalization to Other Group Classes: Such as p-adic Lie groups, algebraic groups, etc.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

Mathematical Rigor

1. Complete Proofs: Every result has rigorous mathematical proofs
2. Multiple Methods: Cleverly combines algebraic topology, differential geometry, and group theory methods
3. Systematicity: Systematically studies multiple important classes of Lie groups

Technical Innovation

1. New Research Perspective: Connects functional equations with topological properties
2. Unified Theory: Reveals the unified structure underlying seemingly different problems
3. Explicit Constructions: Not only proves existence but also provides explicit constructions

Depth of Results

1. Complete Classification: Provides complete existence characterization for tori
2. Geometric Insights: Reveals the geometric essence of dimension parity
3. Wide Applicability: Results apply to multiple important geometric objects

Weaknesses

Technical Limitations

1. Incomplete Classification: Problems for certain important matrix groups remain unresolved
2. Method Limitations: Orientation methods fail in certain cases
3. Computational Complexity: Lacks effective computational methods for high-dimensional cases

Application Value

1. Pure Theory: Currently mainly of theoretical interest with unclear practical applications
2. Specificity: The concept of inverse ambiguous functions is relatively specialized with limited generalizability

Impact

Academic Contribution

1. Pioneering Work: First systematic study of such problems on Lie groups
2. Methodological Contribution: Demonstrates how to combine different mathematical branches to solve problems
3. Theoretical Completion: Establishes topological foundations for inverse ambiguous function theory

Potential Applications

1. Group Action Theory: May be useful in studying symmetry properties of group actions
2. Dynamical Systems: Study of maps with special periodicity properties
3. Algebraic Topology: Provides new perspectives for studying automorphism groups of topological groups

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Mathematics Research: Suitable for researchers in group theory and topology
2. Teaching Purposes: Can serve as an excellent example of connections between different mathematical branches
3. Further Research: Provides foundation for in-depth investigation of related problems

References

The paper cites the following important literature:

1. Hatcher, A.: Algebraic Topology - Provides foundations in fundamental groups and homotopy theory
2. Schmitz, D.: Inverse ambiguous functions on fields (2017) - Establishes foundational theory
3. Silverman, J. H.: The Arithmetic of Elliptic Curves - Provides elliptic curve theory foundations
4. Lee, J. M.: Introduction to Smooth Manifolds - Supports differential geometry theory

This paper plays a connecting role in the development of inverse ambiguous function theory, extending research from finite groups and fields to systematic study of Lie groups, establishing important theoretical foundations. Although some problems remain unresolved, it provides clear directions for subsequent research.