Observational entropy of quantum correlations and entanglement

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10058
• Title: Observational entropy of quantum correlations and entanglement
• Authors: Leonardo Rossetti, Stefano Mancini, Andreas Winter, Joseph Schindler
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 11, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10058

Abstract

This paper connects physical entropy and information-theoretic entropy through coarse graining methods, characterizing the entropy of observers relative to measurements via a precise formulation of "observational entropy." The study considers observers with various locality constraints, including local operations (LO), measurements based on local operations and classical communication (LOCC), and separable measurements (SEP). The core idea is that the "entropy gap" between the minimal local measurement observational entropy and the von Neumann entropy can quantify quantum correlations in a given state.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Theoretical Foundation of Observational Entropy: Observational entropy, originally proposed by von Neumann as an entropy concept more suitable for thermodynamic environments than von Neumann entropy, has demonstrated significant value in recent studies of quantum non-equilibrium thermodynamics.
2. Quantification Needs for Quantum Correlations: In many-body quantum systems, accurately quantifying different types of quantum correlations (entanglement, quantum discord, etc.) has been a central problem in quantum information theory.
3. Practical Significance of Locality Constraints: In actual experiments, observers typically can only perform local measurements. How such constraints affect information extraction from quantum states is an important practical question.

Research Motivation

• Establish precise connections between observational entropy and quantum correlation measures
• Understand how different measurement categories affect information extraction capabilities
• Provide new analytical tools for quantum thermodynamics and quantum information processing

Core Contributions

1. Established a general theoretical framework for entropy gaps: Defined entropy gap E_χ(ρ) for arbitrary measurement categories χ and derived its fundamental properties.
2. Proved the separable measurement theorem: For any separable measurement M, the observational entropy S_M(ρ) is lower bounded by the marginal von Neumann entropy max{S(ρ_A), S(ρ_B)}.
3. Established connections with known entanglement measures:
   • For bipartite pure states, all local entropy gaps equal the entanglement entropy
   • For general many-body states, entropy gaps are lower bounded by relative entanglement entropy
4. Proved strict separation of different measurement categories: Through concrete counterexamples demonstrated E_LO* ≠ E_LO ≠ E_LOCC ≠ E_SEP.
5. Provided new analytical tools for many-body quantum correlations: Applicable to analyzing genuineness and robustness of many-body entanglement.

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The research objective is to quantify correlations in quantum states through observational entropy, specifically defined as:

• Input: Quantum state ρ and measurement category χ
• Output: Entropy gap E_χ(ρ) = S_χ(ρ) - S(ρ)
• Constraints: Measurement categories subject to locality restrictions

Core Concepts

Observational Entropy Definition

For quantum state ρ and POVM M = (M_i)_i:

S_M(ρ) = -∑_i p_i log(p_i/V_i)

where p_i = Tr(ρM_i) is the measurement probability and V_i = TrM_i is the "macroscopic state volume."

Entropy Gap Definition

S_χ(ρ) = inf{M∈χ} S_M(ρ)
E_χ(ρ) = S_χ(ρ) - S(ρ)

Main Measurement Categories

1. LO*: Local projective measurements Π_A ⊗ Π_B
2. LO: Local POVM measurements M_A ⊗ M_B
3. LOCC: Local operations plus classical communication
4. SEP: Separable measurements with elements of the form ∑_k A_ik ⊗ B_ik
5. PPT/RCT: Positive partial transpose/reduced criterion categories

Technical Innovations

Separable Measurement Theorem

Theorem 18: For any separable measurement M ∈ SEP:

S_M(ρ) ≥ max{S(ρ_A), S(ρ_B)}

Proof Strategy: Utilizes operator monotonicity and Jensen's inequality, combined with properties of the reduced criterion.

Optimal Measurement Characterization

Lemma 4: Measurement M is optimal if and only if each POVM element is completely supported on some eigenspace of ρ.

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

1. Werner states: ρ_λ = (1-λ)ρ_+ + λρ_-, where ρ_± are normalized symmetric/antisymmetric projections
2. W states: |W_n⟩ = √(1/n)(|10...0⟩ + ... + |00...1⟩)
3. Classical-quantum states: ρ = ∑_k λ_k|k⟩⟨k| ⊗ ρ_k
4. Four-body entangled states: GHZ states, W states, two-Bell pair states

Evaluation Methods

• Analytical calculations (Werner states, CQ states)
• Numerical optimization (W states for LO/LO* cases)
• Semidefinite programming (PPT categories)

Comparative Analysis

Separates the capabilities of different measurement categories through concrete examples, such as using classical-quantum trine states to demonstrate E_LO ≠ E_LO*.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Complete Analytical Solution for Werner States

For Werner state ρ_λ, all PPT ⊃ χ ⊃ LO* categories have the same entropy gap:

E_χ(ρ_λ) = S_M0(ρ_λ) - S(ρ_λ)

where M_0 is the projective measurement onto diagonal/off-diagonal subspaces.

Universal Results for Bipartite Pure States

Theorem 20: For bipartite pure states |ψ_AB⟩, all local entropy gaps equal the entanglement entropy:

E_χ(ψ_AB) = S(ρ_A) = S(ρ_B)

Genuineness Analysis for Many-Body States

Analysis of 4-body states (GHZ, W, 2-Bell) reveals:

• W states possess the strongest genuine many-body correlations
• W states are most robust to subsystem loss
• Entropy gaps under different partitions can be quantitatively compared

Separation Results

1. LO vs LO*: Classical-quantum trine state, E_LO ≈ 0.415 < E_LO* ≈ 0.541
2. LOCC vs SEP: Based on measurements in 49 that cannot be implemented via LOCC
3. SEP vs PPT: Constructed using inextensible product bases
4. PPT vs RCT: Werner states (d>2) provide separation

Important Findings

1. Eigenspace Separability: E_SEP(ρ) = 0 if and only if all eigenspace projections of ρ are separable
2. Monotonicity: S_χ is monotonically increasing under unital local compatible channels
3. Relative Entropy Bound: E_χ(ρ) ≥ Δ_χ(ρ) (relative χ-ness entropy)

Related Work

Observational Entropy Theory

• Foundational observational entropy theory established by Šafránek et al.
• Applications in quantum thermodynamics
• Connections with Petz recovery maps

Quantum Correlation Measures

• Quantum discord theory
• Relative entanglement entropy
• Separability criterion theory

Local Measurement Theory

• LOCC operation theory
• Properties of separable measurements
• Information processing under restricted measurements

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Observational entropy gaps provide new tools for quantifying quantum correlations
2. Different local measurement categories possess a strict hierarchical structure
3. Entropy gaps have profound connections with known entanglement measures but are not identical

Limitations

1. Entropy gaps are not entanglement monotones (separable states can have positive gaps)
2. Some cases have only numerical results lacking analytical expressions
3. Treatment of infinite-dimensional cases is incomplete

Future Directions

1. Search for entropy gaps as monotones in resource theories
2. Refine analytical theory for important examples like W states
3. Explore quantification of permutation invariance of genuineness
4. Extend to infinite-dimensional systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Establishes a complete theoretical framework from general measurement categories to specific local categories
2. Mathematical Rigor: All major results have rigorous mathematical proofs
3. Practical Value: Provides new analytical tools for quantum information processing and thermodynamics
4. Rich Examples: Verifies and elucidates theoretical results through multiple concrete examples

Weaknesses

1. Computational Complexity: Computing entropy gaps for general states remains difficult
2. Physical Interpretation: Physical significance of certain mathematical results (e.g., eigenspace separability) requires further clarification
3. Resource Theory: Whether entropy gaps are monotones within some resource theory framework remains unresolved

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new perspectives and tools for quantum correlation theory
2. Application Prospects: Potential applications in quantum thermodynamics, quantum computing, and related fields
3. Methodological Innovation: Deeply integrates observational entropy with quantum information theory

Applicable Scenarios

• Correlation analysis in quantum many-body systems
• Entropy production studies in quantum thermodynamic processes
• Quantum information processing under restricted measurement conditions
• Genuineness and robustness analysis of many-body entanglement

References

This paper cites 98 important references, covering:

• Foundational observational entropy theory 1-4
• Applications in quantum thermodynamics 8-26
• Quantum correlation measures 37-42
• Separability and LOCC theory 48-49, 67-68
• Quantum information theory fundamentals 50, 52

Summary: This is an important contribution to quantum information theory that provides new theoretical tools for quantifying quantum correlations through the observational entropy framework. The paper is theoretically rigorous and content-rich, offering profound insights into quantum information processing under locality constraints.