Production of the exclusive $γγ\rightarrow J/ψ+γ$ process in proton-proton ultraperipheral collisions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10318
• Title: Production of the exclusive $γγ\rightarrow J/ψ+γ$ process in proton-proton ultraperipheral collisions
• Authors: Meng-Kun Jia, Xiao-Bo Jin, Kui-Yong Liu, Guang-Zhi Xu
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 11, 2024
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10318

Abstract

This study investigates the production of $J/ψ+γ$ through photon-photon fusion processes in proton-proton ultraperipheral collisions (UPCs) at $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 14$ TeV at next-to-leading order (NLO). The calculations are performed within the non-relativistic quantum chromodynamics (NRQCD) framework, employing photon parton distribution functions derived from the proton electric dipole form factor (EDFF), with explicit retention of the dependence on the impact parameter $b$. The calculated cross sections are 155 fb at leading order and 107.5-130 fb at NLO, demonstrating moderate but controllable $α_s$ suppression. Despite this suppression, the process maintains a sufficiently large cross section to be observable in future high-luminosity measurements.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

The core question addressed in this paper concerns the theoretical calculation and prediction of the process ($γγ → J/ψ + γ$) in which a $J/ψ$ meson and an additional photon are produced through photon-photon interactions in proton-proton ultraperipheral collisions.

Significance

1. Heavy Quarkonium Physics: The $J/ψ$ meson, as a representative charm quark-antiquark bound state, possesses a relatively stable structure and extended lifetime, making it an important probe for studying quantum chromodynamics (QCD) mechanisms
2. Ultraperipheral Collisions: UPCs provide a unique environment for studying photoproduction processes under well-controlled conditions, enabling the investigation of electromagnetic interactions
3. Precision Tests: This process serves as a sensitive probe for testing the NRQCD theoretical framework and heavy quarkonium production mechanisms

Existing Limitations

1. Previous studies have primarily focused on leading-order (LO) calculations, lacking systematic investigation of higher-order corrections
2. The treatment of impact parameter $b$ dependence has been incomplete
3. Theoretical uncertainty assessments have been insufficient

Research Motivation

1. To provide more accurate theoretical predictions for guidance of LHC experiments
2. To systematically evaluate the effects of NLO corrections
3. To comprehensively handle geometric effects in ultraperipheral collisions

Core Contributions

1. First Complete NLO Calculation: Completion of the full next-to-leading order QCD corrections for the $γγ → J/ψ + γ$ process within the NRQCD framework
2. Impact Parameter Integration: Systematic numerical integration of the impact parameter $b$ in the photon parton distribution functions
3. Theoretical Uncertainty Assessment: Systematic evaluation of theoretical uncertainties through renormalization scale variations
4. Experimental Observability Predictions: Quantitative predictions for experimental observation during the HL-LHC era

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Calculate the differential cross section for the $γγ → J/ψ + γ$ process in proton-proton ultraperipheral collisions, with collision energy and kinematic variables as inputs, and cross section magnitude and distributions as outputs.

Theoretical Framework

NRQCD Factorization

The differential cross section is expressed as: $\frac{d\sigma(pp → J/ψ + γ)}{dy} = \sum_n \int \frac{dE_{γ1}}{E_{γ1}} \frac{dE_{γ2}}{E_{γ2}} \frac{d^2N^{(pp)}_{γ1/Z1,γ2/Z2}}{dE_{γ1}dE_{γ2}} \times d\hat{\sigma}(γ1γ2 → c\bar{c}[n] + γ) \otimes \langle 0|O^{J/ψ}_n|0\rangle$

where:

• $d\hat{\sigma}(γ1γ2 → c\bar{c}[n] + γ)$ is the short-distance coefficient
• $\langle 0|O^{J/ψ}_n|0\rangle$ is the long-distance matrix element

Photon Flux Function

The photon number density based on the electric dipole form factor: $N^{EDFF}_{γ/Z}(E_γ, b) = \frac{Z^2α}{π^2} \frac{ξ^2}{b^2} \left[K_1^2(ξ) + \frac{1}{γ_L^2}K_0^2(ξ)\right]$

where $ξ = E_γb/γ_L$, and $K_i$ are modified Bessel functions.

Survival Probability

The probability of avoiding inelastic hadronic interactions: $P_{no-inel}(b) = 1 - Γ(s_{NN}, b)$ where $Γ(s_{NN}, b) ∝ e^{-b^2/b_0}$, with $b_0 = 20.6$ GeV$^{-2}$ (at 14 TeV).

Technical Innovations

1. Complete Impact Parameter Integration: Unlike previous simplified treatments assuming 100% survival probability, this work performs complete integration over the impact parameter
2. Systematic Renormalization: Employs on-shell renormalization scheme for quark mass and wave function, and MS scheme for the strong coupling constant
3. High-Precision Numerical Computation: Uses QGRAF for Feynman diagram generation, FORM for algebraic manipulation, and Package-X and QCDloop for master integral calculations

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

• Collision Energy: $\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 14$ TeV
• Proton Parameters: $Z = 1$, $R_p = 0.7$ fm, $m_p = 0.9383$ GeV
• Lorentz Factor: $γ_L = 7460$
• Charm Quark Mass: $m_c = 1.5$ GeV
• Radial Wave Function: $|R_S(0)|^2 = 0.81$ GeV$^3$

Renormalization Scale Selection

Multiple renormalization scales are considered:

• $\mu_r = \sqrt{x_1x_2s}$, $\sqrt{x_1x_2s}/2$, $2\sqrt{x_1x_2s}$
• $\mu_r = \sqrt{4m_c^2 + p_T^2}$, $\sqrt{4m_c^2 + p_T^2}/2$, $2\sqrt{4m_c^2 + p_T^2}$

Kinematic Cuts

Two scenarios are analyzed:

• $p_T > 0$ GeV (no cut)
• $p_T > 2$ GeV (high transverse momentum region)

Experimental Results

Main Results

Total Cross Section Results ($\mu_r = \sqrt{x_1x_2s}$):

Theoretical Uncertainties

• $p_T > 0$ GeV: NLO cross section range 107.49-130.09 fb, relative uncertainty approximately ±15%
• $p_T > 2$ GeV: NLO cross section range 6.31-10.25 fb, relative uncertainty approximately ±25%

Kinematic Distributions

1. Transverse Momentum Distribution: Shows that the majority of contributions are concentrated in the low $p_T$ region, with more pronounced NLO suppression at high $p_T$
2. Rapidity Distribution: Significant suppression observed in the central rapidity region ($|y| < 2$)

Experimental Observability

Under HL-LHC conditions ($L_{int} = 150$ fb$^{-1}$), considering the branching ratio for $J/ψ → μ^+μ^-$ (5.961%), approximately 961-1163 $J/ψ$ events are expected to be observable.

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Heavy Quarkonium Production Mechanisms: Development and application of the NRQCD theoretical framework
2. Ultraperipheral Collisions: Theoretical and experimental studies of electromagnetic processes
3. Photon-Photon Physics: Photon interactions at high-energy colliders

Relationship to Related Work

• Compared to the LO calculation in Ref. 19, this work provides complete NLO corrections
• Compared to Ref. 41 which assumes 100% survival probability, this work comprehensively handles impact parameter integration
• Extends the research from $e^+e^-$ colliders in Ref. 25 to proton-proton collisions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Significant NLO Correction Effects: Relative to LO, NLO corrections induce 20-30% suppression
2. Scale Dependence: Renormalization scale uncertainty becomes more pronounced in the high $p_T$ region
3. Experimental Observability: Despite the suppression, the cross section remains sufficiently large to be observable during the HL-LHC era

Limitations

1. Color-Singlet Channel Only: Does not include color-octet contributions
2. Missing NNLO Corrections: Scale dependence indicates the need for higher-order corrections
3. Incomplete Relativistic Corrections: Relativistic effects are not fully incorporated

Future Directions

1. Calculate NNLO corrections to reduce theoretical uncertainties
2. Include color-octet and relativistic corrections
3. Extend to other heavy quarkonium states

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: First complete NLO calculation of this process within the NRQCD framework
2. Technical Innovation: Systematic treatment of impact parameter integration, providing more realistic theoretical predictions
3. Experimental Guidance: Provides quantitative theoretical predictions for HL-LHC experiments
4. Uncertainty Assessment: Systematic analysis of theoretical uncertainty sources

Weaknesses

1. Significant Scale Dependence: Considerable renormalization scale dependence persists at NLO
2. Approximate Treatments: Multiple theoretical approximations remain (e.g., considering only color-singlet channels)
3. Numerical Precision: Numerical precision of certain integrals may affect final results

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important theoretical tools for heavy quarkonium physics
2. Experimental Value: Directly guides measurement and analysis in LHC experiments
3. Methodological Significance: Provides technical examples for calculations of similar processes

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-energy proton-proton collider experiments (LHC and upgrades)
2. Precision studies of heavy quarkonium physics
3. Investigation of electromagnetic processes in ultraperipheral collisions

References

The paper cites 45 important references covering key works in NRQCD theory, ultraperipheral collisions, and heavy quarkonium physics, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.