Approximating the coefficients of the Bessel functions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10370
• Title: Approximating the coefficients of the Bessel functions
• Author: Andrew Yao (MIT)
• Classification: math.CA math-ph math.CO math.MP math.OA math.PR
• Publication Date: October 14, 2024 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10370

Abstract

This paper establishes equivalence conditions between the coefficients of exponential holomorphic functions and asymptotic values of Dunkl bilinear forms for root systems of types A, BC, and D. The research establishes conditions for type A and D root systems under the asymptotic regime $|θN| → ∞$, as well as conditions for type BC root systems under the asymptotic regime $|θ_0N| → ∞, \frac{θ_1}{θ_0N} → c ∈ ℂ$. Simultaneously, the paper generalizes existing equivalence conditions and determines the asymptotic properties of Bessel function coefficients under the corresponding asymptotic regimes.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Dunkl Operator Theory: Dunkl operators are differential-difference operators introduced by Charles Dunkl in 1989, associated with finite reflection groups, with important applications in harmonic analysis, special function theory, and mathematical physics.
2. Asymptotic Behavior of Bessel Functions: Bessel functions associated with root systems are symmetric eigenfunctions of Dunkl operators. The asymptotic behavior of their coefficients is crucial for understanding the convergence properties of related probability measures.
3. Free Convolution Theory: Research has revealed that the asymptotic behavior of Bessel functions is closely related to free convolution in free probability theory, particularly in the high-temperature limit.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Refinement: Existing research primarily focuses on type A root systems, while a complete theoretical framework for types BC and D remains incomplete.
2. Methodological Unification: There is a need to develop unified methods for handling the behavior of different root system types under various asymptotic regimes.
3. Application Extension: To provide theoretical foundations for related problems in random matrix theory, free probability theory, and mathematical physics.

Core Contributions

1. Unified Framework: Establishes a unified theoretical framework for handling the asymptotics of Bessel function coefficients for types A, BC, and D root systems.
2. New Asymptotic Regimes: Provides the first complete analysis of equivalence conditions for type D root systems under the regime $θN → c ∈ ℂ$.
3. Equivalence Theorems: Proves the equivalence relationship between exponential function coefficients and asymptotic values of Dunkl bilinear forms (Main Theorem 1.1).
4. Free Convolution Convergence: Establishes results on weak convergence of related probability measures to free convolution.
5. Uniform Convergence of Bessel Functions: Proves uniform convergence of Bessel functions under specific conditions.
6. Operator Theory Generalization: Develops a general theoretical framework for graded operator rings acting on graded vector fields.

Detailed Methodology

Main Theoretical Framework

Root Systems and Dunkl Operators

The paper considers three classes of irreducible root systems:

• Type $A_{N-1}$: $A^{N-1} = \{e_i - e_j : i,j ∈ [N], i ≠ j\}$
• Type $BC_N$: Root systems containing both long and short roots
• Type $D_N$: $D^N = \{e_i ± e_j : i,j ∈ [N], i < j\}$

The corresponding Dunkl operators are: $D_i(A^{N-1}(θ)) = ∂_i + θ \sum_{j≠i} \frac{1-s_{ij}}{x_i - x_j}$

$D_i(BC^N(θ_0,θ_1)) = ∂_i + θ_1\frac{1-τ_i}{x_i} + θ_0\sum_{j≠i}\left(\frac{1-s_{ij}}{x_i-x_j} + \frac{1-τ_iτ_js_{ij}}{x_i+x_j}\right)$

Main Theorem Structure

Theorem 1.1 establishes three equivalence results:

(A) Type A Root Systems: Under $\lim_{N→∞}|θN| = ∞$,

• Condition (a): Specific asymptotic behavior of coefficients
• Condition (b): Asymptotic values of Dunkl bilinear forms

(B) Type BC Root Systems: Equivalence conditions under $\lim_{N→∞}|θ_0N| = ∞, \lim_{N→∞}\frac{θ_1}{θ_0N} = c$

(C) Type D Root Systems: Complete analysis including even and odd degree terms

Technical Innovations

1. Unified Proof Method

Develops a proof strategy applicable to all root system types, avoiding dependence on A-type-specific Jack polynomial theory.

2. Graded Operator Ring Theory

Establishes a general framework for graded operator rings $R = ⊕_{i≥0}R_i$ acting on graded vector spaces $V = ⊕_{i≥0}V_i$, with key concepts including:

• Invertibility definitions
• Eigenvector existence
• Commutativity conditions

3. Combinatorics of Non-crossing Partitions

Utilizes combinatorial properties of non-crossing partitions $NC(k)$ and $NC_{even}(k)$ to express asymptotic coefficients:

$\prod_{i=1}^{ℓ(ν)} \sum_{π∈NC(ν_i)} \prod_{B∈π} |B|c_{|B|}$

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

This paper is primarily theoretical work, with results verified through:

1. Special Case Verification: Validates known results for type A root systems
2. Limiting Case Analysis: Examines behavior under various parameter limits
3. Combinatorial Identity Verification: Confirms involved combinatorial formulas

Application Examples

The paper provides several important applications:

1. Vershik-Kerov Sequences: Reproduces results from AN21, BR25 and generalizes to type D
2. Exponentially Decaying Measures: Generalizes Bessel generating function theory from Yao25
3. Free Convolution Convergence: Establishes weak convergence results for measures

Experimental Results

Main Theoretical Results

Type A Root Systems ($|θN| → ∞$)

Theorem 6.1: For $k ≥ 1, λ,ν ∈ Γ[k], ℓ(λ) ≤ ℓ(ν)$:

$[p_λ, p_ν]_{A^{N-1}(θ)} = θ^{k-ℓ(ν)} \prod_{l=1}^{ℓ(ν)} ν_l π(ν) \left(\prod_{l=1}^{ℓ(ν)} x^{ν_l}\right) \prod_{i=1}^{ℓ(λ)} \sum_{π∈NC(λ_i)} \prod_{B∈π} x^{|B|} N^{k+ℓ(λ)-ℓ(ν)} + R(N,θ)$

Type BC Root Systems

Theorem 7.1: Analogous results under the corresponding asymptotic regime, involving factors $(1+c)^{o(π)}$, where $o(π)$ counts specific parity properties.

Complete Analysis of Type D Root Systems

Theorem 8.16: The odd-degree term analysis for type D root systems involves the Gamma function:

$[ep_λ, ep_ν]_{D^N(θ)} = \prod_{i=1}^{N-k} (1+2(i-1)θ) \times (\text{main term} + R(N,θ))$

Convergence Results

Free Convolution Convergence (Corollary 1.5)

Under appropriate conditions: $\lim_{N→∞} E_{a∼μ^{A^{N-1}(θ)}_{a^{(N)},b^{(N)}}} \left[\sum_{i=1}^N \frac{1}{N}δ\left(\frac{a_i}{θN}\right)\right] = μ$ where $μ$ is the free convolution of $μ_a$ and $μ_b$.

Uniform Convergence (Theorem 10.9)

Under Vershik-Kerov sequence conditions, Bessel functions converge uniformly on compact sets to explicit limit functions.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Dunkl Operator Theory: Dun89, Opd93 established foundational theory
2. Type A Results: BGCG22, Yao25 addressed type A root systems
3. Type BC Results: Xu25 studied specific cases of type BC
4. Jack Polynomial Methods: BF97, BF98, OO97 employed Jack polynomial techniques

Innovations in This Paper

1. Methodological Unification: Avoids dependence on Jack polynomials, develops methods applicable to all types
2. Complete Type D Theory: Provides the first complete analysis of type D root systems
3. General Framework: Establishes general theory for graded operator rings

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Establishes complete theory of asymptotic properties of Bessel function coefficients for three root system classes
2. Proves equivalence between coefficient conditions and asymptotic values of Dunkl bilinear forms
3. Establishes deep connections with free convolution theory
4. Develops technical frameworks with broad applicability

Limitations

1. Non-negativity Assumptions: Some results require non-negativity assumptions on multiplicity functions
2. Convergence Conditions: Uniform convergence results require strong moment conditions
3. Computational Complexity: Practical computation of asymptotic coefficients remains complex

Future Directions

1. Extension to Other Root Systems: Extend to exceptional root systems
2. Removing Non-negativity Restrictions: Develop theory applicable to complex parameters
3. Numerical Methods: Develop efficient numerical computation methods
4. Physical Applications: Explore applications in statistical mechanics and quantum many-body systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Establishes a complete and profound theoretical framework
2. Methodological Innovation: Develops unified methods independent of specific polynomial theory
3. Result Completeness: Covers all major root system types and asymptotic regimes
4. Technical Rigor: Proofs are detailed and technically sound
5. Broad Applicability: Results have important applications across multiple mathematical branches

Weaknesses

1. High Technical Threshold: Requires deep background in harmonic analysis and special function theory
2. Computational Complexity: Practical applications remain computationally challenging
3. Physical Intuition: Lacks intuitive physical interpretation of results

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important advances to Dunkl operator theory
2. Methodological Value: Developed technical frameworks have broad applicability
3. Cross-disciplinary Impact: Connects harmonic analysis, probability theory, and mathematical physics
4. Foundation for Future Research: Establishes foundation for further research in related fields

Applicable Scenarios

1. Random Matrix Theory: Asymptotic analysis in high-temperature limits
2. Free Probability Theory: Limit theorems in non-commutative probability spaces
3. Mathematical Physics: Integrable systems and quantum many-body theory
4. Combinatorial Mathematics: Research on non-crossing partitions and related combinatorial structures

This paper represents an important advance in Dunkl operator theory and asymptotic analysis of related Bessel functions. By establishing a unified theoretical framework, it not only resolves existing problems but also opens new directions for future research. Its technical innovations and theoretical depth make it a significant contribution to the field.