Newtonian potential from scattering amplitudes in super-renormalizable gravity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10270
• Title: Newtonian potential from scattering amplitudes in super-renormalizable gravity
• Authors: Haiyuan Feng (Shanxi Normal University), Rong-Jia Yang (Hebei University)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 11, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10270

Abstract

This paper employs scattering amplitudes to calculate the coupling between general super-renormalizable gravity theories and massive scalar particles. This enables the derivation of the D-dimensional Newtonian potential at tree level and one-loop level, where the one-loop calculation utilizes newly derived three-graviton Feynman rules. In four-dimensional spacetime, numerical results demonstrate that the Newtonian potential remains finite at the origin, providing strong evidence for the persistence of the singularity-free property of super-renormalizable gravity at the one-loop level.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

This research addresses two fundamental issues in quantum gravity:

1. Ultraviolet Divergence Problem: Traditional general relativity exhibits non-renormalizable ultraviolet divergences upon quantization
2. Classical Singularity Problem: General relativity predicts spacetime singularities (such as black hole centers and the Big Bang singularity)

Problem Significance

• The unification of quantum mechanics and general relativity represents a central challenge in modern physics
• The existence of singularities indicates theory failure under extreme conditions, necessitating new physical frameworks
• The effective field theory approach provides a powerful bridge connecting quantum field theory techniques with classical gravitational dynamics

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Traditional perturbative studies have only established finite Newtonian potentials at O(G) order in super-renormalizable gravity
• The behavior at O(G²) order has remained a key open question
• Systematic one-loop calculations are lacking to verify the persistence of singularity resolution mechanisms

Research Motivation

To employ modern amplitude methods (particularly generalized unitarity) to perform the first complete one-loop calculation of the Newtonian potential, verifying whether the singularity-free property of super-renormalizable gravity persists at the quantum level.

Core Contributions

1. First One-Loop Calculation: Completed the first comprehensive one-loop level calculation of the Newtonian potential in super-renormalizable gravity
2. New Feynman Rules: Derived novel Feynman rules for the three-graviton vertex in the non-local framework
3. D-Dimensional Potential Functions: Obtained complete D-dimensional Newtonian potential expressions at tree and one-loop levels
4. Numerical Verification: Numerically demonstrated the finiteness of the potential function at the origin in four-dimensional spacetime
5. Theoretical Confirmation: Provided the first decisive evidence for the persistence of the singularity-free property of super-renormalizable gravity at the quantum level

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Calculate the Newtonian potential generated by massive scalar particles in super-renormalizable gravity theory, including:

• Input: Super-renormalizable gravity action, scalar matter fields, scattering amplitudes
• Output: Tree-level and one-loop corrections to the D-dimensional Newtonian potential
• Constraints: Classical limit (soft graviton approximation), weak non-locality conditions

Theoretical Framework

Super-Renormalizable Gravity Action

The action takes the form: $S = \frac{2}{\kappa^2}\int \sqrt{-g} d^Dx\left(R + RF_1(\Box)R + R_{\mu\nu}F_2(\Box)R^{\mu\nu} + R_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}F_4(\Box)R^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\right)$

where the form factors $F_i(\Box)$ are entire functions, expandable as: $F_i(\Box) = \sum_{n=0}^{\infty} f_{in}\frac{\Box^n}{M_*^{2n}}$

Weak Non-Locality

The form factors are expressed through entire functions: $F_1(\Box) = -\frac{(D-2)(e^{H_0(\Box)}-1) + D(e^{H_2(\Box)}-1)}{4(D-1)\Box} + F_4(\Box)$$F_2(\Box) = \frac{e^{H_2(\Box)}-1}{\Box} - 4F_4(\Box)$

Scattering Amplitude Method

Classical Limit

In the classical limit, graviton momenta are soft relative to massive scalar particle momenta, corresponding to the leading contribution of long-range interactions.

Vertex Function Relations

The relationship between scattering amplitudes and physical pseudo-tensors is: $2\pi\delta(kq)M^{\mu\nu}_{\text{vertex}} = -\kappa\tilde{\tau}^{\mu\nu} + \frac{1}{\xi}\tilde{H}^{\mu\nu}_{\text{non-linear}}$

Metric Corrections

Through Fourier transformation and equations of motion, the metric correction is obtained: $g_{\mu\nu} = \eta_{\mu\nu} - \frac{\kappa}{2}\int \frac{d^Dq\delta(kq)e^{-iqx}}{(2\pi)^{D-1}} O^{-1}_{\alpha\beta\mu\nu}M^{\alpha\beta}_{\text{vertex}}$

Technical Innovations

1. Three-Graviton Vertex Rules: First derivation of complete three-graviton Feynman rules in super-renormalizable gravity including non-local terms
2. Soft Graviton Approximation: Systematic application of classical limits to simplify complex loop integrals
3. Tensor Structure Decomposition: Decomposition of complex tensor integrals into products of scalar integrals and geometric factors
4. Numerical Integration Techniques: Development of numerical methods for handling non-local integrals

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Spacetime Dimension: Primary focus on D=4 physical case, with general D-dimensional results provided
• Form Factor Choice: $\omega(\Box) = e^{-\Box/M_*^2}$, $H_0(\Box) = H_2(\Box) = -\Box/M_*^2$
• Mass Scale: $M_*$ is the mass scale at which higher-derivative terms become important

Computational Strategy

1. Tree-Level Calculation: Verification of known results using linear perturbation theory
2. One-Loop Calculation: Focus on non-analytic contributions from triangle diagrams
3. Numerical Evaluation: Numerical computation of complex integrals

Technical Details

• Use of covariant harmonic gauge
• Dimensional regularization for handling divergences
• Wick rotation for processing non-local integrals

Experimental Results

Tree-Level Results

The Newtonian potential at D=4 is: $\Phi^{(G_N)}(r) = -\frac{G_Nm}{r}\text{erf}\left(\frac{M_*r}{2}\right)$

Key Features:

• Long-Distance Behavior: $\lim_{r\to\infty}\Phi^{(G_N)}(r) = -\frac{G_Nm}{r}$, recovering the standard Newtonian potential
• Short-Distance Regularization: $\Phi^{(G_N)}(r\to 0) = -\frac{G_NmM_*}{\sqrt{\pi}}$, finite at the origin

One-Loop Results

The general form of O(G²) corrections is: $\Phi^{(G_N)^2}(r) = -\frac{\kappa^4m^2}{4}\int \frac{d^{D-1}q_\perp}{(2\pi)^{D-1}} e^{-iq_\perp x_\perp}e^{-\frac{q_\perp^2}{M_*^2}}\times[\text{complex integral expression}]$

Numerical Verification

Figure 3 displays numerical results for the D=4 case:

• The potential function remains completely regular as $r\to 0$
• One-loop corrections grow smoothly with distance, consistent with expected long-range behavior
• Provides direct numerical evidence for the persistence of singularity resolution mechanisms at the quantum level

Key Findings

1. Finiteness Preservation: The Newtonian potential remains finite at the origin at all orders
2. Asymptotic Behavior: Long-distance limits recover standard general relativity results
3. Quantum Corrections: One-loop corrections do not destroy the singularity resolution mechanism

Related Work

Super-Renormalizable Gravity Theory

• Biswas et al. (2012) established the fundamental theoretical framework
• Modesto (2012) developed super-renormalizable quantum gravity
• Tomboulis (2015) studied renormalization and unitarity

Scattering Amplitude Methods

• Bjerrum-Bohr et al. (2018) derived general relativity from scattering amplitudes
• Cheung et al. (2018) developed post-Minkowskian expansion
• Applications of modern on-shell methods in gravity

Effective Field Theory Approaches

• Donoghue's (1994) pioneering work
• Goldberger-Rothstein effective field theory
• Establishment of classical-quantum correspondence

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Consistency: Super-renormalizable gravity maintains singularity resolution properties at one-loop level
2. Computational Feasibility: Scattering amplitude methods provide effective tools for complex quantum gravity calculations
3. Numerical Confirmation: Four-dimensional numerical results clearly demonstrate potential regularity

Limitations

1. Specific Form Factors: Analysis limited to particular form factor choices
2. One-Loop Level: Higher-loop behavior requires further investigation
3. Numerical Methods: Complex integrals lack simple analytic expressions

Future Directions

1. Higher-Order Loop Corrections: Investigation of whether higher-loop levels maintain singularity resolution
2. General Form Factors: Extension to more general form factor choices
3. Physical Applications: Study of applications in cosmology and black hole physics

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Pioneering Calculation: First completion of one-loop Newtonian potential calculation in super-renormalizable gravity
2. Technical Innovation: Development of new Feynman rules and computational techniques
3. Theoretical Importance: Provides crucial evidence for singularity resolution in quantum gravity
4. Methodological Systematicity: Integration of modern amplitude methods with classical gravity theory

Weaknesses

1. Analytic Complexity: One-loop results lack concise analytic expressions
2. Parameter Dependence: Results' dependence on specific parameter choices requires further investigation
3. Experimental Verification: Experimental verification of theoretical predictions remains challenging

Impact

1. Theoretical Physics: Provides important support for quantum gravity theory development
2. Computational Methods: Advances calculation techniques for gravitational scattering amplitudes
3. Cosmological Significance: May have implications for early universe and black hole physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Quantum gravity and string theory research
2. Numerical Simulation: Numerical relativity in strong gravitational fields
3. Cosmological Applications: Singularity resolution mechanisms in the early universe

References

The paper cites 52 important references, covering classical and recent research in scattering amplitude theory, super-renormalizable gravity, effective field theory methods, and related key areas.

Overall Assessment: This is an important paper in quantum gravity theory that rigorously verifies key properties of super-renormalizable gravity theory through careful calculations, providing new theoretical support for resolving gravitational singularity problems.