2025-11-10T02:53:47.003395

Multiple sign-changing solutions for semilinear subelliptic Dirichlet problem

Chen, Chen, Li et al.
We study the following perturbation from symmetry problem for the semilinear subelliptic equation \[ \left\{ \begin{array}{cc} -\triangle_{X} u=f(x,u)+g(x,u) & \mbox{in}~Ω, \\[2mm] u\in H_{X,0}^{1}(Ω),\hfill \end{array} \right. \] where $\triangle_{X}=-\sum_{i=1}^{m}X_{i}^{*}X_{i}$ is the self-adjoint sub-elliptic operator associated with Hörmander vector fields $X=(X_{1},X_{2},\ldots,X_{m})$, $Ω$ is an open bounded subset in $\mathbb{R}^n$, and $H_{X,0}^{1}(Ω)$ denotes the weighted Sobolev space. We establish multiplicity results for sign-changing solutions using a perturbation method alongside refined techniques for invariant sets. The pivotal aspect lies in the estimation of the lower bounds of min-max values associated with sign-changing critical points. In this paper, we construct two distinct lower bounds of these min-max values. The first one is derived from the lower bound of Dirichlet eigenvalues of $-\triangle_{X}$, while the second one is based on the Morse-type estimates and Cwikel-Lieb-Rozenblum type inequality in degenerate cases. These lower bounds provide different sufficient conditions for multiplicity results, each with unique advantages and are not mutually inclusive, particularly in the general non-equiregular case. This novel observation suggests that in some sense, the situation for sub-elliptic equations would have essential difference from the classical elliptic framework.
academic

Multiple sign-changing solutions for semilinear subelliptic Dirichlet problem

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2510.10120
  • Title: Multiple sign-changing solutions for semilinear subelliptic Dirichlet problem
  • Authors: Hua Chen (Wuhan University), Hong-Ge Chen (Institute of Precision Measurement Science and Technology Innovation, Chinese Academy of Sciences), Jin-Ning Li (Wuhan University), Xin Liao (Wuhan University)
  • Classification: math.AP (Mathematical Analysis)
  • Publication Date: October 11, 2025
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10120

Abstract

This paper investigates the symmetric perturbation problem for semilinear subelliptic Dirichlet equations:

\begin{array}{cc} -\triangle_{X} u=f(x,u)+g(x,u) & \text{in}~\Omega, \\ u\in H_{X,0}^{1}(\Omega), \end{array} \right.$$ where $\triangle_{X}=-\sum_{i=1}^{m}X_{i}^{*}X_{i}$ is the self-adjoint subelliptic operator associated with Hörmander vector fields $X=(X_{1},X_{2},\ldots,X_{m})$, $\Omega$ is a bounded open subset of $\mathbb{R}^n$, and $H_{X,0}^{1}(\Omega)$ denotes the weighted Sobolev space. The authors establish multiplicity results for sign-changing solutions using perturbation methods and refined techniques of invariant sets, with the key focus on estimating lower bounds of min-max values associated with sign-changing critical points. ## Research Background and Motivation 1. **Problem Significance**: Sign-changing solutions exhibit more complex qualitative properties compared to positive and negative solutions, such as the number and shape of nodal domains and the measure of nodal sets, thereby presenting interesting mathematical challenges. 2. **Limitations of Existing Research**: - Research on sign-changing solutions for classical elliptic equations has primarily focused on symmetric cases - Studies in non-symmetric cases are relatively sparse, particularly for subelliptic operators - Existing min-max value estimation methods encounter technical difficulties on non-equiregular sub-Riemannian manifolds 3. **Research Motivation**: - Extend the theory of sign-changing solutions for classical elliptic equations to the subelliptic setting - Address technical challenges arising from the degeneracy of Hörmander operators - Provide new sufficient conditions in non-equiregular cases ## Core Contributions 1. **Construction of a new intersection lemma**: Defines min-max values associated with sign-changing critical points for degenerate elliptic equations in the sign-changing setting 2. **Establishment of two distinct lower bound estimates**: - Estimates based on Dirichlet eigenvalue lower bounds - Estimates based on Morse-type estimates and Cwikel-Lieb-Rozenblum-type inequalities in the degenerate case 3. **Provision of two main theorems**: Presents different sufficient conditions for the existence of unbounded sequences of sign-changing solutions to problem (1.1) 4. **Revelation of essential differences between subelliptic and classical elliptic cases**: The two methods each have advantages in the general non-equiregular case and are mutually non-inclusive ## Detailed Methodology ### Problem Formulation Investigation of the existence and multiplicity of sign-changing weak solutions to the semilinear subelliptic Dirichlet problem (1.1), where: - $f$ satisfies conditions (f1)-(f5): odd symmetry, superlinear growth, etc. - $g$ satisfies conditions (g1)-(g3): perturbation terms that break symmetry - The goal is to find unbounded sequences of sign-changing solutions ### Methodological Framework #### 1. Perturbation Theory Framework Construction of the perturbed functional $J(u)$: $$J(u) = \frac{1}{2}\int_\Omega |Xu|^2dx - \int_\Omega F(x,u)dx - \theta(u)\int_\Omega G(x,u)dx$$ where $\theta(u)$ is a smooth cutoff function ensuring that $J$ and the original functional $E$ have the same critical points at high energy levels. #### 2. Technical Treatment of Sign-Changing Setting - Definition of cones $P^{\pm}_a = \{u \in H^1_{X,0}(\Omega) : \pm u \geq 0\}$ - Construction of sign-changing regions $S_a = H^1_{X,0}(\Omega) \setminus P_a$ - Establishment of invariance properties: $K_J(P^{\pm}_a) \subset P^{\pm}_{a/4}$ #### 3. Construction of Min-Max Values Definition of two classes of min-max values: **First Class** (based on eigenvalue method): $$b_k(J) = \inf_{\phi \in \Gamma_k} \sup_{\phi(N_k \cap B_{R_k}) \cap S_{a_k}} J(u)$$ **Second Class** (based on relative genus): $$d_{k,a}(I_p) = \inf\{c \geq 0 : \gamma(I^c_p \cup P_a; I^0_p \cup P_a, I^{-1}_p) \geq k\}$$ ### Technical Innovations 1. **New intersection lemma**: Overcomes the inapplicability of the Castro-Clapp method to Hörmander vector fields 2. **Dual lower bound estimates**: - Eigenvalue method yields condition (A1) - Morse index method yields condition (A2) 3. **Marino-Prodi perturbation technique**: Construction of finitely many non-degenerate sign-changing critical points 4. **Enhanced Morse index estimates**: Combination with degenerate Cwikel-Lieb-Rozenblum inequalities ## Experimental Setup ### Theoretical Verification Framework This is a pure theoretical study verified through the following approaches: 1. **Condition verification**: Examination of the reasonableness of assumptions (f1)-(f5) and (g1)-(g3) 2. **Special case analysis**: Reduction to classical cases when $X = (\partial_{x_1}, \ldots, \partial_{x_n})$ 3. **Concrete examples**: Martinet-type vector field example in Section 6 ### Comparative Analysis Comparison with classical results: - Schechter-Zou [36]: Condition $\frac{2p}{n(p-2)} - 1 > \frac{\mu}{\mu-\sigma-1}$ - Ramos-Tavares-Zou [34]: Condition $\frac{2p}{n(p-2)} > \frac{\mu}{\mu-\sigma-1}$ ## Main Results ### Theorem 1.1 (Eigenvalue Method) Under assumption (L), if $$(A1) \quad \frac{2p}{\vartheta(p-2)} - \frac{\tilde{\nu}}{\vartheta} > \frac{\mu}{\mu-\sigma-1}$$ then problem (1.1) admits an unbounded sequence of sign-changing weak solutions. ### Theorem 1.2 (Morse Index Method) If $$(A2) \quad \frac{2p}{\tilde{\nu}(p-2)} > \frac{\mu}{\mu-\sigma-1}$$ then problem (1.1) admits an unbounded sequence of sign-changing weak solutions. ### Key Estimates - **Lower bound estimate 1**: $b_k(J) \geq C\lambda_k^{\frac{2(2^*_{\tilde{\nu}}-p)}{(p-2)(2^*_{\tilde{\nu}}-2)}}$ - **Lower bound estimate 2**: $b_k(J) \geq C(k-3)^{\frac{2p}{\tilde{\nu}(p-2)}}$ ### Important Findings Through the example in Section 6, it is demonstrated that there exist parameters for which condition (A1) holds but (A2) does not, and vice versa. This indicates that in the subelliptic case, the two methods each have advantages and are mutually non-inclusive. ## Related Work ### Classical Elliptic Case - Bahri's series of works [2-5]: Established foundational theory for perturbed symmetric problems - Rabinowitz [32,33]: Developed min-max methods - Bartsch-Liu-Weth [6]: Existence of sign-changing solutions ### Subelliptic Equations - Jerison-Lee [23], Garofalo-Lanconelli [20]: Early research on subelliptic equations - Chen-Chen-Yuan [15]: Multiplicity results for general Hörmander operators - Luyen-Tri [30]: Specific Grushin-type operators ### Advantages of This Work Compared to existing work, this paper: 1. Addresses the general non-equiregular case 2. Provides two distinct sufficient conditions 3. Reveals essential differences between subelliptic and classical elliptic cases ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. Successfully extends the theory of sign-changing solutions for classical elliptic equations to the subelliptic setting 2. Establishes two distinct methods for estimating lower bounds of min-max values 3. Demonstrates that in the non-equiregular case, the two methods each have advantages ### Limitations 1. Requires assumption (L) regarding lower bounds of Dirichlet eigenvalues 2. Growth of perturbation term $g$ is restricted 3. Theoretical results lacking numerical verification ### Future Directions 1. Seek more general eigenvalue lower bound estimates 2. Study results under more general growth conditions 3. Develop numerical methods to verify theoretical predictions 4. Extend to other types of subelliptic operators ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Innovation**: First systematic study of sign-changing solutions for general Hörmander operators 2. **Technical Depth**: Skillfully combines variational methods, critical point theory, and subelliptic analysis 3. **Completeness**: Forms a complete research system from theoretical establishment to concrete examples 4. **Deep Insights**: Reveals essential differences between subelliptic and classical elliptic cases ### Weaknesses 1. **Restrictive Assumptions**: Condition (L) may limit the applicability of results 2. **Technical Complexity**: The proof process is quite technical with a high threshold for understanding 3. **Lack of Numerics**: Pure theoretical study lacking computational verification ### Impact 1. **Academic Value**: Lays foundation for the theory of sign-changing solutions for subelliptic equations 2. **Methodological Contribution**: Techniques provided may apply to other related problems 3. **Theoretical Completeness**: Fills an important gap in the field ### Applicable Scenarios 1. Nonlinear analysis in sub-Riemannian geometry 2. Theory of degenerate elliptic equations 3. Application of variational methods in degenerate cases 4. Extensions of critical point theory ## References The article cites 48 related references, primarily including: - Classical critical point theory literature (Rabinowitz, Struwe, etc.) - Foundations of subelliptic analysis (Hörmander, Jerison-Lee, etc.) - Research on sign-changing solutions (Bartsch-Liu-Weth, etc.) - Authors' previous work (Chen-Chen series) --- This is a high-quality theoretical mathematics paper that makes significant contributions to the theory of sign-changing solutions for subelliptic equations. It exhibits high technical content, novel results, and establishes a solid foundation for further development in this field.