Perturbative and non-perturbative properties of heavy quark transport in a thermal QCD medium

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10294
• Title: Perturbative and non-perturbative properties of heavy quark transport in a thermal QCD medium
• Authors: Jiazhen Peng, Jiale Lou, Fei Sun, Kejun Wu, Wei Xie, Zuman Zhang, Shuang Li, Sa Wang
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10294

Abstract

This paper investigates the perturbative and non-perturbative transport properties of heavy quarks in a thermal QCD medium. Based on the soft-hard factorization model (SHFM), the original perturbative framework is extended to the region near the critical temperature, where non-perturbative effects become significant. The phase transition behavior of the semi-quark-gluon plasma (semi-QGP) is described by introducing temperature-dependent background fields in the background field effective theory. Through implementation of this approach, the collisional energy loss and momentum diffusion coefficients of charm and bottom quarks are quantitatively evaluated as functions of incident energy and medium temperature. The results demonstrate significant suppression of both energy loss and diffusion coefficients relative to conventional perturbative estimates, particularly near the critical temperature. This suppression originates from the emergence of temperature-dependent color background fields, which effectively reduce the color charge screening of the medium.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Heavy quark transport research aims to understand the microscopic structure of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) formed in high-energy nuclear collisions at RHIC and LHC. Since the heavy quark mass far exceeds the temperature (m_Q ≫ T), they serve as excellent probes of the medium's dynamical properties.

Significance

The transport processes of heavy quarks encode crucial information about the coupling strength of QCD matter, color screening, and critical dynamics. Understanding these properties is essential for:

1. Explaining heavy flavor observables at RHIC and LHC
2. Understanding the microscopic structure of QGP
3. Connecting perturbative and non-perturbative QCD regimes

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Perturbative approaches: Hard thermal loop (HTL) resummation and next-to-leading order (NLO) dynamical calculations are primarily valid in the weak coupling limit (T ≫ T_c)
2. Non-perturbative approaches: Lattice QCD, color magnetic monopole models, and holographic models are effective in the strong coupling regime but lack unified descriptions
3. Theoretical gap: Absence of a unified theoretical framework connecting the high-energy perturbative region with the critical strong-coupling region

Research Motivation

This paper aims to establish a unified theoretical framework extending from the perturbative domain (T ≫ T_c) to the semi-QGP region (T ≲ 2-3T_c) by extending the SHFM model and introducing temperature-dependent background fields.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical framework extension: Extension of the SHFM model to include non-perturbative regions with temperature-dependent background fields
2. Unified description: Provision of a unified theoretical description from perturbative to non-perturbative regions
3. Quantitative calculations: Systematic computation of energy loss and momentum diffusion coefficients of heavy quarks in the semi-QGP
4. Physical mechanism revelation: Clarification of the physical mechanism underlying transport coefficient suppression induced by background fields
5. Phenomenological applications: Provision of theoretical foundation for heavy flavor probes in QGP phenomenology

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigation of the scattering process between heavy quark Q and thermal gluon g: Q(P₁) + g(P₂) → Q(P₃) + g(P₄), calculating the corresponding energy loss and momentum diffusion coefficients.

Theoretical Framework

1. Soft-Hard Factorization Model (SHFM)

Decomposition of the scattering process into three dynamical regions:

• Soft region (-t < -t*): t-channel exchange with small momentum transfer
• Hard region (-t > -t*): t-channel exchange with large momentum transfer
• su region: s-channel and u-channel contributions

Total scattering rate: Γ = Γ_soft(t) + Γ_hard(t) + Γ_(su)

2. Background Field Effective Theory

Introduction of classical background fields:

(A^cl_0)_ab = (1/g)Q_a δ_ab, Q_a ≡ 2πTQ_a

For the three-color case (N_c = 3): Q_a = (Q, 0, -Q)

Temperature dependence:

Q(T) = (1/36)[9 - √(81 - 80(T_c/T)²)]

3. Biadjoint Representation

In the biadjoint basis:

• Quarks: single color line, color index a ∈ {1,2,3}
• Gluons: double color line, color index ab, Q_ab ≡ Q_a - Q_b

4. Modified Thermal Distribution Functions

Background fields modify the thermal distribution functions:

• Bosons: n_B(E ± iQ_ab) = 1/(e^β(E±iQ_ab) - 1)
• Fermions: n_F(E ± iQ_a) = 1/(e^β(E±iQ_a) + 1)

Calculation Methods

Soft Scattering Region

Heavy quark self-energy:

Σ(P₁) = iC_F g² ∫ d⁴Q/(2π)⁴ D_μν(Q)γ^μ 1/(P₁ - Q - m₁) γ^ν

Using the gluon propagator with HTL resummation, the scattering rate is obtained:

Γ^(Q≠0;soft)_(t) = (g²)/(2N_c) ∫_q ∫dω δ(ω - v⃗₁·q⃗){B_L + v⃗₁²[1-(v̂₁·q̂)²]B_T}

Hard Scattering Region

For the hard momentum region, background fields primarily act through modifying statistical distribution functions and color factors:

Γ^(Q≠0;hard)_(t) = (1)/(2E₁)[(1/8)∑^3_(j,k=1)(1-(1/3)δ_jk)] × scattering integral

Technical Innovations

1. Background field integration: First systematic incorporation of Polyakov loop background fields into the SHFM framework
2. Biadjoint representation application: Use of biadjoint representation to handle complex color structures
3. Temperature dependence modeling: Determination of background field temperature dependence through effective potential equations
4. Unified computational framework: Establishment of a complete computational system encompassing soft and hard scattering

Experimental Setup

Physical Parameters

• Heavy quark masses: m_c = 1.5 GeV, m_b = 4.75 GeV
• Critical temperature: T_c = 0.27 GeV
• Strong coupling constant: α_s = 0.3
• Cutoff parameter: -t* = 4m²_D

Computational Range

• Temperature range: 0.3 - 1.0 GeV
• Heavy quark energy: 1 - 50 GeV
• Velocity range: 0 - 1

Evaluation Metrics

1. Energy loss rate: -dE/dz
2. Transverse momentum diffusion coefficient: κ_T
3. Longitudinal momentum diffusion coefficient: κ_L
4. Diffusion coefficient ratio: R_TL = κ_T/κ_L

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Suppression of Thermal Distribution Functions

Background fields induce systematic suppression of Bose distribution functions:

• Ratio n^(Q≠0)_Avg,B/n^(Q=0)_B < 1
• Low-momentum states experience stronger suppression
• Suppression effect weakens with increasing temperature

2. Suppression of Energy Loss

For 10 GeV charm quarks in the temperature range T = 0.3-0.6 GeV:

• Energy loss suppression appears in all scattering channels
• Suppression effect is strongest near the critical temperature
• Soft t-channel scattering is relatively less affected

3. Energy Dependence

At fixed temperature T = 0.3 GeV:

• Background field-induced suppression shows weak dependence on incident quark energy
• Suppression factors in various scattering channels remain approximately constant

4. Momentum Diffusion Coefficient Ratio

In the presence of background fields:

• R_TL = κ_T/κ_L is systematically reduced relative to the perturbative baseline
• In the static limit v → 0, R_TL → 1
• Longitudinal diffusion is relatively enhanced at high velocities

Numerical Results Analysis

Suppression Mechanism

1. Reduced color charge density: Background fields effectively decrease the available color scattering center density
2. Preserved long-range correlations: Long-range color electric correlations in soft t-channel processes remain relatively stable
3. Occupation number correction: Modification of thermal distribution functions is the primary suppression source

Temperature Scaling Behavior

• Near-critical region (T ~ T_c): Strong suppression
• High-temperature region (T >> T_c): Gradual recovery of perturbative behavior
• Transition region: Smooth connection between two limits

Related Work

Perturbative Methods

• HTL resummation theory 1-3
• NLO dynamical calculations
• Soft-hard factorization methods 28-35

Non-perturbative Methods

• Lattice QCD studies 4-6
• Color magnetic monopole models 7-10
• Effective T-matrix theory 11-13
• AdS/CFT holographic models 14-17

Advantages of This Work

1. Provides unified description of perturbative and non-perturbative regions
2. Based on first-principles QCD calculations
3. Systematically accounts for temperature-dependent non-perturbative effects

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Suppression effect: Background fields significantly suppress heavy quark transport coefficients near the critical temperature
2. Physical mechanism: Suppression originates from reduced color charge density rather than dynamical modifications
3. Unified framework: Successfully establishes a theoretical framework spanning the perturbative-non-perturbative boundary
4. Phenomenological significance: Provides theoretical foundation for heavy flavor observables

Limitations

1. Gluon plasma approximation: Considers only gluon contributions, neglecting thermal quark effects
2. Elastic scattering: Does not include inelastic radiation processes and LPM effects
3. Leading-order calculation: Background field corrections to scattering matrix elements are only to leading order

Future Directions

1. Fermion extension: Inclusion of thermal quark contributions to transport coefficients
2. Radiation processes: Incorporation of medium-induced gluon radiation
3. Phenomenological applications: Combination with Langevin transport models for numerical simulations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First systematic application of background field theory to heavy quark transport
2. Computational completeness: Provides complete computational framework from soft to hard scattering
3. Physical insights: Reveals the important role of color correlations in semi-QGP
4. Numerical precision: Provides detailed numerical results and physical analysis

Weaknesses

1. Model assumptions: Pure gluon plasma assumption limits applicability
2. Approximate treatments: Certain technical approximations may affect quantitative accuracy of results
3. Experimental comparison: Lacks direct comparison with experimental data

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new understanding framework for QGP theory
2. Methodological value: Established computational methods applicable to other transport problems
3. Practical prospects: Can be combined with existing transport models for phenomenological studies

Applicable Scenarios

1. Heavy flavor physics in heavy-ion collisions
2. Transport phenomena near QGP phase transition
3. Theoretical studies of strongly-coupled QCD systems
4. Improvements to heavy quark phenomenological models

References

This paper cites 63 relevant references, covering all aspects of heavy quark transport theory, from perturbative QCD to lattice calculations, from effective theories to holographic methods, reflecting comprehensive development in this field.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important contributions to heavy quark transport theory. By introducing background field effects, it successfully establishes a unified theoretical framework spanning the perturbative-non-perturbative boundary, providing new theoretical tools for understanding QGP transport properties. Despite certain limitations in theoretical assumptions, its innovation and completeness make it an important advance in this field.