Equivalence criteria for the two-term functional equations for Herglotz-Zagier functions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10088
• Title: Equivalence criteria for the two-term functional equations for Herglotz-Zagier functions
• Authors: Sumukha Sathyanarayana, N. Guru Sharan
• Classification: math.NT (Number Theory)
• Publication Date: October 11, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10088v1

Abstract

This paper establishes Kronecker limit-type formulas for the generalized Mordell-Tornheim zeta function $\Theta(r,r,t,x)$ near the third parameter $t=1-r$. Subsequently, it is proven that this Kronecker limit-type formula is equivalent to the two-term functional equations of higher-order Herglotz functions obtained by Vlasenko and Zagier. The paper further demonstrates the equivalence between the previously known Kronecker limit-type formula for $\Theta(1,1,t,x)$ near $t=0$ and the two-term functional equation of the Herglotz-Zagier function obtained by Zagier. Through the theory of Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions, the authors obtain results of Ramanujan, Guinand, Zagier, and Vlasenko-Zagier as corollaries, further demonstrating that the Mordell-Tornheim zeta function occupies a central position in numerous modular form relations in the literature, thereby providing a method for understanding these relations within a unified framework.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem

The core problem addressed in this research is to establish the equivalence relationship between two-term functional equations of Herglotz-Zagier functions and Kronecker limit formulas of Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions.

2. Problem Significance

• Theoretical Unification: Modular form relations independently discovered by several renowned mathematicians (Ramanujan, Guinand, Zagier, etc.) can actually be understood in a unified manner within the framework of Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions
• Deep Connections: Reveals underlying mathematical connections between seemingly unrelated functional equations and limit formulas
• Methodological Innovation: Provides new perspectives and tools for studying similar functional equations

3. Limitations of Existing Methods

In traditional research, various modular form relations have been studied independently, lacking a unified theoretical framework to understand their intrinsic connections.

4. Research Motivation

Inspired by the important role of Kronecker limit formulas in number theory, the authors attempt to establish a unified theoretical framework through Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions.

Core Contributions

1. Establishment of New Kronecker Limit-Type Formulas: Expansion of the generalized Mordell-Tornheim zeta function $\Theta(r,r,t,x)$ near $t=1-r$
2. Proof of Equivalence Theorems: Establishment of equivalence relationships between Kronecker limit formulas and two-term functional equations of Herglotz-Zagier functions
3. Unified Theoretical Framework: Integration of classical results from Ramanujan, Guinand, Zagier, and Vlasenko-Zagier into a unified framework
4. Recurrence Relations: Establishment of recurrence formulas for generalized Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions
5. Methodological Contributions: Provision of new methods for studying modular form relations from the perspective of Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study of the generalized Mordell-Tornheim zeta function: $\Theta(r,s,t,x) := \sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\sum_{m=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n^r m^s (n+mx)^t}$ regarding its analytic continuation on the complex plane and asymptotic behavior near its singularities.

Core Mathematical Objects

1. Herglotz-Zagier Function

$F(x) := \sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\psi(nx) - \log(nx)}{n}$ where $\psi(x) = \Gamma'(x)/\Gamma(x)$ is the digamma function.

2. Higher-Order Herglotz Functions

$F_r(x) := \sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{\psi(nx)}{n^r}$

3. Properties of Generalized Mordell-Tornheim Zeta Functions

• Splitting Property: $\Theta(r,s,t,x) = \Theta(r-1,s,t+1,x) + x\Theta(r,s-1,t+1,x)$
• Inversion Property: $\Theta(r,s,t,x) = x^{-t}\Theta(s,r,t,1/x)$

Main Theorems

Theorem 1.1 (New Kronecker Limit-Type Formula)

For $x > 0$ and arbitrary $r \in \mathbb{N} \setminus \{1\}$, near $t = 1-r$: $\Theta(r,r,t,x) = \frac{\zeta(r)(1+x^{r-1})}{t-(1-r)} + x^{r-1}\zeta(r)(\gamma - \log(x)) + \gamma\zeta(r) + x^{r-1}\sum_{k=1}^{r-2}\binom{r-1}{k}\frac{1}{x^k}\zeta(r-k)\zeta(k+1) + O(|t-(1-r)|)$

Theorem 1.2 (Equivalence Theorem)

For any integer $r > 1$ and $x > 0$:

1. The two-term functional equation (1.3) of $F(x)$ is equivalent to the Kronecker limit formula (1.19) of $\Theta(1,1,t,x)$ near $t=0$
2. The two-term functional equation (1.7) of $F_r(x)$ is equivalent to the Kronecker limit formula (1.20) of $\Theta(r,r,t,x)$ near $t=1-r$

Technical Innovations

1. Establishment of Recurrence Relations

Through mathematical induction, the following is proven: $\Theta(r,s,t,x) = \sum_{\ell=0}^{n}\binom{n}{\ell}x^{\ell}\Theta(r-n+\ell,s-\ell,t+n,x)$

2. Integral Representation Methods

Utilization of the integral representation of the Gamma function: $\int_0^{\infty}y^{t-1}e^{-(x+n)y}dy = (x+n)^{-t}\Gamma(t)$ combined with asymptotic expansions of polylogarithm functions for analysis.

3. Analytic Continuation Techniques

Application of the Mellin-Barnes method to analytically continue the function to the entire complex plane and analysis of the singularity structure.

Experimental Setup

Mathematical Verification Methods

As a pure mathematical theoretical research, this paper primarily employs rigorous mathematical proofs to verify results:

1. Analytic Methods: Utilization of complex analysis, integral transforms, and other tools
2. Special Function Theory: Deep application of properties of Gamma functions, zeta functions, and polylogarithm functions
3. Asymptotic Analysis: Investigation of asymptotic behavior of functions near singularities

Verification Strategy

• Verification of new formulas through special cases of known results
• Consistency checking through function symmetries and recurrence relations
• Comparison with classical results in the literature

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Establishment of Unified Framework

Successful integration of the following classical results into a unified framework:

• Ramanujan's modular form relations (1.10)
• Guinand's functional equations (1.11) and (1.12)
• Zagier's two-term functional equation (1.3)
• Vlasenko-Zagier's higher-order functional equations (1.7)

2. Complete Proof of Equivalence

Establishment of complete equivalence between Kronecker limit formulas and two-term functional equations through bidirectional proofs.

3. New Recurrence Relations

Establishment of general recurrence formulas for generalized Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions, providing tools for further research.

Theoretical Findings

1. Confirmation of Central Position

Demonstration that the Mordell-Tornheim zeta function occupies a central position in various modular form relations.

2. Revelation of Deep Connections

Revelation of underlying mathematical connections between superficially unrelated functional equations.

3. Universality of Methods

Demonstration of the universality of studying modular form relations from the perspective of Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Kronecker Limit Formula: Established by Kronecker for imaginary quadratic fields, later generalized by Hecke, Herglotz, Zagier, and others
2. Herglotz-Zagier Function: First studied by Herglotz, with Zagier establishing important functional equations
3. Mordell-Tornheim Zeta Function: Studied by Matsumoto and others regarding its analytic properties
4. Higher-Order Generalizations: Studied by Vlasenko and Zagier for higher-order cases

Relationship of This Paper to Related Work

• Continuity: Built upon the foundation of work by Zagier, Vlasenko-Zagier, and others
• Innovation: First to establish equivalence relationships between different theories
• Unification: Provides a unified perspective for understanding various classical results

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully established equivalence relationships between two-term functional equations of Herglotz-Zagier functions and Kronecker limit formulas of Mordell-Tornheim zeta functions
2. Provided a unified theoretical framework for understanding classical modular form relations
3. Provided new methods and tools for further research on similar problems

Limitations

1. Scope of Application: Primarily targeted at specific types of zeta functions and related functional equations
2. Technical Requirements: Requires deep background in complex analysis and special function theory
3. Computational Complexity: Concrete calculations involve complex asymptotic analysis

Future Directions

1. Higher-Order Generalizations: Study of more general Kronecker limit formulas
2. Three-Term Functional Equations: Establishment of similar theory for three-term functional equations
3. Application Extensions: Application of theory to other types of L-functions and zeta functions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Establishment of profound mathematical connections with significant theoretical value
2. Methodological Innovation: Provision of new perspectives and methods for studying functional equations
3. Strong Unification: Successful unification of multiple seemingly independent classical results
4. Rigorous Proofs: Complete, rigorous mathematical proofs with clear logical structure
5. Clear Exposition: Well-organized paper structure with accurate mathematical exposition

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applications: As pure theoretical research, direct applications are relatively limited
2. High Technical Threshold: Requires substantial mathematical background for complete understanding
3. Computational Complexity: Practical calculations involve relatively complex asymptotic analysis

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new theoretical tools for number theory and special function theory
2. Methodological Contributions: Demonstrates effective methods for unifying different mathematical theories
3. Inspirational Significance: Provides ideas and methods for research on other similar problems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Mathematics Research: Particularly in number theory, complex analysis, and special function theory
2. Functional Equation Research: Provides new methods for studying various functional equations
3. Modular Form Theory: Provides unified framework for understanding modular form relations

References

The paper cites 20 important references, spanning from classical works of Kronecker and Ramanujan to modern research by Zagier, Vlasenko, and others, reflecting the historical development and current research status of the field.

Summary: This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that provides a unified theoretical framework for understanding classical modular form relations by establishing equivalence relationships between different mathematical theories. The main value of the paper lies in its theoretical depth and methodological innovation, providing important theoretical foundations and research tools for further research in related fields.