Gravitational and other shifts of neutron, hydrogen, antihydrogen, muonium, and positronium whispering gallery and gravitational state interference patterns

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10536
• Title: Gravitational and other shifts of neutron, hydrogen, antihydrogen, muonium, and positronium whispering gallery and gravitational state interference patterns
• Authors: V.V. Nesvizhevsky, J.A. Pioquinto, K. Schreiner, S. Baeßler, P. Crivelli, E. Widmann
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10536

Abstract

This paper investigates whispering gallery states (WGS) of neutrons, hydrogen atoms, antihydrogen atoms, muonium, and positronium, and their interference pattern shifts under external fields such as gravitational fields. Based on recently observed shifts of neutron whispering gallery interference patterns under external magnetic field gradients, the authors propose a universal optimization method for designing WGS experiments for various particles, with particular focus on measuring gravitational shifts. This research provides novel quantum interference measurement techniques for fundamental physics experiments, applicable to measuring the gravitational constant and constraining the neutron charge.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Quantization of whispering gallery effects: While whispering gallery phenomena are ubiquitous in wave phenomena such as acoustic and electromagnetic waves, quantum whispering gallery states for massive particles have received relatively limited study
2. Gravitational quantum states research: Gravitational quantum states (GQS) have proven capable of providing high-precision fundamental physics measurements, but are limited by particle velocity and lifetime
3. Antimatter gravitational interactions: The gravitational properties of antimatter represent an important frontier in contemporary fundamental physics

Research Significance

1. Fundamental physics measurements: WGS methods provide new pathways for measuring the gravitational constant G and constraining the neutron charge
2. Antimatter research: Provides novel measurement techniques for antimatter experiments such as GBAR and ASACUSA
3. Quantum reflection mechanisms: Deepens understanding of quantum reflection processes between atoms and surfaces

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Observation time constraints: Traditional GQS methods require extended observation times, limiting the velocity range of usable particles
2. Technical challenges: WGS observation of exotic particles such as antihydrogen atoms faces significant technical hurdles
3. Precision limitations: Existing methods have limited precision in measuring certain fundamental physics parameters

Core Contributions

1. Proposes a universal WGS experiment optimization method: Establishes a systematic parameter optimization framework applicable to neutrons, hydrogen atoms, antihydrogen atoms, muonium, and positronium
2. Designs WGS experimental schemes for multiple particle types: Proposes specific experimental designs and parameter selections tailored to the characteristics of different particles
3. Evaluates feasibility of gravitational shift measurements: Provides detailed analysis of measurement precision and experimental conditions for gravitational shifts in WGS of various particles
4. Provides fundamental physics applications: Demonstrates the potential of WGS methods for measuring the gravitational constant and constraining the neutron charge
5. Establishes theoretical calculation framework: Develops quantum mechanical calculation methods for WGS interference patterns

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The core task of this research is to design and optimize whispering gallery state experiments for various particles to observe and measure interference pattern shifts under external fields such as gravity. Inputs include particle beam parameters, mirror geometry, and material properties; outputs include interference patterns and measurement precision estimates.

Theoretical Framework

WGS Fundamental Principles

The physical mechanism of whispering gallery state formation is based on:

1. Centrifugal acceleration: $a_{WGS} = \frac{V^2_{WGS}}{R_{WGS}}$
2. Quantum state energy: $E_{WGS} \sim \frac{\hbar}{\tau_{WGS}}$
3. State formation time: $\tau_{WGS} \sim \left(\frac{2\hbar}{m \cdot a^2_{WGS}}\right)^{1/3}$
4. Characteristic length scale: $l_{WGS} \sim \left(\frac{\hbar^2}{2 \cdot a_{WGS} \cdot m}\right)^{1/3}$

Optimization Criteria

Key constraint conditions include:

• Energy limit: $\gamma_{WGS} \cdot E_{WGS} \sim E_{lim}$
• Quantum reflection probability: $(P_{QR}(E_{lim}))^{\beta_{WGS}} \sim 0.5$
• Quasi-classical reflection number: $\beta_{WGS} = t_{WGS}/\tau_{WGS}$

Calculation Methods

Wave Function Evolution

The Schrödinger equation describes particle evolution in the potential field: $V(x) = mgx + V_{mirror}(x) + V_{absorber}(x)$

where the first term represents the gravitational potential (centrifugal potential in WGS), and the latter two terms represent mirror and absorber potentials respectively.

Interference Pattern Calculation

Interference patterns are obtained by calculating probability current density: $F(x,v) = n(v)v\frac{k_0}{z}\left|\tilde{\psi}\left(\frac{k_0x}{z}\right)\right|^2$

Technical Innovations

1. Unified optimization framework: Establishes a universal parameter optimization method applicable to particles of different masses and lifetimes
2. Multi-particle adaptation: Provides specialized optimization for each particle type's unique properties (critical energy, lifetime, velocity distribution)
3. Gravitational effect enhancement: Increases the relative contribution of gravitational effects by reducing centrifugal acceleration
4. Precise quantum reflection modeling: Employs van der Waals-Casimir/Polder potential to accurately describe atom-surface interactions

Experimental Setup

Neutron WGS Experiments

• Facilities: ILL's PF1B/PF2/D17 instruments
• Neutron source: Very cold neutrons (VCN) and ultracold neutrons (UCN)
• Mirror: Silicon mirror, length 30 cm - 1 m
• Detection: Position-sensitive detector, spatial resolution ~2 mm

Hydrogen Atom WGS Experiments

• Collaboration: GRASIAN collaboration (Vienna and Turku)
• Atom source: Low-temperature hydrogen atom beam, temperature ~6 K
• Velocity: ~120 m/s
• Mirror: Quartz material, radius ~160 m

Antihydrogen Atom WGS Experiments

• Related experiments: GBAR, ASACUSA and other CERN experiments
• Velocity range: 5×10³ - 10⁵ m/s
• Detection method: Annihilation product detection
• Technical challenges: Antihydrogen cooling and beam control

Muonium and Positronium Experiments

• Muonium: Lifetime ~2.2×10⁻⁶ s, velocity ~2200 m/s
• Positronium: Excited state lifetime up to 10⁻⁵ s, velocity ~5×10⁴ m/s
• Detection challenges: Technical difficulties arising from short lifetime and high velocity

Experimental Results

Neutron WGS Gravitational Shift

• Expected precision: Measurement precision for gravitational constant G achievable at 10⁻³ level
• Neutron charge constraint: Can constrain neutron charge to ~10⁻²² e
• Observation time: UCN storage time up to 20 s

Hydrogen Atom WGS

• Gravitational shift ratio: g/a_WGS ~ 1.1×10⁻¹
• Interference fringes: Clear interference patterns observable
• Time resolution: Requires 0.5-3 ms chopper opening time
• Spatial resolution: Requires 50-300 μm position resolution

Antihydrogen Atom WGS

• Velocity adaptability: Can accommodate antihydrogen velocities up to 10⁵ m/s
• Gravitational shift: Relative shift ~1.8×10⁻³
• Statistical precision: Gravitational shift measurable at several percent precision

Muonium and Positronium

• Muonium gravitational shift: g/a_WGS ~ 10⁻⁵, approaching the sensitivity limit of neutron experiments
• Positronium advantage: Increased excited state lifetime can significantly improve measurement precision
• Technical challenges: Detection schemes require further development

Related Work

Gravitational Quantum State Research

• GQS discovery: First observation of neutron gravitational quantum states by Nesvizhevsky et al.
• Interference measurements: COW effect and gravitational quantum states provide experimental foundation for quantum effects of gravity
• Precision measurements: GQS has been applied to search for new physics beyond the Standard Model

Quantum Reflection Research

• Theoretical foundation: Quantum reflection mechanism of van der Waals-Casimir/Polder interactions
• Experimental observation: Quantum reflection of hydrogen atoms, helium atoms, etc. has been extensively studied
• Antimatter: Quantum reflection of antihydrogen atoms theoretically predicted but not yet directly observed

Whispering Gallery Effects

• Classical whispering gallery: Long history of research on whispering gallery effects in acoustic and electromagnetic waves
• Quantum whispering gallery: Relatively recent study of whispering gallery states of electrons, neutrons, and other particles
• Application expansion: Potential applications from fundamental physics to precision measurements

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method feasibility: Establishes WGS experiment optimization methods applicable to multiple particle types
2. Gravitational measurement: Neutron WGS can achieve 10⁻³ precision measurement of G and 10⁻²² e constraint on neutron charge
3. Antimatter research: Antihydrogen WGS provides new pathways for studying gravitational properties of antimatter
4. Quantum reflection: Provides experimental tools for deeper understanding of particle-surface quantum interactions

Limitations

1. Technical challenges: WGS observation of muonium and positronium faces significant technical difficulties
2. Lifetime constraints: Gravitational shift measurement of short-lived particles is extremely challenging
3. Material limitations: Need to find mirror materials with higher effective critical energy
4. Precision limitations: Systematic error analysis for certain measurements requires further refinement

Future Directions

1. Experimental implementation: Implement proposed schemes at ILL, GRASIAN, GBAR and other experimental facilities
2. Technical improvements: Develop higher-precision detectors and more stable particle beams
3. Material research: Search for and develop mirror materials suitable for different particles
4. Theoretical refinement: Further perfect quantum mechanical descriptions of WGS and systematic error analysis

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Establishes a comprehensive WGS theoretical framework and calculation methods
2. Experimental feasibility: Provides detailed experimental parameters and feasibility analysis
3. Broad applicability: Encompasses multiple particle systems from neutrons to antimatter
4. Precision assessment: Provides detailed measurement precision and sensitivity estimates
5. Clear presentation: Well-structured paper with sufficient technical detail

Weaknesses

1. Experimental verification: Most results are based on theoretical calculations, lacking experimental verification
2. Systematic errors: Relatively limited analysis of systematic errors
3. Technical details: Certain experimental technical details (such as detector design) require further refinement
4. Cost-benefit analysis: Insufficient discussion of implementation costs and technical difficulty

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides novel experimental methods for fundamental physics research
2. Practical significance: Applicable to important fields such as gravitational constant measurement and antimatter research
3. Technology advancement: Promotes development of quantum interference measurement techniques
4. International collaboration: Facilitates cooperation among multiple international experimental collaborations

Application Scenarios

1. Fundamental physics research: Gravitational constant measurement, equivalence principle testing
2. Antimatter research: Measurement of gravitational properties of antihydrogen atoms
3. Surface science: Quantum reflection mechanism research
4. Precision measurement: New physics searches and fundamental constant determination

References

This paper cites 131 relevant references, covering:

• Pioneering work on gravitational quantum states
• Theoretical and experimental research on quantum reflection
• Classical and quantum research on whispering gallery effects
• Recent advances in antimatter physics
• Development of precision measurement techniques

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that systematically develops theoretical frameworks and experimental schemes for whispering gallery states of multiple particle types. Although primarily based on theoretical analysis, it provides a solid foundation for future experimental research and possesses significant academic value and application prospects in fundamental physics and precision measurement.