Speed of sound peak in two-color dense QCD: confronting effective models with lattice data

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10198
• Title: Speed of sound peak in two-color dense QCD: confronting effective models with lattice data
• Authors: Arthur E.B. Pasqualotto, Dyana C. Duarte, Ricardo L. S. Farias, Rudnei O. Ramos
• Classification: hep-ph hep-lat hep-th nucl-th
• Publication Date: October 11, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10198

Abstract

Lattice simulations reveal a unique peak structure in the speed of sound for two-color, two-flavor quantum chromodynamics (QCD) at finite quark chemical potential. Although chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) and the Nambu-Jona-Lasinio (NJL) model have been employed to explain this phenomenon, neither approach fully captures the observed behavior. To address this discrepancy, this work extends the NJL framework by introducing a medium separation scheme (MSS). This method separates medium contributions from divergent integrals, enabling more accurate treatment of finite density effects. Results demonstrate that the diquark gap (Δ) increases substantially with chemical potential, consistent with high-density perturbative QCD predictions. Furthermore, the MSS-corrected NJL model successfully reproduces the observed speed of sound peak.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Issue: Theoretical explanation of the speed of sound peak structure in two-color QCD. Lattice QCD simulations at finite quark chemical potential have revealed a unique peak structure in the speed of sound, yet existing theoretical models cannot fully reproduce this phenomenon.
2. Significance:
   • Speed of sound behavior is crucial for understanding the QCD equation of state
   • Related to neutron star internal structure and multi-messenger astrophysical observations
   • The speed of sound peak is connected to observational data from massive neutron stars
3. Limitations of Existing Approaches:
   • Chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) fails at high density regions
   • Traditional NJL model regularization scheme (TRS) mixes vacuum and medium effects
   • Perturbative QCD is applicable only at extremely high densities
4. Research Motivation:
   • Two-color QCD lacks the sign problem, enabling direct comparison with first-principles lattice calculations
   • Need for an effective model accurately describing finite density effects
   • Separation of vacuum and medium contributions for physically reliable predictions

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of Medium Separation Scheme (MSS): Application of MSS to the two-color NJL model, effectively separating vacuum divergences and medium contributions
2. Reproduction of Speed of Sound Peak: MSS-corrected NJL model successfully reproduces the speed of sound peak observed in lattice QCD
3. Physically Consistent Predictions: Diquark gap increases monotonically with chemical potential, consistent with high-density perturbative QCD predictions
4. Quantitative Verification: Comparison of thermodynamic quantities with lattice QCD data validates the method's effectiveness
5. Theoretical Insights: Provides analytical expressions explaining the physical mechanism of the speed of sound peak

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of thermodynamic properties of two-color, two-flavor QCD at zero temperature and finite density, particularly speed of sound behavior. Input: baryon chemical potential μB; Output: various thermodynamic quantities (pressure, energy density, speed of sound, etc.).

Model Architecture

Two-Color NJL Model

Lagrangian density:

L = q̄(iγμ∂μ - m)ψ + Gs[(q̄ψ)² + (q̄iγ5τ⃗ψ)²] + Gd(q̄iγ5τ2t2Cq̄ᵀ)(ψᵀCiγ5τ2t2ψ)

where Gs = Gd = G is determined by Fierz transformation.

Thermodynamic Potential

Zero-temperature thermodynamic potential:

ΩT=0 = Ω0 + (M-m)² + Δ²/4G - NcNf Σs=±1 ∫d³p/(2π)³ EsΔ

Modified dispersion relation:

EsΔ = √[(√(p² + M²) + sμB/2)² + Δ²]

Technical Innovations

Medium Separation Scheme (MSS)

1. Basic Concept: Complete separation of medium contributions in divergent momentum integrals, with the cutoff parameter Λ regularizing only the vacuum divergent part.
2. Mathematical Implementation: Through repeated application of the identity:

1/(p₄² + (E + sμ̄)² + Δ²) = 1/(p₄² + p² + M₀²) - (μ² + 2sEμ + Δ² + M² - M₀²)/[(p₄² + p² + M₀²)(p₄² + (E + sμ̄)² + Δ²)]

3. Advantages:
   • Avoids mixing of vacuum and medium effects in traditional regularization
   • Eliminates non-physical cutoff dependence
   • Ensures correct behavior in the high-density limit

Gap Equation

Gap equation within the MSS framework:

IMSS_Δ = 2Iquad(M₀) - (Δ² - M₀² - μB²/2 + M²)Ilog(M₀) + [3(A² + M²μB²)/4 - 3M₀²μB²/4]I₁ + 2I₂

where only Iquad and Ilog contain cutoff dependence.

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

Model parameters determined via Nc scaling procedure:

• G = 7.20 GeV⁻²
• mq = 5.3 MeV
• Λ = 657 MeV
• fπ = 75.45 MeV (scaled)
• ⟨qq⟩₀^(1/3) = -218 MeV (scaled)

Comparison Methods

1. Traditional Regularization Scheme (TRS): Direct regularization of all divergent integrals using three-dimensional sharp cutoff
2. Chiral Perturbation Theory (ChPT): Low-density effective theory
3. Lattice QCD Data: First-principles calculations from reference 38

Evaluation Metrics

• Effective quark mass M and diquark condensate Δ
• Pressure P, energy density ε, baryon number density nB
• Speed of sound squared cs² = ∂P/∂ε

Experimental Results

Main Results

Order Parameter Behavior

1. MSS vs TRS Comparison:
   • In TRS, Δ vanishes at μB/mπ ≈ 12.3, exhibiting non-physical behavior
   • In MSS, Δ increases monotonically, consistent with ChPT and perturbative QCD predictions
2. Consistency with ChPT: At low chemical potential (μB < mπ), MSS results perfectly match analytical ChPT expressions

Thermodynamic Quantities

1. Equation of State: MSS produces a softer equation of state at high density, in better agreement with lattice data
2. Energy and Pressure Density: MSS results quantitatively agree with lattice data above ε ≈ 750 MeV/fm³
3. Baryon Number Density: MSS correctly approaches the free Fermi gas limit at high density, while TRS and ChPT deviate

Speed of Sound Peak

Key Finding: MSS successfully reproduces the speed of sound peak observed in lattice QCD, while TRS completely fails to capture this phenomenon.

Analytical Expression: Speed of sound can be approximated as:

cs² ≃ (2Δ² + (μB/Nc)²)/(2NcNfM² + 2Δ² + 3(μB/Nc)²)

Ablation Studies

Comparison of TRS and MSS results validates the importance of correctly separating vacuum and medium contributions:

• Results are similar in low-density regions
• Significant differences at high density, with MSS being more physically reasonable

Experimental Findings

1. Regularization Sensitivity: Thermodynamic quantities are highly sensitive to the regularization scheme
2. Stefan-Boltzmann Limit: Only MSS correctly approaches free gas behavior at high density
3. Peak Position: Speed of sound peak appears at μB ≈ 2-3mπ region, relevant to astrophysical observations

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Lattice QCD: First-principles calculations of two-color QCD, avoiding the sign problem
2. Effective Models: Application of NJL model and linear σ model at finite density
3. Renormalization Group Methods: Systematic approaches to improve cutoff dependence
4. Duality Symmetries: Duality relationships between chiral and isospin imbalance

Advantages of This Work

1. Quantitative Comparison: First quantitative agreement with lattice data
2. Physical Consistency: Ensures correct behavior in the high-density limit
3. Technical Improvement: MSS provides a systematic method for handling divergent integrals

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Effectiveness of MSS: Medium separation scheme successfully resolves regularization issues in traditional NJL models
2. Speed of Sound Peak Reproduction: MSS-corrected model quantitatively reproduces the speed of sound peak structure from lattice QCD
3. Physical Picture: Correct evolution of diquark condensate is key to understanding speed of sound behavior

Limitations

1. Model Range: NJL model may fail in the μ ≫ Λ region
2. Zero-Temperature Approximation: Practical applications require consideration of finite temperature effects
3. Two-Color Restriction: Results need verification in three-color QCD

Future Directions

1. Finite Temperature Extension: Application of MSS to finite temperature scenarios
2. Three-Color QCD: Exploration of MSS applicability in realistic QCD
3. Astrophysical Applications: Constraining model parameters with neutron star observations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation: MSS provides a systematic approach to handling divergences in effective models
2. Experimental Verification: Quantitative comparison with lattice data enhances result credibility
3. Physical Insights: Reveals the microscopic physical mechanism of the speed of sound peak
4. Technical Rigor: Detailed mathematical derivations and transparent computational procedures

Weaknesses

1. Parameter Dependence: Model parameters determined via Nc scaling may introduce systematic errors
2. Applicable Range: Results in high chemical potential regions require further verification
3. Theoretical Foundation: Theoretical basis of MSS requires deeper renormalization group analysis

Impact

1. Field Contribution: Provides new regularization scheme for QCD effective models
2. Practical Value: Applicable to neutron star matter and heavy-ion collision research
3. Method Generalization: MSS can be extended to other non-renormalizable effective theories

Application Scenarios

1. Theoretical QCD: Study of QCD phase diagram and equation of state
2. Neutron Star Physics: Constraining internal structure of compact stars
3. Heavy-Ion Physics: Understanding QCD matter in high-energy nuclear collisions

References

The paper cites 89 relevant references covering multiple fields including lattice QCD, effective models, and neutron star physics, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.