Higher-Order Fluctuations: Unveiling the Final Frontier of QCD at the LHC with ALICE

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2510.10847
• Title: Higher-Order Fluctuations: Unveiling the Final Frontier of QCD at the LHC with ALICE
• Author: Ilya Fokin (on behalf of the ALICE Collaboration)
• Classification: nucl-ex (Nuclear Experimental Physics)
• Publication Date: October 12, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10847v1

Abstract

Lattice QCD (LQCD) calculations predict that chiral symmetry is restored through a smooth crossover transition between the quark-gluon plasma and the hadronic resonance gas (HRG) under conditions of vanishing net baryon density, which are realized in heavy-ion collisions at the LHC. Under these conditions, net baryon number cumulants calculated using HRG and LQCD partition functions show good agreement up to third order. However, starting from the fourth-order cumulant, LQCD results are significantly lower than the corresponding HRG results. This provides a unique opportunity to experimentally verify the complete QCD partition function through measurements of fourth-order cumulants of the net proton number distribution.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

This research addresses the experimental verification of the QCD phase transition, specifically:

1. Experimental Evidence for Chiral Phase Transition: Searching for experimental signals of the chiral phase transition at LHC energies
2. Verification of QCD Partition Function: Validating theoretical predictions through high-order cumulant measurements
3. Distinguishing Baryon Production Mechanisms: First experimental discrimination between different baryon production mechanisms

Research Significance

1. Theoretical Verification: LQCD predictions show significant differences from the HRG model at fourth-order and higher cumulants, providing a critical test of QCD theory
2. Phase Transition Physics: The chiral phase transition is a fundamental prediction of QCD theory; experimental verification is crucial for understanding the nature of strong interactions
3. Small System Effects: Searching for phase transition signals in small systems such as pp collisions challenges conventional understanding

Existing Limitations

1. Experimental Technical Constraints: High-order cumulant measurements face challenges in statistical precision and systematic uncertainties
2. Theoretical Comparison Difficulties: LQCD describes infinite thermally equilibrated systems, while experimental measurements come from finite dynamical systems
3. Background Effects: Effects such as local baryon number conservation and volume fluctuations modify the measured results

Core Contributions

1. First Sixth-Order Measurement: First measurement of net proton number cumulants up to sixth order in pp collisions
2. Fourth-Order Pb-Pb Results: Extension of net proton measurements to fourth order in Pb-Pb collisions
3. Systematic Effects Analysis: Detailed investigation of volume fluctuations, baryon number conservation, and other systematic effects
4. Theoretical Model Comparison: Systematic comparison with multiple theoretical models, including LQCD, HRG, and thermal models
5. Analytical Method Innovation: Development of new methods for handling efficiency corrections and volume fluctuations

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Measurement of high-order cumulants of the net proton number distribution, defined as:

• Input: pp and Pb-Pb collision events recorded by the ALICE detector
• Output: Net proton number cumulant ratios κₙ(p-p̄)/κ₂(p-p̄)
• Constraints: Momentum range, pseudorapidity acceptance, particle identification efficiency

Core Methods

Cumulant Calculation

The relationship between cumulants and susceptibilities is given by: $\chi_n^X = \frac{1}{VT^3}\frac{\partial^n \ln Z}{\partial(\mu_X/T)^n} = \frac{1}{VT^3}\kappa_n(X)$

where the first four-order cumulants are defined as:

• κ₁(X) = ⟨X⟩
• κ₂(X) = ⟨(X-⟨X⟩)²⟩
• κ₃(X) = ⟨(X-⟨X⟩)³⟩
• κ₄(X) = ⟨(X-⟨X⟩)⁴⟩ - 3(κ₂(X))²

Efficiency Correction

Reconstruction efficiency is corrected using a binomial model:

• Event weighting based on single-particle efficiency
• Accounting for detector acceptance and particle identification efficiency effects

Volume Fluctuation Correction

For fourth-order and higher cumulants, volume fluctuation effects must be considered: $\frac{\kappa_4}{\kappa_2} = \frac{\tilde{\kappa}_4}{\tilde{\kappa}_2} + 3\tilde{\kappa}_2\tilde{v}_2$$\frac{\kappa_6}{\kappa_2} = \frac{\tilde{\kappa}_6}{\tilde{\kappa}_2} + 15\tilde{\kappa}_4\tilde{v}_2 + 3\tilde{\kappa}_2^4\tilde{v}_3$

Technical Innovations

1. Event Mixing Technique: Event mixing is used in Pb-Pb analysis to eliminate particle correlations while preserving volume fluctuation contributions
2. Canonical Ensemble Description: A canonical ensemble approach using correlated volume parameter Vc describes local baryon number conservation effects
3. Multi-Model Comparison Framework: Systematic comparison of theoretical predictions from PYTHIA, Thermal-FIST, LQCD, and other models

Experimental Setup

Data Sets

• pp Collisions: √s = 13 TeV, 2018 data
• Pb-Pb Collisions: √sNN = 5.02 TeV, 2018 data
• Event Selection: INEL>0 for pp collisions, centrality classification for Pb-Pb collisions

Detector Configuration

• Particle Identification: dE/dx information from ITS and TPC; TOF used for pT ≥ 1 GeV in pp collisions
• Momentum Range: 0.5 ≤ pT < 1.5 GeV/c for pp, 0.4 < p < 1.0 GeV/c for Pb-Pb
• Pseudorapidity: |η| < 0.8, with extended acceptance for some analyses

Evaluation Metrics

• Cumulant Ratios: κ₂/⟨p+p̄⟩, κ₄/κ₂, κ₆/κ₂, etc.
• Theoretical Comparison: Comparison with LQCD, HRG, and thermal model predictions
• Baseline Deviation: Deviation from Skellam distribution (Poisson baseline)

Experimental Results

Main Results from pp Collisions

1. Second-Order Cumulant: κ₂(p-p̄)/⟨p+p̄⟩ shows approximately 9% suppression relative to the Skellam baseline, remaining consistent across all multiplicity classes
2. Fourth and Sixth Order: Volume fluctuation corrections are necessary for consistency with canonical ensemble models
3. Correlated Volume: Optimal correlated volume Vc = 2.78 dV/dy
4. Criticality Test: No evidence of critical behavior observed in pp collisions at √s = 13 TeV

Main Results from Pb-Pb Collisions

1. Centrality Dependence: κ₂/⟨p+p̄⟩ suppression ranges from 6% in central collisions to 1.5% in peripheral collisions
2. Rapidity Dependence: Can be explained by local baryon number conservation with available correlation length Δy = 5.6
3. Third-Order Cumulant: κ₃/κ₂ consistent with zero, as expected for μB ≈ 0 at LHC energies
4. Fourth-Order Measurement: Maximum deviation of approximately 5% from Skellam baseline, with statistical errors of comparable magnitude

Theoretical Model Comparison

1. PYTHIA Failure: Unable to describe the data due to Lund string fragmentation occurring at unit rapidity scale
2. Canonical Ensemble Success: Canonical ensemble as implemented in Thermal-FIST provides good description of all orders
3. LQCD Predictions: Fourth-order ratio prediction χ₄ᴮ/χ₂ᴮ ≈ 0.75, with sixth-order even becoming negative
4. Volume Fluctuations Critical: Fourth-order and higher require inclusion of volume fluctuations for data description

Related Work

Theoretical Developments

1. LQCD Calculations: HotQCD Collaboration predicts chiral crossover temperature Tpc = 156.5 MeV
2. Universality Classes: Second-order phase transition with two massless quark flavors belongs to O(4) universality class
3. Finite Mass Effects: Physical quark masses lead to smooth crossover transition

Experimental Progress

1. STAR Measurements: Net proton κ₆/κ₂ measured in highest multiplicity pp collisions consistent with zero
2. Multiplicity Analysis: Hadronic multiplicity in Pb-Pb collisions at LHC energies supports phase transition existence
3. Method Development: Continuous refinement of analytical techniques including efficiency corrections and volume fluctuation treatment

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. No Critical Signal: No evidence of chiral critical point signals found in the studied energies and systems
2. Conservation Laws Dominant: Local baryon number conservation is sufficient to explain observed fluctuation suppression
3. Method Validation: Established reliable methodology for high-order cumulant measurements
4. Future Potential: Provides foundation for measurements with larger acceptance and higher orders

Limitations

1. Statistical Precision: Particularly large statistical errors for fourth-order measurements in Pb-Pb collisions
2. Momentum Acceptance: Limited momentum range restricts direct comparison with LQCD predictions
3. Systematic Effects: Theoretical treatment of volume fluctuations and acceptance effects remains uncertain
4. Energy Range: Measurements only at LHC energies, lacking energy dependence studies

Future Directions

1. Probabilistic Methods: Use of probabilistic techniques to extend momentum acceptance
2. ALICE 3: Next-generation detector will enable large-acceptance high-precision measurements
3. Higher Orders: Extension to sixth-order and higher cumulant measurements
4. Energy Scan: Systematic study across different collision energies

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Advanced Techniques: First precise measurement of sixth-order net proton cumulants
2. Rigorous Analysis: Systematic consideration of various experimental effects and theoretical uncertainties
3. Methodological Innovation: Development of new techniques for handling volume fluctuations and efficiency corrections
4. Physical Insights: Provides important information for understanding QCD phase transitions and baryon production mechanisms

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Comparison Limitations: Acceptance constraints prevent direct verification of key LQCD predictions
2. Statistical Challenges: High-order cumulant measurements face inherent statistical difficulties
3. Model Dependence: Treatment of effects such as volume fluctuations depends on specific theoretical models
4. Limited System Range: Primarily focused on LHC energies, lacking broader phase diagram exploration

Impact

1. Methodological Contribution: Establishes standard methods for high-order fluctuation measurements in high-energy nuclear physics
2. Theoretical Verification: Provides important experimental constraints on QCD phase transition theory
3. Technical Advancement: Promotes development of detector technology and analytical methods
4. International Collaboration: Demonstrates the importance of large international collaborations in fundamental physics research

Application Scenarios

1. Fundamental Research: Investigation of QCD phase transitions, critical phenomena, and other fundamental physics questions
2. Method Application: High-order fluctuation analysis methods applicable to other physical systems
3. Detector Design: Provides design reference for future high-energy nuclear physics experiments
4. Theoretical Development: Provides experimental benchmarks for improving QCD theoretical calculations

References

This paper cites 17 important references, covering:

• LQCD theoretical calculations (HotQCD Collaboration)
• Experimental methodology (ALICE Collaboration technical literature)
• Theoretical models (Thermal-FIST, PYTHIA, etc.)
• Analytical techniques (efficiency corrections, volume fluctuation treatment, etc.)

This research represents significant progress in experimental QCD phase transition studies in high-energy nuclear physics, providing valuable experimental data and methodological contributions for understanding the fundamental nature of strong interactions.