Quantum Radar: An Engineering Perspective

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10699
• Title: Quantum Radar: An Engineering Perspective
• Authors: Murat Can KARAKOÇ, Özgün ERSOY, Ahmad SALMANOGHLI KHIAVI, Asaf Behzat ŞAHİN
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10699

Abstract

Quantum radar represents an emerging technological paradigm that leverages entanglement and quantum correlations to overcome the limitations of classical detection in noisy and lossy environments. By utilizing microwave entanglement generated through superconducting devices such as Josephson parametric amplifiers, transducers, and traveling-wave parametric amplifiers, quantum radar systems achieve enhanced detection sensitivity, lower error probabilities, and greater robustness against thermal noise and interference. This review provides a comprehensive overview of the field, beginning with the theoretical foundations of quantum illumination and extending to the generation of microwave-band entanglement. The paper further investigates critical components of quantum radar subsystems, including quantum transducers, amplification chains, and receiver architectures that form the backbone of practical designs. Finally, it surveys the latest experimental systems in the microwave domain, highlighting proof-of-concept demonstrations and their transition from conceptual frameworks to laboratory implementations.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Classical radar systems face performance bottlenecks when detecting weak reflected targets in environments with strong thermal or electronic noise, particularly in scenarios with extremely low signal-to-noise ratios where conventional methods struggle to effectively distinguish target signals from background noise.

Importance Analysis

1. Military Application Requirements: Modern battlefield environments demand high detection performance under strong interference and stealth target conditions
2. Technology Development Trends: The maturation of quantum technologies provides new pathways to transcend classical physical limits
3. Theoretical Breakthroughs: Quantum illumination protocols have theoretically demonstrated advantages over classical approaches

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Classical Radar: Constrained by shot noise limits and thermal noise interference
2. Optical Quantum Radar: While proof-of-concept exists, effective implementation in practical microwave frequencies remains lacking
3. Technical Challenges: Generation, maintenance, and measurement of microwave quantum states remain insufficiently mature

Research Motivation

This paper aims to systematically analyze the implementation pathways of microwave quantum radar from an engineering perspective, bridging the gap between theoretical research and practical applications, and providing guidance for the practical deployment of quantum radar technology.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Integration: Systematically organized the theoretical foundations of quantum illumination, entanglement generation, and quantum correlation measurement
2. Technology Roadmap Analysis: In-depth analysis of three primary microwave entanglement generation schemes: electro-optomechanical transducers, optoelectronic transducers, and Josephson devices
3. System Architecture Design: Proposed a complete quantum radar subsystem architecture, including quantum transmitters, atmospheric channel modeling, and quantum receivers
4. Experimental Progress Survey: Comprehensive review of recent experimental advances and technical challenges in microwave quantum radar
5. Engineering Implementation Guidance: Practical analysis of the advantages, disadvantages, and applicable scenarios for various technical approaches

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Construct a microwave quantum radar system capable of achieving detection performance that surpasses classical limits in noisy and lossy environments. The system input is the target to be detected, and the output is a quantum-enhanced estimate of the target presence probability.

Core Technical Architecture

1. Entanglement Generation Schemes

Electro-Optomechanical (EOM) Transducer:

• Utilizes mechanical oscillators as coupling media between optical and microwave cavities
• Total Hamiltonian: $H_{total} = H_{OC} + H_{MR} + H_{MC} + H_{OC-MR} + H_{MC-MR}$
• Quantum fluctuations handled through linearization approximation: $a_c = A_s + \delta a_c$

Optoelectronic Transducer:

• Employs photodetectors and varactor diodes for optical-to-microwave conversion
• Adjustable coupling strength: $g_{op} = \sqrt{\frac{\omega_{eg}\alpha_c^2}{2\omega_c\varepsilon_0 m_{eff}}}$
• Supports entanglement maintenance at room temperature operation

Josephson Parametric Amplifier (JPA):

• Achieves parametric amplification through nonlinear inductance of Josephson junctions
• Hamiltonian: $H_{JPA} = \omega_0 a^\dagger a + \frac{\Lambda}{6}(a^\dagger + a)^4$
• Generates two-mode squeezed vacuum state (TMSV)

2. Quantum Correlation Measurement

Entanglement Criteria:

• Peres-Horodecki-Simon criterion: $\lambda_S > 1$ indicates entanglement
• Symplectic eigenvalue criterion: $2\eta \geq 1$ indicates separability
• Quantum discord: $D(\rho_{AB}) = S(\rho_B) - S(\rho_{AB}) + S_{min}(A|B)$

3. Atmospheric Channel Modeling

Cascaded beam splitter model describes atmospheric attenuation and target scattering: $\hat{c}_a(\omega) = e^{[jk_{atm}-\kappa_{atm}(\omega)]R}\hat{c}_w(\omega) + j\sqrt{2\kappa_{atm}(\omega)}\int_0^R dz e^{[jk_{atm}+\kappa_{atm}(\omega)](R-z)}\hat{b}(\omega,z)$

Technical Innovations

1. Multi-Technology Route Comparison: First systematic comparison of performance across EOM, optoelectronic, and Josephson entanglement generation schemes
2. Temperature Robustness Analysis: In-depth investigation of entanglement preservation capability across different schemes in high-temperature environments
3. Digital Receiver Design: Proposed FPGA-based real-time quantum signal processing architecture
4. Atmospheric Effects Modeling: Established comprehensive decoherence model for quantum state transmission through atmosphere

Experimental Setup

Experimental Platform

• Temperature Environment: Dilution refrigerator (10 mK) + intermediate temperature stage (4K) + room temperature (300K)
• Device Configuration: JPA/JPC/JTWPA + HEMT amplifier + low-noise amplifier
• Signal Processing: High-speed ADC (1 GS/s) + FPGA + digital post-processing

Evaluation Metrics

1. Entanglement Measures: Symplectic eigenvalues, quantum discord
2. Detection Performance: Signal-to-noise ratio improvement, error probability
3. Environmental Robustness: Temperature sensitivity, loss tolerance

Key Parameters

• Coupling Strength: $g_1 = \sqrt{\frac{\alpha_c^2\omega_m}{2\varepsilon_0 m\omega_c}}$
• Detuning Frequency: $\Delta_c = \omega_c - \omega_{oc}$, $\Delta_\omega = \omega_\omega - \omega_{o\omega}$
• Decay Coefficients: $\kappa_c$, $\kappa_\omega$, $\gamma_m$

Experimental Results

Entanglement Generation Performance

EOM Transducer:

• Operating temperature limit: < 1200 mK
• Mechanical oscillator frequency dependence: $\omega_m = 2\pi \times 10^6$ Hz
• High temperature sensitivity, but excellent conversion efficiency

Optoelectronic Transducer:

• Supports high-temperature operation: up to 3500 mK
• Adjustable coupling parameters: optimal performance at $\mu_c = 0.0002$
• Loses entanglement above 1000 mK after atmospheric transmission

Josephson Devices:

• Significant compression achieved at gain coefficient 0.5
• Wigner function displays strong non-classical features
• Bandwidth performance: JPA (MHz-level) < JPC < JTWPA (GHz-level)

System Integration Performance

Signal-to-Noise Ratio Improvement:

• Excellent agreement between theoretical predictions and experimental results
• Maintains 20% SNR improvement even under 14 dB loss and 75 dB noise background
• Quantum correlations provide measurable advantages even when initial entanglement is completely destroyed

Environmental Adaptability:

• Verification of atmospheric attenuation modeling accuracy
• Path loss analysis for different orbital altitudes
• Turbulence effects modeled through C²ₙ parameter

Related Work

Theoretical Foundations

• Lloyd (2008): Proposal of quantum illumination protocol
• Tan et al. (2008): Gaussian state quantum illumination theory
• Barzanjeh et al. (2015): Microwave quantum illumination theoretical framework

Experimental Progress

• Chang et al. (2019): Quantum-enhanced noise radar
• Barzanjeh et al. (2020): Digital receiver implementation
• Livreri et al. (2022): JTWPA quantum radar demonstration

Technology Development

• Maturation of superconducting quantum devices
• Advances in cryogenic amplification technology
• Enhanced digital signal processing capabilities

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Technical Feasibility: Microwave quantum radar has evolved from theoretical concept to laboratory-implementable technology
2. Performance Advantages: Maintains performance advantages over classical radar even in strong noise and high-loss environments
3. Engineering Challenges: Primary bottlenecks lie in entanglement generation, maintenance, and measurement technologies

Limitations Analysis

1. Temperature Requirements: Most schemes still require extremely low-temperature environments
2. Bandwidth Limitations: Current device operating bandwidth remains relatively limited
3. Distance Constraints: Atmospheric effects limit effective detection range
4. Complexity: System complexity far exceeds classical radar

Future Development Directions

1. Device Optimization: Develop quantum devices with higher operating temperatures and broader bandwidth
2. System Integration: Achieve compact, practical quantum radar systems
3. Application Expansion: Explore applications in satellite quantum communication and environmental monitoring
4. Standard Establishment: Establish performance evaluation and testing standards for quantum radar

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Comprehensiveness: Systematically covers theoretical, technical, and experimental aspects of quantum radar
2. Engineering-Oriented: Practical analysis of various technical approaches with strong guidance value
3. Deep Analysis: Detailed mathematical modeling and physical analysis of critical technical details
4. Cutting-Edge: Timely summary of latest progress and technology trends in the field

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Data: Some analyses based on theoretical simulations lack sufficient experimental verification
2. Cost Analysis: Insufficient discussion of quantum radar system costs and economic feasibility
3. Comparative Study: Quantitative comparison with advanced classical radar technologies insufficient
4. Standardization: Lack of unified performance evaluation standards and testing methods

Impact Assessment

Academic Value:

• Provides important survey reference for quantum radar field
• Promotes integration of theoretical research and engineering practice
• Advances establishment of related technical standards

Practical Value:

• Provides practical design guidance for engineering technicians
• Accelerates industrialization of quantum radar technology
• Promotes civil-military fusion technology development

Reproducibility:

• Provides detailed theoretical derivations and parameter settings
• Experimental schemes demonstrate good repeatability
• Establishes solid foundation for subsequent research

Applicable Scenarios

1. Military Applications: Stealth target detection, electronic warfare environments
2. Civil Radar: Weather detection, traffic monitoring
3. Space Applications: Satellite communication, deep space exploration
4. Scientific Research: Quantum physics experiments, precision measurement

References

1. Lloyd, S. "Enhanced sensitivity of photodetection via quantum illumination." Science 321, 1463–1465 (2008).
2. Barzanjeh, S. et al. "Microwave quantum illumination." Physical Review Letters 114, 080503 (2015).
3. Chang, C. et al. "Quantum-enhanced noise radar." Applied Physics Letters 114 (2019).
4. Barzanjeh, S. et al. "Microwave quantum illumination using a digital receiver." Science Advances 6, eabb0451 (2020).
5. Zhang, Z. et al. "Entanglement-enhanced sensing in a lossy and noisy environment." Physical Review Letters 114, 110506 (2015).

Summary: This paper provides a high-quality engineering technology review for the quantum radar field, systematically analyzing the complete technical chain from theoretical foundations to experimental implementation. While improvements remain possible in certain aspects, its comprehensiveness and practicality make it an important reference in the field, with significant value in advancing quantum radar technology development.