Monogamy of Gaussian quantum steering and entanglement in a hybrid qubit-cavity optomagnonic system with coherent feedback loop

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10334
• Title: Monogamy of Gaussian quantum steering and entanglement in a hybrid qubit-cavity optomagnonic system with coherent feedback loop
• Authors: Hamza Harraf, Mohamed Amazioug, Amjad Sohail, Rachid Ahl Laamara
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10334

Abstract

Monogamy of quantum correlations is a fundamental principle in quantum information processing that constrains the sharing of quantum correlations among multiple subsystems. This paper proposes a theoretical scheme to investigate the monogamy of quantum steering and genuine tripartite entanglement in a hybrid qubit-cavity optomagnonic system with a coherent feedback loop. Entanglement and steerability are quantified using logarithmic negativity and Gaussian quantum steering, respectively. The CKW-type monogamy inequality is verified, and steering monogamy is controlled by tuning the reflection parameter and temperature relationships between tripartite modes. Results demonstrate that coherent feedback loops can enhance entanglement and quantum steering under thermal effects.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed in this research is how to enhance quantum correlations in hybrid quantum systems through coherent feedback mechanisms under thermal noise environments, and to investigate the monogamy properties of these correlations.

Significance

1. Quantum Information Foundation: Quantum entanglement and EPR steering are fundamental resources for quantum information processing, crucial for applications such as quantum key distribution and quantum computing
2. Monogamy Principle: The monogamy of quantum correlations is a fundamental characteristic of quantum mechanics; understanding its manifestation in many-body systems is essential for quantum network construction
3. Practical Value: Cavity magnonic systems demonstrate tremendous potential in quantum technologies, including quantum storage and single magnon detection applications

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Most research focuses on quantum correlations under ideal conditions, lacking adequate consideration of thermal noise effects
2. Research on monogamy of quantum steering and entanglement in optomagnonic systems is relatively sparse
3. Lack of effective feedback mechanisms to counteract environmental decoherence effects

Research Motivation

To utilize coherent feedback techniques to enhance quantum correlations in hybrid qubit-cavity-magnon systems and systematically investigate their monogamy properties, providing theoretical guidance for practical quantum information processing.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Establishment: Proposes a complete theoretical model of a hybrid qubit-cavity optomagnonic system with coherent feedback loop
2. Monogamy Verification: First verification of CKW-type quantum steering monogamy inequality in optomagnonic systems
3. Feedback Enhancement Mechanism: Demonstrates that coherent feedback can significantly enhance entanglement and quantum steering in thermal environments
4. Multi-type Steering Classification: Identifies and classifies three distinct types of steerability: unidirectional, bidirectional, and no steering
5. Parameter Optimization Strategy: Provides specific methods to control quantum correlations by tuning reflection parameters and temperature

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate quantum entanglement and EPR steering in a three-mode hybrid system (cavity mode c, qubit mode q, magnon mode m), quantify their monogamy properties, and analyze the enhancement effects of coherent feedback on these quantum correlations.

Model Architecture

System Hamiltonian

The total Hamiltonian contains three main interactions:

H_T/ℏ = Ω_c c†c + Ω_q q†q + Ω_m m†m 
        + g_m c†c(m + m†) + g_q(cq† + c†q)
        + (E_L c†e^(-iΩ_L t) + E_L* ce^(iΩ_L t)) + uA(c†e^(iβ) + ce^(-iβ))

Where:

• First line: Free evolution terms
• Second line: Magnon-photon coupling and electric dipole interaction
• Third line: Driving field and coherent feedback terms

Quantum Langevin Equations

In the rotating frame, the system dynamics are described by:

dc̃/dt = -k_fb c̃ - ig̃_m m̃† - ig_q q̃ - iuAe^(iβ) + √(2k_c) c_in^fb
dq̃/dt = -Γq̃ - ig_q c̃ + √(2Γ) q_in  
dm̃/dt = -k_m m̃ - ig̃_m c̃† + √(2k_m) m_in

Covariance Matrix

The Gaussian state of the system is completely described by a 6×6 covariance matrix V, obtained by solving the Lyapunov equation:

QV + VQ^T = -D

Where Q is the drift matrix and D is the diffusion matrix.

Technical Innovations

1. Coherent Feedback Mechanism: Implements partial reflection of the output field back into the cavity through a beam splitter, with effective parameter k_fb = k_c(1-2ε cos(θ))
2. Blue-sideband Coupling: Selects appropriate detuning (Δ_fb ≈ Δ_q ≈ -Ω_m) to achieve parametric coupling and generate entanglement
3. Multi-mode Quantification: Simultaneously considers bipartite and tripartite quantum correlations, providing complete system description

Experimental Setup

System Parameters

Based on experimentally feasible parameter settings:

• Magnetic Field Strength: B₀ = 100 mT
• Magnon Frequency: Ωₘ = Γ₀B₀, where Γ₀ = 2π × 28 × 10⁹ Hz/T
• Cavity Parameters: Ωc/2π = 8.35 × 10⁹ Hz, kc/2π = 5 × 10⁶ Hz
• Qubit Parameters: Ωq/2π = 8.44 × 10⁹ Hz, Γ/2π = 0.2 × 10⁶ Hz
• YIG Sphere Parameters: Radius r = 100 μm, refractive index nr = 2.19

Evaluation Metrics

Entanglement Quantification

Using Logarithmic Negativity:

LN = max[0, -ln(2ϑ)]

Quantum Steering Quantification

Using Gaussian quantum steering measure:

G_{X→Y} = max[0, -∑_{j:ν̄^{XY/Y}_j < 1/2} ln(ν̄^{XY/X}_j)]

Tripartite Entanglement

Using Minimum Residual Contangle:

R_min = min[R_{i|jk}, R_{k|ij}, R_{j|ik}]

Comparative Analysis

Main comparison between cases with and without coherent feedback (ε = 0 vs ε = 0.86) in quantum correlation performance.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Feedback Enhancement Effects

1. Without Feedback (ε = 0): Magnon-qubit entanglement exists only at low temperatures, disappearing when T > 0.2K
2. With Feedback (ε = 0.86):
   • Enhanced magnon-qubit entanglement, persisting up to T > 0.6K
   • Emergence of cavity-magnon and cavity-qubit entanglement

Temperature Dependence

• Entanglement Thresholds: Entanglement of different mode pairs disappears at different temperature thresholds
  • Cavity-qubit: T > 0.5K
  • Cavity-magnon: T > 0.44K
  • Qubit-magnon: T > 0.6K

Steering Type Classification

1. Bidirectional Steering: Between cavity-qubit modes, satisfying Gc→q = Gq→c > 0
2. Unidirectional Steering:
   • Magnon→Cavity: Gm→c > 0, Gc→m = 0
   • Magnon→Qubit: Gm→q > 0, Gq→m = 0
3. No Steering: All steering vanishes at high temperatures

Monogamy Verification

Successfully verifies CKW-type monogamy inequality:

G_{k→(i,j)} ≥ G_{k→i} + G_{k→j}
G_{(i,j)→k} ≥ G_{i→k} + G_{j→k}

Tripartite Entanglement Analysis

• When reflection parameter ε < 0.3: R_min shows partial enhancement
• When ε > 0.3: R_min exhibits exponential growth
• Coherent feedback significantly enhances genuine tripartite entanglement

Related Work

Main Research Directions

1. Cavity Magnonics: Coherent interactions between magnons and photons/phonons
2. Quantum Steering: Implementation and applications of EPR steering in different physical systems
3. Monogamy of Quantum Correlations: Distribution patterns of quantum correlations in many-body systems

Advantages of This Work

1. First systematic investigation of quantum steering monogamy in optomagnonic systems
2. Proposes effective coherent feedback enhancement mechanism
3. Provides complete theoretical framework and numerical analysis

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Coherent Feedback Effectiveness: Coherent feedback loops can significantly enhance quantum entanglement and steering in hybrid systems under thermal environments
2. Monogamy Universality: CKW-type monogamy inequality is verified in optomagnonic systems
3. Steering Classification Completeness: System identifies three steering types and their temperature dependence
4. Parameter Control Feasibility: Quantum correlation strength can be effectively controlled by tuning reflection parameters

Limitations

1. Theoretical Model: Based on linear approximation, neglecting higher-order nonlinear effects
2. Experimental Parameters: Some parameter values may be difficult to control precisely in actual experiments
3. Environmental Model: Simplified thermal environment model may not fully describe actual decoherence processes

Future Directions

1. Consider nonlinear effects on quantum correlations
2. Investigate effects of other feedback mechanisms
3. Explore specific applications in quantum information processing tasks

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides complete theoretical framework from Hamiltonian to numerical results
2. Physical Insights: Deeply analyzes physical mechanisms and enhancement effects of coherent feedback
3. Experimental Relevance: Uses experimentally feasible parameters, enhancing practical value of results
4. Numerical Verification: Validates theoretical predictions through extensive numerical calculations

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Experimental Verification: Pure theoretical work without experimental validation
2. Parameter Sensitivity: Insufficient discussion of result sensitivity to parameter variations
3. Comparative Analysis: Limited comparison with other enhancement mechanisms

Impact

1. Academic Contribution: Provides important theoretical foundation for quantum correlation research in cavity magnonics
2. Application Prospects: Guides design of magnon-based quantum information processing devices
3. Method Generalization: Coherent feedback mechanism can be generalized to other hybrid quantum systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Information Processing: Quantum storage, quantum repeaters, and related applications
2. Precision Measurement: High-precision sensing based on quantum correlations
3. Fundamental Research: Experimental verification platform for monogamy of quantum correlations

References

The paper cites 71 related references, covering multiple important research fields including quantum entanglement, EPR steering, and cavity magnonics, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that makes important contributions at the intersection of cavity magnonics and quantum information. The paper features a complete theoretical framework and detailed numerical analysis, providing valuable theoretical guidance for related experimental research.