Cosmological Implications of Thermodynamic Split Conjecture

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10441
• Title: Cosmological Implications of Thermodynamic Split Conjecture
• Author: Oem Trivedi (Vanderbilt University)
• Classification: gr-qc astro-ph.CO hep-th
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10441

Abstract

Building upon preliminary work on the Thermodynamic Split Conjecture (TSC), which posits that the thermodynamic properties of black holes and cosmological horizons are generally inequivalent, this paper investigates the implications of this separation for the Gibbons-Hawking temperature and its role in cosmology. The authors examine critical results in early and late-time cosmology, demonstrating that many important phenomena—such as eternal inflation, vacuum tunneling, quantum breaking, and primordial black holes—may undergo significant modifications. The analysis further reveals that small corrections to horizon thermodynamics driven by TSC may subtly alter Friedmann dynamics, potentially contributing to the resolution of the H₀ and S₈ tension problems.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The fundamental question addressed in this research is: Can black hole thermodynamic laws be directly transplanted to cosmological horizons? Traditionally, cosmology widely adopts the Gibbons-Hawking temperature T_GH = H/2π and the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy formula S = A/4G, both borrowed from black hole physics.

Research Significance

The importance of this question is manifested in:

1. Theoretical Foundation: If TSC holds, many cosmological conclusions based on GH temperature require re-examination
2. Observational Tensions: Current cosmology faces observational issues such as H₀ and S₈ tensions
3. Quantum Gravity: Provides new perspectives for understanding quantum gravity's role in cosmology

Limitations of Existing Approaches

The main limitations of existing methods include:

• Lack of rigorous theoretical foundation to justify the applicability of black hole entropy formulas in cosmology
• Overlooking fundamental structural differences between cosmological and black hole spacetimes
• Absence of independent verification of cosmological "native" thermodynamic laws

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Establishment: Systematically analyzes via the BKE criterion (B-boundary conditions, K-Killing vectors, E-entropy functional) why black hole thermodynamics cannot be directly applied to cosmology
2. Generalized Parameters: Introduces cosmologically native thermodynamic parameters:
   • Effective temperature: T_eff(H) = χ(H)H/2π
   • Cosmological entropy: S_cos(H) = αH^(-p)
   • Effective diffusion coefficient: D_eff(H) = β(H)H³/8π²
3. Early Universe Revisited: Demonstrates how TSC affects eternal inflation, Hawking-Moss transitions, primordial black hole formation, and other key processes
4. Observational Tension Resolution: Proposes that small corrections driven by TSC may help alleviate H₀ and S₈ tensions
5. Observational Testing Scheme: Recommends testing cosmological thermodynamic laws through observational methods such as 21cm intensity mapping

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The core task of this paper is to re-examine cosmological conclusions based on Gibbons-Hawking temperature and establish a more general framework to describe the thermodynamic properties of cosmological horizons.

BKE Criterion Framework

The authors propose the BKE criterion to determine when black hole-type entropy formulas can be applied:

B (Boundary Conditions): Existence of asymptotic boundaries or conserved charges

Qi = ∮_{S^{d-2}_∞} *Ji,  dQi/dt = 0

K (Killing Vectors): Existence of global timelike Killing vectors

∇_{(a}χ_{b)} = 0,  χ²|_{H+} = 0,  ⟨O(t+iβ)O(0)⟩ = ⟨O(t)O(0)⟩

E (Entropy Functional): Existence of universal near-horizon regions

S_macro = A(H+)/4GN + S^{(higher)}_{Wald} + Sq

For black holes: B·K·E = 1·1·1 = 1 For cosmology: B·K·E = 0·0·0 = 0

Generalized Parameter Setup

Based on TSC, the authors introduce three key empirical parameters:

1. Effective Temperature:

   T_eff(H) = χ(H) · H/2π
   

   
   where χ(H) encodes deviations from standard GH thermodynamics
2. Cosmological Entropy:

   S_cos(H) = αH^(-p)
   

   
   where α is a dimensional coefficient and p is an exponent determined by observations
3. Effective Diffusion Coefficient:

   D_eff(H) = β(H) · H³/8π²
   

   
   where β(H) describes deviations from white noise statistics

Early Universe Impact Analysis

Eternal Inflation

In the standard picture, the condition for eternal inflation is:

H²/2π ≳ |V'|/3H²

Under the TSC framework, the condition becomes:

β(H) · H⁴/(2π)² ≳ V'²/9H⁴

When β(H) < 1, noise is suppressed, and many potentials previously supporting eternal inflation no longer satisfy the condition; when β(H) > 1, diffusion is enhanced, making eternal inflation more prevalent.

Hawking-Moss Transitions

The standard transition rate is:

Γ_HM ∝ exp[ΔS_dS] = exp[8π²M²_Pl(1/H²(φ_top) - 1/H²(φ_min))]

Under the TSC framework:

Γ_HM ∝ exp[α(H^(-p)(φ_top) - H^(-p)(φ_min))]

The transition rate is highly sensitive to the entropy exponent p: when p < 2, transitions are suppressed; when p > 2, transitions are enhanced.

Primordial Black Hole Formation

In the standard picture, the variance of field fluctuations is:

⟨δφ²⟩ ∼ (H/2π)²

Under the TSC framework:

⟨δφ²⟩ ∼ D_eff · Δt ∼ β(H) · H³/8π² · H^(-1)

The value of β(H) directly affects the production efficiency of primordial black holes.

Late-Time Cosmology and Observational Tensions

Modified Friedmann Equation

By substituting TSC parameters into the Clausius relation of horizon thermodynamics, a modified Friedmann equation is obtained:

Ḣ = -8π²/χpα · (ρ+p)H^(p-2)

When (χ,p,α) = (1,2,8π²M²_Pl), the standard GR result is recovered.

H₀ Tension Alleviation Mechanism

Introducing a small correction term:

H²(z) = H²₀E²_ΛCDM(z) + F(H(z);α,p,χ)

where F(H) = ε_b(H/H_b)^m H²₀.

When m ≳ 2 and |ε_b| ∼ several ×10^(-2), it is possible to:

• Increase H(z) by several percent during recombination
• Reduce the acoustic horizon r_s
• Infer larger H₀ values at fixed BAO distances

S₈ Tension Alleviation Mechanism

A positive F term in late times enhances the friction term 2Hδ̇_m, suppressing structure growth:

δ̈_m + 2Hδ̇_m - 4πG_eff(a,k)ρ_m δ_m = 0

This naturally leads to a reduction in S₈ = σ₈(Ω_m0/0.3)^(1/2).

Observational Testing Schemes

21cm Intensity Mapping

The authors propose 21cm observations as a key tool for testing TSC:

• 21cm signals span most of cosmic history (z ∼ 30 to reionization)
• Can measure the statistical properties of super-Hubble modes
• By measuring variance and noise kernels, D_eff(H) can be inferred
• Subsequently reconstruct T_eff(H) and S_cos(H)

Other Observational Constraints

• CMB acoustic structure
• Big Bang nucleosynthesis
• Baryon acoustic oscillations
• Supernova observations
• Gravitational lensing
• Redshift space distortions

Related Work

Black Hole Thermodynamics Foundations

• String theory derivations of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy formula
• Microscopic state counting in AdS/CFT duality
• Quantum entropy function methods

Cosmological Thermodynamics

• Derivation of Gibbons-Hawking temperature
• Relationship between horizon thermodynamics and Friedmann equations
• Cai-Kim temperature formula

Observational Tension Problems

• Various solutions to H₀ tension
• S₈ tension and structure formation
• Early dark energy models

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Consistency: TSC reveals theoretical issues with directly applying black hole thermodynamics to cosmology
2. Observational Impact: Key processes in the early universe depend on the assumed GH temperature
3. Tension Alleviation: Small corrections driven by TSC may help resolve observational tensions
4. Testing Schemes: 21cm observations provide pathways to verify cosmological thermodynamic laws

Limitations

1. Parametrization Dependence: Results depend on specific parametrization forms
2. Observational Constraints: More observational data are needed to constrain new parameters
3. Theoretical Development: Deeper quantum gravity theory is needed for support

Future Directions

1. Specific Models: Connect the TSC framework with specific quantum gravity models
2. Observational Programs: Design dedicated observational projects to test cosmological thermodynamic laws
3. Numerical Simulations: Develop cosmological numerical codes incorporating TSC effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Conceptual Innovation: TSC provides a new framework for reconsidering cosmological thermodynamics
2. Mathematical Rigor: The BKE criterion provides explicit standards for judging thermodynamic applicability
3. Broad Application: Systematically analyzes TSC's impact on various cosmological processes
4. Observational Relevance: Connects theoretical predictions with observational tension problems
5. Testing Schemes: Proposes concrete observational testing methods

Weaknesses

1. Parameter Freedom: Introduces multiple new parameters, potentially leading to over-parametrization
2. Microscopic Mechanisms: Lacks specific microscopic physical mechanisms generating TSC
3. Numerical Verification: Requires more numerical calculations to verify theoretical predictions
4. Alternative Explanations: Observational tensions may have other explanations requiring stricter comparisons

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides a new theoretical framework for cosmological thermodynamics
2. Observational Significance: Offers new perspectives for resolving current observational tensions
3. Interdisciplinary Nature: Connects quantum gravity, thermodynamics, and observational cosmology
4. Future Research: Indicates directions for subsequent theoretical and observational investigations

Applicable Scenarios

• Early universe physics research
• Observational cosmology data analysis
• Quantum gravity phenomenology studies
• 21cm cosmology observation planning

References

The paper contains 157 references covering important works in dark energy, dark matter, cosmological tensions, black hole physics, string theory, and other fields, reflecting the comprehensiveness and cutting-edge nature of the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a theoretically significant paper that proposes a new perspective for re-examining the foundations of cosmological thermodynamics. While further theoretical development and observational verification are needed, the TSC framework provides valuable new insights for understanding quantum gravity's role in cosmology, particularly showing potential in addressing current observational tension problems.