The α-representation for Tait coloring and sums over spanning trees

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10213
• Title: The α-representation for Tait coloring and sums over spanning trees
• Authors: Ilyas Kalimullin, Eduard Lerner
• Classification: math.CO (Combinatorics), math.NT (Number Theory)
• Submission Date: October 11, 2025 to arXiv
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10213

Abstract

This paper investigates the algebraic relationship between the Tait coloring number of maximal planar graphs and the weighted sum over spanning trees. The authors consider a connected pseudograph $H$ where each edge is associated with a weight $x_e \in \mathbb{F}_3$, and define $s(H;\mathbf{x})=\sum_{T\in\mathcal{T}(H)} \prod_{e\in E(T)} x_e$ as the spanning tree weight sum. For a maximal planar graph $G$, each face $F$ is assigned a value $\alpha(F)=\pm 1 \in \mathbb{F}_3$, and edge weights are defined as $x_e=\alpha(F'_e)+\alpha(F''_e)$. By introducing a weight function $w_G(\mathbf{x})$ and utilizing Legendre symbols and vertex contraction techniques, the authors prove that the Tait coloring number equals three times the sum of weights corresponding to all $\alpha$ vectors satisfying specific conditions.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Core Problem: This paper aims to establish a new algebraic representation of the Tait coloring number for maximal planar graphs, connecting it to spanning tree weight sums.
2. Historical Background: The research originates from a conjecture proposed by Kontsevich in 1997, which concerns the number of nonzero values of spanning tree weight sums over finite fields. Although the original conjecture has been refuted, it has inspired new research directions.
3. Significance:
   • Tait coloring is equivalent to the Four Color Theorem, a fundamental problem in graph theory
   • Connects techniques from combinatorial graph theory, algebraic geometry, and quantum field theory
   • Provides a new algebraic perspective for understanding planar graph coloring
4. Limitations of Existing Methods: Traditional Tait coloring counting methods rely primarily on combinatorial techniques and lack deep connections with other mathematical branches. This paper establishes an analogy with Feynman amplitude calculations in quantum field theory through the α-representation technique.

Core Contributions

1. Established a new algebraic representation: Proved that the Tait coloring number can be expressed as a sum of specific weight functions involving Legendre symbols and spanning tree weight sums.
2. Introduced the α-representation technique: Adapted the α-representation technique from quantum field theory to the finite field $\mathbb{F}_3$, providing a new analytical tool for combinatorial problems.
3. Connected multiple mathematical fields: Linked the coloring problem in graph theory with Gauss sums in number theory and quadratic form theory in algebraic geometry.
4. Provided explicit computational formulas: Derived explicit formulas for computing Tait coloring numbers through spanning tree weight sums, with theoretical results verified through the example of $K_4$.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Input: A maximal planar graph $G$ (i.e., a planar graph where every face is a triangle) Output: The Tait coloring number $\text{Tai}(G)$ of $G$Constraints: Tait coloring requires adjacent edges to use different colors, and the three edges of each triangular face must use three different colors

Core Mathematical Framework

1. Spanning Tree Weight Sum Definition

For a connected pseudograph $H$ and edge weights $\mathbf{x} \in \mathbb{F}_3^{E(H)}$: $s(H;\mathbf{x}) = \sum_{T\in\mathcal{T}(H)} \prod_{e\in E(T)} x_e$

2. Weight Function Definition

$w_G(\mathbf{x}) = \left(\frac{s(G/W^*(\mathbf{x});\mathbf{x})}{3}\right)/(-3)^{(|V(G/W^*(\mathbf{x}))|-1)/2}$

where:

• $\left(\frac{x}{3}\right)$ is the Legendre symbol
• $W^*(\mathbf{x})$ is the minimum cardinality vertex set such that $s(G/W;\mathbf{x}) \neq 0$
• $G/W$ denotes the graph obtained by contracting vertex set $W$

3. α-Parametrization

For face assignment $\alpha \in \{-1,1\}^{\mathcal{F}(G)}$, edge weights are defined as: $x_e = \alpha(F'_e) + \alpha(F''_e)$ where $F'_e, F''_e$ are the two faces containing edge $e$.

Main Theorem

Theorem 1: $\text{Tai}_0(G) = \sum w_G(\mathbf{x}(\alpha))$ where the sum ranges over all $\alpha \in \{-1,1\}^{\mathcal{F}(G)}$ such that $G/W^*(\mathbf{x}(\alpha))$ has an odd number of vertices, and $\text{Tai}_0(G) = \text{Tai}(G)/3$.

Technical Innovations

1. Application of Gauss Sums: Utilized multidimensional Gauss sums $\text{Gau}(C) = \sum_{y\in\mathbb{F}_3^n} \exp(2\pi iy^TCy/3)$ to handle quadratic forms.
2. Algebraization of Heawood's Theorem: Transformed Heawood's combinatorial characterization of Tait coloring into a solution counting problem for linear equation systems.
3. Fourier Transform Techniques: Employed Fourier transforms over finite fields, particularly the identity: $\sum_{y\in\mathbb{F}_3^*} \exp(2\pi iky/3) = 3\delta(k) - 1$
4. Connection to Laplace-Kirchhoff Matrix: Established relationships between the weight function and principal minors of the graph's Laplace-Kirchhoff matrix.

Experimental Setup

Verification Case: Complete Graph $K_4$

The authors verified theoretical results through detailed analysis of $K_4$:

Data Characteristics:

• 4 vertices, 6 edges, 4 triangular faces
• 16 possible $\alpha$ vectors

Case Analysis:

1. Case 1: All faces have the same sign (2 cases)
   • $x_e = -1$ for all edges
   • $s(K_4;\mathbf{x}(\alpha)) = -16 = -1$
   • Even number of vertices, contributes nothing to final sum
2. Case 2: Only one face has opposite sign (8 cases)
   • Three edges have weight 0, one edge has nonzero weight
   • Weights cancel out, contributes nothing to final sum
3. Case 3: Two faces are +1 and two faces are -1 (6 cases)
   • $s(K_4;\mathbf{x}(\alpha)) = 0$, requires vertex contraction
   • $w_{K_4}(\mathbf{x}(\alpha)) = 1/3$
   • Final result: $\text{Tai}_0(K_4) = 6 \times \frac{1}{3} = 2$

Experimental Results

Main Results

Complete calculation for $K_4$ verified Theorem 1:

• Theoretical prediction: $\text{Tai}_0(K_4) = 2$
• Direct computation: $K_4$ has exactly 6 Tait colorings, thus $\text{Tai}_0(K_4) = 6/3 = 2$
• Results are consistent, validating the correctness of the theoretical framework

Computational Complexity Analysis

For a maximal planar graph with $f$ faces:

• Must traverse $2^f$ $\alpha$ vectors
• Each vector requires computing spanning tree weight sums
• Total complexity is exponential, but provides new theoretical insights

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Heawood's Theorem (1898): Transformed Tait coloring into solving linear equation systems
2. Alon-Tarsi Method: Computed chromatic numbers through graph polynomials
3. Matiyasevich's Algebraic Method: Early algebraic coloring theory
4. Kontsevich Conjecture: Inspired research on spanning tree weight sums

Innovations in This Paper

1. Methodological Innovation: First application of quantum field theory's α-representation technique to graph coloring problems
2. Theoretical Depth: Established deep connections between combinatorial graph theory and number theory, algebraic geometry
3. Computational Tools: Provided new methods for computing Tait colorings

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Contribution: Established precise relationships between Tait coloring numbers and spanning tree weight sums
2. Methodological Significance: Successful application of α-representation technique over finite fields
3. Interdisciplinary Value: Connected techniques and concepts from multiple mathematical branches

Limitations

1. Computational Complexity: The exponential time complexity of the method limits practical applications
2. Scope of Applicability: Currently applicable only to maximal planar graphs
3. Finite Field Restriction: The method is specifically designed for $\mathbb{F}_3$

Future Directions

1. Generalization to Other Finite Fields: Extend to the general case of $\mathbb{F}_q$
2. Non-maximal Planar Graphs: Study similar representations for general planar graphs
3. Algorithm Optimization: Seek more efficient computational methods
4. Application Extensions: Apply techniques to other combinatorial problems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Theoretical Innovation: First connection between graph coloring and quantum field theory techniques
2. Mathematical Rigor: Complete proofs with clear logical structure
3. Interdisciplinary Value: Provides new intersection points for multiple mathematical branches
4. Concretely Verifiable: Detailed verification through the $K_4$ example

Weaknesses

1. Limited Practical Utility: Exponential complexity restricts application to large graphs
2. Generalizability Unverified: Unclear whether the method can be generalized to more general cases
3. Technical Accessibility: Some technical steps are difficult for non-specialists to understand

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new theoretical tools for graph theory research
2. Inspirational Significance: May inspire more interdisciplinary research
3. Methodological Contribution: Successful transplantation of α-representation technique has methodological significance

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Suitable for theoretical analysis in graph theory and combinatorics
2. Small-Scale Verification: Can be used to verify Tait coloring properties of small graphs
3. Educational Demonstration: Excellent case study for demonstrating connections between mathematical branches

References

The paper cites 20 important references covering:

• Classical graph theory results (Heawood, Alon-Tarsi, etc.)
• Finite field theory (Ireland-Rosen, Lidl-Niederreiter, etc.)
• Quantum field theory techniques (Symanzik, etc.)
• Modern combinatorics (Stanley, Stembridge, etc.)

These references provide a solid theoretical foundation for the paper's interdisciplinary approach.